Notes
Using Player-Identified Mechanics to Validate their Existence in Gaming Experiences
107Dynamic systems theory suggests that the brain can change based on the demands of the environment surrounding it, even digital game environments (for review, see Eden et al., 2018). But research on cognitive effects of games is often based on broad, player or nonplayer, or genre-specific effects that can encompass many different kinds of gameplay (see Arsenault, 2009). But today, even the same game can often be played in various ways. Dale et al. (2020) reviews of how far the industry has moved from traditional genres, advocating for a shift away from traditional genre effects studies. Research today still lacks specification of the content the players engage with and the creators decide on, that leads to cognitive effects.
108To explore content, researchers need to consider game mechanics, or creator-developed rules about how the player interacts with the game environment. Removed for Anonymity identified five common and distinct mechanics, demonstrating that one, the setback punishment mechanic (returning to an earlier point in the game upon failure), associates with episodic memory. An important next step is to demonstrate that players can understand these mechanic descriptions. We asked: can participants identify games that use them (RQ1), agree on their presence in popular games (RQ2), and create mechanic profiles for popular games (RQ3).
109Survey participants (18+ who play digital games for at least 30 minutes weekly) will be asked to identify games that use the setback punishment, spatial navigation (creator includes a map and requires players to use it), object tracking (game designer includes fast-moving objects players target), invincibility (little or no punishment after failure), and casual gameplay (short levels that can be started and stopped easily). They will identify these mechanics in popular digital games and applications, including identifying when there are multiple mechanics present, and indicate their familiarity with the games.
110Game mechanics / cognitive effects / setback punishment