Skip to main content

Connecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain: 4. Analytical Framework

Connecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain
4. Analytical Framework
  • Show the following:

    Annotations
    Resources
  • Adjust appearance:

    Font
    Font style
    Color Scheme
    Light
    Dark
    Annotation contrast
    Low
    High
    Margins
  • Search within:
    • My Notes + Comments
    • Notifications
    • Privacy
  • Publication HomeConnecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain
  • Publications
  • Learn more about Manifold

Notes

table of contents
  1. Cover image
  2. Title Page
  3. Imprint
  4. Logos
  5. Contents
  6. Figures
  7. Tables
  8. Abbreviations
  9. 1. Introduction
  10. 2. Literature Review
  11. 3. Methodology
  12. 4. Analytical Framework
  13. 5. Findings and Discussion
  14. 6. Conclusion
  15. References

4. Analytical Framework

Navigating the Analytical Challenges of Ethnographic Inquiry

As outlined in the previous chapter, this research adopts an ethno-case study approach, employing ethnography as a way of seeing (Wolcott, 2008) the foreshadowed problems (Delamont, 2004). An ethnographic way of seeing involves collecting and synthesising heterogeneous data generated in real-life settings, such as fieldnotes, video recordings, ethnographic interviews, and relevant textual or visual materials. Moreover, it requires the ethnographer to remain attentive to what is actually unfolding in the field and how participants experience meanings from their own perspectives, rather than imposing the researcher’s speculations upon the field and its actors. Therefore, the “foreshadowed problems” refer to a broad issue or idea that merits investigation rather than the specific object of inquiry and research questions that will eventually define the niche of the research. The latter ones must be constructed by the researcher during his/her engagement with the field and data. This construction is a non-linear process involving a series of iterative analytical loops (Delamont, 2004), which makes the analysis of ethnographic inquiries challenging. While a range of analytical tools are available to ethnographers, such as identifying patterns or key events, constructing visual representations (Fetterman, 2020), and applying qualitative data analysis techniques such as content analysis, thematic analysis or discourse analysis, there are no off-the-shelf analytical formulas ready for immediate use. Ethnographers must customise their analysis procedures from the outset, as each field is inherently unique, shaped by spontaneous and unrepeatable interactions. Additionally, because ethnography aligns with a constructivist epistemology where knowledge is co-constructed by participants and the researcher, its analysis is profoundly influenced by the researcher’s subjectivity. This subjectivity is shaped by factors such as the relationships he/she builds with participants, his/her initial perspectives on the field, engagement with literature, and prior research experiences. Consequently, the emergent nature of ethnographic analysis challenges researchers to “find their way through the forest” (Fetterman, 2020).

As such, in the following sections of this chapter, I will explain how I navigated the analytical challenges throughout this ethnographic research. I will outline my actions and decisions taken across three phases: (1) re-defining the foreshadowed problem, followed by a return to the field with a revised perspective; (2) conducting an initial round of data analysis in parallel with literature review, which led to the refinement of the object of inquiry and formulation of research questions; and (3) undertaking a second round of data analysis using Grounded Theory Method (GTM), which informed the organisation of my findings as presented in the chapter Findings and Discussion. This procedure is illustrated in Figure 10. By tracing my trajectory of data analysis, I aim to highlight the emergent nature of this research and invite readers to join me in considering the positioning of this ethno-case study within both real-life practices and conceptual frameworks.

Figure 10: Analytical phases.
Figure 10: Analytical phases.

Redefining the Foreshadowed Problem

Although it is essential for ethnographers to avoid bringing preconceived ideas into the field, “the exhortation to beware of bias should not be interpreted as an injunction against prior thought”, since “there is a difference between an open mind and empty head” (Dey, 1993, p.65). To make sense of the field and produce new knowledge, researchers should take advantage of accumulated knowledge rather than dispense with it (ibid.). Therefore, ethnographers enter the field with “an intellectually thoughtful set of foreshadowed problems” (Delamont, 2004, section “Foreshadowed Problem(S)”). These foreshadowed problems are “ideas that will guide the access negotiations, the initial fieldwork, the early writing of the out-of-the-field diary. These come from reading, from colleagues and mentors, from the core of the discipline” (ibid.). As previously discussed, such foreshadowed problems are relatively general notions that will give rise to the specific object of inquiry and research questions.

In this research, the foreshadowed problem was profoundly shaped not only by my engagement with the literature and discussions with my thesis supervisor, but also by the field itself, particularly through my experience of the “waiting field”, as discussed in the section Entering the Field. At the earliest stage of my doctoral research, my intended focus was to explore the role of multilingualism in communication within the context of environmental volunteering. However, following the initial exchanges with the volunteer coordinator, Emma, and early interactions with participants in the waiting field, it became clear to me that this focus did not reflect the major concerns of the people in the field. They did not perceive languages and multilingualism as particularly impactful or contentious in conducting conservation work, organising nature-related activities or communicating environmental goals. For example, as Emma noted in the first interview regarding the “Discussions Publiques” and the NGO’s conservation information flyers:

And so for instance, for the Discussions Publiques, we’ve never had a Discussion publique where suddenly we were like ‘oh no! We cannot find a common language!’ There’s- like even if we don’t indicate a language, we will find a common one, and people will be like ‘oh no worries let’s talk in English’ or ‘let’s talk in French then.’ If that’s like how we can communicate all together. I mean that can go wrong if once you have a person that really doesn’t understand one, or the other language but- and that’s also how I feel about the local sections, I feel like Luxembourgish people know so many languages that it is actually easy for them to switch, and I feel like language is not the most important.[…] We have [the flyers] in French and English. And we said we would do it in French and English, and check out how it will go, and then we would see whether we would get a lot of feedback ‘Oh why don’t you have it in Luxembourgish?’ Or, yeah and then we might translate it but for now it has actually never been a question.

Therefore, had I insisted on my initial foreshadowed problem and imposed it onto the field, it would have created a disconnect between the research and the realities of the field. Such a mismatch would have significantly undermined the richness and validity of the research outcomes and diminished this study’s practical relevance.

