Notes
6. Conclusion
The present research investigates how ordinary citizens construct and perceive their connections with nature in everyday life, and what kinds of human-nature relationships are valued in these connections. To this end, I conducted participant observation and ethnographic interviews with a group of environmental volunteers affiliated with the Luxembourg-based nature NGO, LetzEarth. Drawing on the Grounded Theory Method (GTM) and informed by the theoretical lens of relational values (RV), this study addresses the following research questions:
- Which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening connection with nature?
- What views of nature and human-nature relationships are embedded in participants’ engagement with nature from these perspectives?
Participants emphasised three dimensions integral to developing meaningful connections with nature: embodied experiences, intellectual engagement and emotional resonance. From an embodied perspective, participants highlighted the importance of direct, physical interactions with species and landscapes, treating nature not as an abstract entity or an invisible substrate, but as a concrete and tangible interaction partner. In terms of intellectual engagement, they underlined the value of relational learning about nature, namely acquiring nature knowledge through social networks, recognising ecological interdependencies and cultivating a sense of connectedness. Emotionally, participants expressed that aesthetic appreciation and intuitive empathy foster enduring bonds with nature. Positive affective responses, including hope and optimism, were valued both as motivational forces sustaining a lasting connection with nature and a significant outcome of their nature engagement.
Participants’ engagement with nature through these perspectives reveals a nuanced understanding of human-nature relationships. In their experiences, nature is not a passive backdrop or an inert object to be managed and to project knowledge and emotions onto; rather, it is foregrounded as an active guide, participant and collaborator in their environmental learning and volunteering activities. Through these interactions, participants demonstrated an awareness of nature’s agency, which encompasses its resilience, expressiveness, self-organisation and capacity to affect human actions, perceptions and emotions. Moreover, they embrace a notion of human-inclusive naturalness, valuing human interaction with nature guided by the awareness of co-agency with nature not as a threat to “naturalness” or “wilderness”, but as a meaningful way to cultivate reciprocal human-nature relationships. Their appreciation of nature’s agency and human-inclusive naturalness suggests a shift away from hierarchical, human-dominant paradigms toward a more collaborative model of human-nature relations.
The findings of this research offer heartening implications for re-establishing human-nature connections from three aspects. First, they reveal a variety of accessible, everyday entry points for engaging with nature, grounding the notion of “connection” in concrete actions and emotions that are both feasible and relatable to the general public. Second, the findings highlight the diversity of environmental epistemology embedded in everyday human-nature interactions – specifically, what is considered knowledge about nature and where such knowledge originates. By valuing hands-on practices, informal experiential learning and intuitive emotional connections, the discourses of these environmental volunteers challenge the axiological scientism and point toward a relational, everyday way of knowing nature. Third, this research demonstrates that ordinary individuals can develop nuanced understandings of human-nature relationships through their daily engagement with nature. This further supports the idea that meaningful connections with nature are attainable for the broader public through embodied interaction with nature and relational learning about nature. In response to the growing call to reconnect people with nature, this study offers practical implications for environmental policies and education. It indicates the importance of facilitating physical access to nature and promoting relational approaches to environmental education. Such approaches prioritise learning about ecological interconnections through both direct experiences with nature and social connections, thereby fostering a holistic view of the closely intertwined human-nature relationship.
The finding that participants value nature’s agency challenges the instrumental view of nature, which conceptualises it primarily as a resource and form of capital. This utilitarian perspective, often reflected in environmental policy discourses advocating for reconnection with nature as crucial for human livelihoods and sustainable development (see Díaz et al., 2018; United Nations, n.d.; UNESCO, n.d.a, n.d.b), has been critically examined in previous empirical studies such as Pounds (2021) and Thekaekara (2021). While the instrumental framing raises awareness of the urgency of reconnecting with nature, it ultimately positions nature as a passive object to be utilised or managed. As such, it risks reinforcing the exploitative logic that underlies the contemporary human-nature alienation and the resulting environmental crisis. In contrast, the recognition of human-nature co-agency revealed in this study underlines the importance of reconnecting with nature from a more relational perspective – one in which nature actively shapes human knowledge, emotions and ways of acting. This form of reconnection goes beyond material survival that is emphasised in instrumental framings, and moves towards nature-inclusive eudaimonia, namely a flourishing life in which nature is an integral part (Knippenberg et al., 2018). Such a perspective marks a critical step away from human-dominance models and toward more reciprocal and collaborative human–nature relationships.
