Notes
5. Findings and Discussion
Chapter 5 discusses the findings of this study. By presenting and interpreting the ethnographic data within a narrative framework guided by the theoretical and focused codes generated through the grounded theory analysis described in the previous chapter, this chapter addresses the following two research questions:
- Q1. Which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening meaningful connection with nature?
- Q2. What views of nature and human-nature relationships are embedded in participants’ engagement with nature from these perspectives?
To answer these questions, I draw on distinct data sources: interview data for Q1 and video ethnographic data for Q2. This decision was based on the respective strengths of each data type in addressing the specific focus of each research question. The first research question explores participants’ preferences and beliefs about connecting with nature. These thoughts were more explicitly articulated in interviews than during the activities in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt, which are characterised by physical work and non-verbal interactions. Moreover, for many senior volunteers, previous experiences of environmental engagement play an essential role in shaping their beliefs. Therefore, I draw on the strength of ethnographic interviews in eliciting remembered experiences and personal opinions (Buscatto, 2018) to address Q1. The second research question explores the types of human-nature relationships that are enacted through these multifaceted connections. This entails examining the live dynamics between participants and nature. To this end, I delve into the ethnographic moments (Prost, 2003), which were captured through fieldnotes and video recording and provide access to an emic perspective on the sense-making process embedded in real-life interactions (Koskinen-Koivisto et al., 2020). Although the volume of video data is smaller due to constraints beyond my control (e.g., fixed annual scheduling and weather-related cancellations, as discussed in Chapter 3), the strength of qualitative data stems not from sheer amount, but from its potential to reveal previously invisible phenomena and more nuanced understandings (de Saint-Georges, 2018). Accordingly, I use these two types of data to address the two research questions respectively.
Sowing Seeds and Tending Soil for Connection with Nature
Exploring Connecting with Nature as a Trajectory
Existing sociological environmental ethnographies have been examining the roots of detrimental human-nature relationships and revealing the patterns of actions and perceptions embedded in non-confrontational human-nature interactions. These insights have advanced our understanding of how human-nature connection is deeply impacted by social, political, economic and racial power dynamics, and how reciprocal human-nature connections are enacted in educational, recreational and pro-environmental activities. In addition, a wealth of survey-based quantitative studies and meta-analyses have concluded that physical and psychological connections with nature promote people’s well-being and pro-environmental behaviours (e.g. Barragan-Jason et al., 2023; Martin et al., 2020; Pritchard et al., 2020; Whitburn et al., 2020). The debate, however, seems to overlook a fundamental question: which perspectives do people consider essential for initiating and deepening connection with nature in everyday life? Neglecting this question risks overlooking the diverse and nuanced pathways through which engagement with nature can be sparked and nurtured in everyday life. As such, I will address the question:
Which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening meaningful connection with nature?
Embodied Experiences with Nature
During the interviews, participants frequently describe their direct, physical experiences with animals, plants and landscapes and express their opinion that such practical engagement plays a fundamental role in fostering a close connection with nature. These discourses conceive “nature” neither as an abstract and general reference to all things that are “non-human”, nor as an “environment” that is often invisible as a substrate for human activities. Instead, nature is something concrete and tangible to hold in hand, to experience, to interact and work with. Their connection with this concrete nature, therefore, is enhanced through practical and embodied experiences with it.
“Grasping Nature in Mind Comes from Grasping Nature with Hand”
I begin the detailed analysis with the focused code that emerged directly from my conversation with Eric. Born during the Second World War in a Luxembourgish working-class family, Eric’s early years were marked by modest material conditions but not boredom – his childhood was immersed in the exploration of nature. Due to the challenging post-war economic circumstances and the underprivileged family background, Eric could not afford to pursue higher education in environmental science as he wished. However, he has achieved a fulfilling nature career: he started as a primary school nature teacher and later was recruited as a mentor of nature pedagogy by the Luxembourg Ministry of Education. In addition, Eric is the former president of LetzEarth, its current honorary president, the co-founder of the conservation foundation GreenLove and one of Luxembourg’s leading ornithologists. There is no doubt that Eric has always been in close connection with nature throughout his life. During the interview, Eric recounted the beginning of his journey in nature:
Da habe ich Glück gehabt meine Eltern, die kamen alle beide von dem vom Bauern her
und meine Großaltern die hatte noch einen Bauernbetrieb. Und für mich war es sehr
wichtig, in den Ferien war ich dann dauernd bei ihnen auf dem Hof. Und meine Großmutter,
die war so eine, sagen wir mal, so eine Küche, eine, eine Kräuterfrau. Sie hatten
einen großen Garten. Und ich habe dann allmögliche Dinge gefragt, wie heißt das, und
so. und was machst du damit? Und dann haben wir zusammengekocht. Und das war fantastisch.
Ich habe da so viel, sagen wir mal, erlebt, konkret. Das heißt, mit, das wichtig ist,
ehrlich. Wenn man, man sagt ja, ich habe es begriffen. Man vergisst immer, Begreifen,
das kommt von Grei::fen. Das heißt, wenn man etwas begriffen hat, musste man es vorher
irgendwie auch gegriffen haben, angepackt haben. Und das war so wichtig, wir haben
dann im Garten zusammengearbeitet. Ich habe dann gefragt, oh welcher Käfer ist das
denn jetzt wieder?
(I was lucky, because my parents both came from farmer’s family and my grandparents still had a farm. And it was very important for me, I was always on the farm with them during the holidays. And my grandmother, she was, let’s say, a “herb lady”. They had a big garden. And I would ask them all sorts of things, what is it called and so on, and what do you do with it? And then we cooked together. And that was fantastic. I’ve experienced so much there, let’s say, concretely. That is, the important thing is, when, honestly, when people say, “I’ve grasped something, understood.”, they always forget, grasping something in mind comes from grasping something with hand. This means if you’ve understood something, before that you have to somehow grip it with hands, have hands-on experiences. And that was so important, we then worked together in the garden. I then asked, oh which beetle is that again?)
This passage is part of Eric’s answer to a question that was posed by himself during the interview: “[…] in order to really understand my, let’s say, my engagement with LetzEarth, I must expand a bit. That is quite important, how do you get into nature conservation as, as we often say, a citizen?”8. Answering his own rhetorical question, Eric emphasises the importance of concretely doing, interacting and experiencing in his first contact with nature. Although the word “nature” is not mentioned in this excerpt, its presence is evident in the tangible and experienceable spaces of the farm and garden, where Eric and his family explored and worked with species such as herbs and beetles. His interpretation of the German verbs begreifen and greifen is particularly noteworthy. Both words can be translated as “to grasp” in English, but with different semantic meanings. Begreifen refers to “to understand something completely” and greifen means “to take a strong hold of something”. To preserve Eric’s nuanced linguistic interpretation as much as possible, I translate his argument as “grasping something in mind comes from grasping something with hand”9. It goes beyond a morphological explanation that begreifen is derived from the root word greifen, but highlights Eric’s strong belief that practical experiences in nature form the crucial basis for cognitive understanding of it.
While Eric is the only participant who explicitly articulated this intriguing perception of “grasping”, the data suggests that the idea of “grasping nature with hand” is also valued by other participants. For Christophe, holding a bird in hand is “magical”. In 2005, Christophe moved from France to Luxembourg for work reasons. As a newcomer to the Grand Duchy, Christophe “wanted to visit the country with the approach of nature” and became a member of LetzEarth. He learnt about the wetland reserve and the Reed Marsh team through LetzEarth’s magazine Rose. During his first visit to Reed Marsh, Christophe found “the activity very interesting. People were also very cool and very friendly”, and afterwards joined the bird ringing team. He recalled his contact with Luxembourg’s nature:
The passion to do something connected with nature came progressively, I would say. And I love animals more. Okay, already there are also plants or trees. But the thing with birds is very special. Yes, when you have a bird in your hand, it's magical.
This excerpt suggests that Christophe views connection with nature as a developing process, and for him, the practical interaction with concrete species – in his case, birds – is a significant catalyst for this process. His description of the feelings of having a bird in hand is “special” and “magical”, which are not tactile sensations but rather inner experiences of meaningfulness and wonder. This interestingly echoes Eric’s view that “grasping something in mind comes from grasping something with hand”, suggesting that physical contact with tangible species nurtures internal responses towards nature. These internal responses, in Christophe’s words, can “progressively” develop into the “passion” of engagement with nature.
Michael also values physical contact with nature, as he believes practical experiences promote emotional and cognitive connection. Before his retirement, Michael worked as a primary school nature teacher and a mentor in nature pedagogy at the nature activity centre, Green Charlet, which was affiliated with LetzEarth. At Green Charlet, children are offered outdoor workshops and activities to learn about nature and how to interact with it. Throughout his career, Michael dedicated himself to guiding children to experience and explore nature. Outside of his professional work, he has been a long-term volunteer at LetzEarth’s local section, City. During the interview, Michael used the imagery of hands and brain to vividly explain his perspective that physical practices play a unique and important role in forming an awareness of nature:
Also, alles, ich glaube alles, was man mit den Händen macht, das geht gleich ins Gehirn
rein. Da ist die Verbindung von der Hand, von den Sensoren in der Hand, da geht die
Verbindung bis ins Gehirn. Wenn du das gemacht hast, dann weißt du das. Aber anders
so theoretisch ist das nicht derselbe, den vielleicht verschieden, die sind anders
geschickt, die Gehirne, die können das auch aufnehmen, aber, aber viele brauchen halt,
die meisten, glaube ich, brauchen den Kontakt, damit es klappt, ne? [...] Er muss
damit richtig arbeiten und richtig anfassen.
(So everything, I think everything you do with your hands goes straight into the brain. There’s the connection from the hand, from the sensors in the hand, the connection goes right into the brain. If you do it, then you know it. But theoretical things are not the same, it’s perhaps different, it’s sent in a different way [into]the brain. The brain can also pick it up, but many people need, I think most need the contact to make it work, right? [...] You must really work with it and touch it.)
Besides emphasising the impact of physical interaction on the cognitive connection with nature, Michael argued that such interactions also arouse emotional responses:
Auch die Gehirnzelle wären erst dann bestimmt stimuliert. Dadurch Kinder dann mit
Sachen in die Hand nehmen, selber probieren. Man muss sich mal schmutzig machen, dass
man sieht, was Erde ist. Guckst du, habe auch ein schönes Beispiel, im Kopf, dann,
ein kleines Mädchen hat dann auch dann, einen Wurm. ‚Hei kuck mol, Michael, ein Wurm!‘
Guck, ein Wurm, ne? Die dann, ‚Eeeh----, Wurm.‘ ‚ist ein schéine Wuerm? Guck, wie
den jetzt bewege do. Wie die bewege auf der Hand. ‘ ‚Wo kannst du den anfassen?‘ sagt
ein anderes Mädchen. Der macht ja nichts, der Wurm. Da, so kleine Sachen, den zahlt.
Da kannst du so viel le::sen und so, das kannst du lesen, du kannst Bilder gucken,
ist nicht derselben. Du musst spüren, wie der Wurm sich auf deine Hand bewegt. Oder
ein Käfer, der krabbelt da, ne? Spürst du, wie der so, so ganz, so richtig kitzelt,
ne? So kitzelt. Ja, die kleinen Füßen, die so, ganz, ganz, ganz... fein! Da werden
deine ganz kleine Nerven, da werden, der berührt. Die Berührung geht dann ins Gehirn.
Das geht bis in deinen ganzen Körper. dass du das fühlst, das kannst du nicht so lernen
als Bücher. Das ist richtiger Kontakt mit, mit den Tieren.
(The brain cells would definitely be stimulated then. Through [practices] children hold things in hands, try out by themselves. You have to get your hands dirty to see what earth is. Look, I also have a nice example in mind: a little girl with a worm. “Hey look, Michael, a worm!” Look, a worm, right? Then, “Eeeh----, worm.” “Is a beautiful worm? Look, how it moves there. How it moves on your hand?” “Where can you touch it?” said another girl. It doesn’t harm, the worm. So, little things like that, it counts. You can read a lot, you can read, you can look at pictures, it’s not the same. You must feel how the worm moves on your hand. Or a beetle, it crawls there, right? You can feel how it really tickles, right? It tickles like that. Yes, the little feet that are so, so, so... fine! Your very small nerves are touched. The touch then goes to your brain. It goes all the way into your body. You can’t learn that from books. It’s real contact with the animals.)
The anecdote of the two little girls and the worm illustrates how emotional reactions towards species that are often negatively perceived can be changed through physical interaction. With Michael’s encouragement to hold the worm, the two little girls navigated their feelings from disgust to curiosity, supporting Michael’s opinion that physical contact with concrete species forms a closer inner connection with nature. It is also noteworthy that while Michael believes that the worm and beetles should be held in hands for interaction, he does not perceive them as something under human control and devoid of agency. Holding the worm and beetles is not aimed at demonstrating humans’ power to control over these small animals or the desire to dominate them, but to experience their vitality directly: the worm is “beautiful”, and the beetle “tickles” with their tiny feet. This transition from tactile to emotional sensations, according to Michael’s vivid metaphor of brain and nerves, can only be achieved through physical interaction with nature. He gave another example of “embracing trees” to illustrate this viewpoint:
Auch den Baum fühlen, haben wir auch gemacht, immer den Baum fühlen, auch mit verbundenen
Augen, wie gesagt, die Augen binden. Nur gesagt, müssen den Baum umarmen. Das ist
unser Freund, so, die Baumen. I embrace the tree, and I...I try to be in contact with
him. Es ist so viel, als die Rinde von dem Baum spüren, dass die anders siehst als
die von anderen Aart. Wenn du das Eiche fühlst, du hast eine Birke oder du hast eine
Buchen, die Buchen hat den Stamm glatt, die Eiche hat ganz graue Rinde. Kannst du
gut unterscheiden durch das Fühlen nur. Ich kann es auch im Buch studieren, ja, das
so, so und so und dann, die ist es so und so. Wenn du die nie gespürt hast, dann vergisst
du das wieder sowieso ganz schnell. And dann spürt hast die raue Rinde von der Eiche,
"das ist eine Eiche", da kennst du gleich, ne?
(We also felt the tree, we also did that, always to feel the tree, with blindfolds covering eyes. Just as said, must hug the tree. That’s our friend, the trees. I embrace the tree, and I... I try to be in contact with him. It’s so much, like feeling the bark of the tree, the barks of different tree species are different. If you feel the oak, you have a birch or you have a beech, the beech has a smooth trunk, the oak has very grey bark. You can only tell the difference by feeling it. I can also study it in the book, yes, it’s so, so and so and then it’s so and so. If you’ve never felt it, you’ll forget it very quickly anyway. And then you feel the rough bark of the oak tree, “that's an oak tree”, you know right away, don’t you?)
The gesture of embracing and hugging carries emotional significance. Like Michael mentioned, embracing creates a sense of friendship between people and trees. At the same time, physical contact contributes to nuanced learning about trees. While bark textures can be described in textbooks as verbal knowledge, descriptive language alone cannot create the embodied learning experiences that Michael believes are an efficient way of understanding nature.
While Eric, Christophe and Michael shared encouraging experiences of how hands-on interactions with nature have promoted the cognitive and emotional human-nature connection, Birgit, the president of LetzEarth local section Nord, expressed her concern about what Pyle (1993) terms as extinction of experience:
Die [Kinder] haben keine Zeit mehr, um dann auch noch da irgendwas über Schmerterlinge
zu lernen oder über den Fuchs zu erfahren, oder irgendwie so etwas. Das fehlt sehr.
Okay, die Kinder lernen auch ein bisschen über die Natur in der Schule, aber nicht
so das Praktische. Das fehlt einfach, und wirklich mal ein Regenwurm anzufassen, mit
den bloßen Händen in der Erde zu wühlen und zu gucken, was es dafür Lebewesen gibt
in der Erde und so.
(The [children] don’t have the time anymore to learn something about butterflies or experience things about foxes, or anything like that. That’s missing very much. Okay, the children also learn a bit about nature at school, but not such practical things. That’s just missing, actually touching an earthworm, digging in the soil with their bare hands and seeing what kind of creatures there are in the soil and so on.)
Birgit’s critical view that the “practical things” are missing in today’s environmental education implies that she considers hands-on contact to be essential in learning about nature. It impressed me how strongly her examples of the physical contact with nature resonates with her fellow volunteers. The fundamental role of “hand” in initiating contact with nature is highlighted once again, emphasising that an inner connection with nature starts with actions such as grasping, holding, touching, and digging.
While expressing the perspective that hands-on contact with animals, plants and non-living forms such as soil is fundamental for developing meaningful connections with nature, participants described their lived experiences of “grasping” nature. They picked up everyday plants and animals in the surroundings and interact with them with curiosity, care and joy. For example, Michael and his students collected frog eggs and built mini paludariums to observe the life cycle:
Michael: Formerly I was a teacher, a normal teacher in primary school. But I always was interested in nature activity, so I went with my little students, I went outside always when I was a normal teacher already. We had, we collected frog eggs to see the evolution in class, and afterwards we put them back in the pond. So the children could see the evolution of life because with frogs you can see a little bit of evolution. Life came from water and it goes on the land. A bit compacted history of evolution.
Yimin: I never thought frogs in that way, but now...
Michael: Yes, but it’s really stunning to see that. You go to the pond with the kids and they collect the eggs and you take them in a little aquarium and then you must make also a land place where the little frogs can go. But you have to put them very quick outside again because they don’t get the food they need when they are in an aquarium. You can feed the little frogs afterwards. We had also, I had to make contact with, I always was impressed how much is necessary for children to be in contact with animals.
What strikes me most in Michael’s experience is how profound knowledge about nature can be visualised through small, entertaining interactions with familiar animals. The macroscopic concept of evolutionary history becomes tangible through creating a paludarium and observing the life cycle of frogs. This fun interaction with frogs serves as an intuitive and embodied approach to learning about the species’ living habits and the history of organisms transitioning from aquatic to terrestrial life. Moreover, hands-on activities transform such knowledge from purely cerebral understanding into an experience that evokes a sense of wonder and emotional connection with nature. As Michael puts it, “It’s stunning to see that”.
Birgit also recalled her interactions with frogs and their amphibian relatives, but within a different context. Each year from mid-February to mid-April, the mild nighttime temperatures along with the humid climate in Luxembourg create ideal conditions for toads, frogs and other amphibians to migrate from their winter terrestrial habitats to spawning waters. Yet their migratory paths are cut off by motorways and highways, with speeding vehicles further increasing the danger of these animals being killed during the crossing. As such, LetzEarth has launched the annual “rescuing toad in migration” action in cooperation with the Luxembourg Nature and Forestry Administration (ANF)10 to help the amphibians reach their spawning waters safely. During the migration period, ANF staff set up fences at the borders of the concerned terrestrial habitats to prevent the animals from crossing the motorways by themselves. The LetzEarth volunteers then collect the migrating amphibians in buckets and take them across the motorways. The toad rescuing action is one of the first activities that Birgit participated in when she started volunteering at LetzEarth. This engagement has left a deep impression on her:
Und damals haben sie Kröten und Frösche über die Straßen gesetzt, damit sie nicht
überfahren werden. Und das war in der Zeit, wo ich dazu kam. Da kann ich mich noch
so gut daran erinnern, ja. Wie geht das? Werden die wirklich überfahren und so? Ja,
die werden wirklich überfahren. Auch wenn man sie in die Mitte nimmt von den Rädern
und sterben sie durch den Luftdruck und so weiter. Das sind alles Sachen, die man
dann gelernt hat und später dann auch weiter gemacht. Als richtig Erwachsener, dann
habe ich dann selbst zwischen Bettendorf und Monsdorf Kröten und Frösche und Molche
über die Straße gesezt. Und ja, so hat das sich aufgebaut und immer wieder was in
der Natur getan.
(And back then they took toads and frogs across the road so they wouldn’t get run over. And that was at the time when I joined. I can still remember it so well, yeah. How does that work? Do they really get run over or things like that? Yes, they really do get run over. Even if they are in the middle of the wheels they die from the air pressure and so on. These are all things that you learnt and then continued to do later. As a real adult, I then help toads and frogs and newts across the road between Bettendorf and Monsdorf by myself. And yes, that’s how it built up, always do things in nature.)
In this excerpt, Birgit did not describe the practical interactions she had with toads in this action. Nevertheless, her recollection of this practical experience reveals its profound influence on her awareness of the often-overlooked, nuanced ways in which everyday human activities impact nature. Through the hands-on rescuing actions, Birgit realised that the motorways and vehicles that people take for granted seriously pose mortal danger to these small animals. She learnt about the subtle vulnerability of nature caused by human activities, a phenomenon that is highly unlikely to be found in any biology textbook. Even if a frog wheels do not crush a frog, the pressure differential caused by the car passing over it can still kill it. This awareness, knowledge, and the willingness to act for nature are “built up” in such practical engagement with nature.
Eric’s experiences also strongly support his intriguing perspective of “grasping” nature:
Und da es kein Fernseher gab, das heißt, die Freizeit, die wir hatten, die verbrachten
wir wo? Draußen. In der Natur. Und da haben wir, ich habe mit meinen Brüdern, wir
hatten da nicht weit entfernt von unserem Haus, da gab es einen Bach, damals war der
Bach noch sauber. Wir haben da Fische gefangen, kleine. Die haben wir dann in Aquarien
gemacht und wir haben dann gesehen, wir haben Froschleicht genommen. Und wir haben
dann gesehen, wie aus den Eiern da auf einmal kleine Fröscht kommen, Kaulquappe und
so. Das war so, so wichtig, dass wir das konkret erlebt haben. Der Nachbar, der war
auch ein Bauer bei uns. Und jetzt hat, auf einmal, hat seine Katze, die hatte drei
Junge bekommen. Und er hat uns jedem, von meinen zwei Brüdern damals, der Jüngste
war noch nicht auf der Welt, wir bekamen dann einen Katz. Ah! Das war! Das war natürlich
SO wichtig, dass wir uns da auch darum kümmern mussten, wir haben dann festgestellt,
ja wie, was fressen die, wie verhalten sie sich, und so weiter und so weiter. Und
da es kein Fernsehen gab, was machten wir? Sonntags mit unseren Eltern haben wir jeden
Sonntag wenn frei war, gehen wir spazieren in die NATUR. Und da haben wir, alle, wir
haben Pilze gesammelt. Wir haben Früchte gesammelt. Wir haben Blumen gesammelt, einen
Blumenstrauß für meine Mutter. Das war so wichtig. Ich habe die Bäume kennengelernt,
die Blätter der Bäume, die Früchte der Bäume. Und das war die BASIS, sagen wir mal,
für meinen ganzen Naturschutzgedanke. Ohne diese Basis, glaube ich, hat man es sehr,
sehr schwer.
(And since there was no television, so to say, the free time we had, where did we spend it? Outside. In nature. And there, I, with my brothers, we had a stream not far from our house, back then the stream was still clean. We caught fish there, small ones. We built aquariums and we saw, we took frog spawn. And we saw how from the eggs, little frogs emerged, tadpoles and so on. It was so so important that we experienced this concretely. The neighbour, he was also a farmer near us. And then once, his cat had three kittens. And he gave each of us, my two brothers at the time, the youngest wasn’t born yet, we each got a cat. Ah! That was! That was, of course, SO important, that we had to take care of them, we then found out, yeah, like what do they eat, how do they behave, and so on and so forth. And since there was no television, what did we do? On Sundays with our parents, every Sunday when we were free, we went for a walk in NATURE. And there, all, we collected mushrooms. We collected fruits. We collected flowers, a bouquet for my mother. It was so important. I got to know the trees, the leaves of the trees, the fruits of the trees. And that was the BASIS, let’s say, for my whole idea of nature conservation. Without this basis, I believe, it is very, very difficult.)
This enthusiastic recollection resonates powerfully with his viewpoint that grasping nature with hands lays the foundation of grasping nature in mind. In Eric’s view, nature is so concrete, inviting and within reach: it is the stream near his childhood home; it is the fish and frogs that he and his brothers caught and observed; it is the kitten that he took care of; it is the mushrooms, fruits, leaves and flowers that he picked with his family. As demonstrated by his repeated statement “that/it was so important” and explicit emphasis on these practical experiences as the essential basis for his conservation mindset, Eric is convinced that hands-on interactions with nature are fundamental for fostering cognitive connection with nature.
Immediately after sharing with me the fulfilling memories of “concretely experiencing nature” with his family, Eric continued with a fond recollection of his primary school teacher, who had guided children in hands-on explorations of the natural world:
Jetzt kam dann noch dazu, wir hatten dann einen Lehrer, der war auch ganz interessiert
an Naturkunde. Und bei dem haben wir unwahrscheinlich gelernt. Ein Beispiel. Wir gingen
in den Wald im Herbst und sammelten dann wilde Kirschbäume. Und jeder der Schüler
und Schülerinnen, nein das waren nur Schüler, damals waren wir noch getrennt, manche.
Jeder von den Kindern, Jungen, da bekam einen wilden Kirschbaum, den wir selbst aus
dem Wald genommen haben. Der wurde in die Schule mitgenommen und der Lehrer, der bekam
von der Gemeinde, ein Stück Garten zur Verfügung, da pflanzen wir diesen Kirschbaum
da ein und er konnte pfropfen. Du weißt was das ist? Pfropfen, das heißt, da werden
Sprosse des echten Kirschtbaums auf den Alten gepfropft. Also, das ist eine ganze
Wissenschaft für sich.
(And what’s more, we had a teacher who was also very interested in natural history. And we learnt an incredible lot from him. One example. We went to the forest in autumn and collected wild cherry trees. And every boy and girl, no, we were only boys, at that time we were still separated, some. Every child, boy, got a wild cherry tree that we took from the forest ourselves. We brought it to school and the teacher, he got a garden from the commune, so we planted the cherry trees there and he grafted them. Do you know what that is? Grafting, that is, to graft the new branches of the cherry onto the old one. It’s a whole science itself.)