While participants did not view language and communication as a major concern in their environmental volunteering, their reflections on human-nature connections emerged as a recurring theme throughout the fieldwork. Senior volunteers from different local sections independently articulated a shared concern about the growing disconnection they observed between the younger generation and nature, which is reflected in the noticeable lack of younger volunteers within the NGO. They often spoke about their physical interactions with nature or efforts to facilitate such experiences for others, and expressed both the enjoyment they found in learning about and being with nature as well as the deep concerns about the contemporary anthropogenic environmental problems. Their environmental volunteering activities, such as cleaning nest boxes, ringing wild birds, and maintaining traditional orchards and wetlands, left a strong impression on me. These practices suggested to me that domesticated, managed and even human-created landscapes are regarded by these people as part of nature, and that human presence and intervention in nature are acknowledged and valued. This perspective reflects a rejection of the notion of human-nature dichotomy, instead emphasising connection, interaction and mutual influence between human and nature. Therefore, I discerned that the issue of the human-nature connection held central significance for the people in the field. Consequently, after six months of initial engagement with the “waiting field” and a series of data discussion sessions with my thesis supervision committee, I decided to shift my research focus toward exploring the human-nature connections in the field.

Thus, I began the first round of data analysis guided by the revised foreshadowed problem: how participants’ connection with nature was unfolding, perceived and constructed on the ground.

First Round of Data Analysis: Refining the Object of Inquiry and Formulating Research Questions

Figure 11: Procedure of the first round of data analysis.
Figure 11: Procedure of the first round of data analysis.

Centred on the revised foreshadowed problem of human-nature connections, the first round of data analysis followed an iterative process that was both data-driven and literature-informed. The goal of the initial round of analysis was to construct the object of inquiry and to formulate research questions. This phase involved identifying key events within the data and generating relevant themes, reviewing pertinent empirical studies that could help interpret these events and themes, re-examining the data through writing, and finding operating concepts (Figure 11).

Identifying Key Events and Generating Themes

The initial identification of the key events was conducted intuitively. I began by asking myself two introspective questions: Which moments from the fieldwork or interview narratives left the strongest impression on me? How do these moments speak to me? When scrutinising the data through the lens of these two questions, I tried to position myself more as a “storyteller” than a “researcher”: If I were to tell the story of the people I encountered during fieldwork, what kind of story would it be? Which episodes would I choose to share with the audience, and how might these episodes come together to form the chapters of the story? With these questions in mind, my first step was to identify the incidents from each session of fieldwork and interview that resonated with me emotionally or challenged my prior assumptions. I documented my responses to these moments. Then, I reviewed the data with these key events as a reference point, in order to determine whether each event formed a part of a broader pattern or stood out as a singularly significant incident. In the following paragraphs, I will elaborate on this procedure through two examples.

During an interview with Eric, who is one of Luxembourg’s most prominent ornithology experts and the author of several scientific publications on the country’s avifauna and natural landscapes, I was surprised to learn that he had never pursued formal education in relevant disciplines such as biology or ecology. Instead, Eric took pride in having acquired extensive knowledge and deep insights into local ecology through self-directed learning characterised by sustained physical engagement with nature. I noted down my reflections:

Very touched by Eric. He was born during the WWII in a working class family in Luxembourg. Due to the difficulty circumstances, he never had a chance to go to the university despite his excellent academic performance in school. However, thanks to his curiosity and love of nature, he self-taught himself into an expert on bird conservation and contributed to several books on science communication. Reviewing the interview with him, I can’t help reflecting on my own luck and privilege, on my fantasy of higher education being the only place for knowledge production, and also on my unnecessary pride of being a PhD student. (Reflective notes on 27.03.2024)

Eric’s extraordinarily fruitful learning experiences outside formal education contexts sensitised me to the theme of “learning about nature”. Using this key event as a reference point, I asked the following questions as part of a larger set that guided the re-examination of the data: Did other participants also value learning about nature? If so, how did they learn? Did they place particular emphasis on learning within or outside formal education contexts? These questions enabled me to detect participants’ opinions, narratives or actions that related to the same theme in other parts of the data, which may be articulated in a subtle and indirect way or not have left as strong an impression on me. I refer to these as “satellite events”. The key event, alongside satellite events, gave rise to a broader thematic pattern. Regarding the theme of “learning about nature”, I identified several statements, narratives and actions in interviews and fieldwork that reflect how participants perceive and engage with this learning. For example:

Birgit: Das ganze Wissen, was ich zum Beispiel erhalte über die Natur, habe ich mir selbst beigebracht. Also ich bin keine Biologin, nichts gelernt, gar nicht. Habe ich nur alles im Laufe der Jahre selbst beigebracht und all die Pflanzen, all die Vögel, all die Tiere, die ich kenne, und Zusammenhänge und so weiter, wie gesagt, alles selbst beigebracht. Und eben auch am Hand von LetzEarth, wo ich Kurs mitgemacht habe und solche Sachen, weil ich Aktivitäten dabei war und gelernt habe und das heute halt wieder weitergebe.

(All the knowledge, for example, what I know about nature, I taught myself. I’m not a biologist, I didn’t study it, not at all. I’ve just taught myself everything over the years, all the plants, all the birds, all the animals I know, and how they are connected with each other and so on, like I said, I learnt all by myself. And also with the help of LetzEarth, where I took courses and stuff like that, because I participated in the activities and learnt things, and now I’m passing that on.)

Daniel: […] und so habe ich dann mich Stück für Stück immer weiter familiarisiert mit den Arten und so weiter. So viel zumindest zum Bestimmen der Arten und dann ja weitere biologische Zusammenhänge oder ökologische, dass das kommt dann noch so ein bisschen dazu. Je mehr man, wie sagt. die Protagonisten in der Natur kennt, dann auf einmal versteht man auch wie die miteinander so ein bisschen wechsel, wirken.

([…]and so, little by little, I gradually became more and more familiar with the species and so on. At least that’s how much I know about identifying species, and then there are other biological and ecological connections that come into play as well. The more you know about the protagonists in nature, the more you understand how they interact with each other.)

Bob: […] So I’ve always said, among experts, I’m a layman, but among laypeople, I’m an expert. So the people who go on these walks don’t want hugely expert opinion. If I can say, “That’s a golden oriole and it lives there and it does this,” people go, “wow! How do you know that?” It’s just something I’ve acquired over the years.