Participants’ recognition of human-inclusive naturalness further illustrates their explicit relational valuing of nature. Rather than being entirely committed to the notion of nature’s intrinsic rights and moral worth independent of humans (see Elliot, 2025; Muradian and Pascual, 2018), they foreground the interconnection and inseparability between people and nature. This finding confirms the necessity of the relational turn in valuing nature, which argues that reconnecting people with nature requires grounding our understanding of nature in everyday, tangible relationships rather than abstract philosophical conceptualisations. By anchoring the notion of human-inclusive naturalness in real-life human-nature interactions and personal thoughts, this research provides concrete examples of how people value “preferences, principles and virtues associated with relationships with and responsibilities towards nature” (Muradian & Pascual, 2018, p.8, emphasis in original) in everyday life. In doing so, it offers a grounded answer to de Groot’s (1992) question: “what are the values, the desirable qualities, specific to the people-nature relationship?” (p.531). The findings of this research suggest that human actions in nature should not be entirely demonised – especially in the context of today’s environmental crisis – and that enforcing a strict human-nature dichotomy may not be the most effective remedy. Instead, we should encourage human-nature interactions that reflect a collaborative orientation and recognition of human-nature co-agency.
By challenging the instrumental view of nature and foregrounding a relational perspective, this research not only affirms the relevance and practical significance of the relational value framework, but also contributes to the growing body of empirical studies on relational values. As discussed in the section Researching Relational Values, there remains a scarcity of qualitative research exploring how relational values are enacted in ordinary people’s everyday interaction with nature. This study takes a step toward addressing this gap by illuminating the perceived benefits, preferences, and beliefs people hold about their connections with nature in daily life. Moreover, while the concept of relational values serves as a conceptual bridge between people and nature, previous studies reviewed in the literature chapter have primarily centred on human experiences and social constructs, such as sense of community, identity, eudaimonia, and place attachment (see Bataille et al., 2021; Cundill et al., 2017; Kaltenborn et al., 2017; Klain et al., 2017; Kleespies & Dierkes, 2020; Knippenberg et al., 2018; Pratson et al., 2023; Saito et al., 2022). Few have examined relational values in terms of how people perceive nature itself and the meaning of “naturalness”. In this context, the findings of this study suggest that a relational approach to interacting with nature fosters nuanced perceptions of nature, particularly the recognition of nature’s agency and humans as integral to naturalness. Therefore, this research conceptually expands the relational value framework by illustrating how relational values can encompass not only human-centred meanings but also perceptions of nature per se.
In addition to the practical and conceptual contributions, this research also expands the scope of empirical inquiry within environmental ethnography. By amplifying the voices of ordinary citizens and exploring their everyday connections with nature through ethnographic methods, this study addresses the need for an ethnographic exploration of mundane, non-crisis-based encounters with nature. The findings showcase that the small and routine interactions with nature can foster meaningful connections between people and nature. These interactions, although they often remain invisible in activism or crisis narratives, have the power to motivate environmental engagement and shape nuanced environmental perceptions among ordinary people. As such, this study offers an alternative perspective for studying human-nature relationships – one grounded in everyday experience and framed through a lens of hope.
