Notes
Don’t worry, they've got help. Diversity within fictional media characters, perception, engagement, ethical considerations and why representation matters after all.
11But she is not alone.
(Black Widow, Infinity War)
12In this position paper the representation of diversity within fictional (fantasy) characters will be discussed. While many studies and papers focus on the portrayal of characters and their diversity, only few looked at factors and aspects which made such portrayals successful (Zerebecki et al. 2023). Reasons for this lack of clarity which portrayal is successful and what successful even means lie within certain aspects of the methodological approaches in this field. Several qualitative studies looked at representations of minorities and give excellent in-depth insights, however, mainly focus on single media pieces and experiences and generalization of findings is rather complicated (Malik et al, 2022). Indeed, the experience and perception of characters are pretty much individual and clearly relate to the characteristics of the audience itself. Thus, the question arises if it is even possible to investigate diversity within character portrayals on a bigger scale and in the end hopefully develop recommendations for the media industry. To answer this question, I will present several studies on character engagement and its effect. Examples are quantitative studies concerning 1) gender identities, sexual orientation and PoC portrayal within Thor – Love and Thunder and the effects on character trait perception, recognizability and PSR; 2) female and (non)stereotype PoC portrayal within Black Panther – Wakanda Forever and the effect on recognizability, PSR, realness, authenticity and enjoyment of the character from a (non)PoC audience; 3) (least) favorite female character engagement within House of the Dragon and its effects on the female audience; and last but not least 4) qualitative approaches towards the development and inclusion of diversity over the last 4 decades within the Star Wars universe.
13I will focus on certain aspects of fictional characters that lead to an increased engagement in the audience and thus, can raise awareness and acceptance of certain (stigmatized) groups (Banas et al., 2020; Wong et al., 2022). In addition, the focus will lie on narratives and storylines of these characters and which role stereotype writing plays. For instance, which amount of stereotypical behavior, attitude and appearance might even be necessary to read a character in a certain way and how overcoming obstacles within the narrative can overwrite exactly those stereotypes (Mittel, 2015) and empower the represented audience as well as educate the non-represented side. In addition, I will discuss if and to what extent certain tests concerning portrayal of diversity (e.g., Bechdel, Vito Russo etc.) work or do not and how important diversity on the media production site is. Last but not least, ethical considerations will be targeted such as the question if I as a white, cis, straight (female) German scientist can or should investigate diversity. In other words: Am I up to this particular murder mission? “Rage and vengeance, anger, loss, regret, they're all tremendous motivators, they really clear the mind, so I'm good to go” (Thor, Infinity War) – and don’t worry, I got help.
14Character diversity / parasocial relationship / representation / portrayal / narrative / murder mission