Notes
10 things you need to consider when analyzing media effects
27The bread and butter of media psychologists is the analysis of how media consumption affects their users (Oliver et al., 2019). Is using TikTok detrimental for adolescents? Does communicating on Signal increase social connectedness? Does browsing Instagram stoke envy?
28Although there is an abundance of relevant research questions, currently there is a particular focus on the effects of social media use on adolescent well-being (Beyens et al., 2020; Dienlin & Johannes, 2020; Meier & Reinecke, 2020; Orben, 2020). Positions are polarized: While some argue that social media use is the number one driver behind a current adolescent mental health crisis (Haidt, 2023; Twenge, 2017; Twenge et al., 2022), others deny this is the case (Orben et al., 2019; Orben & Przybylski, 2019a, 2019b).
29The research question itself is simple and straightforward. Which makes it quite concerning that no consensus can be reached. Why is that?
30In my view, one problem is that our current research strategies and priorities are amiss. We need to reconsider our approach. We also need to reevaluate what we consider good research. So far, we got the priorities wrong. We ask questions and test models that are popular with other scientists, but that are irrelevant to the public.
31To stimulate further research on this question, in my talk I present 10 practices that need to be implemented in order to advance our understanding of how media consumption affects their users. These ten practices focus on theory, study design, and statistical analyses. They are as follows:
- First focus on measuring, then on explaining
- There are no between-person “effects”
- Get behavioral data on media use
- Dare to single-measure outcomes
- Don’t conduct panel studies, go intensive
- Measure how effects unfold over time
- Control for varying and non-varying confounds
- Don’t control for mediators and colliders
- Define a SESOI
- Minimal effects might matter
33Media effects / media use / social media / well-being