After explaining to me the term pfropfen (to graft), Eric continued to share the nature activities that the teacher organised:
Und jetzt hat dann das, ah, für mich sehr wichtig, zum Schluss des Schuljahres bekam
jeder seinen Kirschbaum mit nach Hause. Super! Und wir konnten dann diesen Kirschbaum
in unseren Garten einpflanzen. Das war eine unheimliche Erinnerung. Und der Lehrer,
der hatte auch Bienen. Da haben wir mit ihm Honig zusammen gemacht. Er hatte einen
großen Garten, da haben wir dann Erdbeeren gepflanzt und so. Das war auch sehr wichtig,
dass man da so ein Lehrer hat, der vermittelt einen Aspekt aus der Natur. Und wenn
man das nicht hat, ist das sehr, sehr schwierig.
(And then, ah, very important for me, at the end of the school year everyone got their own cherry tree to take home. Super! And we could plant the cherry tree in our garden. That was an incredible memory. And the teacher also had bees. We collected honey together with him. He had a big garden and we planted strawberries there and so on. It was also very important to have a teacher like that who conveys an aspect of nature. And if you don’t have that, it’s very, very difficult.)
Eric has learnt “an incredible lot” from this teacher, who “conveyed an aspect of nature” through the hands-on activities such as picking wild cherry trees, grafting and planting them, collecting honey and growing strawberries. In these activities, nature was experienced as a tangible partner – a partner into which labour is invested and which, in return, offers fruit, honey and joy. Rather than viewing the harvesting practices through an exploitative lens, Eric perceives such practical engagement as joyful learning experiences that have formed the foundation of his conservation ideas, which would have been “very, very difficult” to develop without such experiences.
Overall, hands-on contact with animals, plants, and their living environment is highly valued as a fundamental way of forming a close, internal connection with the natural world. As Eric insightfully put it: grasping nature in mind comes from grasping nature in hand. Such physical contact can be simple actions such as touching a worm, holding a bird, hugging a tree, and picking up a wildflower, or it can be more skilful practices, such as building paludariums, grafting fruit trees, and rescuing migrating amphibians. Through these on-ground, practical interactions with nature, people can develop nuanced knowledge about nature, positive emotions towards it and awareness of the relationship between humans and nature.
While participants perceive “grasping nature with hand” as an essential way to initiate and develop experiential, cognitive and emotional connection with nature, they also acknowledge other pathways to experience nature physically. In the next section, I invite readers to join my participants in experiencing nature as a serious leisure.
Interacting with Nature as Serious Leisure
When I started participating in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt in October 2022, weekends became almost the last thing I was looking forward to. I would prefer to spend my after-work time in a more relaxing way than getting up before sunrise and exposing myself to the damp chill of late autumn mornings “in the middle of nowhere in Luxembourg’s nature” (as I often joked with colleagues). Yet, my research participants, such as the volunteer bird ringers at the local section, Reed Marsh, seem to hold a different view.
The local section Reed Marsh is located in a wetland conservation area on the eastern edge of the Canton of Luxembourg. Its main activity is bird ringing, which is mainly done by volunteer ringers led by the founder of the section, Tom. Bird ringing consists of the following techniques: mist-netting, extracting, processing, measuring and releasing. For mist-netting, fine nylon nets are set up along the wetland habitat. The nets are too thin to be visible to birds, so they fly into them (see Figure 2 “Bird netting among the reeds”). To ensure the safety of birds, volunteers do not open the nets in inclement weather such as heavy rainfall. After setting up the nets, the volunteers regularly check the nets every 30 to 40 minutes to ensure all captured birds are extracted in a timely manner. When removing the birds from the nets, the volunteers handle the birds with a gentle but firm grip and carefully untangle the nets from the birds’ wings and legs. The birds are then put into breathable cloth bags and taken back to the ringing station for processing. With ringing pliers, the ringers place a uniquely numbered aluminium ring on the bird’s leg. Then, they determine its species and sex, measure its weight and the length of the wing and leg, and record the data in the database. The birds are released once the ringing is completed and the data are documented.
On February 18th, 2023, I visited the Reed Marsh team for the first time. Tom asked me to meet him at 8:30 am. Upon arrival, I realised that I was already the last person arriving at the wetland. Tom, Ken and John had already started their ringing session.
I feel a genuine love and dedication from Tom, Ken and John. The meet time is early (8:30 today), and the best time to set up the bird sampling net is 30 min before the sunrise, which means in summer it’s going to be around 5am. Ken got up at 6 am on a Saturday morning (me too). John comes from Trier. Tom has been doing this for a lifetime. A regular participation like this requires persistence. Tom also mentioned that sometimes in order to observe the birds, they even set up tents in the wetland and spend the whole night there. (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 18.02.2023)
Love, dedication and persistence are the key words that describe my first impression of these bird ringers. A few months after my visit, Tom introduced Laura to me, who was not present during my visit but was interested in participating in my research interview. Having obtained her Bachelor’s degree in biology and Master diploma in evolutionary anthropology, Laura works at the ecological service of commune W in Luxembourg. Laura learnt about Reed Marsh through her internship supervisor at a nature conservation syndicate in Luxembourg. She joined the local section at the beginning of the large-scale lockdown due to the COVID-19 pandemic:
Wie ich es kennengelernt habe, Reed Marsh, also ich habe als Student, habe ich ein
Praktikum gemacht bei [Name des Syndikats]. Und da war mein Betreuer, er hat von der
Reed Marsh geredet und er hat gesagt, ich kann mal vorbeikommen. Und deswegen, also
ich habe es durch ihn dann kennengelernt, Reed Marsh. Und da bin ich ein paar Mal
da hin und es war auch, also es war genau zu Beginn von Corona. Und man konnte sehr,
sehr wenig andere Sachen machen. Aber Reed Marsh, das war, geradewegs, auch Corona
mit Maske und so, aber trotzdem man konnte geradewegs dahingehen. Und deswegen, weil
es mir so gut gefallen hat, also bin ich am Anfang so zwei Mal die Woche dahin, ich
hab irgend nichts Besseres zu tun. Und irgendwann habe ich gemerkt, auch dass nach
Corona-Zeit es mir immer noch gefallen hat. Und so bin ich da hängen geblieben. […]
Das war wirklich nur Zufall. Ja, weil eigentlich, also wirklich, sagen wir mal so,
er hat das dann vorgeschlagen, aber so wirklich gedacht so, auch das schaue ich mir
jetzt an, das war wirklich, ach verdammt, ist jetzt schon ein Monat hier zu Hause,
ich muss was machen.
(How I got to know it, Reed Marsh, well when I was a student, I did an internship at [syndicate name]. And there was my supervisor, he talked about Reed Marsh and said I could come by. And that’s why I got to know Reed Marsh through him. And I went there a few times and it was right at the beginning of Corona. And you could do very, very few other things. But Reed Marsh, during Corona too, with a mask you could still go straight there. And that’s why, because I liked it so much, I went there twice a week in the beginning, I have nothing better to do anyway. And at some points I realised that even after Corona I still like it. And so I’m sticking around. […] It was really just a coincidence. Yes, because actually, in fact, let’s say, he suggested it back then, but I only really considered it like, let’s now really have a look, it was really, damn, it’s been a month at home, I must do something.)
At the beginning of March 2020, the Luxembourg government adopted a series of control measures amid a sharp increase in COVID-19 cases, including suspension of education activities, promotion of home office, prohibition of large events and limitation of private gatherings. The interruption of occupational routine and restrictions on recreational activities resulted in many people suddenly having an abundance of unoccupied time. In this context, Laura turned to nature to fill this undesired idleness, which is articulated as a choice with no other alternatives and an unintentional “coincidence” that would unlikely to have happened without the excessive free time. However, Laura stayed in the team after the pandemic, even though she no longer needed to pass the time, which suggests that Laura perceived this engagement beyond simply a time killer.
Research found that one common motivation for people to visit nature during the COVID-19 pandemic is to “relax and unwind” (Peterson et al., 2024). Nevertheless, Laura’s account of her experiences, along with my fieldwork at Reed Marsh and exchanges with her fellow volunteers, reveals an alternative narrative of experiencing nature during leisure time that does not necessarily align with a conventional notion of “relaxation”. As discussed before, bird ringing requires technical skills, dedicated time and personal effort. Yet, such demands do not undermine Laura’s involvement. She does not see getting up early on weekends as an off-putting; quite contrary, it is among the reasons why she enjoys working there:
Yimin: […] Aber trotzdem bist du schon im Team geblieben, trotzdem da keine Pflicht dafür
haben. Und darf ich fragen, wieso ist das, dass du, ja, well, there is no obligation,
aber trotzdem bist du geblieben?
Laura: Weil... it is more... also es gibt mehrere Gründe. Erstens, das ist, man macht es
morgens früh. Und ich habe so den Eindruck, wenn ich am Wochenende nichts morgens
plane, dann vertrödele ich den Morgen. Gehe ich dahin, dann habe ich den Eindruck,
ich habe schon etwas gemacht. Es fühlt sich ja, für mich fühlt es sich nicht nach
Arbeit an. Es ist einfach so, ich gehe dahin, ich bin in der Natur. Das ist auch so
was, gerade jetzt auch, wo ich arbeite, ich bin viel im Büro eigentlich und da bin
ich dann draußen und dann habe ich so sozusagen und schon mein Pensum an Natur habe
ich dann bekommen. […] Ich würde nicht einfach so morgens und fünf Uhr grundlos aufstehen,
niemals. Aber wenn ich ein Ziel habe, dann geht es. Und dann ist das kein Problem.
Also stört mich nicht. Also jetzt wo ich arbeite, merke ich, ich kann nicht mehr jedes
Wochenende dahin gehen. Das schaffe ich nicht. Und ich kann auch nicht zwei Tage hintereinander,
weil ich muss irgendwann halt schlafen. Aber ja, trotzdem, irgendwie stört es mich
nicht so. Und irgendwie ist es auch schön, dann ja, irgendwie stört es mich tatsächlich
nicht, dass das so früh ist.
(Yimin: […] But still, you stayed in the team even though there’s no obligation to do so. And may I ask, why is that? Well, there is no obligation, but still, you stayed?
Laura: Because... it is more... there are several reasons. First, it’s something you do early in the morning. And I have the impression that if I don’t plan anything in the morning on weekends, I waste the morning. If I go there, I feel I’ve accomplished something. For me, it doesn’t feel like work. It’s just that I go there, I’m in nature. That’s also something, especially now, while I’m working, I spend a lot of time in the office actually, and there I’m outside, and so to speak, I’ve already fulfilled my quota of nature. […] I wouldn’t just get up at five in the morning for no reason, never. But if I have a aim, I can do it. And then that’s not a problem. So it doesn’t bother me. So now that I’m working, I realise I can’t go there every weekend. I can’t manage that. And I can’t go two days in a row either, because I have to sleep well at some point. But still, somehow it doesn’t bother me that much. And somehow it’s also nice, then yes, somehow it actually doesn’t bother me that it’s so early.)
Laura does not perceive the fact that bird ringing requires her to be active in wetlands early in the morning on weekends as an unpleasant challenge or a discouragement, but rather as a joyful impetus that enriches her life with a sense of accomplishment. Her comparison between her engagement with birds and work suggests that this activity is something that she genuinely enjoys rather than an enforced obligation, despite the significant time and energy it demands.
In addition to the willingness to invest time and effort, Laura demonstrates a strong sense of passion and identity alignment with this engagement. She notes that she often speaks excitedly and frequently to her family about the wetland reserve, and as a result, her grandparents and aunt visited Reed Marsh to watch the swallow migration:
Also weil ich es mag und so viel immer über Reed Marsh rede, weil, immer wenn wir
irgendwie, Sachen die man mag, auf die, auf die kommt man ja automatisch immer auf
das zu sprechen, über die erzählt man dann mit Leidenschaft. Und weil ich dann oft
über die Reed Marsh rede, weil ich es sehr mag, dann meine Großeltern und meine Tante,
die waren dann auch schon mal so kommen, als die Schwalben im Juli – das ist so schön,
das musst du dir anschauen, das ist so schön, weil die kommen dann und dann fliegen
die so umher, es war immer mehr um Tausende und dann gehen sie in den Schilf schlafen.
Das ist ein richtiges Spektakel. Und dann sind sie gekommen, um das zu schauen.
(So, because I like it and I always talk about Reed Marsh so much, because whenever, somehow, when it comes to the things you like, you automatically talk about them, you talk about them with passion. And because I often talk about Reed Marsh, because I really like it, then my grandparents and my aunt, they came when the swallows in July – it’s so beautiful, you must see it, it’s so beautiful, because they come and then they fly around like this, there were always thousands of them and then they go to sleep in the reeds. It’s a real spectacle. And then they come to watch it.)
Laura’s enthusiasm for the wetland reserve and the birds stands out in this excerpt. Her strong identification with the engagement is evident in her self-report of “speaking proudly, excitedly, and frequently about [it] to other people”, and her tendency to “present [herself] in terms of [this engagement] when conversing with new acquaintances” – as she did with me (Stebbins, 1982, p.257). While she began by narrating how her grandparents and aunt were influenced by her passion to come to watch the bird migration, she shifted the focus mid-sentence from narration to a spontaneous and warm invitation to me. It is not an invitation to merely “be in nature” or “do something in nature”, but to immerse oneself in nature by mindfully admiring birds and their migration as a “beautiful spectacle”. The migrating swallows are not merely components of the wetland scenery, but rather the focus of the experience that evokes appreciation and passion.
Laura also observes the shared enthusiasm within the Reed Marsh team among her fellow volunteers:
Laura: Dann, was ich auch so mag, weil ich Anthropologie studiert habe, die anderen zu
beobachten, ich finde es lustig zuzuschauen, gerade die, die so voll Vogel fokussiert
sind, wie die da aufblühen oder, ich finde es lustig, ich glaube, like, denke nicht,
dass ihnen das auffällt. Aber manchmal kommt so ein Rotmilan und dann stehen alle
auf, dann kannst du vergessen. Dann sind sie alle da fokussiert, dann ist alles andere
unwichtig, oder so wie deren Augen glühen, ich mag das, so zuzusehen.
Yimin: Ja, die Begeisterung in den Augen.
Laura: Ja, dass du es so siehst. Und das... das ist einfach irgendwie die Natürlichkeit,
dass du nicht deine Freude unterdrücken musst, weil du dann sozusagen als so Naturfreak
oder so dergestalt bist, weil wir sind dann unter uns. Und ja, du kannst sozusagen
deinen Gefühlen zu den Vögeln dann auf einen freien Lauf lassen.
(Laura: Then, what I also like, because I studied anthropology, is observing other people. I find it interesting to see, especially the ones that are so fully bird-focussed, how they glow in high spirits or, I find it funny, I think, like, I don’t think they noticed that. But sometimes a red kite comes and then everyone stands up, then you can forget. Then they’re all focused, then everything else is not important, or the way their eyes glow, I like seeing that.
Yimin: Yes, the enthusiasm in their eyes.
Laura: Yes, that you see it like that. And that... that’s just kind of the naturalness, that you don’t have to suppress your joy, because then otherwise you’re like a nature freak or something, because then we’re among ourselves. And yes, you can let your feelings for the birds run free, so to speak.)
Her observation of the nuanced emotional expressions of her fellow volunteers reflects not only her deep understanding of them, but also her own shared sense of wonder towards the birds. Laura’s comments on her observation convey a sense of community and identity. The sentence “we’re among ourselves” signals her identity alignment with the bird ringers. While within the community, the excitement about birds is regarded as “naturalness”, namely something normal and common, such enthusiasm might be considered negatively as exaggerated or even pretentious as a “nature freak”. As such, the wetland reserve represents a special safe space to share their passion for birds unreservedly.
Laura’s engagement with birds at Reed Marsh began as a way to pass time during the COVID-19 lockdown, and evolved into a form of passionate leisure that embodies personal effort, dedication, fulfilment and identity alignment. These features convey a sense of seriousness, that Laura takes her engagement with birds seriously as something meaningful and enduring, rather than an evanescent pleasurable pastime. This “seriousness” does not undermine her enjoyment of the experiences, as it entails “earnestness, sincerity, importance, and carefulness, rather than gravity, solemnity, joylessness, distress, and anxiety” (Stebbins, 1982, p.258). As such, I came to understand that nature can be experienced and valued as serious leisure. Through the lens of serious leisure, Laura’s gradually developing connection with birds and the wetland crystallises through both experiential and emotional dimensions.
This combination of seriousness and joyfulness is also evident in other participants’ discourses on their engagement with nature. Eric shared his extensive experiences of carrying out various on-ground conservation projects in his early years. These projects demanded substantial physical, mental and time investment, and Eric undertook them on a full voluntary basis outside of work. He spent five years conducting fieldwork in Luxembourg’s natural landscapes and an additional five years co-authoring an atlas of breeding birds in Luxembourg, based on this fieldwork, which was published by the predecessor of LetzEarth. Disappointed by the lack of awareness and institutional action to prevent the overexploitation of natural habitats, Eric, alongside Tom, mobilised grassroots donations for the purchase of land in Northern Luxembourg to establish nature reserves. This initiative eventually evolved into the establishment of LetzEarth’s conservation foundation, GreenLove. He also engaged in building one of the biggest wildlife rescue stations in Luxembourg. While none of these projects sound like light tasks, Eric perceives these experiences with nature as “incredibly fun” and remarked that he was still trying to continue some activities in nature as much as possible despite age-related mobility limitations:
Aber das macht unheimlich Spaß. Ich bin jetzt 81, leider muss ich jetzt feststellen,
also mit der Dynamik, die ich mal früher hatte, ist es nicht mehr so. Aber das ist
das Leben, das ist normal. Man wird älter und ich mache jetzt nur noch das, was ich
schaffe. Ich habe Probleme mit meinem Knie und so. Ich mache jetzt nur noch das, was
mir Spaß macht. Ich helfe Guihelm und Tom beim Ringen. […] Aber daher will ich dann
noch so gut ich kann, macht mir Spaß. Ich bin nach wie vor ein begeisterter Ornithologe.
Also die Vogelwelt interessiert mich natürlich nach wie vor am meisten. Aber ich bin
genauso interessiert an Pflanzen, an alles was kreucht und fleucht, alles was rein
der Natur vorkommt interessiert mich.
(But it’s incredibly fun. I’m 81 now, unfortunately, I must admit that I no longer have the dynamism I used to have. But that’s life, it’s normal. People get older and now I only do what I can manage. I have problems with my knees and so on. I only do what I enjoy now. I help Guilhem and Tom with ringing. […] But that’s why I still want to do as much as I can, I enjoy it. I’ve always been an enthusiastic ornithologist. Well of course I’m still most interested in the world of birds, as always. But I’m just as interested in plants, in everything that creeps and flies, everything that occurs in nature interests me.)
Eric’s genuine and enduring love for actively engaging with nature is evident in these excerpts, as showcased in his continuing involvement in bird ringing. Although his stamina declines due to ageing, his high spirit and perseverance remain. His remarks indicate the psychological continuity for this lifelong endeavour with nature, which is another essential quality of serious leisure (Stebbins, 1982). The enjoyment and dedication have forged a lasting and close bond between Eric and nature.
Like Eric, Bob was an old-timer of LetzEarth. He worked as a tax inspector in the UK before moving to Luxembourg in his twenties to serve as an EU official responsible for translating and editing. Upon settling down in the town M in south-western Luxembourg in the 1980s, Bob and his ex-wife engaged in local conservation and were among the founders of the local section M. In 2020, he was awarded the prize “GreenLove” by LetzEarth for his lifelong outstanding dedication. According to Bob, one of the reasons he was awarded the prize was his leadership in creating a standing water area by excavation of ponds to restore biotope diversity around town M, as a remedial measure for the environmental impacts of infrastructure development:
We got the prize GreenLove for digging lots and lots of ponds because M has very heavy soil. If you dig a hole in M and just leave it, it fills with water and you’ve got a pond. So, we did, we dug ponds and we did planted hedges and we cut hedges and we planted trees, and we did all kinds of things and we were amazingly active. But it’s exhausting. [laughing] After a time you start thinking “I can’t keep up this pace.” So gradually slowed down a bit, but we, we were really active. […] What’s really fun, what’s really “dirty” though, is digging a pond by hand. I mean we, the first one we did in M, we took an entire summer holiday to do it, the school holidays. And we have people there every single day, just with spades and shovels and wheelbarrows. And it requires incredible organization because if you have people just digging a hole, then they reach a point where you think, “How do I get the earth out of this hole? I haven’t left a barrow run.” [Yimin laughing] So you have to dig a barrow run. [laugh] I mean, you really get the sense though, at the end of that work, you’ve done something incredibly constructive. Because, like we said, in M, you just leave nature to establish itself. Just dig the hole and nature will come. The vegetation will come, and the rainwater will come, and it’s got nowhere else to go so it just fills the pond. And after a time you’ve got the most amazing habitat there and it’s very very inspiring.
Digging ponds in an area with “very heavy soil” is obviously time-consuming and laborious work that was “exhausting” and “took an entire summer holiday,” indicating the commitment and effort that Bob put into his engagement with nature. Meanwhile, his passionate involvement and sense of achievement stand out through several emotional expressions with positive connotations of enjoyment such as “what’s really fun”, “incredibly constructive”, “most amazing habitat” and “very very inspiring”. The example of someone who might forget to leave a barrow run and therefore would end up trapping himself in the hole implies that the work required skills and careful planning – in his words, “incredible organisation” – and humorously frames the activity as a fun experience rather than a tedious or arduous work. Therefore, it can be concluded that Bob also experienced nature as a form of serious leisure. The challenging but fun work has paid off for both Bob and nature. Bob had the opportunity to personally experience nature’s self-reconstruction and reaction to human interventions, which deepened his inner connection with nature. The pond area has evolved into one of Luxembourg’s nature reserves, serving as a successful example of renaturalisation and compensation for infrastructure development, thereby projecting the dynamics and balance that people seek in their relationship with nature.
Maria’s case provides another example of how engaging with nature as serious leisure promotes a deeper, internal connection with nature. Maria joined the section Nord about ten years ago. Initially, she felt hesitant and timid about participating in the section’s activities, as she was concerned about her lack of specific knowledge about flora and fauna. Eventually, Maria “gathered her courage”11 to try the activities such as butterfly observation hikes, ringing water birds and cleaning nest boxes in the woods, and found them beginner-friendly and interesting. She also began attending continuing education courses offered by LetzEarth on topics such as butterflies and birds. She recounted how she has developed a passion for birdwatching and contributed to the red-backed shrikes inventory created by LetzEarth:
Ich bin auch jetzt süchtig nach, ich habe da ein Fernglas gekauft, schon immer, und
natürlich muss man das haben, wenn man Vögel, und dann bin ich ein paar Mal die Woche
geh ich da, ob schon, da viel mal, ja nicht jeden Tag als super Neues, aber ich gucke
mir dann gerne an Besonderes, wenn die jetzt wieder zurückgekommen sind, die Maise,
und dann gehen die Vögel wieder gucken, sind die da und so? Die sind, die zurück.
Und ich mache jetzt auch beispielsweise bei einer Bestandsaufnahme von dem Neuntöter.
Das ist ein kleiner Vogel, der, also, nur im Sommer bei uns ist. Und das kommt auch
von der [Ort], von der LetzEarth. Die machen jedes Jahr Bestandsaufnahmen von Vögel
und so. [...] Und der Neuntöter, den ich jetzt gemacht habe, den, der sitzt gerne
auf Dornen, Hecken und der spießt seine Käfer da drauf, und so. Ein sehr schöner Vogel.
Die gute Nachricht ja, sie sind sehr häufig dieses Jahr, an der Fenstergestelle, überhaupt,
ich habe auch mit Daniel schon gesprochen.
(I am also now addicted to, I bought a pair of binoculars, always, and of course, you must have them if you [watch] birds. So, a couple of times a week, I go there, even though, well, often it’s not like you have something super new every day, but I like to see something special, like when the tits return, I go watch the birds again, are they there and so not? They’ve returned. And now I’m also participating, for example, in making an inventory of the red-backed shrike. That’s a small bird that’s only with us during summer. And it [the inventory] is also from [place], from LetzEarth. They do bird inventories every year. […] And the red-backed shrike, in which I’ve been engaging now, it likes to sit on thorns, hedges, and it impales its insects on them, and so on. A very beautiful bird. The good news is that they are very common this year, on the window frames, whatever, I’ve also already discussed it with Daniel.)
Maria’s enthusiasm for birdwatching becomes evident in her description of feeling “addicted to it”, a phrase that also suggests sustained participation and deep emotional attachment. She invested in equipment such as binoculars and spent time on repeated observations, which indicates her persistent effort. Furthermore, specific knowledge and skills are developed in this pursuit. Using everyday language, Maria concisely describes red-backed shrikes’ physical appearance (small), behaviours (only in Luxembourg during summer, sit on thorns and hedges and impale the prey on them) and distribution changes (appear more common this year), demonstrating her knowledge gained from her firsthand observation of the bird and relevant training. The observation skills and species knowledge enabled her to contribute to the scientific inventory project. This marks a significant progress in Maria’s engagement with nature and personal growth, given that she once hesitated to join the local section due to a lack of confidence in her knowledge of nature. As such, Maria has also experienced nature in the sense of serious leisure, which has primarily nurtured her cognitive connection with it.
As demonstrated in the above analysis, several common qualities have emerged in participants’ accounts of their experiences engaging with nature: passion, skills and knowledge, identification with the pursuit, significant personal effort, persistence, psychological continuity, personal growth and enrichment. These qualities form the discourse of experiencing nature as serious leisure. Thirty years after first introducing the concept of serious leisure, Stebbins, together with Davidson, examined the concept in relation to nature challenge activity (NCA) in their 2011 book Serious Leisure and Nature. While the authors highlight nature as a dominant element of serious leisure pursuits, they still mainly conceive nature as a “setting” and an “environment” to practice the leisure activities, as indicated in their definition of NCA:
A nature challenge activity (NCA) is a leisure pursuit whose core activity or activities centre on meeting a natural test posed by one or more of the six elements [air, water, land, animals, plants, ice and snow]. A main reason for engaging in a particular NCA is to experience participation in its core activities pursued in a natural setting. (p.2)
As such, NCA as serious leisure substantially focuses on the challenges that participants seek in nature. From this angle, the authors provide detailed descriptions of how relevant outdoor activities are rendered “challenging” by the natural environment, essentially treating nature as the backdrop but not the content of the serious leisure. As a result, the authors did not delve into the link between serious leisure and conceptions of nature (Bissix, 2014). In my participants’ discourses, nature is meaningfully experienced as serious leisure. For them, it is the birds, the ponds that create new biotopes, and “everything that creeps and flies” that have generated curiosity, enthusiasm and the sense of wonder and enrichment. While a passionate birdwatcher like Maira may not hold a bird in her hand as bird ringers like Laura and Christophe do, she nonetheless establishes a personal connection with birds and experiences this connection through sensory engagement. By engaging with nature as serious leisure, people deepen their emotional and cognitive connections with nature, which are reflected in their enjoyment of nature and their strong willingness to learn about and act for nature.
