Notes
Habituation and Adaptation to Repeated Media Exposure
6Digital technologies have become ubiquitous and it is now commonly accepted that we are permanently online and permanently connected. This permanent digital connectivity implies that we are repeatedly exposed to media during the day. This frequent exposure has led to concerns about the potential detrimental impact of digital technologies for our cognitive functioning (e.g., distractibility) as well as our well-being (e.g., life-satisfaction, self-esteem). Despite a growing body of empirical research in this field, there is still a substantial discussion on whether digital media does indeed affect its users, and if so to what extent. Empirical studies, particularly longitudinal studies, typically find “small” effects, leading some researchers to conclude that media effects are likely to be “negligible”.
7In this position paper, I argue that this lack of effects is partly due to a limited conceptualization of media effects in the current literature. Media effects are typically defined as a “change” or “shift” on a specific outcome on the intra-individual level. However, this conceptualization provides us with a limited understanding of how media effects occur over time after repeated media exposure. In our current digitalized environment, we are repeatedly, if not constantly, exposed to digital media. Thus, to effectively understand and examine media effects we need to conceptualize repeated exposure in our theoretical thinking as well as in our methodological considerations. Importantly, in our current “change or shift”-paradigm, usually linear effects are implied: the more frequent the exposure, the stronger the effect.
8This linearity assumption of media effects is, however, highly unlikely, and at the same time limits our understanding of what constitutes a media effect and how it evolves over time. It is unlikely to expect a linear increase resulting from repeated media exposure because established psychological theories of repeated exposure propose very different effect patterns. Specifically, theories on (hedonic) adaptation, habituation, and learning, all suppose that individual responses to stimuli either decline or stabilize after repeated exposure. A common example is the typical learning curve, with a steep increase at the beginning and a stabilization of the learning effect over time.
9I will delineate in this position paper, how these fundamental adaptation, habituation, and learning processes are crucial in understanding the effects of repeated media exposure and how they can help us towards a new and potentially more accurate conceptualization of media effects. Importantly, I argue that such a conceptualization of media effect patterns has not only far-reaching consequences for the theoretical conceptualization of media effects, but also for the conceptualization of future study designs, and the interpretation of existing findings. Because cross-sectional and short-term longitudinal studies only examine a small part of these media effects curves, they may “miss” and thus underestimate existing media effects. By integrating psychological theories on habituation, adaptation and learning with media effect theories, the current paper will thus propose a new view on media effect theories and existing empirical findings in the field.
10Media effects / change / habituation / adaptation