Notes
The side-effects of Instagram
23Instagram, the constantly growing image-based social platform can negatively affect body image, life satisfaction and self-esteem. In addition, its use has been linked to eating disorders. Two online studies tested the effects of Instagram on self-esteem and affect, with a particular focus on eating symptomatology. In Study 1, a total of 307 adult women saw Instagram posts showing overweight women in bathing suits with either body-positive or body-negative comments that were manufactured. The results indicated a negative correlation between Instagram use and trait self-esteem. However, the emotional valence of comments had no significant effect on the reported state self-esteem after seeing the posts. In contrast, reported eating disorder severity was positively related to negative emotional responses to the posts, whereas it was negatively related to positive affect. Low trait self-esteem, more eating disorder symptoms and a negative body image predicted low state self-esteem, but Instagram use or the emotional response to the posts did not. Overall, the results of Study 1 suggest that the impact Instagram can have on women depends more on the characteristics of the users who are exposed to the content, rather than the content itself.
24But how do men respond to body-positive or body-negative comments to Instagram pictures of overweight men? To date, only few studies have addressed the impact of Instagram on male users. Therefore, a second online survey with an adult male sample (N=104) tested the relationship between Instagram use, social comparison, self-esteem, body image, and the emotional response to made-up Instagram posts and comments. As in Study 1, participants indicated their eating disorder symptomatology. Instagram posts showed overweight men in bathing suits together with either body-positive or body-negative comments. Does the pattern of results found in Study 1 also apply to men? The data analysis has not yet been completed.
25Instagram / self-esteem / emotional state / body image / gender