Skip to main content

Position Papers: The State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review

Position Papers
The State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review
  • Show the following:

    Annotations
    Resources
  • Adjust appearance:

    Font
    Font style
    Color Scheme
    Light
    Dark
    Annotation contrast
    Low
    High
    Margins
  • Search within:
    • My Notes + Comments
    • Notifications
    • Privacy
  • Publication HomeProceedings of the 13th Conference of the Media Psychology Division (DGPs)
  • Publications
  • Learn more about Manifold

Notes

table of contents
  1. Book Cover
  2. Title Page
  3. Editorial
  4. Technology-Mediated Moral Outrage: A Theoretical View on Intrapersonal, Intergroup, and Network Effects
  5. Habituation and Adaptation to Repeated Media Exposure
  6. Don’t worry, they've got help. Diversity within fictional media characters, perception, engagement, ethical considerations and why representation matters after all.
  7. On the Road to Media PsAIchology? Mapping the potentials and challenges of artificial intelligence for research in media psychology
  8. The Interplay of Psychological and Communicative Processes in Right-Wing Radicalization – An Integrative Model
  9. Accessibility of VR experiences: a brief overview
  10. 10 things you need to consider when analyzing media effects
  11. The State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review

The State of Evidence in Digital Hate Research: An Umbrella Review

Jörg, Matthes, University of Vienna (joerg.matthes@univie.ac.at) / Koban, Kevin, University of Vienna (kevin.koban@univie.ac.at) / Bührer, Stephanie, University of Vienna (stephanie.buehrer@univie.ac.at) / Kirchmair, Thomas, University of Vienna (thomas.kirchmair@univie.ac.at) / Weiss, Phelia, University of Vienna (phelia.weiss@univie.ac.at) / Khaleghipour, Maryam, University of Vienna (khaleghipm94@univie.ac.at) / Saumer, Melanie, University of Vienna (melanie.saumer@univie.ac.at) / Meerson, Rina, Julius Maximilian University of Würzburg (rinameerson@googlemail.com)

34Social media platforms’ unique socio-technical conditions (Brown, 2018; Manata & Spottswood) have led to digital hate (understood as any kind of digitally transmitted malicious expressive conduct performed by and directed against individuals or collectives) emerging as a pivotal challenge for individuals' psychosocial health and modern societies at large. Building reliable knowledge around every facet of digital hate to inform both public discourse and policymakers in a societally advantageous manner can be considered scholarship's core mission. To be effective in this mission, conceptual noise (e.g., clatters and clamors [Bayer & LaRose, 2018] or horizontal and vertical expansions [Haslam, 2016]) should be avoided as much as possible; arguably, digital hate research has largely failed in this regard as it is plagued by a plethora of definitionally, conceptually, and empirically overlapping phenomena, implying an overwhelming heterogeneity of ostensibly incommensurable facets that obscure overarching patterns, prevent cross-conceptual synergies, and, thus, complicate possible policy applications from the outset (see Strippel et al., 2023 for a very recent overview).

35To gain a systematic overview of this scholarship, an umbrella review (see Papatheodorou, 2019) constitutes a suitable means to “provide an overall examination of the body of information that is available for a given topic, [...] highlight whether the evidence base around a topic is consistent or contradictory, and to explore the reasons for the findings” (Aromataris et al., 2015, p. 133). This paper will present such an umbrella review concerning digital hate outside of legal discourses. Primary goals are to investigate (a) general characteristics of available reviews with respect to review types, analyzed platforms, respondents, and cultural regions (RQ1a c), (b) definitions and conceptualizations (RQ2), (c) main findings (RQ3), and (d) research gaps (RQ4). We do so by taking up an actor-centered approach that distinguishes between perpetrators, audiences, and targets to determine whether review characteristics, definitions/conceptualizations, key findings, and research gaps converge (or diverge) across this triad.

36Based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement (Page et al., 2021), we conducted an extensive literature search on Web of Science to identify all reviews, meta-analyses, or other kinds of syntheses (published by March 2023). According to pre-defined inclusion and exclusion criteria, titles of 406 extracted documents were screened by two trained coders, resulting in 146 documents for abstract screening and, eventually, a final sample of N = 119 reviews. This final sample of reviews was then examined both quantitatively and qualitatively. More specifically, a total of 14 categories were quantitatively analyzed: publication year, method, main concept(s), language scope, number of included papers, age (differentiated between children, adolescents, young adults, and adults), actors (differentiated between perpetrators, audiences, and targets), content, and social media platform. Validity for the quantitative coding was tested via a randomized coding procedure realized by two trained coders (using Krippendorf’s α ≥ .8 as the criterion). Once sufficient validity for each category was met, a single coder addressed the remaining reviews. The qualitative part included the geographical allocation of the authors, definitions of the main construct(s), main result(s), and research gap(s).

37Umbrella review / digital hate / hate speech / cyberbullying / incivility

Annotate

Previous
CC BY-SA 4.0
Powered by Manifold Scholarship. Learn more at
Opens in new tab or windowmanifoldapp.org