Therefore, I came to realise that “learning about nature” is a theme that resonated broadly with the participants. Accordingly, it warrants deeper investigation in the next stage of analysis.

One standout key event was Jenny’s planting of non-native fruit tree seedlings in the local traditional orchard. During the fieldwork in several of Luxembourg’s traditional orchards, I learnt that the country’s meadow orchards are predominantly composed of native fruit tree species, most notably apples and pears, with occasional plums and cherries. However, during a session of fieldwork in late September 2023, I observed Jenny planting fig tree seedlings in the orchard she and her fellow volunteers looked after. Although this act initially struck me as somewhat “unnatural”, it was, in fact, Jenny’s attempt to support the orchard in adapting to the impacts of climate change. In addition to recording Jenny’s actions with the videocam, I documented my observations and thoughts in the fieldnotes:

Jenny called the three fig trees “an exotic corner” and “an experiment”. The label of the fig is “dessert king”. There were disagreeing voices regarding planting fig trees in the orchard of [place], because they are not “traditional” and “einheimisch”7 species in Luxembourg. But against the backdrop of climate change (see also the video when we talk about apples this year). The temperature is getting higher, and recently it has been less raining. Unlike it used to be, in the recent years the orchard is facing drought – no natural water in weeks during summer. Such climate is not good for the “traditional” apple and pear species, and Jenny and her colleagues are witnessing this change. However, such climate is suitable for fig to grow. So they start this experiment in their orchard against the “tradition” and “einheimisch”. She joked with Jules if in the coming years they would be planting coffee beans. Pay attention to their change and development of actions with nature, how they deal with / do and talk about the usually taken as negative issue – climate change. (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 30.09.2023)

This incident stood out as a singularly significant key event, not only because the action of introducing non-native species did not occur in other fieldwork sessions or interview narratives, but also because it uniquely encapsulated a complicated aspect of the human-nature relationship. The seemingly mundane act of planting fruit tree seedlings revealed a compelling paradox: While the action initially struck me and met with external criticism as “unnatural”, the participant perceived it as a “natural” strategy for enacting nature’s resilience in response to environmental change. Challenging my assumptions about the meaning of “natural”, this key event pointed to the interplay between human actions in nature and people’s perceptions of the human-nature relationship as a potential lens for interpreting the data.

The above two examples illustrate the initial stage of the first round of data analysis, in which I identified key events and considered whether these incidents indicated broader patterns or represented singular, meaningful cases. Importantly, this reflective process did not begin only after I exited the field in November 2024; instead, I engaged in it throughout the entire data collection phase. As Cohen et al. (2017) remark, qualitative data analysis is not an isolated later stage of the research, but rather an ongoing process that runs through the entire project, meaning that data collection and analysis are frequently conducted simultaneously. Since the key events embody a concrete manifestation of the foreshadowed problem of the human-nature connection, maintaining a continuous attentiveness to them during both data collection and analysis provided me with a problem-oriented lens. Through this lens, I could engage with the fragmented field and heterogeneous data with an awareness of what I could – though not necessarily should – look for in fieldwork and unstructured interviews. Here, I emphasise that these key events informed me about what I could, rather than should, attend to, because I believe these key events should serve as inspirations that suggest possible directions for navigating the field and engaging with the data, rather than instructions that impose fixed perceptions onto the field. Treating key events as rigid guides risks bringing preconceptions into the field and desensitising the researcher to other meaningful niches in data, which is what ethnographic research explicitly seeks to avoid. In the meantime, attentiveness to key incidents helped me identify potential points of convergence within the data, as well as divergences or even tensions between participants’ differing experiences and perspectives. These preliminary findings prompt me to make sense of the data more comprehensively and construct a “story” from the data, as mentioned previously.

I documented this tentative analysis guided by the identification of key events in a Word document titled Story of Data and an accompanying Excel table. In Story of Data, I organised the key events, satellite events, and my impressions, reflections and preliminary interpretation within a thematic structure. Each theme was derived in relation to the foreshadowed problem – human-nature connection – and used as the section title. I included screenshots from video recordings and excerpts from interviews or fieldnotes that outline the key events, alongside my tentative interpretations and, where applicable, contextual information or supporting literature. To facilitate the subsequent analysis, I used colour codes to highlight what I considered particularly noteworthy about the key event. Figures 12 and 13 present example pages from Story of Data. In the accompanying Excel table, I documented all the themes from Story of Data, as Figure 14 shows. Next, I move to explain how a data-driven literature review has contributed to constructing my object of inquiry.

Figure 12: Page from "Story of Data" (1).
Figure 12: Page from "Story of Data" (1).
Figure 13: Page from "Story of Data" (2).
Figure 13: Page from "Story of Data" (2).
Figure 14: Excel table with themes derived from key events.
Figure 14: Excel table with themes derived from key events.

Reviewing Existing Empirical Studies

By identifying key events and generating tentative themes, I developed an initial understanding of the ethnographic data. As shown in the Excel table (Figure 14), learning about nature emerges as a prominent theme. Additionally, participants perceived human presence and activities in nature from a relatively positive perspective compared to the crisis narrative of Anthropocene, while also navigating mixed emotions related to their environmental engagement. However, this preliminary understanding did not yet constitute a clearly defined line of inquiry. To sharpen the analytical focus, it became essential to situate this study within specific areas of research and clarify the academic debates to which it aims to contribute. To this end, I engaged with existing empirical studies that have explored human-nature connections and addressed themes that resonate with those emerging from my data. This step helped position my research within ongoing scholarly conversations and therefore contributed to refining the broad foreshadowed problem into a more focused analytical thread.

As outlined in the section Re-Defining the Foreshadowed Problem, this ethnographic research aims to explore human-nature connections by examining how people perceive and construct these connections in their interactions with nature and the ways they articulate their relevant experiences. The themes emerging from my data pertain to people’s lived practices, emotions, perceptions and meaning-making processes related to nature. Accordingly, this research has the potential to contribute to the discussions within the fields of environmental ethnography and environmental discourse. Environmental ethnography seeks to understand how environmental concepts and issues are perceived and experienced on the ground by relating diverse nature-related “knowledge, everyday perspectives and experiences” to one another (Greschke, 2015, p.137). The field of environmental discourse examines the “ensemble of ideas, concepts and categories” through which meaning is given to nature and which are expressed and reproduced through language and practices related to human–nature interactions (Hajer & Versteeg, 2005, p.175). Therefore, I anchored this research at the intersection of these two fields, and mapped the landscape of relevant empirical studies by compiling an annotated bibliography, as exemplified by Figure 15:

Figure 15: Example page from annotated bibliography.
Figure 15: Example page from annotated bibliography.