Reaping Meaningful Connections with Nature through Embodied Experiences
In grasping nature with hands and interacting with nature as serious leisure, participants do not conceive nature as an empty substrate or an object that is subjected to exploitation and power domination. Instead, nature is a valued entity – one from which to learn and draw inspiration, deserving of mindful attention, passionate investment and dedicated effort to establish a meaningful connection with, and with which a once-strained relationship needs to be repaired through actions. This constitutes a discourse that embodies experiences with nature foster meaningful human-nature connections. Here I use the preposition of “with” instead of “in” to describe the relevant experiences, because my participants’ discourse does not push animals, plants and biotopes into the background as merely a substrate to perform human activities; rather, nature stands in the centre of the physical and sensory interactions. This perspective suggests that physical engagement with nature driven by curiosity, reverence and self-enrichment sparks people’s positive experiential, emotional and cognitive connections with nature. It provides a meaningful contrast to the capitalist and extractivist view of human-nature interactions, which centres on commodification, the acquisition and appropriation of natural resources, and the perpetuation of exploitative relations between humans and nature, as well as among people.
Dominant scholarly discourses on human activities in nature tend to take a critical stance. The concept of Anthropocene has become an intellectual zeitgeist to address the anxiety over the harmful consequences of “the end of nature” – the idea that nature is no longer untouched by human activities (Lorimer, 2015, 2017). The meta-narrative of Anthropocene tends to view the future as dystopian, where human exploitation of natural resources will eventually threaten the continuity of human life (Chernilo, 2017), highlighting anthropogenic pollution, climate change, and biodiversity loss. At a more micro level, researchers also criticised the “tendency to consider the environment as a backdrop or a substrate for humans/children to act upon: to be loved, to care for, to save, to conserve, to steward, to sympathise for, to respect, to experience and to appreciate” (Weldemariam et al., 2017, p.346). Nevertheless, my data and findings suggest an alternative perspective to ponder on the role of human agency in the human- nature connection. Active direct interactions with animals, plants and natural landscapes form embodied experiences with nature, which nurture people’s connection with nature at cognitive, emotional and philosophical levels.
Sometimes, mindful embodied experiences can be achieved without exercising actions that intervene in nature but simply through bodily sensations. Through feeling and sensing nature, people can refocus on nature itself as an entity with subtle vigour transcending the noise of human society, as Michael’s experience with children shows:
Michael: It was my mother who, die hat uns so Augenbinde genäht. Augenbinde, bin ich mit
den Kindern, so haben wir barfuß dann, sind wir durch die Wald gegangen, mit den Augenbinden
haben sie, einander so mit der Hand genommen, dann den durch den Wald zu gangen, um
den Wald zu fühlen mit den Füßen. With our feet. Meine Mutter hat uns die Augenbinden
genäht, weil wir hatten kein Geld für meine Projekte, also ich hatte kein Geld, gar
nichts. So habe ich angefangen, mit so Augenbinden, die meine Mutter noch genäht hat.
[laughing softly]
Yimin: Ja, dann without seeing anything, you feel better.
Michael: Yes. You can more concentrate if you don’t see. Afterwards you tell the children, “What did you feel?” Or you go to make one kid next to a tree and you say, “Listen, and listen to what you hear.” But it was a funny experience. One of the kids he said afterwards, “I heard a spinner, a Spinne, a spider going down near me.” How could you hear a spider? He thought, he said that, but I don’t believe it. I think he looked, he saw it, yes, but he didn’t hear it. To hear a spider, it must be a noisy spider, I think. [laughing] That was funny, yeah? And then, we had the planes that passed, they didn’t hear them. They didn’t talk about it. It was, for them, perhaps, natural noise for them. There were three in the time set, for five minutes, we concentrate and we just listen what we hear. So there was the noise of the cars on the road, they didn’t tell about it and also the planes that passed, they didn’t tell about it. They excluded these noises. Because they hear it all the time, I think.
Yimin: Yeah and people take it for granted.
Michael: Yes, yes. So the small noises that are just, normally we don’t hear when a bee is fleeing by or some...So, these small... And there are kids that are here, then the leaves are moving in the wind.
Yimin: Yeah, it’s like when the wind, es zieht, wenn es zieht, aber ja? Die Blätter…
Michael: Ja die Blätter rauschen. Das Blätterrauschen. Auch wenn es nur ein bisschen ist,
das hört man, dann muss sich konzentierte, hörte man das. Das sind all die Sachen,
die man auch dann im Wald, dann spüren muss.
(Michael: It was my mother who sewed these blindfolds for us. Blindfold, I went with the children, we walked barefoot through the forest, with the blindfolds, we held each other by hand, then walked through the forest to feel the forest with our feet. With our feet. My mum sewed the blindfolds for us because we didn’t have money for my projects, well I had no money, nothing at all. That’s how I started, with blindfold sewed by my mum. [laughing softly] […]
Yimin: Yeah, it’s like when the wind, it blows, when it blows, no? The leaves...
Michael: Yes, the leaves rustle. The rustling of the leaves. Even if it’s just a little bit, you can hear that, then you must concentrate, you hear that. These are all the things that you must feel in the forest.)
Practical engagement with nature through mindfulness is regarded as an important pathway for cultivating inner connections with nature, as these lived encounters raise awareness by making aspects of nature perceptible and tangible. For example, Michael shared how observing birds breeding in garden nestboxes contributes to an understanding of ecology and prompts reflection on everyday treatment of nature:
Michael: Bilder von Vögeln, das ist schön, aber weil du den selbst im Garten sehen kannst,
wenn sie dann die, ich habe im Moment zwei Brüten bei mir im Garten, zwei so Nistekästen,
wo in dem einen ist eine Blaumeise, in dem anderen ist eine Kohlmeise. Da siehst du
die mal reinfliegen und so, dann kriegst du ein anderes Verhaltnis auch zur Natur.
Das finde ich wichtig für die Kinder oder auch für die Erwachsene, dass sie diese
Erfahrung auch machen können. Dass du die Tiere genau beobachten wirst. Wenn du sie
nicht kennst, wirst du auch nicht schützen.
Yimin: Ja, und dann direkt Kontakt mit den Tiere.
Michael: Direkt Kontakt, ja. Die bringt dann Maden und Raupe oder so, bringt sie dann rein
zu füttern. Das kannst du dann beobachten. Dann siehst du auch, die nützt die Raupe
jetzt hier von der Brennessel. Also muss ich die Brennessel auch mal vielleicht im
Garten stehen lassen. Weil diese auch nützlich nicht nur für die Raupen, mäi auch
für den Vogel, der die Raupen frisst. Dass das ein ganzer Kreislauf ist, die Natur.
Wenn ich alle Unkräuter im Garten rausreiße, dann haben auch diese Insekten und diese
Vögel nichts mehr zu fressen. Dass die Leute wieder die ganzen Kreuze aufsehen wissen.
(Michael: Pictures of birds, that’s nice, but because you can see them personally in the garden, when they, I have two broods in my garden at the moment, two nest boxes, where in one is a blue tit and in the other is a great tit. You can see them flying in there and so on, and you get a different relationship with nature. I think it’s important for children and adults to be able to have this experience. That you observe the animals closely. If you don’t know them, you won’t protect them.
Yimin: Yes, and then direct contact with the animals.
Michael: Direct contact, yes. They bring maggots and caterpillars or something, then bring them in to feed. You can then observe that. Then you can also see [the birds] use the caterpillar from nettles. So maybe I also have to let the nettles grow in the garden. Because it’s not only useful for the caterpillars, but also for the bird that eats the caterpillars. It’s a whole cycle, nature. If I pull out all the weeds in the garden, then these insects and birds have nothing left to eat. People are aware of these crosses again.)
In this example, consciously engaging with nature through embodied experience is perceived as a gateway to an ecological view of nature. The notion of ecology unfolds concretely in on-the-ground, everyday scenarios through mindful observation of nature, forming a “different relationship with nature” – a connection that is empirical rather than conceptual, and driven by experiential environmental knowledge and awareness (“If you don’t know them, you won’t protect them”).
Hendee (1969, as cited in Dunlap & Hefferman, 1975) distinguished “appreciative” and “consumptive” activities in nature. Participants in appreciative nature activities, such as hiking, camping and photography, engage with nature without altering it (in a substantial or intentional way), whereas practitioners of consumptive activities like hunting and fishing intentionally take things from nature (Dunlap & Hefferman, 1975). I borrow this conceptual distinction to elaborate on the significance of embodied experiences with nature for people’s connection with it. My data indicate that, in addition to appreciative experiences with nature such as touching, observing and listening, certain consumptive interactions with nature can also enhance people’s environmental awareness in nuanced ways. An example is how Birgit and Maria have experienced the “Krautwësch” tradition. Krautwësch is bouquets made of wildflowers, herbs, cereals and vegetables for the herbal consecration on the Feast of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary on 15th August in Luxembourg. On 14th August, people collect plants in their neighbourhood and prepare the bouquets. On the day of the Feast, the bouquets are brought to the church and blessed during the Mass (Figure 23). A typical Krautwësch contains the following plants: crops (e.g. wheat, oats, barley, rye), a carrot, an onion, a walnut leaf, dill, oregano, St John’s wort, sorrel, willowherb, kingcup, mugwort, sage, yarrow, camomile and lovage (Arendt et al., 2020). Birgit and Maria have been participating in this tradition for a long time, and they noticed that climate change has manifested in their bouquets:
Birgit: Das ist ja immer viel Arbeit, aber es macht auch Spaß.
Maria: Ja, das macht Spaß. Der einzige Nachteil, finde ich, weil jetzt die Sommer so warm
sind, viele Kräuter finden nicht mehr. Beispielsweise Johanniskraut.
Birgit: Ja, das ist bei mir im Garten verblüht.
Maria: Ja, aber ja, vor einer oder zwei Wochen herrlich. Aber das dauert jetzt noch ein
Monat. Dann ist das verblüht, ist alles also früher jetzt Kräuter.
Maria: Ein bisschen Schwierigkeiten, müsste Marirhimmelfährt-
Birgit: - müsste vorverlegt werden. Nee, das ist wirklich, also, okay, wir nehmen halt jetzt
verblühten Johanniskraut, deshalb dann, man hat nicht mehr so schön blühtig drauf
wie das früher war, sondern eher vertrocknete, die nicht mehr blüht.
(Birgit: It’s always a lot of work, but it’s also fun.
Maria: Yes, it’s fun. The only downside, I think, is that because the summers are so warm now, you don’t find many herbs anymore. For example, St John’s wort.
Birgit: Yes, they withered in my garden.
Maria: Yes, but yes, a week or two ago it was marvellous. But there’s still one more month [until the Assumption]12. Then it’ll have faded, all the herbs are earlier.
Maria: A bit of difficulties, Assumption of Mary -
Birgit: - would need to be brought forward. No, that’s really, well, okay, we’re using faded St John’s wort now, so then, you don’t have the beautiful flowers as it used to be, but rather dried up flowers that no longer bloom.)
Through collecting the plants for Krautwësch over the years, Birgit and Maria are able to experience the concrete impacts of climate change on nature first-hand. For them, climate change becomes real and tangible through direct contact with the wilted St John’s wort. Their observation resonates with LetzEarth’s primary objective of promoting this activity with strong religious characteristics: to familiarise people with the diversity of everyday herbs and to raise awareness about the decline of this diversity. As such, moderate consumptive interactions with nature can render environmental issues tangible, thereby raising public awareness of them.
Moreover, bodily interactions with nature are believed to cultivate positive views of nature and prevent feeling drained by environmental issues. Bob told me how he and his ex-wife brought their children into embodied interactions with nature to encourage their positive attitude toward nature:
So, yeah, and during that time, we were discussing all kinds of environmental issues at home. I remember, I mean the 1970s and 80s there was the oil price shock. And this was when the environmental movement was really accelerated. So we were part of that. And I remember we had to be very careful with the children. We would have mealtimes and we were talking about environmental issues and problems. And at one stage we said, ‘No, we’ve got to be careful about this. We’re talking very negatively. I mean, the children have got to grow up thinking positive about the environment.’ So we made sure that they knew birds, they went on walks with us, they helped dig the ponds, sometimes willingly and sometimes reluctantly.
Bob’s view supports my previous findings, which suggest that hands-on interactions with nature, when experienced mindfully, foster a positive emotional and cognitive connection with nature. Through such embodied interactions, nature is construed primarily not as a desperate victim of human destruction, but as a source of joy, wonder and fulfilment.
The discourse that embodied experiences with nature foster meaningful connections with nature may explain a somewhat surprising result in my research: a critical voice against certain conservation regulations from a nature enthusiast. The 30-year-old Daniel is the vice-president of the section Nord. His interest in nature emerged during the COVID-19 lockdown, when he began identifying species on his walks. His interest was further piqued by the “City Nature Challenge”, where participants were encouraged to take photos of plants, animals, fungi, and anything they found in nature and upload the photos to an online community for nature lovers. During a local butterfly excursion in 2022, he met Birgit, who was impressed by his keen interest in nature and thus invited him to join the section Nord. During the interview, Daniel openly expressed his opposition to the regulation prohibiting the private capture of butterflies:
Daniel: Also, mein Problem, dass man, wie soll ich sagen, man darf keine Schmetterlinge
fangen, pauschal. Also selbst wenn man sie einfach mal einfängt, um sie zu bestimmen
und dann sofort wieder frei ist. Ja, das ist verboten hier in Luxemburg.
Yimin: Man kann keine Schmetterlinge fangen?
Daniel: Ja. Das Fangen, selbst wenn man sie nicht tötet, um sie in die Sammlung zu tun,
dann hab nur kurz fangen und dann wieder so schauen, was habe ich gefangen und dann
sofort wieder frei, was ja überhaupt keinen Schaden angerichtet. Das ist verboten.
Man braucht dann eine Ausnahme, also man braucht eine Genehmigung dafür. Und dann
muss man so eine Formular ausfüllen mit persönlichen Daten und so weiter. Aber das,
was ich ärgere, ich finde, auf diesem Formular muss man auch wissenschaftliche Publikationen
und Referenzen von anderen, in dem Fall Lepidopterologen oder was, die dann bezeugen
können, dass man irgendwie eine Ahnung hat. Aber was ich daran so irrsinnig finde,
ist, wie soll man irgendwie wissenschaftliche Publikationen dazu sagen, wie mal Schmetterlingen
oder sonst, was veröffentlichen können oder schreiben können, wenn es verboten ist,
die Teile überhaupt mal zu fangen. Also da beißt sich die Katze in den Schwanz, weil
man braucht hier seine Referenzen, um fangen zu dürfen, aber um überhaupt was Vernünftiges
schreiben zu können, muss man bereits fangen dürfen. Das ist sehr unsinnig. […] Die
Leute, die müssen Kontakt zu Natur haben, um sich überhaupt damit zu interessieren,
damit auszukennen, damit überhaupt zu verstehen, was es da ist, was man irgendwie
schützen sollte. Und wenn man solche Regeln hat wie hier, dass man nicht mal Schmetterlinge
einmal kurz fangen darf, um sich zu, um sich anzuschauen und zu bestimmen, dann entfremdet
das die Leute von der Natur. […] Also es gibt schon Fälle, wo einzelne Individuen
sehr großen Schaden anrichten. Aber dann sollte man diese Fälle irgendwie separat
behandeln und dann separat die Orchideen oder Bärlapp oder was auch immer, da schützen
sollen. Nicht sagen irgendwie, alles ist PAUSCHAL geschützt. selbst die Arten, wo
es gar keinen Sinn ergibt. Weil dann zieht man nur eine Barriere, eine Mauer zwischen
den Menschen und der Natur hoch und das ist weder für die Menschen noch für die Natur
gut.
(Daniel: Well, my problem is that, how should I put it, you’re not allowed to catch butterflies in general. So even if you just catch them for identification and release them immediately. Yes, that’s forbidden here in Luxembourg.
Yimin: You can’t catch butterflies?
Daniel: Yes. Catching them, even if you don’t kill them to put them in the collection, just catch them briefly and then look and see what I’ve caught and then immediately set them free again, which does no harm at all. That is forbidden. You then need an exception, so you need a licence. And then you have to fill in a form with personal details and so on. But what I find annoying is that on this form you also have to include scientific publications and references from others, in this case lepidopterists or whatever, who can then prove that you have some knowledge. But what I find so insane about it is that how are you supposed to be able to publish or write scientific publications about butterflies or anything else if it’s forbidden to catch them in the first place? That’s cat biting its tail, because you need your credentials to be allowed to catch them, but to be able to write anything that makes sense at all, you have to be allowed to catch them. That’s such nonsense. […] People need to have contact with nature in order to be interested in it at all, to get familiar with it, to really understand what it is that should be protected somehow. And if you have rules like this, where you’re not even allowed to catch butterflies to observe and identify them, then that alienates people from nature. […] Well there are certainly cases where single individuals cause a lot of damage. But then these cases should somehow be treated separately, the orchids or lycopods or whatever should be protected separately. Not somehow say that everything is GENERALLY protected, even the species where it makes no sense at all. Because then you’re just putting up a barrier, a wall between people and nature, and that’s neither good for people nor for nature.)
The legal framework Daniel refers to here is Article 19 (2) of Luxembourg’s Act of 18 July 2018 concerning the protection of nature and natural resources and amending related legislation13:
Sauf autorisation du ministre, sont interdites la capture, la tenue en captivité et
le relâchement dans la nature de spécimens appartenant aux espèces animales sauvages
quelle que soit leur provenance […]
(Unless with ministerial authorisation, the capture, keeping in captivity, and release into the wild of specimens belonging to wild animal species, regardless of their origin, are prohibited […])
Under this Act, the capture of butterflies without prior official authorisation is illegal. Daniel takes a strong critical stance against this regulation, as indicated by phrases such as “I find so insane”, “that’s cat biting its tail”, “that’s such nonsense.”, “that alienates people from nature” and “putting up a barrier, a wall between people and nature”. Here, I do not seek to delve into a discussion on environmental policy and its enforceability, but try to understand Daniel’s view on human-nature connection based on his opinion on this regulation. He opposes this regulation because it delegitimises the practice of capturing in general, attributing exclusively environmentally negative connotations to it. Such connotations disregard non-destructive capture as a means to establish direct physical contact with nature and the significance of hands-on interactions with nature in fostering reciprocal human-nature connections. Moreover, the practical implementation of this regulation, namely, one needs a scientific reference to apply for the authorisation, imposes that discourse that physical interactions with nature can only be legitimised by institutional knowledge. This contrasts with the viewpoint of Daniel and the experiences of other participants, that direct practices with nature are an important pathway to gain environmental knowledge and awareness. As such, Daniel perceives this regulation posing a dilemma of “cat biting its tail” and erecting “a wall between people and nature” that cuts off not only the physical but also the cognitive connection between people and nature, hindering the on-the-ground understanding of “what it is that should be protected”. Daniel’s critical view on the conservation Act suggests that he highly values embodied experiences with nature as a crucial entry point to learn about nature and integrate environmental awareness.
In the current section, I elaborated on the finding that participants value embodied experiences with nature as a significant gateway to meaningful connection with nature at experiential, emotional and philosophical levels. Participants’ lived experiences and opinions reveal that such embodied experiences can be realised through “grasping nature with hands”, namely hands-on interactions with nature, and mindfully experiencing nature as a form of serious leisure. They believe that embodied experiences with animals, plants and biotopes form the foundation of inner connection with nature as a tangible and vigorous entity rather than an overlooked substrate to exert human domination. This view constructs a positive discourse on the role of human activities in human-nature relationships. In the next section, I will move to another perspective that is valued in fostering reciprocal human-nature connections: intellectual engagement with nature.
Intellectual Engagement with Nature
Besides embodied experiences, the nature friends recognise intellectual engagement with nature as an important lens for enhancing one’s connection with nature. They emphasise the significance of identifying species and understanding animals’ habitats, behaviours and ecological roles as means of fostering a closer connection with nature. Several participants are also committed to imparting knowledge about nature and raising environmental awareness through writing, mentoring and consulting. Participants believe that such intellectual engagement promotes a comprehensive perception of nature, particularly concerning the species that are socially constructed as negative. They view intellectual engagement with nature as a meaningful way to mediate tensions between people and nature, encourage environmental behaviours and inspire reflections on human-nature relationships. The sense of wonder and fulfilment that arises from such intellectual engagement acts as a powerful catalyst for further exploration of nature. Through gaining and communicating ideas about nature, people recognise nature as a complex system with intricate internal connections, where species have their own ways of interacting that should not be defined solely by human standards.
Relational Learning about Nature
One prominent form of intellectual engagement is learning. Examining how participants describe and reflect on their experiences of learning about nature and how they facilitate such learning, I noticed that learning about nature is perceived as deeply relational. The process and content of learning about nature involve relationality in three interconnected dimensions: the relationship among people, the relationship between people and nature, and the ecological relationships within nature itself.
Using an example of “learning about seeds”, Michael elaborated on his observations and concerns regarding the declining awareness of ecological processes among people, emphasising that such processes should not be appropriated or obscured by commercialisation:
Wir zeigen, wo kommt der Samen her. Das ist ein Projekt mit den Bienen. Die Bienen
machen die Befruchtung, das wir säen und denen können wir wieder nehmen, um dann neues
Gemüse zu sähen. Wann, fragt die meisten Leute, wo kommt der Samen in diesen Tüten
her? Die kaufen da sind Tüten, mein Salatsamen oder Tomatensamen. Aber dass das dann
auch von den Pflanzen kommt, das sind die auch nicht mehr sich bewusst so richtig.
Also es kommt aus dem Läden.
(We show where the seeds come from. This is a project with bees. The bees do the pollination, we sow the seeds, and we can harvest seeds again to grow new vegetables. Most people then ask, where do the seeds in these bags come from? They buy bags, my lettuce seeds or tomato seeds. But they’re no longer really aware that, those seeds also come from the plants. It comes from the shops.)
Therefore, he believes it is important for people to (re)learn about nature:
It’s important to learn about it. Because the other generations before they knew everything about nature. And now people in the big cities they don’t know any more anything. And I think there’s more than one generation that got lost there. Because it was also everything of, we knew about nature was transported from the grandparents to the parents and the children and so on. And there was a cut when we went into big cities.
Michael emphasises learning about “where seeds come from” as a dynamic, relational process involving plants, animals and human practices, rather than “what seeds are” as isolated botanical units. Here, learning about seeds is framed as understanding the interconnectedness within nature: that the life cycle of plants is closely linked to other organisms like bees, and therefore, seeds should be perceived as part of the ecological process instead of merely as commodities. In addition to the content of learning, Michael also perceives the process of learning about nature as relational. According to him, the widespread lack of knowledge about nature today is largely a result of diminished close contact with nature caused by people’s migration to urban areas. This view suggests that learning about nature is believed to occur through a direct relationship with nature. In the meantime, Michael believes that learning about nature is achieved through relationships among people, for example, intergenerational connections that pass on knowledge and experiences.
For Eric, the “key experience” that sparked his love for birds is his first successful identification of a fieldfare:
Aber dann gab es da ein Schlüsselerlebnis. Meine Mutter, die hat im Winter immer Vögel
gefüttert, damals gab es noch echte Winter mit viel Schnee. Heute ist es Konfekt.
Gut. Und dann hat her, meine Mutter hatte dann eine Futterstelle eingerichtet hinter
dem Fenster, dann saß ich hinter der Gardine und habe dann gesehen, welche Vögel kommen
da. Und da hat, damals hatte die Vorgängerin von LetzEarth, die Vögelschutzliga. Die
hat einen Büchlein veröffentlicht, die wichtigsten Vögel Luxemburg. Und das hat meine
Mutter mir geschenkt. Es gab damals in unserer Familie, in unserem Haus, gab es wie
gesagt jetzt aber schon drei Bücher. Es gab die Bibel, [laughing], dann hatte meine
Mutter mir, den Meyers Kinderschul-Lexikon geschenkt. Das war so ein Ding, sagen wir
mal, ein Lexikon mit allen über die Natur hauptsächlich. Ja, ja, ja, ja. Und ob du
glaubst oder nicht, ich habe dieses Buch auswendig gekennt. Also, tatsächlich. Ich
habe nur immer darin gelesen und habe da eine ganze Menge gelernt, auch wenn ich nicht
alles verstanden habe. Und das dritte Buch war dieses Vögelbuch, Vögel. Und ja, dann
habe ich dann den Vögel nach-, zugeschaut, das war sehr schön. Und da plötzlich taucht
ein Vogel auf, der gar nicht, den wir noch niemals gesehen hatten. Auch meine Mutter
hat ihn noch nie gesehen. So wie eine Amsel, ich habe das auch hier in diesem großen
Buch beschrieben. Du hast das ja. Das habe ich auch beschrieben da. Und plötzlich
saß dieser Vogel da wie eine Amsel, aber grau und braun. “Wah! Was ist das?” Und dann
in meinem Büchlein, tatsächlich, da war der Vogel abgebildet, da war eine Wacholderdrossel,
damals, war die äußerst selten, heute brüten sie in Luxemburg, heute, aber damals
war sie nur im Winter da, na? Wow ich war so begeistert, und da begann meine Liebe
zu den Vögeln.
