Notes
Who watches fail clips? Light and dark personality dispositions to watching the misfortunes of others
113Background: Fail clips are videos that show people inadvertently failing to do something (Döring & Mohseni, 2019) and are a popular genre on social media (Hallinan et al., 2021) with millions of viewers (e.g., FailArmy on YouTube). I consider fail clips to be the media genre that most explicitly involves the experience of schadenfreude, the pleasure at the misfortunes of others (van Dijk & Ouwerkerk, 2014). The question arises whether laughing at others’ misfortunes is rather a dark and malicious pleasure that mainly serves the self-enhancement of the observer via social downward comparison (Wills, 1981), or a light and naïve pleasure that is just fun and does mean no harm to anyone. Clues to this question can be provided by looking at the personality of fail clip users, which has not yet been studied.
114Research question: Which personality traits are associated with frequent use and enjoyment of fail clips?
115I assume that fail clip use corresponds with traits related to schadenfreude identified in past research (psychopathy, Machiavellianism, belief in a just world, social comparison orientation). Importantly, I add the perspective of humor styles that have been neglected in this context so far. Based on humor theories, I hypothesize that fail clip use corresponds with certain humor styles that can be differentiated into a) lighter and b) darker styles (Ruch et al., 2018), namely a) aggressive humor (Martin et al., 2003) that involves disparagement of others and b) benevolent humor (Ruch & Heintz, 2016) that includes a benevolent view on one’s own and others’ failures.
116Methodological approach: In an online survey, the 1) frequency and 2) enjoyment of fail clip use are investigated. The above-mentioned personality traits and humor styles, gender, and age serve as predictors. The sample will consist of N = 500, representative of Germany.
117Fail clips / personality / Schadenfreude / humor / emotion