This data-driven literature review, with a focus on empirical studies, contributed to the construction of my object of inquiry. Since both environmental ethnography and environmental discourse are interdisciplinary research fields rather than stand-alone academic disciplines, reviewing empirical studies from both areas revealed a range of theoretically and conceptually grounded themes from diverse disciplines that resonate with those emerging from my heterogeneous data. For example, environmental knowledge is a central theme of studies in Indigenous studies and environmental education. Insights from these studies often illuminate how and what people learn about nature, and how this learning interplays with how they relate to nature. This prompted me to approach the theme of “learning about nature” through the lens of the human-nature relationship. Human domination of nature frequently appears as a theme in studies of environmental justice and ecofeminism. Their argument that the human power over nature is rooted in the suppression of women and marginalised groups led me to reflect on and redefine the theme of environmental stewardship in my own data. Ecolinguistics’ focus on the role of language in shaping people’s view of nature and their relationships with it highlights language as an effective entry point to elicit and understand participants' emotions and perceptions regarding nature. Thus, reviewing these empirical studies from environmental ethnography and environmental discourse provided me with a frame for linking my data to the concepts of human-nature connection and relationship from epistemological, ontological and methodological perspectives. It also encouraged my deliberate engagement with conceptual tools from multiple disciplines – including linguistics, sociology, psychology, education and philosophy – to examine the scattered data on two interrelated levels: first, how participants connect with nature with respect to practices and experiences; and second, how they relate to nature in terms of the meaning and quality of the relationships they perceived and constructed. Therefore, this data-driven review of empirical studies has informed a further refinement of the object of inquiry. The foreshadowed problem of the human-nature connection has been developed into a two-layered set of questions: How do participants connect with nature, and what kind of relationships are constructed through connections?

Re-Examining Data Through Writing

The two questions derived from the data-driven review of existing empirical studies guided a re-examination of the data. In this step, the tentative themes were subject to “continual modification, addition, refinement, excision, extension and amendment” (Cohen et al., 2017, section 32.1). During this process, the lenses of connection with nature and relationship with nature served as “pre-ordinate analytical tools” that had been decided prior to the re-examination phase (ibid.). The objective of this phase is to explore what insights the data can offer into how participants experience, enact and perceive their connections with nature and how they position themselves in relation to nature. For this purpose, I employed writing as a method of analysis. According to Richardson (2024), writing is “a method of inquiry, a way of finding out about yourself and your topic” (p.179, emphasis in original). In a similar vein, Mitchell and Clark (2021) remind us that “[w]riting does not just report – but adds to and becomes part of the research method” (p.1). Specifically, my analytical writing involved composing a series of texts in the form of an “extensive abstract” that documented preliminary research questions, data interpretations and emerging arguments across different stages of the research. In the following, I present several excerpts from these “extensive abstracts”:

[July 5th 2023]

my project sets out to uncover the beliefs and values towards nature and the human-nature relationship of a group of environmental volunteers and staff at a nature NGO in Luxembourg and their perceptions of their engagement there. […]

This project aims to answer the following questions:

  • What does “nature” mean to the volunteers and staff of this nature organisation?
  • Why and how do people connect with nature through volunteering at an environmental NGO?
  • What and how are the knowledge and values about nature and connecting with nature created, negotiated, and conveyed in these activities?

What gains and challenges do the environmental volunteers experience in their engagement?

[…] I argue that a comprehensive understanding of nature and the human-nature connection enables us to find appropriate ways and mindsets for a mutually beneficial co-existence between human society and natural environment, and that eventually, we should understand “nature” as a social construct and that it is not to be regarded as a wild area that is apart from the society. […]

[September 27th 2023]

[…] my dissertation explores the meanings of nature and human-nature relationships that are expressed, shaped, challenged, re-constructed and reinforced by a group of ordinary citizens from various walks of life who are highly engaged in environmental activities. Through the study of their experiences and views, this project seeks to understand from a grassroots perspective how and why people (re)connect with nature and the meanings they endow the natural world.

[…] what do people talk about when they speak about nature? What do people do to connect with nature and contribute to conservation? What beliefs and values lie behind these talks and actions? In brief, the general research question is: what are the Discourses on nature and human-nature relationship of ordinary citizens with strong environmental engagement?

To answer the general research question, I delve into concrete questions such as: why do people care and act for nature? What challenges and tensions are people experiencing in their environmental engagement? How do people talk about nature? How do people learn about nature and translate their knowledge and concerns into action? How do people reflect on their experiences?

[…] Revealing the Discourses of ordinary citizens on the notion of nature, my research contributes in an innovative way to the environmental discourse analysis by addressing some facets of the diversity and complexity of human-nature relationships from a grassroots perspective. Since grassroots environmental participation is characterised by its hands-on, wide-ranging, practical and participatory nature, it has great prospects to contribute to possible solutions to the environmental issues faced by our world. As such, the relevance of this study lies in its highlighting of new perspectives to understand this topic and potential inspiration of wider involvement with pro-nature activities.

[July 5th 2024]

[…] My fieldwork also shows that participants actively manage the local natural landscapes through maintenance and monitoring work, in Weldemariam and colleagues’ words, “to care for, to save, to conserve, to steward […]”, while sharing knowledge and skills about nature in their interactions. Researchers argue that such a view of nature risks diminishing the agency of non-human nature and forcing anthropocentric human-nature relationships (Weldemariam et al., 2017). However, my further examination of the participants’ discourse reveals that this notion of nature often motivates people to establish a long-term connection with nature, which leads them to go beyond merely viewing nature as a site for exerting human agency. They see through the agency of non-human beings and nature during their leisure time, informal learning and stewardship in nature: they talk about animals’ survival strategies, emotions and decision-making, even though some of the claims are biologically unscientific; they narrate their experiences of (almost) being hurt by wildlife as anecdotes, which indicates the respect for animals’ intrinsic right to self-defend irrespective of any human intentions or interpretations; they design awareness-raising activities that put human participants into the shoes of animals, inspiring a non-human perspective on the laws of nature; they describe nature as an active, dynamic, resilient, self-operating whole system rather than a passive substrate for human activities.