(But then there was a key experience. My mother, she used to feed birds during winter – back then we still had real winters with lots of snow. Today it’s just confectionery. Anyway. So, my mother had set up a feeding station behind the window, and I would sit behind the curtain and watch which birds came. And then, back then, the predecessor of LetzEarth, the Bird Protection League, had published a booklet about the most important birds of Luxembourg. And my mother gave it to me as a gift. At that time, in our family, in our house, there were, as I said, only three books. There was the Bible [laughs], then my mother gave me the Meyers Children’s School Encyclopedia. That was like, let’s say, an encyclopedia mainly about nature. Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, and believe it or not, I knew that book by heart. Well, really. I just kept reading it and learned a lot from it, even if I didn’t understand everything. And the third book was this bird book, birds. And yes, I watched the birds, it was wonderful. And then suddenly a bird appeared that we had never seen before. Even my mother had never seen it. It looked like a common blackbird, I also described this in the big book, you have it. I described it there. And suddenly this bird was sitting there, like a blackbird, but gray and brown. “Wow! What is that?” And then in my booklet, really, the bird was illustrated, it was a fieldfare. Back then, it was extremely rare. Today they breed in Luxembourg, but back then they were only around in winter, no? Wow, I was so excited, and that’s when my love for birds began.)
In this account, young Eric’s learning about nature, particularly birds, began from two aspects. On the one hand, he eagerly engaged with cognitive learning by reading and even memorising the Meyer Children Encyclopaedia, despite not fully understanding its content. On the other hand, what he highly values as “key experience” is the direct observation and identification of birds. The highlight of this experience lies not merely in acquiring factual knowledge about the fieldfare from the handbook, but in forming a direct, affective relationship with birds. As he put it, “that’s when my love for birds began”. Through identification and recognition, previously unfamiliar, or even unseen species are no longer “something” vague and abstract, but become “someone” with a concrete form of existing, clear presence and identity, which creates a sense of personal relationship. This process showcases a form of relational learning about nature, where learning is fostered through lived experiences and personal connections.
Similar to Eric’s passion for birds, Birgit has a particular interest in bees and wasps. Besides serving as the president of the local section Nord, she also volunteers as a wasp consultant for LetzEarth, advising people who are concerned about wasp nests. The goal of such consultancy is not to assist people in removing the nest and eliminating the wasps, but rather, to calm people down by explaining that wasps do not attack humans blindly and to offer ways to co-live with wasps. Birgit shared her thoughts about her relationship with wasps in the interview:
Also Jugendliche habe ich auch [making a shocking face]. Ja, man wusste auch nicht,
Wespen sind wichtig für die Natur. Und so man hat das einfach so gelernt, "Wespen
stechen, Wespen sind schlecht, Wespen stören, man kann Allergie bekommen, man kann
sogar sterben davon." Die Tiere waren einfach negativ. Man hat sich einfach nicht
die Zeit genommen, um sie mal wirklich zu beobachten, was sie machen und so weiter.
[…] Zu Hause habe ich sowieso Vogeltränke stehen und da kommen die Wespen dann auch
trinken, weil sie halt um, so wie gestern warst es so schwül warm, über 30 Grad und
so. Die müssen dann auch die Nester kühlen. Und dann kommen die Arbeiterinnen heraus,
nehmen Wasser auf, und bringen das wieder ins Nest rein und damit kühlen sie das Nest
und sie machen auch mit den Flügeln, dass es verdunstet, um Kühle in das Nest einzubringen.
Und wenn die da dann sitzen und das Wasser aufnehmen, und dann beobachtet man sie,
wo sie hinfliegen. Das habe ich dann anfangs auch gemacht. Da habe ich auch gemerkt,
ah, da oben, da ist das Nest, da liegen reinraus.
(Well, as a teenager, I also had [making a shocking face]. Yeah, we didn’t know that wasps are important for nature. We just learned things like, “Wasps sting, wasps are bad, wasps are annoying, you can get an allergy, you can even die from it.” These animals were just negative. People just didn’t take the time to really observe them, to see what they actually do, and so on. […] At home, I have a birdbath anyway, and the wasps come to drink there too, because they, like it was so hot and humid like yesterday, over 30 degrees, like that. They also need to cool their nests. So the worker wasps come out, collect water, and bring it back to the nest to cool it down. They also fan their wings, so the water evaporates, to cool down the nest. And when they sit there and drink the water, you can watch where they fly off to. That’s what I did at first. I noticed, ah, up there, that’s where the nest, lying there.)
Birgit attributed both her own and others’ biased view of wasps solely as dangerous animals to a lack of relational understanding: specifically, a lack of knowledge about their ecological role and the absence of a personal, attentive relationship with the species. The example of her personal observation of wasps implies a strong sense of attentiveness and signals the development of a close, caring relationship with the species. Through careful observation of their behaviour, a more nuanced understanding of the wasps emerges: stinging is not their only behavioural trait; they are not always aggressors, but also engineers with sophisticated survival strategies. Such observation enables one to perceive species in their own right beyond anthropocentric assumptions and fears, fostering a convivial relationship with nature.
Observing and identifying species also play a fundamental role in Daniel’s connection with nature. Daniel “didn’t know much about nature before 2020” 14 until he started photographing and identifying the plants and animals he saw while taking walks during the COVID pandemic. He participated in the “City Nature Challenge”, an annual international community science competition for people to find and document plants and wildlife in cities. Participants of this challenge share their observations through the online platform iNaturalist, which is “an online social network of people sharing biodiversity information to help each other learn about nature” (iNaturalist, n.d.). The following screenshot illustrates how iNatualist works:
Daniel considers this experience to have had an important influence on his learning about nature:
Seit dann im Frühjahr 2020 angefangen habe, meine, zu dokumentieren, was in der Natur
so kräust und fleust und wächst, da habe ich halt schrittweise immer weiter gelernt.
Ich meine, ich habe dann auch einige Bestimmungsbücher, über zu Pflanzen, Pilzen,
Vögel, Schmetterlinge, Insekten, im Allgemeinen und so weiter, habe ich mir dann auch
besorgt, aber hauptsächlich auch habe ich dann dadurch gelernt, also zumindest der
Bestimmung, die Arten zu erkennen, indem ich die Fotos auf iNaturalist gepostet habe
und dann gesehen habe, was dann wie die, ja die automatische, der automatische Vorschlag
ist, was es sein könnte, respektive dann, gibt es ja auch noch andere Leute auf iNaturlist,
die dann auch noch eine Bestimmung liefern oder bestätigen. Und so habe ich dann mich
Stück für Stück immer weiter familiarisiert mit den Arten und so weiter. So viel zumindest
zum Bestimmen der Arten und dann ja weitere biologische Zusammenhänge oder ökologische,
dass das kommt dann noch so ein bisschen dazu. Je mehr man, wie sagt, die Protagonisten
in der Natur kennt, dann auf einmal versteht man auch wie die miteinander so ein bisschen
wechsel, wirken. Genau.
(Since I started in spring 2020 to document everything that crawls, flies, and grows in nature, I’ve been always gradually learning more and more. I mean, I also have some identification handbooks on plants, fungi, birds, butterflies, insects, in general and so on, I also got. But mainly I learned through, at least when it comes to identifying species, by posting photos on iNaturalist and seeing what the automatic suggestions were for what it might be. And there are also other people on iNaturalist who provide or confirm identifications. In this way, I got more and more familiarised with the species and so on, little by little. So much at least for identifying the species, and also further biological or ecological connections, that comes then. The more, like I said, the more you know about the protagonist in nature, then you also understand how they exchange, influence each other. Exactly.)
In this example, Daniel’s learning about nature is relational in two ways. First, it is socially relational in process. Identifying species is a community-based activity. Learning about the species builds on collaborative knowledge within the online community. Second, it is ecologically relational in content. The outcome of this learning is not limited to identifying species individually but leads to the perception of ecological interactions among them. Identifying a species is not only about acquiring isolated factual knowledge, but also about understanding it within a broader ecological context involving intricate interactions. As such, this relational learning about nature fosters knowledge about nature and ecology, thereby enhancing cognitive connection with nature.
In addition to the City Nature Challenge and learning with the online community, he shares his experiences of exploring new species during activities organised by the section Nord:
Also was ich interessant finde ist, wenn ich irgendwelche Dinge sehe, die ich noch
nicht gesehen habe, irgendwelche Arten. Ich meine zum Beispiel am 1. Mai bei der Wanderung,
wo ich auch mitgeholfen, die zu organisieren, da wurden, da ging es auch um Weiher
und so weiter. Und da wurde auch eine Reuse am Vortag ausgelegt, wo dann halt Amphibien
sich drin sammeln können, damit wir dann am Tag der Wanderung da vielleicht was zu
sehen haben. Und da war alles drin. Da hatten wir, das haben wir, Bergmolch, den man
häufiger sieht, der war da drin, aber dann war auch der Fadenmolch drin, der Teichmolch
und sogar einen Kammmolch war drin und auch ein Blutegel, sogar. Das finde ich, besonders
der Kammmulch in diesem kleinen Weiher, der von der SICONA15 da erst ein paar Jahre vorher angelegt wurde, war schon, wir waren beeindruckt, dass
da sogar einen Kammemulch drin zu finden war. Genau. Oder bei dieser Wasseramsel Beringung.
Ich meine, natürlich die winzig kleinen Wasseramsel. Die waren schon cool, weil die
irgendwie so einen riesigen Schnabel hatten. Und die waren so ein paar kleine [xxx]161 schon sehr lustig aus. Aber was ist dann noch was besser fund, das war, dass wir
da am Ufer zufälligerweise da haben. Da habe ich eine Pflanze gesehen, die ich noch
nie gesehen habe. Das war irgendeine Sommerwurzen, habe ich leider den Namen vergessen.
aber so eine parasitäre Pflanze, die gar kein Chlorophyll ausbildet und an anderen
Pflanzen, da gibt es ja sehr viele von diesen Sommerwurzen. Aber das hier, ich habe
jetzt die genaue Art leider vergessen, aber zumindest dieses [xxx] , das fand ich
schon sehr spannend, so ein Zufall.
(What I find interesting is when I see some things I’ve never seen before, whatever species. I mean, for example, on May 1st during a hike I helped organise, there was, it was about ponds and such. The day before, a trap had been set to collect amphibians, so we might have something to observe during the hike. And there was everything in it. We had, we have alpine newts, which people see more often, it was there, but also smooth newts, palmate newts, and even a crested newt were inside, and even a leech. I found, especially the crested newt in this small pond, which had been released by SICONA only a few years before, was really, we were amazed that even a crested newt was found there. Exactly. Or during the dipper bird ringing. I mean, of course the tiny little dippers. They were cool, because they somehow have such big beaks. And there were a few small [xxx] quite fun. But what I found even better was that we happened to have on the bank, I saw a plant there that I’d never seen before. It was some kind of summer root, unfortunately I forgot the name, but it was a parasitic plant that doesn’t produce any chlorophyll and [is parasite] on other plants, there are lots of these summer roots. But this one, unfortunately I forgot the exact species, but at least this [xxx], I found it very exciting, such a coincidence.)
During this interview conducted almost two months after the hiking, Daniel could still effortlessly remember and list the different newt subspecies that he had observed at the time. In Daniel’s view, the individual animals are not merely “newts” as a homogeneous species, but are perceived with distinctions. This reflects not only his nuanced understanding of the species, but also an emotional engagement, as implied by the phrase “we were amazed”. His emotional connection with nature, marked by curiosity, wonder and enthusiasm, particularly stands out in the example of the parasitic plant. Although he cannot remember its exact name, his intuitive understanding of parasitic relationships between plants, along with the lingering excitement and sense of wonder, remains vivid. As such, his learning about nature is relational: it occurs through direct interactions with nature, interplays with emotional engagement with it, and visualises ecological interactions within nature.
Considering himself a “small expert in butterflies in Luxembourg”16, Daniel also shared how his engagement with butterflies had developed during the past few years. It can be largely attributed to a personal network. When he started doing nature photography during the COVID-19 pandemic, “butterflies in particular crystallised as my main interest”17, and therefore, he joined the butterfly excursion organised by the section Nord in 2022. In this excursion, Daniel met Mark, one of the most prominent lepidopterists in Luxembourg. As their acquaintance developed over time, Marc showed Daniel his collection of butterfly specimens, taught him techniques to research butterflies and took him on transactions. Later, through Mark’s introduction, Daniel began volunteering at the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST), where he regularly conducts systematic surveys along transects to gather data on insect distribution.
Ja, daraufhin, ich meine, hab ich auch dann privat mich mit Mark ausgetauscht. Und
da hat er mich auch mal mit zum Leuchten genommen, also um Nachts, dann einfach eine
Lichtquelle, da irgendwo platziert mit einem Netz runter rum, um halt Nachtfalter
anzulocken. […] auch hat er mir das gezeigt und dann auch ein paar Microlepidoptera,
die man heute unter der Stereo-Lube untersuchen muss, die er mitge-, der er dann angefangen
hat. Dann am Tag darauf dann gezeigt, wie er das dann irgendwie auch präpariert in
seine Sammlungen gezeigt und so weiter. Er ist auch mit mir seine Transakte mal gelaufen,
und hat auch den Kontakt zum LIST hergestellt. Wie gesagt, ja gut, das war dann nicht
direkt über LetzEarth, aber das war, da dann die Schmetterlingswanderung, wo, wo ich
dann auch einerseits von LetzEarth rekrutiert wurde und andererseits habe ich dann
Kontakt mit Mark bekommen, der mir dann auch noch weitere Dinge gezeigt hatte, dass
er dann irgendwie Kontakt zum LIST hergestellt hat. Also das war schon irgendwie dann,
da haben wir mal eine wichtige Wanderung davon, weil da viel Kontakt hier und da hin
hergestellt wurde.
(Yes, after that, I mean, I also exchanged privately with Mark. And he once took me with him to light things up, so at night, he simply placed a light source somewhere with a net around it to attract moths. […] and he showed me that and then also a few micro-Lepidoptera that you have to examine nowadays under the stereoscope, which he started with. Then the next day he showed me how he somehow prepared them in his collections and so on. He also went through transects with me and put me in contact with LIST. As I said, well, it wasn’t directly via LetzEarth, but it was the butterfly excursion, where I was recruited by LetzEarth on the one hand and on the other I got in touch with Mark, who then showed me other things and somehow made contact with LIST. So that was kind of an important excursion, because a lot of contacts were made here and there.)
This excerpt shows that Daniel’s connection with butterflies is anything but an unaccompanied journey involving only himself and the butterflies. His practical learning about the species is essentially supported by the “lot of contacts”, including the ones with Mark and LIST. Without Mark’s guidance, it would likely be difficult, if not entirely impossible, for Daniel to get such direct, hands-on experience with the specific lepidopterist research practices, which significantly promotes his learning process from a practical perspective. As such, Daniel learns about lepidoptera through the relationship with the knowledge keeper. This relational dimension of learning about nature is highly valued, as indicated by Daniel’s comment, “that was kind of an important excursion”.
Similar to Daniel’s fruitful learning from Mark, Michael had an interesting experience of learning from a “donkey whisperer” in southern France. When Michael started working at the Green Charlet, he had to develop nature pedagogy projects from scratch with his colleagues. One of Michael’s first projects at the nature activity centre was to build a donkey stall. To prepare for this project, Michael visited the donkey whisperer to learn about the animal.
It was a woman who was very like eine Pferdflüstererin18, also eine Eselflüstererin19, who could do very good with the donkeys. And there I went for a week with her, we made the stalls there. It was very interesting. We learnt everything about donkeys there, how to guide them, how to look after their feet, everything and so on. We even went to a guy who makes the saddles for them.
One of the takeaways from this learning experiences was that donkeys are not as unintelligent as they are often assumed to be:
Michael: The donkey was always considered as a not intelligent.
Yimin: Oh yeah, same here in Europe?
Michael: Not being intelligent, yes. And if you learned bad in class, for example, you said you were a donkey. And even there was a time, the children who didn’t work well in class, they had the donkey ears. They had to put them on their head, on their head and they had to sit on the last bench of the class. That was before my, before I lived. But I remember that, yes. A generation before, yes. Yes, always donkey considered as a not intelligent animal, but they are more intelligent than horses, because you say they are stubborn, no, they are not stubborn. If you come on your way, you come on a place where there is water, in the middle of the road or in the wood, the donkey, he will not go in the water when you pull him. He stops, because he does not know if it’s deep or not, the water. A horse is going, just leading you, leading him through the water. There’s no problem. He’s not reflecting it. And then the donkey, also when there is some problem and he is afraid, so he runs and after a few passes he stops and he returns and he looks, what was the problem now? And the horse is running and running, never turning back.
Yimin: Oh yeah, the horse is like always forward.
Michael: Yes, forward. The donkey is more sensitive also.
Yimin: Oh, I didn't know about that.
Michael: Yes, therefore, I didn’t know also because I did that stalls in South France. This woman really, she knew everything about donkeys. She lived all her life with donkeys. That was her life in donkeys. But it was a kind of [xxx] there, where the housing, because she made more, she did care more for the donkeys than for people.
The relationality of Michael’s learning about donkeys is intriguing from three perspectives. First, it is socially relational. This learning process is fundamentally realised and supported through the connections that Michael had with the people who knew well about the animal, such as the donkey whisperer and the saddle maker. Secondly, the learning was grounded in the forming of a living relationship with the animal rather than abstract facts from textbooks or lectures. Taking care of the animal and learning relevant skills from someone who deeply cares for it is a profoundly relational act. Third, the learning outcome is a changing perception of the animal. The example of using donkey ears as the symbolic punishment for underachieving children reflects a long-standing association of donkeys with insensitivity and stupidity. However, through directly engaging with the animal and a caring relationship with it, Michael came to understand donkeys beyond cultural stereotypes, forming a new cognitive connection with the animal. Therefore, the learning is deeply grounded in a relational context where the relationships between people and donkeys unfold rather than in isolated abstract facts.
Reflecting on his experiences of learning about nature, Michael offered the compelling metaphors of sponge and blinkers, which I find intriguingly capture the multidimensional relationality of learning about nature:
Ja, das ist auch, weil ich viel Kontakt damit hatte, all diesen Leuten hatte. Im Green
Charlet habe ich auch dann Spezialisten für den Wald begenet , ich habe Spezialisten
für die Vögel begegnet und sogar dann, wie man dann Steinmauern baut, die auch gut
für die Natur sind, wo Tiere sich verstecken können. Es ist halt gut, wenn man irgendwo
arbeitet, wo viele Spezialisten sind, dann kann man von jedem so was aufsaugen. So
wie ein Schwamm musst du sein und alles so aufsaugen. Information von da, von da.
Wenn du eine Frage hast, kannst du zu jemanden hingehen. Das ist schön für mich als
Lehrer. Von alles ein bisschen kannte, aber nicht viel. Nicht ein Spezialität. Machmal
wenn du sehr Spezialist bist, hast du ein bisschen Scheuklappen. Du siehst nicht nach
rechts nach links alles. Du hast Scheuklappen haben. Du musst kucken zu allen Seiten,
so finde ich.
(Yes, that’s also because I had a lot of contact with all these people. At the Green Charlet I also met specialists for forest, I met specialists for birds and even how to build stone walls that are also good for nature, where animals can hide. It is indeed good when you work somewhere where there are lots of specialists, then you can absorb things from everyone. You must be like a sponge and absorb everything, information from here and there. If you have a question, you can turn to someone. That’s nice for me as a teacher, I know a little bit about everything, but not much. Not a speciality. Sometimes when you’re very specialised, you have a bit of blinkers. You don’t see everything from right to left. You have blinkers. You have to look to all sides, I think.)
According to Michael, one should learn about nature like a sponge and without blinkers. By learning like a sponge from a community of nature friends, one develops knowledge and skills of nature through a personal network. In this way, the learning process is embedded in social ties, and is thus socially relational. The metaphor of the sponge absorbing everything, combined with Michael’s experience of learning from colleagues with diverse focal interests in nature, also suggests his view that learning about nature involves understanding it from different perspectives within a comprehensive context, rather than solely focusing on fragmented aspects. This belief becomes more evident in his metaphor of blinkers. It suggests that any element of nature should not be only learnt or understood in isolation, but rather within a broader, ecological context.
In the examples above, learning about nature is perceived as a highly relational process. Participants value social networks that supported their learning about nature, the bonds formed between people and nature during the learning process, and the ecological interactions they came to recognise as a learning outcome. Relational processes such as observing, identifying, and exchanging ideas with others are considered more important than isolated, abstract facts, as the processes were frequently recalled with passionate emotions, while the factual content often went unmentioned. Participants’ experiences and views also suggest that meaningful connections with nature are fostered in learning that is grounded in real-world and ecological contexts, where direct engagement with nature and ecological interactions within nature can unfold. Relational learning promotes nuanced understanding of species, encourages perceptions that transcend cultural and social bias, and nurtures an ecological view of nature. It also boosts a sense of wonder, curiosity and conviviality towards nature.
While learning about nature is valued as an essential way to engage with it intellectually, participants also emphasise disseminating knowledge and raising awareness about nature as an important pathway to enhance human-nature connections. In the next section, I will discuss how “giving nature a voice” plays a significant role in fostering this connection.
Giving Nature a Voice
Before I begin the discussion in this section, I ask readers’ indulgence to express my respect and condolences for Bob. Just a few months after the interview, I came across an unexpected and saddening piece of news on LetzEarth’s Facebook homepage: Bob had passed away. Although I learned during the interview that Bob was living with cancer, his humour and optimistic spirit touched me so much that I did not expect that he would leave us so soon. His kind words at the end of the interview, “you will never bother me. I just love this kind of contact and I realise I have a lot to say because I’ve done a lot here”, had sadly become a bittersweet full stop for our brief yet joyful encounter, instead of a hopeful comma that signals more wholesome conversations to come. In its tribute post, LetzEarth thanked Bob for his lifelong dedication to “give nature a voice”. I find this thoughtful phrase aptly encapsulates how Bob and his fellow volunteers have been trying to bring people and nature closer together. Therefore, I borrow the phrase here to discuss how Bob and other nature enthusiasts have engaged with nature in a meaningful way.
Although Bob was actively engaged in the physical labour related to nature conservation, such as excavating ponds to restore local biotope diversity, he considered himself rather as a “head worker” who contributed mainly by writing about nature:
I think from my point of view I’ve certainly contributed far more by writing than I have by doing by hand. Because ja, I’ve dug ponds and I’ve planted hedges and I’ve done Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt but I don’t feel entirely at ease with that. I’m not a natural worker with my hands. I'm a head worker. And so if I can contribute by writing, then I prefer to do that. That’s using the skill I have.
Bob’s self-reflection offers an interesting alternative perspective to my first finding that meaningful connections with nature originate from grasping nature in one’s hands. He considered that his multilingual writing and translating skills had contributed more to nature than his hands-on work. He served as the editor for the organisation journal, Rose, for nearly 10 years and authored numerous popular science articles focused on nature. He contributed to several nature-themed publications of LetzEarth and translated major works from German to English. Furthermore, Bob translated and subtitled into English a series of short documentary videos in Luxembourgish, produced by LetzEarth, which introduce nature reserves in Luxembourg. In 2012, he founded the LetzEarth’s Language section, aiming to include people whose most comfortable languages are other than Luxembourgish, German and French in nature-related activities. In the interview, Bob proudly mentioned one of his main works, the English translation of Die Gefiederten Freunde des Großherzogtums20 , an introductory guide to birds that breed in Luxembourg or pass through Luxembourg on migration.
They were discussing whether to do an English version of the Die Gefiederten Freunde des Großherzogtums, because they were already the German and the French version. And I said, “Look, you actually need an English version. There are thousands of people here who are interested in nature, and they read English if they can.”
Bob tried to build a “more personal” bridge between English speakers in Luxembourg and nature using his professional multilingual writing skills as an EU translation officer:
That’s my English. I get a little acknowledgement on the fly because the authors are Eric and Peter, but it says English text by Bob. I was quite pleased with that because I know both Eric and Peter, and I said to them, “Look, I know your German work. I know the French one. Can I change the English slightly? I mean, I make it a different style. And they say, “Yeah, go ahead.” And Peter, in particular, has very good English. So I sent him everything I was writing and he said, “Yeah, I like this. It sounds good.” So it’s very much my style of that. […] I know the way my colleagues write German, most of them are retired schoolteachers. So they write in a rather formal way, which is not my way of writing. So, I mean, they can do that in German and French if they like, but it just sounds terrible in English, which is why I said, I’m gonna make this much more informal, more personal. And several readers have said, I like that style.
Intrigued by “Bob’s style”, I wondered how Bob had “changed the English slightly” to make the text sound “more personal”. Therefore, I read both the original German version of Die Gefiederten Freunde des Großherzogtums and Bob’s translation in comparison. Here, I take the entries “Goldcrest” and “Eagle Owl” as examples for analysis. To give readers a clear view of the changes Bob made in his English translation compared to the original German text, I highlighted the non-literal translation in red. My analysis does not seek to judge whether the German or English version is better, but rather focuses on how Bob’s translation choices, namely additions, omissions and modifications of certain details, include English speakers in Luxembourg into the local conservation discourse and give nature a voice.
| Original German version | English version by Bob |
|---|---|
| Das Wintergoldhähnchen zeigt, anders als das Sommergoldhähnchen, eine deutliche Vorliebe für Nadelholzbestände, besonders Fichten, und zieht Hochwälder der parkähnlichen Landschaft vor. Zum Brüten genügen manchmal schon einzelne, in den Laubwald eingestreute Nadelbäume, die durchaus auch in Waldnähe oder gar parkähnlichem Gelände und nahe menschlicher Siedlungen stehen können. Neststandort und Nistmaterial ähneln denen des Sommergoldhähnchens. Das Wintergoldhähnchen ist ein nicht seltener Standvogel, der 1-2 Jahresbruten mit je 8-10 Jungen aufzieht. Es ist die kleinste Vogelart Luxemburgs und Wappenvogel der Zeitschrift „Regulus“. | Unlike the Firecrest, the Goldcrest has a marked preference for coniferous woodland (especially spruce), and for high forest over parkland habitats. It is not picky, though. For breeding purposes, all it sometimes needs is a few conifers in otherwise deciduous woodland. They can be near woodland, or in parkland, or close to human settlements. The positioning and structure of the nest is the same as for the Firecrest. The Goldcrest is a fairly common year-round resident, raising two annual broods of 8-10 young each. The Goldcrest is Luxembourg’s smallest bird, also the national bird, and the emblem of the eponymous national conservation magazine “Regulus”. |
Compared to the original German text, Bob’s English translation introduces several additional details. First, he added a comment, “it is not picky”, after describing the bird’s habitat preference. This is an anthropomorphic expression that subtly attributes a human trait of being undemanding to the bird. Such personification evokes more positive and relatable feelings in readers. Furthermore, Bob’s translation adds two culturally significant pieces of information: that the Goldcrest is the national bird of Luxembourg and that Regulus21 is the country’s national conservation magazine. These additions suggest Bob’s effort to make the translation more inclusive for English-speaking readers who may lack background knowledge about Luxembourg. Instead of assuming prior knowledge from readers, he enhanced the information accessibility and readers’ engagement by providing the context. These details help contextualise the symbolic role of Goldcrest in Luxembourgish culture and conservation efforts. As such, Bob’s translation conveys not only a sense of cultural inclusiveness but also the connectedness between the bird and people.
