Notes
Can news diversification go too far? How different diversification metrics affect tolerance and political participation
43News recommender systems (NRSs) could take on an important democratic function; e.g. by facilitating tolerance towards others’ opinions or political participation through increased exposure diversity (Helberger, 2019). However, while various democratically informed news diversification metrics that could help increase exposure diversity have been proposed (e.g. Vrijenhoek et al., 2021), their effects remain largely unexplored.
44Drawing on two metrics suggested by Vrijenhoek et al. (2021), our study therefore tests how 1) the inclusion vs exclusion of minority voices as an active agent (‘alternative voices metric’) and 2) the presence vs absence of emotional language (‘activation metric’) affect news engagement and democratic deliberation:
45RQ1: How do different diversification metrics during a concrete information search scenario affect a) tolerance b) political efficacy, c) intended political participation and d) general news engagement among readers?
46We will carry out a pre-registered 2 (activation metric) x 3 (alternative voices metric) between subjects experiment where we expose participants to diversified news feeds with five pre-tested articles on the topic. Depending on the condition, the news feeds consist of 20 or 80% of articles with emotional language and 0, 40, or 80% of articles that include transgenders (our context-relevant minority) as an active agent.
47Our results will provide insights into the conditions where increased exposure diversity can facilitate democratic deliberation or cause backfire effects (e.g. decreased engagement). Moreover, the experimental conditions can be mapped onto different types of democratic NRS (Helberger, 2019), which enables us to test whether their effects align with their normative goals.
48News recommender systems / exposure diversity / tolerance / political participation / democratic theory