[…] The participants’ trajectories of connecting to nature show that anthropocentric perceptions can serve as an encouraging start to connection with nature. These perceptions are not rooted in human chauvinism or human exceptionism, but in weak anthropocentrism. Weak anthropocentrism advocates that non-human organisms and environment have not only material utilities and instrumental value for humans but also intrinsic value to enrich the human spiritual world; therefore humans have a moral obligation to care for nature (Niu, 2019). Framing nature as a setting for serious leisure, social relationships and informal learning, the participants act in nature to explore the intrinsic value of the natural world. The initiation often evolves into long-term engagement with nature that empowers people to adopt a biocentric perspective, which acknowledges the inherent value and moral standing of non-human life and advocates that the human moral concern should be extended beyond humankind to encompass non-human nature (Wang, 2019). This biocentric vantage point takes people’s connection to nature to a deeper level, where non-human beings and nature are perceived as subjects that can actively participate in and influence the connections between humans, non-humans and the abiotic environment.

Based on these findings, I argue that a dichotomous perspective to understand people’s views on nature does not help us grasp the complex and dynamic process in which people establish and negotiate their relationships with nature. People value human agency in nature and pursue their material and spiritual needs based on a rational understanding of human interest and nature’s inherent value, while simultaneously conceiving nature and other organisms as active entities with intrinsic values and agency. (Re)Connecting to nature is a long-term dynamic process of learning and unlearning diverse notions of nature and non-human “others” through concrete interactions with nature and acquiring knowledge, skills and meaningful social relationships in these interactions.

Readers may note that the research goals, questions, findings and arguments presented in these texts differ from those of the book; some even diverge significantly from the contents here or are entirely absent here. However, this process of writing-as-analysis constitutes an important part of the trajectory towards niche research questions. It prompted me to reflect on how my data provides insights into the issue of human-nature connections and relationships. As writing made my understanding of data and the reasoning process visible and traceable, revisiting the data through writing enabled me to recognise the “data earworms” and uncover the “plot of my data” (Mitchell &Clark, 2021). In writing the “extensive abstracts”, I repeatedly engaged in summarising, grouping and interpreting data to organise the relevant themes around the issue of human-nature connection, and developed arguments about how my data offers insights into fostering reciprocal human-nature relationships. As such, composing these texts stimulated an iterative reading of the data. During this process, it gradually crystallised that the data speak to three interrelated perspectives of participants’ connection with nature: how they interact with nature, how they view nature, and how they relate to nature. Participants interact with nature through physical contact, hands-on practices and intellectual engagement; they view nature as deeply interconnected with human existence and possesses non-instrumental value and agency; they reject the notion of human domination of nature but rather see themselves as part of nature. Thus, by this point, the object of inquiry and “plot of data” gained further clarity: This research sheds light on how people develop connections with nature, and how they view nature and their relationships with it in these connections.

Finding Operating Concepts

Following the clarification of my object of inquiry, I turned to the refinement of my research questions. For qualitative research, defining appropriate research questions is a challenging task. This is because the research questions of qualitative inquiries “should be general enough to permit exploration but focused enough to delimit the study” (Marshall & Rossman, 2016, p.176) due to the exploratory nature of qualitative research. As qualitative inquiries set out to “explore the general, complex set of factors surrounding the central phenomenon and present the broad, varied perspectives or meanings that participants hold” (Creswell & Creswell, 2018, p.192), the research question should address a phenomenon or concept rather than be limited to a specific research field. This requires the researcher to anchor the research questions into certain conceptual framework(s). Therefore, before formulating the research questions, I aimed to define the operating concepts of this study, namely the analytical lenses through which I would develop data analysis.

As clarified, the central object of inquiry in this research is people’s connection with nature. Consequently, the concept of human-nature connection became the key notion shaping the research questions and guiding data interpretation. As discussed in the Literature Review chapter, the terminologies and conceptualisations regarding this concept are highly heterogeneous and fragmented. Depending on the discipline or research context, scholars have approached this connection from different perspectives, including material dependence, cerebral cognition and emotional attachment (Ives et al., 2018). This heterogeneity presented the challenge of selecting a conceptual framework that aligns with my data. Therefore, I revisited the data, the emerging themes, and the extensive abstracts to identify the types of connections with nature that were prominent in my ethnographic field. I found that participants practice and perceive their connection with nature through a range of perspectives, from physical experiences to emotional resonance. It therefore became essential to select a notion that could encompass the multiple dimensions emerging from the data. With this in mind, I adopted the conceptual framework of human-nature connection (HNC) proposed by Ives et al. (2017), which identifies five types of connections to nature, ranging from material, experiential, cognitive, emotional and philosophical. Compared to related concepts that focus on a single aspect of either psychological attachment or physical interactions with nature, such as “nature connectedness”, “nature relatedness” and “contact with nature”, the five-dimensional HNC framework offers a more comprehensive approach to exploring people’s connection with nature from diverse perspectives. It enables me to approach the theme of connection with nature not only as a general phenomenon under examination but also to delve into its diversity and multifaceted nature in a more nuanced way.

As the relationship between participants and nature also emerged as a core theme in this research, the notion of the human-nature relationship also became an operating concept. Notably, this concept is included within the HNC framework, which is referred to as the philosophical aspect of the human-nature connection (Ives et al., 2018). However, I chose to treat this concept as a primary analytical lens rather than as a subordinate element within the HNC framework. This decision was guided by the engagement with data. Iterative data examination revealed that themes centring on human-nature relationships – such as “stewardship”, “people as part of nature”, and “recognition of domesticated landscapes as nature” – emerged as “data earworms”, namely recurring motifs, forming a pattern with analytical significance in its own right. While participants’ actions and accounts revealed the process and means by which they developed connections with nature, they also illuminated how participants positioned themselves in relation to nature within those connections. In this sense, the human-nature connection lens enables me to explore people’s practices and experiences in building connections with nature, while a human-nature relationship perspective allows for a deeper examination of the meanings people attribute to those connections. Therefore, I decided to treat the human-nature relationship as an operating concept on equal footing with human-nature connections.