In the entry on Eagle Owl, we can also see Bob’s cultural sensitivity and awareness of the close connection between humans and birds.
| Original German version | English version by Bob |
|---|---|
| Der Uhu, der wegen seines auffälligen Rufes zu seinem Namen kam, ist die größte Eule Europas. Bis in die 30er Jahre des vorigen Jahrhunderts brütete er in felsenreichen Wäldern und Flusstalern, wo er Felsnischen als Brutplatz auswählte. Danach galt er jahrzehntelang als ausgerottet. 1982 konnte erstmals wieder eine Brut nachgewiesen werden. Augenblicklich dürften 15-20 Paare regelmäßig bei uns brüten, wobei Ringfunde belegen, dass die Neubesiedlung unseres Landes ihren Ursprung aus Wiedereinbürgerungsprogrammen in der Eifel hat. Natürliche Felsen und solche in Steinbrüchen und ehemaligen Tagebaugebieten (Eisenerz) werden als Nistplatz ausgewählt. So brütet der Uhu auch auf dem Gebiet der Stadt Luxemburg. Er ernährt sich von Kleinnagern, Ratten, Igeln und zum Großteil von Vogeln bis zur Größe einer Krähe. Viele Uhus verunglücken an Stromleitungen und Stacheldrahtzäunen oder werden Opfer des Straßen- und Bahnverkehrs. Zudem engt zunehmender Druck Erholungssuchender auf ruhige und entlegene, naturnahe Gebiete ihren Lebensraum ein. | The Eagle Owl is Europe’s biggest owl. It was a breeding species in Luxembourg until the 1930s, occupying nest sites in rocky woodland and valleys and building its nest on rock ledges. For decades afterwards Eagle Owls were absent from Luxembourg, mainly because of hunting persecution, until a pair returned and bred again in 1982. The current breeding population is put at a regular 22-25 pairs. Ringing recoveries have shown that this recolonisation of Luxembourg has its origins in reintroduction programmes in the nearby Eifel region of Germany. Eagle Owl nest sites are natural rock faces and man-made ones in quarries and in abandoned opencast (iron ore) mines. Eagle Owls also breed within the borders of the city of Luxembourg. They feed on small rodents, rats, hedgehogs and – to a great extent – birds, up to the size of a crow. Many Eagle Owls fall victim to collisions with power lines and barbed-wire fences, or with road vehicles and trains. They also suffer from habitat disturbance caused by human intruders in remote, natural parts of the country. |
In this entry, Bob’s nuanced alterations to the original German text can be classified into four aspects. The first one concerns phonological untranslatability. In German, Eagle Owl is called Uhu [`u:hu], which is a phonetic mimic of the bird’s call. Since its English name is not onomatopoeic, Bob chose not to translate the German explanation of its name. The second aspect is fact-based revision. Since Bob’s translation came five years after the publication of the German version, the breeding status of Eagle Owl in Luxembourg had improved during the time, increasing from 15-20 pairs to 22-25 pairs. As such, Bob made the corresponding revisions in his English text. Thirdly, Bob again introduced contextual information. By specifying the location of the Eifel region, Bob’s translation is more accessible to readers unfamiliar with the natural landscapes around Luxembourg, making the text more culturally inclusive. The last aspect is the translator’s voice. I argue that by bringing his own translator’s voice into the text, Bob gave nature a voice. There are two relevant excerpts in this text, as shown in the following table:
| Original German version | Literal translation 22 | English version by Bob | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excerpt 1 | Danach galt er jahrzehntelang als ausgerottet. 1982 konnte erstmals wieder eine Brut nachgewiesen werden. | After that, it was considered extinct for decades. In 1982, a brood was confirmed for the first time. | For decades afterwards Eagle Owls were absent from Luxembourg, mainly because of hunting persecution, until a pair returned and bred again in 1982. |
| Excerpt 2 | Zudem engt zunehmender Druck Erholungssuchender auf ruhige und entlegene, naturnahe Gebiete ihren Lebensraum ein. | In addition, increasing pressure from people seeking relaxation in quiet, remote areas close to nature is restricting their habitat. | They also suffer from habitat disturbance caused by human intruders in remote, natural parts of the country. |
It is evident that in both excerpts, Bob shaped the translation with his own voice. In excerpt 1, he used the emotive and critical phrase “hunting persecution” to provide additional information on the reason why Eagle Owls once became extinct in Luxembourg. It was not an outcome of neutral “hunting”, which can often be perceived as justifiable human activity for survival or cultural reasons. Rather, it was a tragic consequence of “persecution”, which is a deliberate hostile act aimed at harassment and damage. Compared to the German sentence, Bob’s translation goes beyond a factual description. He critically emphasised that the extinction was not a neutral phenomenon, but a consequence of harmful human activities toward nature. Then, Bob translated the return of Eagle Owls in an active sentence with the species as the subject: “a pair returned and bred again”. Compared to the German sentence whose literal translation is “a brood was confirmed for the first time”, Bob’s translation does not frame the owls merely as an object of observation and research, but rather as agentive individuals actively performing their actions. The sentence “a pair returned and bred” not only describes a neutral ecological phenomenon, but also vividly conveys a hopeful dynamics of life starting anew. Similarly, in excerpt 2, Eric critically reframed the role of human beings in the survival challenges that Eagle Owls are still facing. Instead of keeping the expression with a somewhat positive connotation, “people seeking relaxation in quiet, remote areas close to nature”, Bob pointed out sharply that these people are “intruders” invading Eagle Owls’ natural habitats. In his translation, the birds are again brought to the foreground, becoming the subject of the sentence who “suffer from” such invasion. Therefore, Bob’s critical voice on humans’ disturbance to the species is stronger than the original German text. His critical translator’s voice makes such tensions visible to readers with greater emotional impact, highlighting the fact that the birds are actively living while bearing the harmful consequences of human disturbance. As such, Bob’s translator’s voice gives a voice to the speechless Eagle Owls within the unequal power relationship between humans and nature.
The above examples illustrate how Bob used his translation skills to foster people’s knowledge and awareness of nature. Through language as a medium, he illuminated the close relationship between birds, people and culture, gave the voiceless species a voice within human-nature relations and made these voices accessible to a broader public.
Like Bob, his friends Eric and Birgit are also committed to giving nature a voice. Instead of doing so through writing and translation, they contribute by offering consultation. As a keen ornithologist, Eric volunteered to take consulting calls from people with questions about bird encounters. He shared a case where he convinced a woman to accept a wryneck in her garden:
Eric: Und dann ruft eine Frau mich an, sagen sie mal, „Jetzt bin ich aber wütend wütend
wütend!“„Ja was denn?“„Ich habe ein Nistkasten im Garten hängen. Und da waren jetzt
Meisen, die hatten Eier gelegt und so. Und jetzt kommt so ein Vogel, er sieht aus
wie ein Spatz, so braun und gestreift und so. Und der geht jetzt in den Nistkasten
rein und schmeißt alles aus dem Nistkasten drauf, die Eier und die, die, das Moos
und so. Sauerei, was mach ich jetzt?“ Ich sage, „meine liebe Dame, da haben Sie aber
Glück.“„Wie denke?!“„Ja“, sage ich, „da haben Sie einen sehr seltenen Vogel, der da
auch in diesen Nistkasten will.“„Ach so, ja“, sagt der. Der ist der Wendehals. Kennst
du den?
Yimin: Nee, nicht genau.
Eric: Der gehört zu den Spechten, der Wendelhals. Und der braucht Nistkästen, ja, mit
einem bisschen größeren Loch als die Kohlmeise und so. Und der säubert, er legt seine
Eier einfach nur auf den nackten Boden. Er baut kein Nest. Und wenn da ein Nest drin
ist, das stört ihn. Und dann wird das ganze Material raus. Und ich sagte dann der
Frau, „Glauben Sie mir, Sie haben eine große Rarität. Lassen Sie das Tier bitte in
Ruhe und sagen Sie mir, ob das hingebaut, ob das funktioniert. Das würde mich sehr,
sehr interessieren und sehr freuen.“ Die Frau, „das gibt es doch nicht, ich habe nie
davon gehört.“„Ja, ich, habe Sie das Vogelbuch? Schauen Sie mal Wendelhals, da lesen
Sie mal. Sie haben jetzt das Glück, einen Wendelhals zu haben, das ist nicht so häufig.“
Und die Frau begreift, das hat geklappt. Der Wendelhals hat doch gebrütet mit Erfolg.
(Eric: And then a woman calls me and says, “Now I’m angry, angry, angry!” “Yeah, what happened?” “I have a nesting box hanging in my garden. And there were tits, they laid eggs and so. And now comes a bird along, it looks like a sparrow, brown and striped and so on. And now it’s going into the nest box and throwing everything out of it, the eggs and the moss and everything. It’s a mess, what do I do now?” I say, “dear madam, you’re very lucky.” “What do you mean?!” “Yes,” I say, “you have a very rare bird that also wants to use this nest box.” “Oh, yeah?” she says. That’s the wryneck. Do you know it?
Yimin: No, not really.
Eric: It belongs to the woodpecker family, the wryneck. And it needs nest boxes, yeah, with a slightly larger hole than the great tit and so on. And it cleans, it just lays its eggs on the bare ground. It doesn’t build a nest. And if there’s a nest in there, it gets bothered. And then all the stuff gets thrown out. And then I told the woman, “Believe me, you have a great rarity. Please leave the animal alone and let me know whether it takes over, if it works. I would be very, very interested and very happy to hear. The woman said, “That’s impossible, I’ve never heard of that.” “Yes, I, do you have the bird book? Take a look at the wryneck, read about it. You’re lucky to have a wryneck, they’re not that common.” And the woman realised that it had worked. The wryneck had successfully bred.)
What is intriguing in this anecdote is how the tension between the woman and the wryneck arose and how Eric mediated in it. The fact that the woman hung nest boxes in her garden indicates that she was not hostile to birds. However, she was not familiar with the wryneck species and therefore saw its behaviours merely through an anthropocentric lens. She had not realised that its “mess making” was an innate natural behaviour for nesting and interspecific competition, perceiving it as a disruptive violation of an assumed order. This suggests that certain everyday tensions between people and nature cannot be entirely attributed to human exploitation, apathy or hostility toward nature, but may also arise as a result of a lack of ecological knowledge and awareness, even among those who intend to develop a positive connection with nature. In the case of the wryneck, as the bird was unable to introduce itself or speak in its own defence, Eric lent it his voice using his knowledge and communications skills. Besides suggesting that the woman learn about the bird by referring to the bird handbook, Eric emphasised that she was “lucky” to have the “uncommon” species in her garden. Rather than focusing on lecturing her on factual knowledge and the relatively abstract principle that species’ instincts should be respected, Eric tried to inspire her excitement and sense of wonder toward the bird. As such, Eric’s consulting work represents an act of advocacy for nature by making ecological information accessible and encouraging a shift away from an anthropocentric view of nature.
Likewise, Birgit talked about her work as wasp consultant during the interview:
Birgit: Es so, ja, also ich bin, jetzt gebe ich wieder ein bisschen an, ich bin bei der
Gruppe Wespenberater. Da bin ich mit dabei und da können die Leute, die irgendwo zu
Hause oder irgendwo in Bienennestsen, Wespennestsen haben, was sie stört, oder was
sie meinen, es würde stören, können sie dann anrufen und wir beruhigen die Leute dann
erstmal und im schlimmsten Fall fahren wir hin, wir gucken uns die Sache an und meistens
kriegt man die Leute beruhigt und sagt, sie können das Nest ruhig da lassen, sie bauen
jetzt einen Paravent, einen Paravent, irgendwas vorne dran bauen, damit die Wespen
nach oben wegfliegen und dann sind sie nicht gleich auf ihrem Tisch und so weiter.
Wenn Sie am Tisch setzen, sitzen zu essen, dann setzen Sie hier neben daran die Teller
mit ein bisschen Marmalade drin, ja, dann gehen die Wespen dahin und die lassen Sie
da in Ruhe. Und so, solche Tricks, die wir den Leuten dann erklären und zeigen. Und
ja, also, wir erklären dann auch auf, nicht nach den Wespen- machen, wie [blasen]
Maria: - schlagen oder so,
Birgit: Auch nicht machen! Das mögen sie überhaupt nicht. Den Sauerkstoff mögen sie überhaupt
nicht, den man ausbläst, das mögen sie überhaupt nicht. Und dann werden die erst aggresive.
Also man soll einfach nur, nur zachte Bewegung machen. Auch wenn man das Tier dabei
berührt, das mach gar nicht. Also die haben nicht so schnell den hinteren gedreht
und Sie gestochen, wenn Sie einfach so das Tier wegdrücken und, oder es einfach fliegen
lassen, es einfach mal gucken, beobachten was es macht. Manche kommen auch gefloch-,
setzen sich dahin, und dann gucke ich, das sind jetzt da rein? Okay, dann pass ich
auf. [making a gesture as if a wasp as if a wasp flew into her neckline] Wenn sie
da dann gedrückt wären, könnten sie stechen. Ich beobachte sie dann, irgendwann fliegt
sie wieder weg. Und ich nehme sie auf den Finger, komme's auf den Finger krabbeln.
Maria: Oh! Oh?
Birgit: Dann beobachte ich sie so, und irgendwann fliegt sie weg, weil sie hat bemerkt,
da gibt es nichts zu fressen, fliege ich wieder weiter.
Maria: Das muss man sich überwinden vielleicht.
Birgit: Ja, auf jeden Fall.
(Birgit: Well, now I’m going to brag a little bit again, I’m part of a wasp advisory group. I participate in that. People who have bee hives or wasp nests somewhere at home or elsewhere that are bothering them, or think they might get bothered, can call us and we calm them down first. In the worst case, we go there, take a look at the situation, and most of the time we can reassure people and tell them they can leave the nest where it is. They can build a screen or something in front of it so that the wasps fly upwards and don’t end up on their table or so. When you sit at the table to eat, you can put a plate with a little marmalade next, and then the wasps go there and won’t bother you. And so, we explain and show people such tricks. And yeah, we also explain what you should not do to the wasps, like [blowing].
Maria: - slapping them or something like that.
Birgit: Don’t do that either! They don’t like that at all. They don’t like the oxygen you blow out, they don’t like that at all. And then they become aggressive. So you should just, only make gentle movements. Even if you touch the animal, it really doesn’t matter. Well, they won’t turn around and sting you so fast if you just push the animal away like this, or let it fly away, just watch and see what it does. Some of them come flying in, sit there, and then I look to see if they’re in there. Okay, then I’ll be careful. [making a gesture as if a wasp flew into her neckline] If they were pressed there, they could sting. I watch them, and at some point they fly away. And I pick them up with my finger, let them crawl onto my finger.
Maria: Oh! Oh?
Birgit: Then I observe them, and eventually they fly away because they realise there’s nothing to eat, so I fly on.
Maria: Maybe people must overcome that.
Birgit: Yes, definitely.)
As Birgit describes it, the purpose of the wasp consultation is to help people learn how to coexist with wasps. The practical tips she shared suggest that the everyday tensions between people and wasps, such as the annoyance people feel when wasps fly nearby, often stem less from the insect’s actual stinging behaviour but more from people’s fear of encountering them in the first place. To overcome this fear, it is important to understand that wasps’ act of stinging humans is a defensive reaction rather than a predatory attack. In this sense, Birgit’s consultation work is not only about offering technical advice on dealing with wasps or educating people on factual knowledge about the species, but also about advocating for adopting wasps’ perspective, a shift away from the one-sided view of the species as aggressive pests, and coexistence with them. In the above excerpt, it is interesting how a mini consultation session unfolded between Birgit and Maria. Notice how Birgit shared recommended practices with Maria: “they don’t like [slapping] at all. They don’t like the oxygen you blow out,” and explained that when wasps realise there is no food, they simply fly away. These suggestions are articulated from the wasps’ perspective, treating them as agents in their own right rather than a problem to be dealt with. As such, drawing on factual knowledge and practical skills, Birgit and her consultant colleagues mediate the tension between people and wasps by giving it a voice, as her following words indicate:
Und das probieren wir helf den Leuten, diese Angst zu nehmen. Und was die Leute auch
nicht wissen, dass die Wespen nur ein Sommer da ist. Das Nest stört dann im spätesten,
ging welche Art, es ist im November ab. Und dann sind sie weg, dann ist es keine mehr
da. Die Leute meinen immer, die würden da drinnen überwintern und im nächsten Jahr
wieder da, aus dem gleichen Nest dann wieder, das stimmt auch nicht. […] Und halt,
ja, wenn irgendwie was ist, den Leuten erklären, den Leuten erklären, wie das zusammenhängt
und dass die Wespen nicht so gefährlich sind.
(And we try to help people overcome this fear. What people also don’t know is that wasps are only around in the summer. The nest only disturbs latest until, whatever kind of wasps it may be, by November it’s gone. Then they’re gone, and no wasps are left. People always think they would hibernate there and come back the next year, from the same nest, but that’s also not true. […] And, yes, whatever it is, is to explain to people, explain to them how things are interconnected with each other and that wasps aren’t that dangerous.)
In this section, I discuss how participants engage in meaningfully negotiating people’s relationship with nature through practices of nature-related writing, translation and consultation. By practising these communicative acts as a form of advocacy, participants give voice to the otherwise speechless nature, navigating human-nature relationships with both cognitive understanding of the issue and emotional resonance with the concerned species. In giving nature a voice, they make it more emotionally relatable, disseminate factual knowledge about it in accessible ways, and mediate tensions between people and nature from a less anthropocentric perspective. As such, they foster reciprocal connections with nature from cognitive, emotional, and philosophical perspectives among the wider public.
Towards a Relational Understanding of Intellectual Engagement with Nature
The previous two sections discuss two forms of intellectual engagement with nature that are valued by research participants: relational learning about nature and giving nature a voice. Examples from both aspects showcase how intellectual works such as learning, reflecting, communicating and negotiating can encourage positive connections with nature. Participants value their intellectual engagement with nature more as the process of “coming to know” through social networks and direct contact with nature than as the status of “processing the knowledge”. This perspective becomes evident in their recognition of autonomous learning about nature, and in their view that valid knowledge, especially the one that sparks further interest and curiosity about nature, is not exclusive to academic institutions. For example, Laura recognised that her learning about birds in Reed Marsh is more interest-driven compared to formal educational contexts. As she explained:
Es ist ein anderes Lernen als jetzt in der Schule und an der Uni, weil da ist immer
so, du lernst und dann immer leicht gezwungen, weil du später eine Prüfung hast. Aber
hier ist dann also, du machst es für dich, in deinem Rhythmus so viele Informationen
für dich interessieren.
(It’s different from learning at school or university, because there you always learn and then you’re kind of forced to because you have an exam later. But here, you do it for yourself, at your own pace, and you take in as much information as you’re interested in.)
In a similar vein, Birgit described her year-long self-directed learning about nature as “simply fun”:
Das ganze Wissen, was ich zum Beispiel erhalte über die Natur, habe ich mir selbst
beigebracht. Also ich bin keine Biologin, nichts gelernt, gar nicht. Habe ich nur
alles im Laufe der Jahre selbst beigebracht und all die Pflanzen, all die Vögel, all
die Tiere, die ich kenne, und Zusammenhänge und so weiter, wie gesagt, alles selbst
beigebracht. Und eben auch am Hand von LetzEarth, wo ich Kurs mitgemacht habe und
solche Sachen, weil ich Aktivitäten dabei war und gelernt habe und das heute halt
wieder weitergebe. Ja, das macht einfach Spaß.
(All the knowledge, for example, what I know about nature, I taught myself. I’m not a biologist, I didn’t study it, not at all. I’ve just taught myself everything over the years, all the plants, all the birds, all the animals I know, and how they are connected with each other and so on, like I said, I learnt all by myself. And also with the help of LetzEarth, where I took courses and stuff like that, because I participated in the activities and learnt things, and now I’m passing that on. Yeah, it’s simply fun.)
She does not identify as a “biologist”, suggesting her subtle distancing from the idea that meaningful knowing about nature is only grounded in institutional credentials. Instead, she foregrounds the role of intrinsically motivated and self-paced learning about nature, accumulated personal experiences and participation in community nature activities in fostering an affective rather than purely cerebral connection with nature, asserting these forms of engagement as valid pathways of knowing nature.
The emphasis on the process of learning and engaging over intellectual mastery is also reflected in Bob’s recognition of “non-expert” knowledge:
I’m not a bird expert, because I came to it too late. People who grow up with this just know it. I mean, people like Eric and George and Tom, I mean, they know birdsong, they can listen to birdsong. So that, that, that and that. I can do it to an extent, but not to their extent. So when I do a walk, I’m not really an expert, but I’m sufficiently an expert to be able to tell other people what’s this bit. You know from teaching. You don’t have to be an academic to teach school classes, you just have to be a few steps ahead of the class. So I’ve always said, among experts, I’m a layman, but among laypeople, I’m an expert. So the people who go on these walks don’t want hugely expert opinion. If I can say, “That’s a golden oriole and it lives there and it does this,” people go, “wow! How do you know that?” It’s just something I’ve acquired over the years.
By repeating “I’m not an expert” and hedging (“I can do it to an extent, but not to their extent”), Bob was not delegitimising himself but rather asserting his legitimacy as a mediator between people and birds. His acknowledgement of his own “expert layman” identity suggests a belief that meaningful engagement with nature does not require an academic authority of knowledge. According to Bob’s experience, what sparks interest is not the “hugely expert opinion”, namely knowledge as a product of formal expertise, but rather acquiring situated knowledge as a process of “getting to know”, which makes nature relatable through concrete sensory understandings.
A similar acknowledgement of the “self-learner” identity and an understated distancing from institutional authority can also be found in Eric’s account:
Ich bin Autodidakt, aber ich habe viele Kurse mitgemacht. Ich bekam auch regelmäßig
Post aus dem Ausland, und da wurde ich immer adressiert ‚Dr. [Familienname]‘. Habe
aber nie ein Doktor, nie ein Doktor gemacht, aber das stört mich nicht. Das stört
mich nicht. Man muss ein Leben leben. Und ich habe ein erfülltes Leben gehabt. Ich
bedauere nichts.
(I’m self-taught, but I’ve taken many courses. I also received regular mails from abroad, and they always address me as “Dr. [surname]”. But I never got a doctorate, never did a PhD, but that doesn’t bother me. It doesn’t bother me. You must live your life. And I’ve had a fulfilling life. I don’t have any regrets.)
This brief excerpt reveals a nuanced confrontation between two competing discourses on the legitimacy of knowing nature. The external assumption of Eric’s doctoral title suggests a prevalent view that extensive knowledge of nature is typically the product of higher education and institutional science. This view essentially represents the discourse of credentialism, the belief that the best measure of a person’s ability or intelligence is formal qualifications such as academic degrees (Oxford English Dictionary, n.d.). Eric’s resistance to this credentialism discourse is suggested by his emphasis on “it doesn’t bother me”, which downplays the importance of the formal institutional status. He places greater value on a relational discourse of engagement with nature – the nature-inclusive eudaimonia, where the value of learning about nature lies in the process of living “a flourishing life in which nature is an integral part” (Knippenberg et al., 2018, p.43).
As such, participants’ distancing from credentialism and emphasis on informal, intrinsically motivated learning about nature reinforces the idea that intellectual engagement with nature is valued from a highly relational perspective. As discussed in the section Relational Learning about Nature, the approach of relational learning foregrounds the dynamic process of knowing that is deeply embedded within personally, socially and ecologically relational contexts over the static state of having decontextualised knowledge. Moreover, participants perceive factual knowledge about nature not merely as the end goal of their engagement, but as a means to fostering a constructive relationship with nature, as the examples of Giving Nature a Voice suggest. In other words, facts and knowledge about nature are valued as a relational tool to stimulate reflections on tensions between people and nature and prompt a human-nature relationship of care and responsibility. As Michael concisely put it:
Wenn du sie nicht kennst, wirst du auch nicht schützen.
(If you don’t know them, you won’t protect them.)
From her experience as a wasp consultant, Birgit noted that a lack of knowledge about nature could lead to a confrontational human-nature relationship:
Die Leute sehen ein Nest, das muss weg. Wie gesagt, die deutsche Wespe, die gemeine
Wespe, das sind die, die auf den Tisch kommen und mitessen wollen. Alle die anderen
Arten, die kommen nicht, die machen das nicht. Und die Leute verstehen das nicht.
Sie sehen ein Nest, sie sehen die Wespe, das muss weg. Sie verstehen nicht, wenn das
jetzt eine andere Art ist, dass sich überhaupt nicht gefährlich ist, dass man hier
ruhig da sein lassen kann, ohne dass was passiert, und da verstehen die Leute nicht.
(People see a [wasp] nest and it must be got rid of. As I said, the German wasp, the Common Wasp, are the ones that come onto the table and want to eat with us. All the other species don’t come, they don’t do that. And people don’t understand that. They see a nest, they see wasps, they must get rid of them. They don’t understand that this is a different species, that it’s not dangerous at all, that you can just leave it alone and nothing will happen, and people don't understand that.)
What Birgit emphasised here is the role of ecological literacy – “the key ecological knowledge necessary for informed decision-making” (McBride et al., 2013, p.3) – as a fundamental mediator in the human-nature relationship. In the case of wasps, people commonly regard them indiscriminately as a nuisance, without understanding the behavioural differences among subspecies or the underlying drivers of the behaviours – foraging rather than attacking. This general lack of ecological literacy leads to an antagonistic relationship between people and wasps: wasps are perceived solely as a threat, and their nests are destroyed unnecessarily. As such, the intellectual engagement with nature is not confined to the mere acquisition of information, but involves cultivating a relationship-oriented awareness.