Situated within the interdisciplinary field of Environmental Humanities, this research employs the Grounded Theory Method to elicit environmental discourses rooted in real-life human-nature interactions. By attending to participants’ language use that articulates their arguments, ideas, concepts and categories related to their interactions and relationships with nature (Hajer & Versteeg, 2005; Mühlhäusler & Peace, 2006), this study also adopts a discourse-oriented approach. Thereby, it contributes two novel perspectives to applied linguistics research on human-nature connections. First, it introduces value as a key dimension in studying the role of language in shaping human-nature relationships, complementing existing emphases on knowledge (Harrison, 2023) and ideology (Stibbe, 2015). By focusing on how ordinary people articulate their personal preferences, beliefs and principles regarding their connection with nature, this research sheds light on individual foundations that inform broader social and cultural orientations toward nature. In doing so, it helps identify practical leverage points – “places in complex systems to intervene to generate change” (Ives et al., 2018, p.1389) – for fostering public reconnection with nature. Second, this study demonstrates the potential of ethnographic methods in advancing environmental discourse research. As discussed before, much of the existing literature in this field relies on textual analysis of media, policy documents, and literary works. In contrast, relatively few studies have examined environmental discourses as they emerge in real-time, everyday interactions. This is a gap that ethnographic methods, such as participant observation and ethnographic interviews, are well-suited to tackle. Compared to the relatively stable and fixed nature of textual data, the heterogeneous and context-dependent nature of ethnographic linguistic data poses challenges in both data collection and analysis. However, the dynamic nature of ethnographic data enables the capture of complexity and nuance grounded in lived experience. This research embraces this challenge and offers grounded insights into how human-nature relationships are articulated and negotiated in real-life discursive practices.
This ethnographic case study, conducted at an environmental NGO in Luxembourg, opens new avenues for future empirical research on human-nature relationships. As most participants are senior citizens, their discourses often reflect a sense of “nature nostalgia” – a retrospective sentiment for the more nature-connected ways of life in earlier decades, characterised by less technological intrusion and slower paces of life. This nostalgia is often accompanied by a lament over the younger generation’s lack of interest in and direct experiences with nature. However, it is important to recognise that younger people are navigating a distinct set of social, cultural and political contexts and challenges, which likely shape their perceptions and experiences of connection – and disconnection – with nature in different ways. Future research could therefore illuminate the lived experiences with nature of younger generations and elevate their voices in articulating what nature means to them. Moreover, this study focuses on a group of environmental volunteers whose relationships with nature are largely non-consumptive and reciprocal. To develop a more comprehensive understanding of the diversity and complexity of human-nature relationships, it would be valuable to explore communities whose practices with nature may initially appear extractive, such as hunters, fishermen and loggers. Their perspectives may reveal the role of nature in cultural traditions, insights into sustainable human-nature coexistence, and tensions between people and nature, as well as between community values and environmental policies. Overall, this ethnographic inquiry demonstrates how attending to people’s lived experiences and personal values can shed light on the multifaceted issue of human-nature connection. By embracing this approach, future research can uncover the diversity embedded within this connection and help identify common ground for fostering more harmonious coexistence between humanity and nature.
At the very end of this book, I invite readers to revisit my main findings and arguments in a non-conventional format: a poem co-created by Michael and myself. The lines of the poem are drawn from the interview with Michael, previously cited in Chapter 5. In rearranging his words and shaping them into a poetic form, I aim to highlight once again the insightful and heartfelt lessons shared by my participants: meaningful connections with nature can be cultivated through seemingly small actions and everyday moments. Nature, through its expressiveness and agency, never stops being a part of human life. In reconnecting with it, we are not only working to prevent further environmental degradation, but also searching for sources of relief, resilience, and hope.
We must be grounded, in contact with the soil,
so when the voltage runs too high,
the Earth protects you – you won’t die.
Deers in the forest, birds in the garden.
Collect fruit, make jam.
My grandpa, my father.
We can get food from nature,
we can be in harmony with it.
With the children, barefoot in the woods,
with blindfolds covering their eyes.
Hand in hand, we stand together,
Feeling the forest with our feet.
“What did you feel?”
“A spider going down near me.”
A bee flying by, leaves rustling.
These are all the things,
that we must feel in the woods.
Feel the trees, they are our friends,
embrace it with closed eyes.
The beech has a smooth trunk,
The oak wears grey bark.
We are not grounded anymore.
There must be contact with the soil.
When the voltage runs too high,
the Earth protects you – you won’t die.