To define human-nature relationship as an analytical concept for this research, I turned to the literature in environmental philosophy. Environmental philosophers often use metaphors to describe this relationship, for example, portraying humans as a master, processor, engineer, guardian or caretaker of nature, or as an adventurer, participant in nature (see de Groot, 1992; de Groot et al., 2006). While these are powerful illustrations of the power dynamics views of nature embedded in the diverse human-nature relationships, they do not provide a systematic analytical model with explicit entry points to approach this notion. Additionally, I do not seek to use my data to validate any existing relationship image, but rather to examine how the data can elicit new insights into this concept. Therefore, a more structured conceptual framework is required. In light of this, I chose to draw on the conceptualisation and sub-concepts within Muradian and Pascual’s (2018, p.10) human-nature relational model to develop my data analysis.

Table 4: An Elementary Typology of Human-Nature Relational Models (This table is derived from A Typology of Elementary Forms of Human-Nature Relations: A Contribution to the Valuation Debate, by R. Muradian and U. Pascual, 2016, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, p.8–14. © 2016 Elsevier B.V.).
RelationalModelSociety–Nature DistinctionNature with agencyHuman–Nature RelationshipEmotional DriversPractices
DetachmentYesNoNature invisibleIndifference

Absence of codified

practices

DominationYesNoNature as inferior to humansFear

Rules and norms

based on human

entitlement and superiority

DevotionNoYesNature superior to humans

Seek of transcendence

Obligation

Rituals, taboos, religious practices
StewardshipNoNoHumans as part of natureCare, sense of belonging, identityConservation- and management-oriented rules and norms
WardshipYesNoNature as separate entity with intrinsic rightsAppreciation, peacefulness, care

Rules and norms

where delimitation of

pristine spaces or

conditions, and

biocentrism prevail

Ritualized exchangeNoYesHumans and nature as equalsObligation

Rules and norms

based on the sense of

partnership

UtilizationYesNoNature as separate entity without intrinsic rights

Needs satisfaction,

hedonic pleasure

Rules based on

rational calculation

and market

orientation

This conceptual framework of human-nature relational models serves as a useful analytical tool for this research. From a theoretical point of view, it breaks down the notion of human-nature relationship into conceptually grounded, explicit dimensions for analysis. From a data-driven perspective, since the themes emerging from my data encompass the society-nature distinction, nature’s agency, emotional drivers and interaction approaches with nature, this framework enabled me to transform what initially appeared as scattered themes into nuanced dimensions for examining human-nature relationships.

Compared to the more straightforward selection of human-nature connection and human-nature relationship as operating concepts, the choice of the third concept, relational values, was less direct. This was because it emerged as a notion that was “responsive to the emerging data and their analysis and interpretation (a posteriori)” (Cohen et al., 2017, section 32.1, emphasis in original). While participants’ narratives of their experiences with nature and real-life actions during fieldwork offered insights into how people cultivate various connections with nature in practice, the data also revealed that participants held compelling understandings of why connection with nature is important. They also expressed ethical stances on how one should interact with nature and what qualities make their relationships with nature reciprocal. These understandings and stances reflect their beliefs about what is important, right, and preferred, which is the core concern addressed by the notion of value. The value-related themes emerging from my data include a sense of responsibility towards nature and future generations, hope and optimism for environmental engagement, and respect for nature as an active agent rather than an inert subordinate to humans. These perspectives clearly diverge from the notion of instrumental value, which treats the valued object merely as a means to an end. However, I also found the lens of intrinsic value inadequate for interpreting my data, as it did not appear that participants viewed nature as possessing moral worth independent of human presence.

A pivotal moment in identifying relational values as a suitable concept occurred during my exchange with Prof. Riyan van den Born, Director of the Centre Connecting Humans and Nature at Radboud University. Inspired by her work on people’s visions of nature (e.g. van den Born et al., 2001; van den Born, 2006a, 2006b, 2008; van den Born et al., 2018; van den Born et al., 2024), I reached out to her via LinkedIn to ask for her advice on my preliminary findings at the time (see Figure 16). To my appreciation, Prof. van den Born responded warmly and suggested that I explore the concept of relational values. As elaborated in the Literature Review chapter, relational values proved to be a useful analytical lens for making sense of my data. First and foremost, it addresses the people’s preferences, principles and virtues associated with their relationships with nature (Chan et al., 2016), which closely resonate with my emerging findings. It provides a conceptual tool to explore participants’ views, beliefs and meaning-making regarding their relationships with nature. Analysing the data through the lens of relational values also added practical significance to my research: it highlights why (re)connecting matters for both people and nature, and why studying this connection is essential for understanding how to foster meaningful and reciprocal relationships with nature.

Figure 16: My message to Prof. van den Born about my preliminary findings.
Figure 16: My message to Prof. van den Born about my preliminary findings.

Determining Object of Inquiry and Research Questions

The first round of data analysis involved an iterative engagement with both the data and literature. Throughout this process, the object of inquiry was crystallised: This research aims to explore how people connect with nature, what kinds of relationships they construct with it, and how they value these connections in their everyday engagement with nature. To refine these broad research objectives into specific research questions, it was essential to ground the research questions in the operating concepts, as well as the “story”, or, in Cohen and colleagues’ (2017) terms, the “plot” of the data. To this end, I revisited the key events, emerging themes and extensive abstracts through the lenses of the HNC framework, models of human-nature relations and relational values. This final step in determining the research questions can be metaphorically understood as “improvisational weaving”. In this metaphor, the key notions of human-nature connection, human-nature relation and relational values function as the warps, providing a continuous structure for data analysis. The ethnographic data and emerging themes serve as the wefts, threaded through the warps. Together, the warps and wefts shape the fabric – the story of the data – while the emerging research questions are the pattern of the fabric, formed by the dynamic movement of wefts across the warps and eventually becoming visible on the surface. This weaving is improvisational because the pattern was not predefined by a weaving draft, but instead emerged from the interwoven threads of warps and wefts. The determination of the research questions is akin to the moment when the weaver steps back from the loom and recognises the delightfully surprising pattern that has appeared.