A similar point of view is also evident in Michael’s recollection of his experience as a nature educator:
We did collect Schnecken von aller Arten, und sie machen die auch Terrarium also,
die behalt da auch Pflanzen drinnen, um die zu beobachten, und auch Experimente mit
denen zu machen. That’s, across a knife, go over a knife, so you see they have slime
that is protecting them not being cut. So you can go over the knife, yes. And then
you make some Essig, here is the Schnecke, und here is the Salat and dann machst du
hier Essig hin, da macht sie hier kehrt. Sie will da hinter zu den Salat, aber der
Essig, das schreckt sie ab. So zwei Experimente haben wir auch mit den Kindern mit
den Schnecken gemacht, dass sie einfach keine Angst haben vor Schnecken, dass die
auch die anfassen und gucken, wie schön die auch sind, wenn dann ihre Augen so in
die Höhe strecken.
(We did collect all kinds of snails, and they also make terrariums, where you have plants in it, and can observe them and also do experiments with them. [… And then you make some] vinegar, here is the snail, and here is the lettuce, and then you put some vinegar here, the vinegar makes it go around. It wants to go behind [to eat] the lettuce, but the vinegar scares it away. With children, we did such two experiments with snails so that the kids wouldn’t be afraid of snails, so that they would touch them and see how beautiful they are when they stretch their eyes up like that.)
It is noteworthy that Michael framed the objective of the two experiments not as teaching biochemical knowledge about snails, such as the secretion mechanism of protective mucus or their chemical perception of acidic stimuli, but ultimately as cultivating an affective perception of snails beyond a feared garden pest. This reflects a relational view of understanding nature: it is not only about acquiring decontextualised knowledge through detached observation, but also about trying to gain an emic insight into nature and reflecting on the people and nature relationships that have often been taken for granted within an anthropocentric worldview. It echoes Birgit’s remark:
Und das ist dann unsere Aufgabe als Verein, mit Aktivitäten und so weiter, die Leute
aufzuklären und zu sagen, hier, versuch das doch mal, guck doch mal, ist das so schlimm,
wenn da eine Schwalbe brütet? Und da ist unten Halt ein bisschen Kacke von denen,
das ist gar nicht so schlimm.
(And that is our association’s mission, through activities and so on, to explain to people and say, here, try this, take a look, is it really so bad if a swallow makes its nest there? There’ll be a bit of their poo, but that’s not so bad at all.)
As Birgit’s understanding of LetzEarth’s mission suggests, a meaningful intellectual engagement with nature is not only about facts – for example, the appearance, taxonomy or biological behaviours of swallows – but also about adopting a relational stance toward nature that involves reflecting on certain anthropocentric views that frame nature as a nuisance, and moving toward a coexistent relationship rather than a judgemental one.
In this section, I discussed the second perspective that participants consider important for developing meaningful connections with nature: intellectual engagement. The process of forming a cognitive connection with nature, such as knowledge and awareness, is perceived as deeply relational. It involves learning through social networks, cultivating direct and intimate relationships with nature and recognising the web of ecological interactions. Participants emphasise their strong preference for acquiring knowledge about nature within living contexts where these relationships unfold, rather than through detached and isolated approaches. Factual knowledge is not valued as the end goal of intellectual engagement with nature, but rather as a relational tool to mediate tensions and achieve reciprocal human-nature relationships. As such, relational intellectual engagement with nature emerges as a significant perspective for deepening one’s connection with nature. In the following section, I will discuss the third perspective of fostering connection with nature: affective attachment.
Emotional Resonance with Nature
So far, I have discussed two perspectives that participants value for initiating and deepening human-nature connections, namely embodied experiences and intellectual engagement with nature. In the present section, I focus on the third perspective that is perceived to underlie meaningful connections with nature: emotional resonance. As mentioned in Chapter 4, one of the four basic questions I asked when scrutinising the interview data during initial coding is “what emotions do participants experience in relation to their engagement with nature?”. Upon analysing the initial codes that correspond to this question, I found that emotional resonance with nature permeates the trajectory of connecting with nature. Like embodied experiences and intellectual engagement, emotional resonance with nature is valued as a meaningful spark to initiate a lasting connection with nature. Through the process of engaging with nature, hope is believed to be an effective approach to developing a reciprocal relationship with it. Finally, participants reported that their hands-on and learning experiences with nature generated emotional attachments and affective responses. As such, an emotional resonance with nature is perceived to pervade the entire arc of the connection with it, and is therefore regarded as a valuable perspective for developing this connection.
Intuitive Attachment as an Entry Point
As I discussed in the previous section, Michael argues that cognitive connection with nature underpins environmental mindset and behaviours – “if you don’t know them, you won’t protect them”. Interestingly, Birgit offered a contrasting perspective. From her perspective, people are not necessarily drawn to nature through cognitive knowledge or perceived responsibility, but through emotional and aesthetic appreciation. This view is profoundly shaped by her mom:
[…] es ging ja schon zu Hause an, dass die Mutter eine auf Sachen aufmerksam gemacht
hat. ‚Guck mal, der schöne Käfer, da pass auf, tritt nicht drauf.‘ Obwohl sie nicht
wusste, was für einen Käfer es ist, aber sie hat Respekt einem beigebracht, beigebracht,
auch vor einem Käfer, nicht nur vor einem großen Hund oder einer großen Kuh oder so,
sondern auch von kleinen Sachen, oder der Blümchen, ‚guck mal wie schön das Blümchen
ist!‘ und so, obwohl sie die Namen nicht wusste. Deshalb bin ich heute immer noch
ein bisschen, also nicht so ganz mit dem Spruch einverstanden, ‚Erst was man kennt,
schützt man.‘ Es ist eine Art Wahrheit dran, aber es muss nicht das Kennen sein. Ich
muss nicht wissen, was für eine Blume es ist, damit ich sie schütze und sie nicht
ausreiße oder umgrabe, und so. Und ja, also von Kindheit an, Interesse an der Natur
und die Schönheit gesehen und so.
([…]it had already started at home, my mother inspired me. “Look, a beautiful beetle, be careful, don’t step on it.” Even though she didn’t know what kind of beetle it was, she taught us to respect it, also to respect a beetle, not just big dogs or cows or so on, but also small things, or flowers: “Look how beautiful that flower is!” and so on, even though she didn’t know their names. That’s why until today I still don’t quite agree with the saying, “You only protect what you know.” That makes some sense, but it doesn’t necessarily have to do with knowledge. I don’t have to know what kind of flower it is to protect it and not pull it out or dig it up and so on. And yeah, so from childhood, I’ve been interested in nature and its beauty.)
This excerpt clearly reflects Birgit’s disagreement with the notion that knowledge is the exclusive foundation for a lasting and meaningful connection with nature. She explicitly challenges the idea that knowledge is a prerequisite for care for nature through disalignment and partial alignment expressions: “until today I still don’t quite agree with the saying” “that makes some sense, but it doesn’t necessarily have to do with knowledge”. She emphasised that her mother’s lack of taxonomic knowledge did not diminish her deep, inner connection with nature marked by empathy and care. On the contrary, this intuitive bond was so powerful that it profoundly shaped Birgit’s first emotionally significant experiences with nature, characterised by interest and affection, preceding her later learning and physical engagement. This echoes Seamon’s (1984) argument: “[l]ove and responsibility for the earth cannot only be thought about cerebrally; they must be felt emotionally, with the heart” (p.769). This viewpoint does not oppose knowledge-centric environmental ethics, which emphasises the role of ecological literacy in shaping how people relate to nature; rather, it offers a complementary perspective that values the emotional foundation underlying a deep connection with nature.
Maria reported her similar experience of “affect before intellect”:
Meine Eltern waren Bauern, ich war viel draußen, kannte die Natur, immer die schöne
Blumen, aber auch nie genau, das ist die und die Blumen. Aber das hat mich immer schon
gefallen.
(My parents were farmers, I spent a lot of time outdoors, I knew nature, always [as] beautiful flowers, but I never knew exactly, this is this or that flower. But I always liked them.)
Maria’s description reveals that her affective connection with nature had emerged before cognitive understanding. However, Maria expressed a sense of insecurity regarding her intuitive perception of nature and limited scientific knowledge during the interview. Interestingly, Birgit’s reaction to Maria’s account reinforced the viewpoint that cerebral knowledge about nature should not be over-emphasised as the privileged – if not the only – pathway for meaningfully connecting with nature, in contrast to emotional and aesthetic attachments.
Maria: Aber ansonsten, nie, bis jetzt spät, späte, davon zehn Jahren so zirca. Aber ich,
das hat mir immer gefallen, wollte immer dazukommen, zu diesem Verein hier, da habe
ich, ich habe immer gedacht, ich kenne doch so, „die kennen alles“ –
Birgit: – ah nee! –
Maria: – „kennen jeden Vogel und jede Blume“ –
Birgit: – umm...[laughing] –.
Maria: – „ich bin doch nicht da geeigenet.“ Da bin ich aber einmal, habe meine Mut gefassen,
so ging dahin, hat mir sehr gut gefallen, auch die Aktivitäten, die wir machen jetzt.
(Maria: But apart from that, never, until now, late, late, about ten years ago. But I always liked it, always wanted to join this association, [but] at that time I always thought, I thought so, “they know everything” –
Birgit: – ah no! –
Maria: – “know every bird and every flower” –
Birgit: – umm...[laughing] –.
Maria: – “I’m not suitable there.” But then I gathered my courage, went along, and really liked it, also the activities we do now.)
Compared to Birgit, who began environmental volunteering in adolescence, Maria perceived her own engagement that started in her 60s as “late”. One factor behind this “delay” is her assumption that comprehensive knowledge of nature is the prerequisite, and even a gatekeeper, for engagement with nature. This belief is reflected in Maria’s othering and self-positioning as an outsider of the community, as expressed in her remarks: “they know everything” and “I’m not suitable there”. Maria’s previous self-censoring reflects an axiological scientism (Stenmark, 1997) view of the human-nature connection, that science – knowledge and the state of knowing – is the most valuable part of connecting with nature. This view inevitably dismisses the significance of the intuitive and emotional aspects of people’s experience with nature in forging the connectedness with it, often rendering these aspects as superficial or secondary. Interestingly, as a more experienced environmental volunteer, Birgit immediately expressed her rejection of the expectation that “they know everything” through a vocal disagreement, humorous hesitation (“umm…”) and laughter. This excerpt suggests that even the most unadorned affection for nature, such as the simple feeling of “liking”, which is not grounded in scientific understanding, should be encouraged as a valuable entryway into human-nature connections, rather than overshadowed by the discourse of axiological scientism. I conclude this section with a quote from the American naturalist John Burroughs (as cited in Sobel, 1996, p.10):
Knowledge without love will not stick. But if love comes first, knowledge is sure to follow.
Hope as an Approach
During data collection, the participants’ positive vibes for nature impressed me. I frequently heard phrases such as “I enjoy it”, “it’s fun” and “I like (doing) it”, which have left me the impression that their experiences and viewpoints in relation to nature are underpinned by genuine enjoyment, satisfaction, curiosity and amazement. Meanwhile, I am not implying that my research participants hold a naïve view about human-nature relationships, or that they are ignorant of the environmental issues and the power inequalities that have caused and aggravated these problems. In contrast, they demonstrated a deep understanding of issues such as biodiversity loss, people’s disconnection from nature, the impacts of industrialisation, commercialisation and urbanisation on human-nature relationships and the appropriation of nature by capitalism. This, however, does not mean that they stick to disappointment, anger and desperation as a way of relating to or acting for nature. Instead, they value positive emotions as a meaningful approach to engaging with nature.
I previously analysed the following remark by Bob in the section “Harvesting Meaningful Connections with Nature through Embodied Experiences”. Here, I revisit this excerpt from a different perspective: positive emotion as a valued approach to connect with nature.
So, yeah, and during that time, we were discussing all kinds of environmental issues at home. I remember, I mean the 1970s and 80s there was the oil price shock. And this was when the environmental movement was really accelerated. So we were part of that. And I remember we had to be very careful with the children. We would have mealtimes and we were talking about environmental issues and problems. And at one stage we said, ‘No, we’ve got to be careful about this. We’re talking very negatively. I mean, the children have got to grow up thinking positive about the environment.’ So we made sure that they knew birds, they went on walks with us, they helped dig the ponds, sometimes willingly and sometimes reluctantly.
Bob’s remark draws a clear boundary between the “negative” and “positive” aspects of human-nature interactions: the anthropogenic environmental crisis versus the mutual flourishing engagements. On the one hand, he cautiously evaluates a mere focus on the negative aspect as potentially harmful for developing a reciprocal connection between children and nature. On the other hand, Bob values a positive construing of human-nature interaction and prioritises hope over pessimism, which is reflected in his deliberate effort to cultivate uplifting experiences with nature for his children by making nature part of family memories. Inherently encompassing positive emotions such as hope, optimism and joy, “thinking positively about the environment” is perceived to be a valued approach to nurture constructive connection with nature. This perspective aligns with Sobel’s (1996) argument that “[w]hat’s important is that children have an opportunity to bond with the natural world, to learn to love it, before being asked to heal its wounds” (p.10). Being merely exposed to environmental problems, as pointed out by Sobel, leads to ecophobia marked by hopelessness, powerlessness and a sense of lack of control, which impedes people’s motivation to build transformative connections with nature.
However, it must be acknowledged that in the context of environmental degradation, it is highly unlikely for those who are environmentally conscious to remain unaffected by the emotional burden of ecological problems, and sometimes, other people’s indifference, inaction and harmful behaviours towards nature. They have to navigate an emotional balance. During the interview, Birgit recounted a confrontation with a wooden furniture vendor at a spring fair in Luxembourg City. Concerned by the large-scale rainforest destruction in Southeast Asia resulting from the international timber trade, Birgit questioned the vendor if he was aware that his business led to deforestation and harm to indigenous communities who rely on the rainforest for their livelihood. To Birgit’s indignation, the vendor responded indifferently, saying that those impacts were not his concern and he only cared about the business’s profit. Taking this confrontation as an example, Birgit expressed her indignation over the environmental inequalities driven by the imbalanced power dynamics both among human beings and between humans and nature, and a sense of powerlessness. Yet, she still aligned with Maria, that despite these negative aspects, their seemingly mundane engagement with nature brings hope and joy, which has been sustaining their lasting motivation to act for nature.
Birgit: […] Und das deprimiert mich. Das deprimiert mich! Ich habe Depressionen deswegen,
weil ich das einfach nicht verstehe.
Maria: Wenn man da machtlos ist, vielleicht…
Birgit: Ja, ja, ja. Also man, man, wenn auch auf der einen Stelle was Gutes passiert, kannst
du sicher sein, 100 Kilometer daneben wird es zerstört.
Maria: Aber trotzdem um jetzt auf uns Aktivität zurück, das war ja Ihre Frage. [facing
Yimin]
Birgit: Ah sicher, ja.
Maria: Auch wenn wir nicht jetzt die Welt damit retten, viel wir machen, wir sehen doch
ein kleines Resultat. Nistkasten aufhängen, aufhängen, vielleicht ein paar Vögel retten,
ein paar Blumen, das macht doch Freude. Also wir retten die Welt nicht dadurch. Das
ist ein anderes Thema. Ja, da können wir nichts dagegen machen. Aber...
[…]
Maria: Wir machen es ja trotzdem, du auch, ne?
Birgit: Ja--!
Maria: Man darf nicht zu viel denken, die Welt, die Dunkel oder so, man muss eine kleine
Arbeit da.
Birgit: Ja, auch wenn mal einer, grantig ist oder frech ist, dann ärgert man sich die erste
Stunde drüber und denk aber dies und dessen, aber man vergiss sich schnell wieder
und nee, man will, man macht weiter.
(Birgit: […] And that depresses me. It depresses me! I get depressed because I just don’t understand it.
Maria: When you’re powerless, maybe...
Birgit: Yes, yes, yes. I mean, even if something good happens in one place, you can be sure that 100 kilometres away it’s being destroyed.
Maria: But anyway, back to our activities, which was your question. [facing Yimin]
Birgit: Ah, sure, yes.
Maria: Even if we’re not saving the world by doing this now, we do a lot, we still see a small result. Putting up nesting boxes, maybe saving a few birds, a few flowers, that brings joy anyway. We’re not saving the world by doing this. That’s a different issue. Yes, there’s nothing we can do about that. But...
[…]
Maria: We’re doing it anyway, you too, aren’t we?
Birgit: Ye--s!
Maria: You can’t think too much, the world, the darkness or things like that, you have to [do] the little bit of work.
Birgit: Yes, even if one is grumpy or angry, you get annoyed about it for the first hour and think this and that, but you quickly forget about it and no, you want to, and you do keep doing.)
Regarding the human-nature relationship, Birgit and Maria share two opposing sets of emotions. In the face of the widespread anthropogenic environmental problems at a global scale, they both feel a sense of powerlessness, which is evident through their explicit expression, such as “when you’re powerless”, and figurative language use such as “100 kilometres away” and “we’re not saving the world”. At the same time, they do not dismiss the hope and joy that the “small results” of their mundane interactions with nature have generated. As the end of the cited excerpt suggests, what lasts and motivates is not the “darkness”, but such hope and joy. “Forgetting” about the anger and annoyance and turning to hope is not an act of avoidance, but an approach of continuing to fight for nature.
Michael’s remark resonates with this viewpoint:
It’s also important in all this work to see the positive points. Sometimes you see there are a kind of insect that was, we thought it was, it had disappeared, it is found again somewhere. So these examples are very positive. Or you see some birds begin again to nest here, so that is a positive sign. You do not have always to show the negative. That is depressing people and not going to make them stand up for more nature. If you just say we are just destroying everything and everything is going to die, people get depressed and don’t stand up to protect. Just being angry and doing nothing is not good.
In Michael’s argument, “hope” is embodied in the revival of species. A concrete example of such heartening results of conservation efforts can be found in the previous section Giving Nature a Voice, that the number of breeding Eagle Owl pairs in Luxembourg has increased from 15–20 to 22–25 from 2015 to 2020. Michael highly values the “important” role of feeling hopeful for the positive conservation outcomes in encouraging environmental behaviours, contrasting it with the negative impacts of solely addressing the environmental crisis as “depressing” and discouraging. He explicitly distanced himself from the approach of focusing exclusively on negative issues through the evaluation that “just being angry and doing nothing is not good”. This view resonates nuancedly with Moore’s (1992, as cited in Sobel, 1996, p.9) findings about the effects of West Germany’s curriculum implementation that intended to raise pupils’ awareness of the environmental crisis in the 1980s:
Concerned about acid rain effects on German forests, the ozone hole, heavy-metal pollution in European rivers, the aftermath of Chernobyl, and other environmental problems, the Germans implemented a conscientious national curriculum endeavor. […] As a result of the curriculum initiative, education officials found that students felt hopeless and disempowered. The problems were seemingly so widespread and beyond their control chat the students tended to turn away from, rather than face up to, participating in local attempts at problem solving.
As the above examples of how people negotiate their emotional perception of environmental issues suggest, positive emotion, especially hope, is perceived as an effective approach to encourage and shape constructive connection with nature. It is noteworthy that such hope is not random or naïve, but is based on practical engagement with nature and understanding of conservation endeavour. The hope grounded in practice and cognitive awareness offers emotional support for (re)connecting with nature.
Affective Response as a Gain
Finally, yet importantly, positive affective responses, such as fascination and relief, are perceived as a valued outcome of meaningful connection with nature. For example, Laura observed how her emotional intimacy and fascination toward birds have developed in the course of her engagement at the ringing station:
Das heißt, also, ich bin nicht so, extrem Vogel bezogen, ich merke jetzt mit der Zeit,
weil ich jetzt schon so lange dahin gehe, dass ich mittlerweile so kann sagen, diese
Vögel merke ich lieber als diese, und ich entwickle langsam, bin ich selbst, bin ich
so mich beobachten selbst, es erstaunt mich so, immer mehr eine Faszination, entwickle.
(That means, well, I’m not extremely bird-oriented, [but] I’ve noticed over time, because I’ve been going there for so long now, that now I can say that I like these birds better than those, and I’m slowly developing, I’m observing myself, and I’m amazed at how a fascination is developing more and more.)
As elaborated in the section Interacting with Nature as Serious Leisure, Laura began participating in bird ringing not because she was a bird enthusiast, as she said, “extremely bird-oriented”. While her connection with birds was not kindled by a preceding intuitive attachment, a positive emotional resonance with birds has developed in the process of her practical interaction with the species. In this case, while emotional connection does not serve as a spark that explains how Laura started to engage with birds, as an appreciated outcome of the process, it articulates why she returned to the animal and the wetland reserve for a long-term attachment.
From Michael’s viewpoint, the amazement emerged from experiencing and learning about nature plays an essential role in forging a profound connection with nature:
Michael: […] wenn du, eine Schnecke nimmst du und du siehst wie die über also eine Klinge
klettern kann, dann hast du Respekt vor der Schnecke. You, bestaund, ja? Staunen.
Yimin: Yes, it’s amazing.
Michael: Ah It’s amazing that! It’s not possible. I can’t do that. I will be cut, the blood
will be shed when I touch it, but the Schnecke [snails], he can do it. So much like things. You must, so “Aha-Erlebnis”, “Oh-ha!”, ist fanstastisch.
Sie ist dann, son-, wie eine Pusteblume so, Löwenzahn, da fliegen die Samen, dann,
die haben hier Fallschirme dran. Die können überall hinfliegen, so, die lässt sich
überall wieder und dann kommt eine neue. Auch das sind so Wunder, wie du sagst, „Oh-ha!“
Die muss man den Kindern und den Erwachsenen auch manchmal noch tragen.
(Michael: […] when you, you take a snail and see how it can climb over a blade, then you’ll have respect for the snail. You are amazed, yeah? Amazement. […So much like things.] You must, such an “Aha-moment”, “Oh-ha!”, is fantastic. It’s, like a blowball, dandelion, the seeds fly away, and they have parachutes. They can fly everywhere, and then they land anywhere and a new one comes. That’s also a wonder, like you say, “Oh-ha!” You must let children and also adults experience that.)
Michael highly values the sense of wonder and amazement as the emotional outcome from experiences with nature, as indicated by his repeated use of the modal verb “must”, which conveys a strong belief in necessity. His vivid emphasis on the “Aha-moment” points to how powerfully the feelings of surprise, wonder, joy and awe that are gained in direct experience with nature touch people, and therefore form a deep inner connection with nature.
In addition to amazement, Michael argues that relief holds significant emotional value in the connection with nature:
I think the world for kids is being concentrated in the cubic classroom, disconnected of the real nature. That’s the main problem, I think. Therefore kids are going to explode and. There are no more, nicht mehr geerdet [not grounded anymore]. So when we have here, this must be geerdet [grounded]. There must be contact with the soil, to get when there is too much Volt, it’s going through your body and it’s going in the soil. You don’t die from it. I think that we need also, we have to be in contact with nature and soil.
Through the metaphor of earthing wire, Michael powerfully expressed his belief that contact with nature provides stress relief and emotional comfort, thereby playing a crucial role in supporting well-being, much like a grounding wire channels high voltage safely into the ground in case of danger. While this metaphor vividly illustrates relief as one of the perceived emotional benefits of connecting with nature, Bob’s reflection on the human-nature relationship through the lens of mortality offers a clear and heartfelt expression of this perspective:
I’ve thought now twice about mortality and you just get used to the idea of, you know, we all die, we don’t have to die just yet, but still, I mean, that’s the way of life. And I think that’s one of the things that nature study has taught me as well. I mean, I have no religious beliefs. I observe how life starts and ends in nature. And we’re part of nature too. We’re just another animal, mammal species. And life starts. You lead your life, you reproduce and you die. Just like every other species. I find that very reassuring.
This excerpt essentially presents a critical reflection on human exceptionalism. From the perspective of the life cycle and mortality, human beings are simply living organisms and therefore are not more privileged than other mortal species in nature. In this sense, Bob blurred the boundary between human and nature in his discourse: nature is no longer an “other”, but an entity to which we belong; animals are not outsiders either, but our kin. In Bob’s case, this perception meaningfully extended beyond a pure rational cognition, but also held deep emotional significance. As someone living with terminal cancer, the insights he gained from nature brought him reassurance and peace. The relief that Bob found in nature at the end of his life made his lifelong connection with it profoundly moving.
The present section elaborates on the third dimension that participants value in their connection with nature: emotional resonance. My findings suggest that emotional experiences shape how people initiate, sustain, and construe the meanings of their connection with nature. The emotional experiences with nature closely interplay with the other two forms of interaction with nature: embodied experiences and intellectual engagement. Viewing the three perspectives comprehensively, I find that they mutually shape one another without being mutually exclusive, nor do they form any linear cause-and-effect relationships in which one serves as a prerequisite or consequence of the others.
Pollinating Blossoms and Harvesting Fruits of Human-Nature Relationships
Zooming into the Meanings of Connecting with Nature
The previous section uncovers three key perspectives that participants value in developing meaningful connections with nature: embodied experiences, intellectual engagement, and emotional resonance. To further explore how participants perceive their relationships with nature as they unfold through these multifaceted connections, this section addresses the second research question: What views of nature and human-nature relationships are embedded in participants’ engagement with nature from these perspectives?
To ground the answers to this question in participants’ live interactions with nature and their real-time sense-making process, I examine the video data and fieldnotes collected through participant observation. The analysis reveals that nature is positioned not as a passive backdrop or object, but as an active guide and participant in shaping individuals’ embodied, intellectual and emotional engagement. Furthermore, participants challenge the image of “human as the steward of nature” (van den Born, 2006a, 2006b), instead positioning themselves as collaborators with nature. In doing so, they embrace the notions of the agency of nature (Nash, 2005) and human-inclusive naturalness, which contest two fragmented understandings of human-nature relations: human dominance over nature and the human-nature dichotomy.
Nature as a Guide and Participant
On October 15, 2023, I joined Michael and his two fellow volunteers from the section City, Jenny and Jules, for an Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session in a suburban forest in southern Luxembourg. In addition to the four of us, there were also four participants of the activity who were not regular members of the section but had joined after seeing the open call. To distinguish these four participants of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt from my core research participants, namely Michael, Jenny and Jules, I will refer to them in the following text as “spontaneous volunteers”. The purpose of that day’s Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session was briefly outlined in the program of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt:
Clean nest boxes at [place]
We’ll clean and, if necessary, replace nest boxes at [place].
