Notes
Informal learning with social media: An experiment comparing YouTube Videos and Instagram Reels
26Theoretical background: Social media such as YouTube, Instagram, or TikTok offer opportunities for informal and incidental learning, especially of procedural information. The instructors in these videos often are peers (vs. experts/teachers); the videos, thus, provide an opportunity for social learning from similar others. Most prior research, only assessed attitude or self-reported learning rather than knowledge tests as dependent variable. There is also not much work systematically comparing platforms beyond discussing their different affordances. We fill this gap by comparing learning with YouTube videos and Instagram Reels. People usually search for How-To videos on YouTube, whereas they often stumble upon Instagram Reels. Reels are also shorter and faster, and it is not possible to change the playback speed, increasing the cognitive load and making it more complicated to process the information. These disadvantages could, however, be at least partly compensated by a positive attitude towards learning with Instagram Reels.
27Research question: What is the influence of the social media platform (YouTube vs. Instagram) and the attitudes toward learning with the respective social media platform on learning? H1: Participants have a more positive attitude towards learning with YouTube than towards learning with Instagram Reels. H2: Participants learn more by watching a YouTube video than from watching an Instagram Reel. H3: Attitudes towards learning with the respective platform are positively associated with learning.
28Methodological approach: A preregistered online experiment (n = 135) with 2 conditions was conducted in December 2022. Participants either watched a short YouTube video or an Instagram Reel on baking Christmas cookies. After watching the video, they answered a knowledge test consisting of 10 multiple-choice questions. The attitude toward learning with YouTube and Instagram was assessed with five 7-point semantic differentials (αs = .82 and .85 for YouTube and Instagram Reels, respectively). Hypotheses were tested with a regression analysis.
29Informal learning / YouTube / Instagram / knowledge