This improvisational weaving forms the fabric: my data reveals that participants connect with nature through various perspectives, including experiential, cognitive and emotional aspects. They consider these connections important for both nature and themselves, as engaging with nature through these perspectives enabled them to gain knowledge, skills, enjoyment and hope, and to develop an ecological understanding of nature. In their experiences, they constructed relationships with nature that recognise the agency of both humans and nature, and they believe that such relationships should be preferred as a remedy for the current disconnection between people and nature, as well as for addressing the environmental crisis. This plot of data sheds light on the following questions:

  • Which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening connection with nature?
  • What views of nature and human-nature relationships are embedded in participants’ engagement with nature from these perspectives?

Thus, the first round of data analysis achieved its aim: constructing the object of inquiry and defining research questions.

While the initial phase of data analysis represents the path toward formulating the research questions, the second round of analysis constitutes the trail toward answering them. In the following section, I detail my actions and decisions taken during this phase.

Second Round of Data Analysis Using Grounded Theory Method (GTM)

Once the research questions were defined, the study progressed to the next phase: systematically organising and interpreting the data using analytical tools to address the research questions. This marked the second round of data analysis, for which I selected the Grounded Theory Method (GTM) as the primary analytical tool. In this section, I explain the rationale behind this choice, describe how I coded data using GTM and operationalised the key concepts during the coding process, and clarify how I adapted the method to suit the nature of my object of inquiry and ethnographic data.

Why Grounded Theory Method as an Analytical Tool

Before I delve into the rationale behind the choice of grounded theory as the data analysis method, it is necessary to first situate this approach within my research and clarify the use of the relevant terms. According to the founders of grounded theory, Barney Glaser and Anselm Strauss (1967/2006, p.1), the approach is designed for “the discovery of theory from data” and aims to “provid[e] us with relevant predictions, explanations, interpretations and applications”. As Timmermans and Tavory (2007) elegantly noted: “In essence, grounded theory presents an analytical choreography with a deep immersion in data and then a transcendence of this data to reach higher levels of abstraction” (p.496). While Glaser and Strauss’s original definition encapsulates the core features of grounded theory, namely its close attentiveness to empirical data and its goal of constructing theories inductively, they were “often unclear in their book as to when grounded theory referred to the end product and when it referred to the methodology” (Hadley, 2019, p.265). In fact, the emphasis on “the discovery of theory from data” suggests a strong focus on grounded theory as a product, which stands “in sharp contrast to the use of grounded theory method today where it is known primarily as a method of qualitative data analysis” (Urquhart, 2023, p.4). Therefore, today’s researchers often explicitly distinguish between the Grounded Theory Method and grounded theory as the outcome of GTM’s inductive analysis (Hadley, 2019).

In this research, I employed grounded theory as an analytical tool and deliberately refrained from claiming that the study aims to construct a grounded theory of human-nature connection. This caution is based on an awareness of the limitations of the current study and the existing literature on the topic. First, as discussed in the Methodology chapter, this ethno-case study was conducted within a relatively limited timeframe and with constrained immersion in the context, which restricts the capacity of this study to construct a comprehensive stand-alone theoretical framework. Second, as demonstrated in the Literature Review chapter and the Finding Operating Concept section of this chapter, the human-nature connection is not a topic for which little or no theoretical or conceptual frameworks exist. Accordingly, the aim of this research is to offer new insights that may empirically confirm, challenge or extend existing literature, rather than to construct a self-contained theory on human-nature connection. Grounded theory as an analysis method can contribute to this purpose despite the aforementioned limitations, because

while the application of the GT method can result in a theory, in many cases, it amounts to a new or better conceptualisation or a framework that links concepts but falls short of a fully elaborated theory that covers all aspects, stages, consequences, and likelihood of a process or a phenomenon. (Timonen et al., 2018, p.4)

Therefore, treating grounded theory as a method for data analysis allows for the identification of new concepts from my ethnographic data that contribute to the development of existing theoretical explanations of the relevant experiences and phenomena (Corbin & Strauss, 2015). Hence, I chose grounded theory as the analytical tool for this research. In the following text, I use the term GTM to refer to my use of grounded theory as a data analysis method.

It is the core tenets of GTM that make it a suitable method of data analysis for this research: its embeddedness in data, its emphasis on emic and context-sensitive understandings of the object of inquiry, its theory-building orientation aimed at eliciting and constructing analytical relationships between concepts emerging from data, and its applicability to ethnographic data. First, GTM is an “exploratory, open-ended and emergent” (Hadley, 2019, p.265) method for inductive data analysis. As the attribute “grounded” indicates, the analysis starts from and is rooted in empirical data rather than predefined notions or frameworks. GTM enables data to generate analytical concepts, rather than letting concepts dictate the interpretation of data. It provides rigorous yet flexible guidelines for an inductive analysis that begins with an open exploration of the data (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). This characteristic closely corresponds to the emergent, data-oriented nature of this research. As illustrated in the previous section on the first round of data analysis, not only the object of inquiry but also the operating concepts of this research were constructed and identified from data. Therefore, GTM enables me to continuously engage in a data-driven mode of analysis, allowing my findings to remain deeply rooted in the ethnographic data. In doing so, it supports my aim of informing existing literature on human-nature connections and nature’s relational values with new insights generated from real-life settings.

GTM’s groundedness in data requires researchers to maintain openness to the empirical world and a willingness to understand the issue under examination from the perspectives of those who have experienced it (Charmaz & Thornberg, 2021). This entails paying close attention to participants’ actions and the contexts in which they are situated, as well as how they make sense of the actions and situations (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). As Charmaz (2006) describes: “we try to learn what occurs in the research settings we join and what our research participants’ lives are like. We study how they explain their statements and actions, and ask what analytic sense we can make of them” (p.2–3). This leads to the second tenet of GTM: its emphasis on pursuing context-related and emic understandings of the processes and phenomena. This core principle makes GTM a powerful tool for analysing my data in a way that aligns with the research aim, namely to elicit participants’ perceptions and values regarding their connections and relationships with nature by examining their real-life practices.