Michael, Jenny and Jules brought various tools: a ladder approximately two meters tall, hammers, scrapers, nails, work gloves, and a handcart loaded with several brand-new nest boxes. Our group of eight followed the trail deeper into the woods. Jenny discovered the first nest box. She set up the ladder, climbed up, and took down the nest box. Inside the box was an empty bird nest made of moss and twigs, interspersed with down feathers. Jenny took it out and handed it to Jules. Instead of throwing it away, Jules showed the empty nest to the rest of us and said that he would take it with him and use it as material for his participation in the Science Festival.
Jules: Also ech huelen déi Näschter elo mat, well ech um Science Festival matgedeelt, iwwer
Deieren, déi an den alen Vullennäscht sinn. Mir brauchen nach e puer Äschten, bis
well hu mir weineg Deieren rauskritt. I will take these nests for my workshop on science
festival, to see what kinds of beasts are inside.
(So, I’m taking the nests with me now, because I participated in the Science Festival, about animals that live in old bird nests. We still need a few twigs, so far we’ve found a few animals. [I will take…])
The four spontaneous volunteers were intrigued by Jules’ “animals in bird nest” project. One of them asked further: “Beasts?”. Realising that his choice of words was inaccurate, Jules explained himself in Luxembourgish: “Also nee, Vullen – also net – ech weisen Iech et. (Well, no, birds – well not – I’ll show you)”. Saying so, he took out from his jacket pocket a bird identification booklet and an A4 sheet printed with pictures and names of several insects.
Jules: An deenen Näschter kann ee Saache fannen ewéi dat do, Fléi, vill Larven, Matten,
Instektenlarven, Milben, Käferen, Stëbleis, Collenbole.
(In those nests, you can find things like that – fleas, many larvae, moths, insect larvae, mites, beetles, dust lice, woodlice.)
This interaction represents an ethnographic moment for me, because the ways in which Jules engaged with the material, nature and people reframed the activity in a way that diverges from how it was initially framed in the program. The moment when Jenny took out the empty nest from the box and cleaned out the dust with the flat scraper, the task “cleaning nest box”, as specified on the program, is completed. The empty bird nest could have been discarded, and the group could have already moved to the next nest box. However, rather than treating the nest as a waste, Jules valued it as a learning material that could engage the audience. The moment when Jules took out the booklet and the A4 paper was unexpected and striking for me. These materials, together with Jules’ explanation to the spontaneous volunteers, reframed the event from a work-oriented maintenance activity into a knowledge-sharing interaction oriented toward learning. This instance provides us with an ethnographic demonstration of relational learning about nature discussed in Section 4.1.3. The spontaneous volunteers were learning about the otherwise invisible ecological relationships between birds and insects embedded within bird nests through direct contact with the natural construct and interaction with the nature knowledge holder, Jules. In this moment, nature – here the birds, the nest and other creatures inhabiting it – was not only perceived as something to be helped, cared for or managed, but also as a guide that supported people’s relational learning. The natural configuration of the nest, rather than a controlled experiment, shapes the learning process. As such, this ethnographic moment indicates that nature is not perceived merely as an inert object to be learnt about, nor a passive substrate where learning happens. Rather, it shapes people’s nature literacy – “the ability to learn from and respond to direct experience of nature – means seeing nature as a connected, inclusive whole” (Sobel, 1996, vi, emphasis in original) – as an agentive force.
While Jules was introducing the other residents of the bird nest, Jenny finished cleaning the first nest box and hung the box back onto the tree. In the meanwhile, Jules continued sharing:
Also, déi Näschter ginn erausgeholl, wéinst deen, wéi ech Iech gewisen hunn, déi Parasitten,
déi dra sinn. Dat heescht an där doter Këscht ass nach vill Plaz, an do géif nächst
Joer d’Meesen en Nascht do drop bauen, mee an deenen Näschter do sinn déi Parasitten
an dann hunn déi Jonk direkt déi Parasitten. Bah, Dir hutt do déi Fléien, déi suckele
Blutt bei deenen jonke Vullen, mee Fléien sinn esou richteg onsympathesch Déieren.
Déi Vullefléi ginn och un ons Blutt suckelen.
(So, the nests are removed because of the parasites I showed you, the parasites inside the nests. That means in this box here, there’s still a lot of space, and next year the tits would build a nest on top of it. But in those nests, there are parasites, and then the chicks would immediately have those parasites. Ugh, you’ve got those fleas that suck blood from the young birds. Fleas are really unpleasant animals. Those bird fleas even suck our blood too.)
This excerpt continues to illustrate how Jules facilitated others’ relational learning about nature, albeit from a different layer than the previously analysed moment. Capturing the complex dynamics that autonomously form within nature, Jules grounded the understanding of the animals and human intervention in a dynamic and relational context. In this moment, Jules moved from sharing descriptive knowledge about nature – namely what inhabits in a bird nest – to offering explanatory knowledge about biological and human-nature interactions – how the animals interact with one another and why the maintenance work was necessary. Combining direct contact and intellectual engagement with nature, this moment highlights another layer of nature-related literacy: a kind of literacy that goes beyond a basic identification of flora and fauna, touching on ecological literacy – “the key ecological knowledge necessary for informed decision-making” (McBride et al., 2013, p.3). In other words, it is not only about naming species – be they fleas, mites, or lice – but about letting the biological interactions occurring in nature tell why and how humans might interact with nature.
The group moved forward in the forest. After a spontaneous volunteer hung up two new nest boxes on trees, the group came across another old nest box that needed cleaning. Jenny climbed onto the ladder and took it off. She handed the box to a spontaneous volunteer, who then passed it to Jules. When Jules opened the box, he immediately identified the old owner of the nest: “Hei ass Kleiber dran! (Here is a nuthatch!)” What strikes me as an ethnographic moment is not Jules’ immediate identification per se, but the group’s curiosity and fascination about the nest: the moment Jules opened the box and named the bird, the spontaneous volunteers gathered around with soft yet audible exclamations of “wow” (Figure 29). This moment, although only lasting less than two seconds in my fieldwork video, represents a significant ethnographic moment for me that indicates that this nest box cleaning session was beyond a merely work-focused activity aiming at completing a task within a limited time frame. It is also a form of exploratory learning, characterised not only by the transfer of information but also by an emotional atmosphere of curiosity and a sense of discovery.
To everyone’s amazement, this nest box was a “shared flat”, like a spontaneous volunteer humorously put it: “eng WG23!”. Behind the nuthatch nest is another nest of a flycatcher family (Figures 30 and 31).
Jules: Dat hei war dran. Hei ass Kleiber dran an -
Michael: Kleiber ass mat denen Holzschuelen.
Jules: Jo, an dat anert hannendrun ass e Nascht vum Méckefänkert. Kréien ech den iergendwéis
hei eraus? Jo. An hei ass den Nascht vum –
Jenny: Jo den ass do dran, dat sinn zwee Bruten also. Do war suguer eng Kéier-
Michael: Eng Mees.
Jenny: Eng Mees déi ugefangen huet.
(Jules: This one had inside. Here is a nuthatch and -
Michael: The nuthatch is the one with the wooden shavings.
Jules: Yes, and the other one behind it is a nest of a flycatcher. Can I somehow get it out? Yes. And here’s the nest of -
Jenny: Yes, it’s in there. There are two broods. There was even once -
Michael: A tit.
Jenny: A tit that had started [nesting])
Again, Jules took out his bird booklet and explained more details about the flycatcher to the group (Figure 31):
Also hei ass- Ech weisen Iech den hei. E schwarze Méckefänkert. Ech weisen Iech den
am Buch. Also dat do, dat hei Nascht ass vun dem dote Vull, schwaarze Méckefänkert.
T’ass een dee bis an Afrika flitt, déi kommen Enn Abrëll, Ufank Mee erem. An déi ginn
och an esou Këschten.
(So here is – I’ll show you here. A European pied flycatcher. I’ll show it to you in the book. So that, the nest here is of that bird, the European pied flycatcher. It’s one that flies all the way to Africa. They return around the end of April or beginning of May. And they also use these kinds of boxes.)
While attending to this “shared flat” nest box, Jules, Michael and Jenny initiated another moment of knowledge sharing. Once again, the abandoned nests were not treated as something useless only to be cleared out. Rather, they were perceived as a stimulus for learning. Rather than beginning with theoretical, abstract knowledge, the group’s intellectual engagement with the birds depended on the specific nests. What made this ethnographic moment revealing was that Jules and Michael let the nests “tell” before Jules consulted his identification booklet. The materials, shapes and spatial overlap of the nests revealed the actual behaviours of, and possible interactions between, the bird species. As such, this learning interaction was guided and shaped by nature itself, namely by the birds and their natural constructs, rather than a pre-planned agenda. In this sense, this ethnographic moment evokes a metaphor of emergent and contextual learning about nature: nature “designs” the “curriculum” of environmental learning with the elements and interactions within it.
As the cleaning work continued, the group moved from one nest box to another. Birds had taken advantage of almost all the boxes that we checked. Upon opening each one, Jules and Jenny – or perhaps the nests – revealed something about the former inhabitants. As the group discovered another nuthatch nest, one of the spontaneous volunteers was intrigued by the extraordinarily small size of the box’s entrance hole. In response to her question, Jules explained more about nuthatchs’ nesting behaviour.
Jules: Hei war Kleiber.
Spontaneous volunteer: Och wann d‘Lach esou kleng war?
Jules: Also wat de Kleiber mëcht, gesäit een hei, dat hei ass, esou Buedem. Se huelen Buedem,
den esou Leem den naass ass, an den dréckt den dann mat sengem Schniewel uewen bäi.
Spontaneous volunteer: Maach den net futti, den kënnt dir dann an der Ausstellung weisen.
Jenny: Dat Nascht – mir fanne méi schein Kleibernäschter, also dat do ass elo net dat schéinst.
Hei waren och schonn Spawecken dran an all méigleches.
Jules: Also dee mescht, wann dem d’Lach ze grouss ass, mecht den, ehh, dat méi kleng. Dat
heecht, dat gëtt da wéi Bëton an dir hutt heiansdo Këschten, also déi éischt déi mir
haten, do mat dem grousse Lach, déi- wann de Kleiber do esou richteg aktiv ass, da
kritt dir déi Këschte wierklech ganz schlecht op, well da braucht dir en Hummer fir
dat futti ze schloen well wann dir wëllt am Hierscht botzen, dat ass wéi Steen. Hien
hëllt, an der Mëtt dat ass da wéi e klengt Lach wou hien erakennt. Dat heescht, hie
mëcht wann him d’Lach ze grouss ass - Also dat do ass e normalt Lach, do kënnt hie
ran, also, wann et nach méi grouss ass mëcht hien dat zou, dat keen anere rakënnt.
Also, och heiansdo suguer esou zou, wann hei op der Säit esou splécke sinn, ginn déi
och nach zougemauert, dat een d’Këscht wierklech net méi opkritt. Do ass en, do rifft
hien jo elo. Also den dir elo héiert, dat ass de Kleiber.
(Jules: Yes, a nuthatch was here.
Spontaneous volunteer: Even though the hole was so small?
Jules: So what the nuthatch does, you can see it here, such soil, it takes soil, like wet clay, and presses it with its beak on the top.
Spontaneous volunteer: Don’t break it, you can show it in the exhibition.
Jenny: The nest – we’ve found nicer nuthatch nests; this one isn’t the prettiest. Here is also spiderweb and all sorts of things.
Jules: So, if the hole is too big, it makes it smaller. So it becomes like cement, and sometimes you get boxes like the first ones we had, with the big hole. If the nuthatch is really active, you can barely open the box. You need a hammer to break it open when you want to clean it in autumn, it’s like stone. In the middle, there’s a small hole where it can get in. So, if the hole is too big, it does that [seals it up]. This is a normal hole, so it can get in. But if it’s bigger, it seals it so others can’t enter. Well, sometimes even so sealed up, that the sides got walled up, so you really can’t open the box anymore. There it is, it’s calling now. Now you can hear it, that’s the nuthatch.)
This moment showcases a telling combination of embodied and intellectual engagement with nature. Notably, the nest and bird, rather than pre-existing frameworks, guided this relational learning process by shaping what people want to learn and how they connect with nature. Here, what people learn and how they learn largely depend on what nature has to offer. The small nest entrance hole sparked the inquiry. The nest was recognised as a tangible prompt for learning, as indicated by the spontaneous volunteer’s suggestion to preserve the nest for Jule’s exhibition at the Science Festival. At the end of this episode, Jules’ recognition of the nuthatch’s birdsong and his gesturing toward it represents a meaningful instance of embodied sharing of tacit knowledge. As such, the group engaged in a form of inductive, situated learning that challenges the traditional theory-first, practice-later model of deductive learning aligned with cognitivist approaches.
As introduced previously, the predecessor of LetzEarth placed a strong focus on bird conservation and ornithology. Consequently, the installation and maintenance of nest boxes have been a traditional and defining activity of LetzEarth that continues to be practised by its local sections today. During my fieldwork with the three local sections, I observed five sessions of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt that focused on setting up, cleaning and repairing nest boxes in the local park, orchard or forests. Each time a volunteer took out an old bird nest from a box, the group would gather around to discuss the texture of the nest and its inhabitants. Sometimes participants even found unhatched eggs or fragments of eggshells, which also offered clues about the former occupants of the nest. As the ethnographic moments discussed above indicate, the nests sparked curiosity and a sense of wonder that transformed the maintenance work into a setting for emergent, situated learning. Moreover, the natural materials, organisms, and species’ behaviours and interactions functioned as a driving force behind the embodied experiences, such as touching and listening, that shaped the intellectual engagement. In this way, a subtle ontological shift seemed to emerge in this embodied and intellectual engagement with nature: nature appeared to be perceived as an active guide that influences how people came to know about it, rather than only a passive entity that needs human care. This gestures towards the new materialist thought, which “[c]onceiv[es] matter as possessing its own modes of self-transformation, self-organisation, and directedness, and thus no longer as simply passive or inert” (Coole & Frost, 2010, p.10).
While the previous analysis has shown that nature actively shapes people’s embodied and intellectual engagement with it, two ethnographic moments from my fieldwork on 9th November 2024 with Birgit, Maria, and their fellow volunteers of section Nord reveal that nature is also perceived to play an agentive role in shaping the emotional resonance with it. These two moments occurred when that day’s Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session had already finished, and Birgit and I were having a casual conversation. Thus, I did not turn on my video camera or voice recorder at that time. As such, these ethnographic moments are retrieved from my fieldnotes. Birgit’s words, originally spoken in German, are therefore rendered here as paraphrased English rather than as direct citations or translations.
As we were passing by a community orchard, Birgit stood by an apple tree and pointed to it: “this is a typical apple tree” (Figure 34). The “typicalness”, according to Birgit, refers to the flattened dome shape of its crown. “The shapes of the trees actually look like their fruit,” said Birgit. She then explained that the crown of a pear tree tends to be more conical in shape compared to that of an apple tree, just as the shape difference between pears and apples. She told me with admiration in her voice, that this apple tree is “very old, could be even one hundred years old, but in good shape and healthy”. “This tree speaks to me. I don’t always feel this with all trees, but with this one I feel something. It shines healthily, and I feel it speaks to me.”
We kept walking along the trail beside the orchard. In late autumn, fallen fruits were scattered along the roadside. Birgit bent down and picked up an apple that had been hollowed out by an animal (Figure 35). “I wonder what animal had eaten it. Maybe some kind of rodent. Look how thoroughly and skilfully it gnaws!”
In these two moments, Birgit’s actions and words demonstrate a genuine emotional resonance with nature marked by her sensitivity, admiration and fascination with its subtle nuances. It is noteworthy how materiality closely interplays with her emotional connection with nature in these two moments. She perceives the shape of the tree crown as expressive – it tells the characteristics of the tree. Moreover, she appeared to perceive her emotional connection with the apple tree as initiated by the tree, who “speaks” to her through its radiating, contagious vitality. This perception suggests an acknowledgement of the tree’s active role in shaping this connection. Similarly, when the gnawed apple elicited Birgit’s admiration for the animal’s eating skill, the apple became meaningful as a trace of an animal’s agentic behaviour. In both moments, Birgit’s emotional resonance with nature is grounded in her physical and sensory contact with it. As such, these instances suggest how nature is recognised as an active participant in the formation of the emotional human-nature connection, rather than a passive object onto which human emotions are projected, echoing the new materialism perspectives.
In the present section, I draw on the ethnographic moments from two fieldwork sessions to elucidate my finding that when participants engage with nature through embodied, intellectual and emotional perspectives, species and materials in nature are foregrounded as an active guide and participant of their experience with nature, rather than treated as a void background to practice actions or an inert object to project knowledge or emotions on. Nature forms the process of “coming to know”, producing meanings in participants’ cognitive and emotional connections with it. This finding suggests that a new materialist understanding of nature’s “capacity to affect and be affected” (Deleuze & Guattari, 1988, as cited in Fox & Alldred, 2022, para.10) can be manifested in seemingly mundane, everyday interactions with nature.
In the next section, I will move to demonstrating how participants position themselves as collaborators with nature.
From a Steward of Nature to a Collaborator with Nature
On an afternoon in late September 2023, Jenny and Jules worked in a community orchard in Luxembourg City. According to the program of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt, the main task for the day was to collect ripe apples. However, compared to the scene I witnessed in end October 2022 in the same orchard, where naturally ripened apples had fallen beneath the trees, almost forming a carpet exuding the sweet fragrance of apples mixed with a faint scent of fermentation – the scene in 2023 appeared rather cheerless (figure 36).
Just as I assumed that we had come too early this year and that the apples had not ripened yet, Jenny explained that I actually arrived already too late for the apples – most of the apples had already fallen a week earlier when she last checked:
Jetzt gehen wir mal zu den Äpfeln, denn letztes Jahr waren wir ja Ende Oktober hier,
da haben wir gesehen die Äpfel waren fast alle runter. Jetzt bin ich vor einer Woche
runtergegangen, die Äpfel sind fast alle runtergefallen. Und, jetzt müssen wir uns
anschauen was noch da ist, es waren schöne Äpfel. Aber, müssen wir halt schauen was
jetzt ist, aber das kann man nie richtig planen in der Natur. Dieses Jahr ist alles
ein Monat früher als sonst. Auch die Weinlese an der Mosel ist auch früher. Es ist
einfach so heiß ist. Zuerst wegen dem vielen Regen gut wachsen, und jetzt mit der
Sonne wurde es frühzeitig reif, nicht gut reif geworden. Aber, da muss man flexibel
bleiben. Es ist der wärmste September seit Wetteraufzeichnung glaube ich, dieses Jahr.
Und da ist halt alles früher reif. Aber die Dates für den [Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt] müssen
wir schon im Frühjahr einreichen und da weiß keiner wann das alles, das alles reif
ist. Da ist viel- also Theorie und Praxis ist nicht immer das Gleiche.
(Now let’s go to the apples, because last year we were here at the end of October, and we saw that almost all the apples had fallen. Now I went down there a week ago, and almost all the apples already fell. So now we have to see what’s left. They were nice apples. But we’ll just have to see what’s there now. You can never really plan these things in nature. Everything is a month earlier than usual this year. The grape harvest alongside the Moselle is also earlier. It’s just so hot. At first, the rain helped them grow well, but now with the sun, they ripened early but didn’t ripen well. But you have to remain flexible. I think this is the warmest September since we had weather records, this year. And everything is ripening earlier. But we have to submit the dates for Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt already in the spring, and no one knew at that time when everything would be ripe. There’s a lot of- well, theory and practice aren’t always the same.)
Through working in the orchard regularly, Jenny experienced firsthand the concrete impacts of climate change on plants. Pointing out the mismatch between theory and practice, she expressed her belief that knowing nature should be grounded in embodied experiences with it rather than abstract theories. Her direct observation and experiences of the natural phenomena led her to perceive nature’s unpredictability as an adaptive and autonomous reaction to environmental changes. In response to this unpredictability, it is striking that Jenny’s remark reflects a tone of acceptance rather than lament, and an emphasis on adaptation rather than resistance. Even though the unusually high temperatures that led to early fruit ripening are highly likely related to global warming, Jenny did not frame the situation as a crisis that had to be managed or controlled. Instead, she emphasised it as a scenario requiring human adjustment and flexibility. She stressed that instead of planning for nature, we should adapt to nature. Attuning to nature’s tempo and rhythms is not about controlling and altering them, but about allowing nature to enact its resistance and reminding people to remain adaptive and responsive to nature.
In addition to Jenny’s flexible attitude toward the early-ripening apples, what also struck me on that day’s of the Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session was that Jenny and Jules planted two fig tree seedlings in the orchard. As a species native to regions ranging from Asiatic Turkey to northern India, as well as the Mediterranean (Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2025), it was pretty surprising to find it cultivated in a community orchard in Luxembourg, which has a continental climate. Jenny explained that this was their trial in the orchard to adjust to the increasingly dry and hot summer conditions.
Jenny: Er ist früh aufgeschossen und Feigenbaum hat gute Chancen hier, denn es ist steinig,
es ist Luxemburger Sandstein, es ist sehr trocken, es ist ein Südhang, es ist kein
Wasser hier. Wir haben noch keinen Anschluss zum Wasser, also werden wir jetzt das
Experiment mit den Feigenbäumen. Aber der hier ist angekommen. Und die sieht im Moment
ziemlich resistent bei uns. So, ja...ja der ist schon gut. Den do... Hier steht Winterschutz
im ersten Jahr, aber ich glaube das ist kein Problem. Hier ist so ein warmer Hang.
Die klassischen Obstbäume sind in den letzten Jahren alle verdurstet. Und, schau der
Name, Desert King.
Jules: [laugh] Desert King, dat passt.
Jenny: Desert King, da steht auch für unvorteil-, unvorteilhafte Standorte geeignet. Und
dann habe ich gedacht, das ist der richtige, wenn er das erste Jahr schafft, dann
ist gut.
Yimin: Ich glaube in Luxemburg, da gibt es viel Regen, rain?
Jules: Manchmal ja.
Jenny: Also, wenn es regnet, dann regnet es viel und lange. Also im Sommer hatten wir 4-5
Wochen, da hat es nur geregnet. Es war, menge ech, August, August oder Juli. Juli,
das war Pech, und nachher hat es überhaupt nicht mehr geregnet. Ja, das, nein wir
hatten aber in- also letztes Jahr war nur trocken, das war schlecht. Aber die normalen
Sommer bei uns sind immer so durchwachsen. Jaja, da hat viel geändert, ganz viel.
Normalerweise hat es genügt hier im Herbst ein Obstbaum zu setzen, der ist am Frühling
angewachsen, aber das funktioniert nicht mehr.[…] Hier sind eben ganz, ganz viele
Steine, das ist das Problem hier. Und die, ja, da gibts so Theoretiker. Die meinen
dann, an einem Bongert wächst das und das, aber man muss auch die Geologie gucken,
wo soviel Steine sind.
(Jenny: It sprouted early and the fig tree has a good chance here because it’s stony, it’s Luxembourg sandstone, it’s very dry, it’s a south-facing slope, there’s no water here. We don’t have a water connection yet, so we’re going to experiment with fig trees. But this one has arrived. And it looks pretty resilient at the moment. So yeah…yeah it’s fine. That one... It says winter protection in the first year, but I don’t think that’s a problem. It’s on a warm slope. The classic fruit trees have all died of thirst in recent years. And look at the name, Desert King.
Jules: [laugh] Desert King, that fits.
Jenny: Desert King, it also says suitable for unfavour-, unfavourable locations. And then I thought, that’s the right one, if it survives the first year, then it’s fine.
Yimin: I think in Luxembourg there’s a lot of rain?
Jules: Sometimes, yes.
Jenny: Well, when it rains, it rains a lot and for a long time. In the summer we had 4-5 weeks where it only rained. It was, I think, August, August or July. July, that was bad luck, and afterwards it didn’t rain at all. Yes, that, no, but we had- last year was just dry, that was bad. But normal summers here are always mixed [with rainy and sunny days]. Yeah, a lot has changed, a lot. Normally, it was enough to plant a fruit tree here in autumn, and it would grow in the spring, but that doesn’t work anymore. […] There are so so many stones here, that’s the problem. And then there are these theorists, they say that this and that grows in an orchard, but you also have to look at the geology, where there are so many stones.)
In this ethnographic moment of planting fig tree seedlings in a Luxembourg-based community orchard as a response to the changing climate, Jenny once again demonstrated her deep situated understanding of the local natural environment, plant characteristics and the ecological interaction between flora and their environment. The climate-change-induced dryness and heat, combined with the rocky terrain that limits soil permeability, have posed challenges for the survival of fruit trees. In response to this challenge, she reiterated her critical stance toward “theorists”, suggesting her opinion that interactions with nature should be guided by contextual, experiential understanding rather than abstract or oversimplified hypotheses. As discussed above, Jenny’s on-the-ground engagement with the orchard allows her to perceive climate change as a tangible force exerting concrete impacts. Faced with these impacts, the trial with the fig trees suggests the volunteers’ relational stance toward the environmental issue. In this instance, Jenny (and Jules) did not position the orchard as a purely passive victim of climate change. Acceptance of climate change’s effects does not equate to powerlessness or inaction. The adaptability and flexibility reflected in Jenny’s words and actions are based on the acknowledgement of nature’s resilience. By introducing fig trees into a traditionally apple-dominated orchard, Jenny and Jules did not distance themselves from the environmental issue but tried to enact and enhance nature’s own resilience.
Reviewing the video recording of this fieldwork session, I initially coded the discussed ethnographic moments as “participant as a steward of nature”. However, comparing the data with relevant literature, I found that while the concept of stewardship can address Jenny’s physical labour in the orchard, her sense of responsibility and care for the trees and her reflections on climate change, it does not fully capture the nuanced relationship with nature she perceives and constructs in these moments. Muradian and Pascual (2018) propose that “[i]n the Stewardship model, the natural entity is perceived as not having agency but there is no clear-cut subject-object distinction, since humans are seen as part of (and dependent on) nature” (p.12). In a similar vein, de Groot et al. (2006) define that
Man the Steward comprises the caretaker of nature who sees nature as a subtle, fragile system to be handled with care and precaution for the benefit of humankind, and the guardian of nature who recognises not only that but also that nature has an intrinsic value of its own, borrowed as we have it from God or future generations. (p.12)
As such, a stewardship view of the human-nature relationship is intrinsically hierarchical despite its environmental orientation, positioning humans as superior to nature. It implies that nature is inert, fragile, instrumental to human interest and dependent on human care. My findings from the above ethnographic moments diverge from this view. In the instance of the early-ripening apples, Jenny perceives the active force of nature beyond predictability. Her view that people should adapt to nature subtly reverses the implied hierarchy embedded within the stewardship model. In the moment with the fig tree seedlings, Jenny recognised their resilience to heat and drought, and turned to nature’s own capacity as a response to environmental challenges. As such, I found the initial code “steward of nature” inaccurate, given that the participant engaged with nature more as a “collaborator”, showing responsiveness to nature and acknowledging its capacity for self-regulation. At the same time, the human-nature relationship demonstrated in these ethnographic moments does not yet reach the level of “partnership with nature”, where “human and nature both carry much of the same value and share the planet in relationships of work, play and spirituality” (de Groot et al., 2006, p.12) and “[nature] rises to stand side by side with us, also at the level of our spirituality and love” (de Groot, 1992, p.486). Therefore, I use the code “collaborator with nature”.
One month after working with Jenny and Jules in the orchard, I joined Maria for an Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session organised by her local section, Nord. The task focused on maintaining a piece of wetland by clearing withered grass and branches. During this fieldwork session, I shadowed Maria as she cleared dried grass and fallen branches with a pitchfork. At the beginning, she did not thrust the pitchfork deeply into the ground, but started by removing the surface-level, non-rooted grass (Figure 39). As the clearing progressed, she had to exert more effort to uproot the dry grass and lift larger piles mixed with fallen branches (Figure 40). She used her body weight to pull out the entire grass and then deposit it into a collection pile (Figure 41). As the pile grew larger, she had to lift the loads higher to stack the grass and branches together. As I realised the physical demands of the work, I stopped video recording and joined Maria with a pitchfork (Figure 42). Therefore, I personally experienced the challenge of this task. The weight of the pitchfork, combined with the grasp of the grass roots in the soil, required force to insert the pitchfork, putting a strain on the arms, shoulders and back. After helping Maria for a while, I resumed video recording. Since the collar microphone continuously fell off Maria’s sweater due to her movements, I decided not to use it anymore. Hence, the recorder captured my own panting. After this fieldwork,
my arms and back were sore for two days. As such, I had a firsthand sense of the significant effort Maria put into this task. Ten volunteers participated in this Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session, me excluded. Despite everyone working hard like Maria, they could not finish clearing the entire field in one morning.
Reviewing the video recordings and recalling how physically demanding the work was, I wondered: now that the task requires considerable effort and time, why do the volunteers insist on conducting the work manually? Why was machinery not an option? Therefore, I wrote an email to the board of the local section Nord to ask for their insights. Birgit replied as follows:
Yimin: Warum können diese Arbeiten nicht mechanisch erledigt werden?
Birgit: Bei mechanischer Bearbeitung der Fläsche, würde durch die schweren Maschinen die
Biodiversität zerstört werden. Der Boden würde zudem verdichtet werden und die Pflanzen
hätten Schwierigkeiten neu zu spriessen im Frühjahr. Durch die Verdichtung des Bodens
würde auch das Wasser nicht richtig einziehen und der Feuchtbiotop würde nicht mehr
seinen Zweck erfüllen. Auch würden die um diese Zeit noch verbleibenden Lebewesen
die sich noch auf der Fläsche befinden zerdrückt und getötet werden. Dann möchten
wir auch gerne unsere Mitglieder und die allgemeine Bevölkerung auf die Wichtigkeit
des Gebietes aufmerksam machen, indem wir sie auf die Fläsche locken. Wie kann man
das besser, indem man sich mehrere Stunden auf dem Gebiet aufhält und durch vorführen
der Arbeit zeigt: 1. was haben wir hier? 2. Was muss wie getan werden um das Gebiet
so zu erhalten? 3. Warum ist es wichtig so ein Gebiet zu erhalten? Und es macht einfach
Spaß mit Menschen zusammen zu arbeiten für den Erhalt unserer doch soooo bedrohten
und geschundenen Natur.
(Yimin: Why can't this work be done mechanically?
Birgit: With the mechanical processing of the area, biodiversity would be destroyed by the heavy machines. The soil would also become compacted, and the plants would have difficulties sprouting again in the spring. And the compaction of the soil would also prevent the water from soaking in properly, and the wetland biotope would no longer fulfil its purpose. Also, the remaining creatures that are still on the land at the time would be crushed and killed. We also want to make our members and the general public aware of the importance of this area by attracting them to the site. What could be a better way to do this, than to spend several hours in the area and to demonstrate through our work that shows: 1. What do we have here? 2. What must be done to maintain the area? 3. Why is it important to maintain such an area? And it’s simply fun to work together with people to maintain our soooo threatened and abused nature.)
By shunning mechanical operations and relying on manual labour, the volunteers not only work on the wetland, but also work with it. Birgit’s protective stance towards nature is evident in her awareness of the destructive impacts of mechanical intervention on soil structure and small animals, and in her positioning of nature as a victim of human threat and abuse. This framing gestures towards restitutive justice that requires people to make restitution to nature harmed by humans (DesJardins, 2023). This protective orientation reflects the classic environmental stewardship discourse. However, what also introduces a collaborative dimension into their decision and practice is the perception of manual labour as a means of cultivating embodied and intellectual engagement with the land. Opting for physical interaction with the wetland, the volunteers do not impose human convenience onto it, but let the land tell people what it is, what it needs, and why it matters, as suggested by the three questions Birgit posed. From this perspective, the wetland is not merely something to be protected or somewhere the environmental maintenance work is conducted, but also shapes people’s environmental actions and awareness through its configuration, needs and ecological significance.
In the same email, I also asked several other contextual questions about the work. One detail in Birgit’s response that drew my attention was her correction of my use of the word “weeds” to “plants”:
Yimin: Was könnte passieren, wenn man das trockene Unkraut und Schilfrohr am Weiher nicht
beseitigt würde und dies Gebiet einfach im Stich lassen?
Birgit: Wie oben schon beschrieben, das Gebiet würde verlanden und verbuschen und nicht
mehr seinem ursprünglichem Zweck dienen. Wenn die Pflanzen (nicht Unkraut :-) die
gemäht auf der Fläsche liegen bleiben, haben die Pflanzen die im Frühjahr spriessen
möchten, Schwierigkeiten durch das Mähgut zu kommen und die Fläsche würde auf Dauer
verarmen.
(Yimin: What could happen if the dry weeds and reeds around the pond were not removed and the area were simply left alone?
Birgit: As described above, the area would become land again, overgrown with shrubs and would no longer serve its original purpose. If the plants (not weeds :-) that are mowed are left in the area, the plants that want to sprout in the spring will have difficulty getting through the mowed stuff and the area would become impoverished over time.)
Birgit’s rejection of the word “weed” can be read as a subtle but telling signal of her perception of the volunteer-nature relationship not as a conventional form of stewardship, but a less hierarchical, collaborative relationship. The category “weed” implies unwantedness and disturbance, which is essentially a human-imposed hierarchy. As Mabey (2012) points out in the book Weeds: In Defense of Nature’s Most Unloved Plants:
Given the impact of weeds on the planet, it’s not always obvious that they are plants whose reputation – and therefore fate – is, in the end, a matter of this kind of personal judgement, that it’s in our gift to demonise or accept them.
Challenging this hierarchical framing, Birgit distances herself from an anthropocentric hierarchy, which, I further argue, distances her view from the stewardship model of human-nature relationship. As scholars agree, the “human as the steward of nature” relationship sits at the boundary between anthropocentric and non-anthropocentric perspectives, leaning more towards the former (see Calderón Moya-Méndez et al., 2022; de Groot, 1992; Raymond et al., 2013; van den Born et al., 2001; van den Born, 2006a). As the sense of responsibility toward nature underlying stewardship originates from the perception that humans are part of and dependent on nature (Muradian & Pascual, 2018), this responsibility is ultimately directed toward humans. Within the stewardship model, it is humans who decide what counts as desirable. By rejecting the human-imposed category of “weeds”, Birgit appears to step outside this anthropocentric frame and perceive their maintenance work as serving not primarily people but nature. Challenging the value-laden term of “weed”, she positions the volunteers not as judges of nature, but more as mediators – those who work with flora and fauna, attuning to their inherent needs, autonomous interactions and capacity to affect, to support biodiversity and landscape diversity.
Returning to an ethnographic moment from this Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session, I came to realise why referring to the grass as “weeds” would be unfair, even though they had been mowed. At the end of the work session, the group left several piles of grass on the land (Figure 43). Maria told me that they would later discuss whether to contact nearby farmers to help transport the heaps to the composting site using tractors. One of her fellow volunteers pointed to a smaller pile and noted that it would also be a good idea to leave some piles on-site, as they could serve as ideal winter habitats for hedgehogs:
They like to hide in there. They like to sleep in the winter. They go inside, they sleep in the winter. That is a good idea, to make- yeah.
This brief moment reveals that the mowed grass was not perceived as waste or nuisance, but was acknowledged for its potential to meet non-human needs as habitats. As such, a collaborative and relational view of the grass and the maintenance work, as demonstrated in Birgit’s response to my questions, is not an isolated linguistic instance, but a perception that other members of the section Nord may share. This suggests that the group worked with and for nature, which constructs a collaboration frame entailing attentiveness to nature’s needs, recognition of the values of those nature elements that are often marginalised in traditional environmental stewardship discourse, and a willingness to let nature shape human practices.
In February 2024, I visited the section Reed Marsh and shadowed Neo, whose task for the Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt session was to install two relatively large nest boxes for owls in an overgrown meadow orchard near the wetland reserve. Compared to the nest boxes for smaller birds such as tits and nuthatches, the boxes for owls are much larger, with a length of nearly one meter. Such nest boxes cannot be hung on the tree trunk but must be securely placed between the main branches. Therefore, before setting up the boxes, Neo had to saw off limbs to create enough space for the boxes. He also needed to prune smaller branches to ensure the nest box was placed stably.
Neo leaned the ladder against a sturdy tree and climbed up with a saw in his hand. His fellow volunteer, Paul, stands under the ladder (Figure 44). My recording only captured Neo’s speech clearly since he was wearing the only collar microphone, while Paul, speaking from a distance beneath the tree, was often inaudible.
At the beginning of the work, Neo and Paul discussed how to trim the branches to make space for the nest box.
Paul: Mol kucken fir en hei eraus ze kréien.
Neo: Jo. A wanns du wëlls gëff mir eng Kéier d’See, ech machen den mol direkt fort hei.
Paul: De Mëttelsten den hënnert op jiddefall.
Neo: Ah jo.
[…]
Neo: Dat Holz ass och... Okay. Geet awer. Hält dat heiten dann eppes aus?
Paul: Sou dropsetzen an.
[…]
Paul: Oder, den do an do ofgeseet, op der Héicht wou d‘Këscht dropläit, dann mam Hënneschten
op dem hei, an dann do, an dei kleng hei eran.
Neo: Den heiten ofgeseet?
Paul: Nee den aneren.
Neo: Den doten?
Paul: Jo, dass se do an [xxx].
(Paul: Let’s see if we can get it off here.
Neo: Yes. And if you want, give me the saw, I’ll take it away directly.
Paul: The middle one needs to be cut off anyway.
Neo: Ah, yes.
[…]
Neo: That wood is also... Okay. […] It works, though. Does this hold anything?
Paul: Just put it down like that.
[…]
Paul: Or, cut this one and that one, at the height where the box is placed, then the bottom on this one, and then there and the little one here.
Neo: Cut this one?
Paul: No, the other one.
Neo: The one over there?
Paul: Yes, so it’s [xxx].)
Having trimmed the scattered branches, Neo placed the nest box among the limbs. He descended the ladder, looking up to assess whether the box was securely positioned (Figure 45)
Paul: T’ass zwar schif. [laugh]
Neo: Sou, no hannen. Kritt ee vläit awer nach e bëssi. Oder ech schneide nach e bësse
mei.
(Paul: It’s leaning though. [laugh]
Neo: So, towards the back. Maybe I still get a little more. Or I can cut a bit more.)
Neo and Paul found that the angle of the nest box was slightly tilted and not completely horizontal, with the rear being higher than the front. Neo climbed up the ladder again to trim a protruding branch beneath the rear of the box and adjust its position. He sawed the base of a side branch. Then, he repositioned the birdhouse and sought Paul’s feedback from under the tree. Since they still thought that the nest box was not completely stable, Neo continued to saw through the thicker branch stub.
Paul: [xxx] nach e bëssen.
Neo: Sou?
[…]
Neo: Oh, t’ass, oh t’ass ‘lo och net vill besser muss ech soen oder? Ech kann awer nach
e steck erofhuelen, oder mengs du dat et gudd wier?
Paul: [xxx]
Neo: Gelifft? Oh, ech kann d’Spëtzt nach bessi forthuelen.
Paul: Jo. [xxx]
Neo: Jo. Ech maach so nach.
(Paul: [xxx] still a bit more.
Neo: Like this?
[…]
Neo: Oh, it’s, oh, it’s still not much better now, I have to say, right? I can take another piece off, or do you think it would be good?
Paul: [xxx]
Neo: Pardon? Oh, I can cut off the top a bit more.
Paul: Yes.
Neo: Yes. I’ll do it this way)
Having finally placed the box in a balanced position, Neo secured it to the tree with straps, and Paul gave him advice and assistance under the tree. Finally, Neo shook the birdhouse box forcefully to check whether it was securely fastened to the tree.
In the process described above, where Neo installed the nest box for owls with Paul’s assistance, I would like to draw readers’ attention to a perspective that may seem uncommon or unexpected: how Neo and Paul treated the tree. The above description and transcripts show that Neo and Paul engaged in careful discussion about how to trim the branches to support the nest box. Rather than indiscriminately clearing all scattered branches without consideration, Neo’s action was based on a joint assessment and informed decision-making aimed at consciously minimising interference with the tree. As such, the tree was not treated merely as an instrumental support for the nest box. Although it was inevitable to cut off its branches, the intervention was carried out in a deliberate and restrained manner. Admittedly, this moment may not fully and strongly exemplify a collaboration with the tree, as it would be overreaching to claim a responsiveness directed toward the tree or co-agency with it. However, it is reasonable to suggest that Neo and Paul shifted away from a top-down stewardship model and engaged in an implicit negotiation with the tree. Viewing this ethnographic moment alongside other ethnographic data, it contributes to our grounded understanding of the nuance between managerial stewardship and a more relational, collaborative way of relating to nature in environmental engagement.
In this section, I analysed the ethnographic moments from fieldwork sessions conducted with the LetzEarth local sections City, Nord and Reed Marsh. These moments exemplify how participants are involved in environmental engagement in mundane yet diverse ways. In their environmental volunteering activities, participants come into close physical contact with nature, actively reflect on their interactions with it, and demonstrate a delicate understanding of the human-nature relationship. Moving away from a classic stewardship model, participants express a willingness to adapt their practices according to nature’s rhythm and needs, challenge the notion of nature as inert, reject human-imposed hierarchy over nature, and show an eco-centric mindset characterised by care, attentiveness and responsiveness toward nature. As such, they position themselves not as top-down stewards of nature, but as collaborators with it.
Toward a Human-inclusive Naturalness
At the outset of the section Defining Nature and Human-Nature Connection, I clarified that the term nature is used in a broad sense throughout this book, depending on the ethnographic context, encompassing specific species, natural or semi-natural landscapes, and larger-scale concepts such as flora, fauna and ecosystems. This conceptual clarification, however, seems to fail to answer some provoking questions emerging from the ethnographic moments: are the community orchards, where the fruit trees were planted and tended by people, nature? Are the artificial habitat structures (Watchorn et al., 2022), such as nest boxes, part of nature? Are practices like planting non-native trees and clearing dried grass in a wetland considered “natural”? To address these questions that delve into the relationship between human actions and nature, “the concept of nature as a category of things loses its concreteness” (de Groot, 1992, p.213). We need a “conceptualisation [that] takes not nature, but naturalness (or wilderness, or self-ordering, or spontaneity) as its point of departure” (ibid., emphasis in original). The concept of naturalness is often understood in an inverse relation to human influence. For example, van den Born and de Groot (2009) define “(degree of) naturalness [as] (degree of) being or happening without human interference” (p.48). There are also alternative notions that do not exclude human activity from naturalness. For instance, naturalness is conceptualised as “the degree to which species have established themselves spontaneously and maintain themselves, irrespective of what human activity may be the cause”, or as “the degree to which human influences remain within natural dynamics” (de Groot, 1992, p.219).
If I were to answer the previously raised questions solely based on my field experience, my response would be affirmative to all three. Participants evidently perceive the orchards as a valued natural environment. According to an outreach publication by LetzEarth, traditional community orchards, in Luxembourgish “Bongert”, are “particularly valuable biotopes” and “habitat for at least 3,000 wild species”. As for the nest boxes, the fact that almost every box contains a bird nest suggests that these artificial structures have been incorporated into nature – with the birds’ approval. The volunteers perceive their intervention practices as facilitating rather than disturbing nature. Scrutinising these intuitive impressions and my ethnographic data through the lens of naturalness, I find that participants’ discourses challenge the notion that naturalness should be negatively correlated to human practices, and embrace a conceptualisation of human-inclusive naturalness. As the above analysed ethnographic moments showcase, participants ground their informed intervention practices – such as installing and cleaning nest boxes, planting and tending fruit trees and handling dry grass on wetlands – in direct engagement with nature, situated learning and contextual knowledge, and an emotional sense of curiosity, appreciation, respect and care. These practices are recognised as forms of support for nature and reciprocal human-nature connections, rather than being perceived as threats to nature’s authenticity. Based on this finding, I propose the conceptualisation of human-inclusive naturalness, which acknowledges human-nature interactions as integral to nature itself. Such interactions should be guided by an awareness of co-agency with nature and align with a collaborative, relational orientation, rather than adhering to a hierarchical relation model that positions humans above nature. One instance from my ethnographic data that supports my proposal is Birgit’s perception of human influence as both the diagnosis and treatment for the Anthropocene. In this view, human activities have long been entangled with nature, and, therefore, a human-exclusive naturalness should not be taken as the norm.
Yimin: Manche glauben, dass nur die Natur ohne Menschen und menschliches Eingreifen wirklich
„Natur“ ist, und wir sollten die Natur in Ruhe lassen. Was halten Sie davon?
Birgit: Das stimmt Heute leider nur mehr bedingt. Der Mensch hat in der Zeit wo er auf der
Erde ist, die Landschaft dermassen verändert dass wiederum der Mensch eingreifen muss
um die verschiedenen Biotope zu erhalten, dass ALLE Lebewesen eine Überlebenschance
haben
(Yimin: Some believe that only nature without humans and human intervention is truly “nature”, and that we should leave nature alone. What do you think about that?
Birgit: Unfortunately, this is only partly true today. Since mankind’s existence on Earth, humans have changed the landscape so much that now, in turn, humans have to intervene to preserve the various biotopes, so that ALL living beings have a chance to survive.)
I would like to conclude this conceptual discussion section by illustrating the concept of human-inclusive naturalness with a bird nest and a nest box that impressed me in the fieldwork. Figure 46 shows a nest that Jenny found in a nest box in the orchard where she planted the fig trees. She pointed to a fleck of orange fibres in the nest and asked me if I had any idea where the colourful flecks could come from. To my surprise, those fibres are not “natural”: the bird collected them from the carpets hung out to dry by residents nearby.
You do know from where the colours came? From the carpet from the neighbours. They
put, here is tradition to put the carpet in the garden to, that to – wéi nennt een
dat? Fir ze lëften. Um sie zu belüften. Und die Teppiche werden geknuppt raus, der
Staub net ze hunn. Und da sind Vögel, die gehen zur Wolle und die haben meistens Lieblingsfarben.
Hier ist das orange. Im Park ist eine Meise die immer nur die blauen und violetten
Tupfer holt aus der Wolle von den Teppichen. Die haben so Lieblingsfarben die Meisen.
Das ist eben von den, wenn die da Teppiche aushängen.
([…that to – ]How do you say that? To air them out. To air them out. And the carpets are taken out and beaten to get rid of the dust. And there are birds that go for the fibres, and they usually have favourite colours. Here it’s orange. In the park, there’s a tit who always picks the blue and purple flecks from the carpets fibres. The tits have their favourite colours. That’s just how it is when the carpets are hung out.)
While this nest offers a compelling example of how nature itself has actively integrated human traces, the nest box that the volunteers from the Nord section showed me provides a vivid illustration of how people proudly inscribe their environmental practices into nature. Figure 47 shows a nest box that was made 25 years ago by a boy whose name is Robert. The volunteers told me that it was a tradition of their section, that children carve their names in the nest boxes they help to make. In this way, the names of Robert and his friends have been accompanying the birds in the forest for decades.
These two examples effectively exemplify my proposal of human-inclusive naturalness. Like the carpet fibre woven into the bird nest, human traces have been integrated into nature by both people and nature. As such, I argue that the concept of naturalness should encompass responsiveness, co-agency and the mutual shaping processes between humans and nature, rather than reinforcing a separation, or even a dichotomy, that casts human as the antithesis of nature. This concept offers us an alternative narrative on human-nature co-existence, moving beyond the dominant crisis discourse of the Anthropocene and suggesting a perspective that may foster reciprocal human-nature connection and mutual influence.
Nature Awakes with Agency
I have discussed how nature plays an active role as a guide and participant in people’s embodied, intellectual and emotional engagement with it. I also expounded how the environmental volunteers adapted their practices to follow nature’s needs and rhythm, thereby challenging the conceptualisation of nature as merely instrumental and inert. These findings gesture toward an aforementioned concept: the agency of nature. In the section Niche Concepts for Everyday Relational Values, I presented how environmental historians and educators have challenged the notion of agency as an exclusively human attribute. Their interrogation resonates with the new materialist understanding of agency, which “no longer privileges human action” but instead perceives agency, namely the “capacity to affect and be affected” (Deleuze & Guattari, 1988, as cited in Fox & Alldred, 2022, para.10 ) as “a feature of all matter: human and non-human, animate and inanimate” (Fox & Alldred, 2022, para.10). The agency of nature is thus understood as its inherent capacity to shape the world, including human practices and perceptions, even in the absence of an “ability to convert ideas into purposeful actions” (Nash, 2005, p.67) or “causally efficacious mental states and events” (Schlosser, 2019, para.1).
Participants’ awareness of the agency of nature can be discerned in the ethnographic moments where they let nature guide and shape their environmental volunteering activities. Integrating situated learning about nature into environmental management work, participants do not treat nature merely as a passive object to be acted on or cared for, but as an active participant in the process of their coming to know about nature. They appreciate nature for being expressive, interconnected and resilient, and incorporate this attentive perception into their practices by adjusting their actions in response to what nature is, what it needs and why it matters. In participants’ explicit or implicit negotiations with nature, it is no longer treated as a passive backdrop or inert entity subject to human-induced consequences or awaiting human salvation, but as an active and agentive guide, participant and collaborator, with the capacity to influence, express and self-organise.
In addition to these ethnographic moments, participants’ awareness of nature’s agency also emerges in their accounts of experiences with nature during interviews. Let us revisit some meaningful experiences that Michael, Eric and Bob cherish in their lifelong engagement with nature. In Michael’s career in environmental education, snails’ innate ability to secrete protective mucus shielding them from sharp surfaces transformed children’s perception of the animal from an unpleasant pest to a capable creature worthy of amazement. For Eric, a fieldfare that happened to visit his childhood garden played a crucial role in sparking his curiosity and enthusiasm for ornithology. For Bob, species’ natural life cycles prompted his reflections on the meaning of human-nature relationship and mortality. In these instances, as well as in the ethnographic moments examined in this chapter, nature – the animals, trees, bird nests, and land – does not act with intention or consciousness, or in Schlosser’s (2019) terms, with “causally efficacious mental states and events”. However, it shapes people’s experiences and perceptions from embodied, intellectual and emotional perspectives, which constitutes the expression of its agency.
My findings based on ethnographic data suggest that nature shapes people’s embodied, intellectual and emotional engagement with it. They also indicate that people are aware of and recognise the agency of nature in mundane interactions with it. This recognition does not imply perceiving nature as capable of thinking or making conscious decisions – this idea may still feel overreaching for many. Rather, it emphasises a willingness and awareness to let nature influence, guide, and participate in our practices and process of meaning-making. It is indeed possible to embrace a new materialist understanding of the agency of nature in everyday engagement with it, which prompts a step outside the human-above-nature hierarchy and toward a collaborative, reciprocal human-nature relationship.
Notes
- 8 […] um meinen, sagen wir mal, meinen Engagement bei LetzEarth richtig zu verstehen, muss ich ein bisschen schon ausholen. Das ist ja wichtig, wie kommt man zum Naturschutz, als, gewöhnlicher sagen wir mal, Bürger?
- 9 Man vergisst immer, Begreifen, das kommt von Greifen.
- 10 Administration de la nature et des forêts.
- 11 habe meine Mut gefassen
- 12This interview was conducted on July 12., 2023.
- 13 Loi du 18 juillet 2018 concernant la protection de la nature et des ressources naturelles et modifiant.
- 14 Ich meine, ich selbst, vor 2020, hatte ich jetzt auch nicht so viel Ahnung.
- 15 Le syndicat intercommunal pour la conservation de la nature, “Intercommunal nature conservation association”.
- 161This part contains incomprehensible or inaudible words. The same applies below.
- 16 Bei Tagfaltern als kleiner Experte
- 17 Schmetterlinge insbesondere haben sich dann auch als Hauptinteresse dann rauskristallisiert, deswegen dann auch die Schmetterlingsführung.
- 18Horse whisperer
- 19Donkey whisperer
- 20Grand Duchy’s Feathered friends, pseudonym for the publication.
- 21The scientific Latin name of Goldcrest is “Regulus regulus”.
- 22Literal translation by DeepL Translator https://www.deepl.com/en/translator.
- 23abbreviation of Wunngemeinschaft [LB], shared flat.