Thirdly, while this research does not seek to construct a fully elaborated theory, it aims to go beyond the mere identification and description of emerging themes. The objective is to conceptualise the themes and illuminate the relationships between them. In other words, this study not only explores what types of connections and relationships participants form with nature, as well as the values associated with these experiences, but also examines how these elements are interconnected. This aim aligns with the “theory” aspect of GTM. Compared to other qualitative data analysis methods, GTM allows for to a “more abstract and complex level of ‘conceptual density’ – that is, the place where core concepts were derived from the data, affording the basis for clear articulation of the relationships between concepts and the generation of new theoretical insights” (Bryant, 2017, p.73). However, this does not suggest that GTM is incompatible with other qualitative research approaches, particularly not with ethnography, which emphasises “thick description”. In this research, I adopted GTM within an ethno-case study framework and combined it with thematic analysis in the initial round of data analysis and techniques from discourse analysis, as will be elaborated later. Charmaz (2014) synthesises GTM with ethnographic approaches, stating: “Grounded theory ethnography gives priority to the studied phenomenon or process – rather than to a description of a setting” (section Grounded Theory in Ethnography). Therefore, GTM’s theory-building orientation enabled me to conceptualise the themes emerging from the ethnographic data and analyse the interplays between these concepts, in addition to identifying and describing them.

Finally, from a standpoint of practicability, I chose GTM as an analytical tool because it is applicable and sufficient for analysing data collected in this study, including fieldnotes, video recordings and interviews. Participant observation and qualitative interviewing are among the most commonly used data collection methods in the grounded theory approach (Timonen et al., 2018). GTM offers systematic yet flexible, data-oriented guidelines for analysing qualitative data, making it a well-suited analysis tool for this research.

Having outlined the rationale for choosing GTM as the analytical tool, I now turn to elaborating on how I applied GTM to analyse data following its guidelines.

How Grounded Theory Method Was Applied in Data Analysis

GTM encompasses a range of techniques and steps, including theoretical sampling, analytical data collecting, coding, memo writing, sorting, saturating and theorising (Charmaz, 2014; Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). As previously discussed, while this research applies GTM as a tool for data analysis, it is not a grounded theory project in the traditional or strictest sense. The study does not aim to construct a self-contained theory. Similar to how ethnography is treated in this research (as discussed in the Methodology chapter), grounded theory is adopted here as a process rather than a product. Accordingly, I selectively borrowed techniques from GTM rather than following the entire grounded theory procedure in a step-by-step manner. Specifically, I employed a GTM-informed approach to coding as the primary analytical technique for this research. Coding is “the process of defining what the data is about” (Bryant, 2017, p.120). It means identifying what the data are about by categorising segments of data with a label that simultaneously summarises and accounts for each piece of data (Charmaz, 2006). Grounded theory coding consists of three phases: initial coding, focused coding and theoretical coding (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). I now elaborate on how I applied each of these phases to code and analyse my data.

Initial Coding

Initial coding, also referred to as open coding, is the phase in which the researcher stays close to and open to the data by scrutinising and assigning codes to pieces of data, word by word, line by line, paragraph by paragraph, or incident by incident, or using a combination of these strategies (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014; Urquhart, 2023). One of the key principles of initial coding, as indicated by its alternative name, is to remain open to data (Bryant, 2017; Charmaz, 2006). This requires the researcher to avoid examining the data through the lens of pre-existing knowledge or ideas, and to be prepared to be surprised or challenged by data (Bryant, 2017).

To foster flexible ways of seeing, researchers pose general and open-ended analytical questions to explore and define what is happening in the data (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). Grounded theorists have suggested a range of questions for initial coding from various perspectives. The following non-exhaustive list presents some example questions I encountered and categorised from the literature:

  • Questions focusing on the plot of data: What is this data a study of? What is actually happening in the data? (Glaser, 1978, p.57) What does the data suggest? Pronounce? From whose point of view? (Charmaz, 2006, p.47)
  • Questions focusing on the process under study: What process(es) is at issue here? How can I define it? How does this process develop? When, why, and how does the process change? What are the consequences of the process? (Charmaz, 2006, p.51)
  • Questions focusing on participants’ perspectives: What is the participant’s main concern? (Glaser, 1998, p.140) How does the research participant(s) act while involved in this process? What does the research participant(s) profess to think and feel while involved in this process? What might his or her observed behavior indicate? (Charmaz, 2006, p.51).

Since this study’s research aims to explore participants’ perceptions of their connections with nature, I guided the initial coding process by asking myself four participant-focused questions: What are they doing here? What do they observe? How do they think? How do they feel? These questions helped me to remain close to participants’ perspectives without imposing pre-existing notions onto the data.

To facilitate the coding process, I used the qualitative data analysis software MAXQDA. I used a colour-coding system: green for codes regarding opinions, yellow for observations, red for emotions, and blue for actions (see Figure 17). In Figures 18, 19, 20, 21, I show how I conducted the initial coding using these four open-ended questions, drawing on excerpts from the interview transcript with Bob as an example. The open coding generated an initial coding system, as shown in the Figure 22.

Figure 17: Questions for initial coding.
Figure 17: Questions for initial coding.
Figure 18: Coding example 1.
Figure 18: Coding example 1.
Figure 19: Coding example 2.
Figure 19: Coding example 2.
Figure 20: Coding example 3.
Figure 20: Coding example 3.
Figure 21: Coding example 4.
Figure 21: Coding example 4.
Figure 22: Initial coding system.
Figure 22: Initial coding system.

As the generated coding system showcases, the open coding process led to sorting and clustering of initial codes. As a result, the researcher was able to identify the most prominent and frequent initial codes that warranted further analysis (Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014). With these insights in mind, the researcher moves to the next phase: focused coding.

Focused Coding

In focused coding, also known as selective coding, the initial codes are organised into conceptual categories that capture the underlying patterns (Glaser, 1998; Thornberg & Charmaz, 2014; Urquhart, 2023). The goal of this step is to “synthesise and explain later segments of data” (Charmaz, 2006, p.57). This is the phase where I operationalised the key concepts identified in the first round of data analysis (see section 4.3.4 Finding Operating Concepts). In particular, the concept of relational values informed this process. At first glance, this may appear to be a violation of GTM’s tenet that researchers should approach data with an open mind and avoid imposing extant concepts. However, grounded theorists have addressed the misconception of “the researcher as a blank slate” (Urquhart & Fernández, 2013; Urquhart, 2023) and the belief that “engaging with the literature and existing theory spoils grounded theory” (Timonen et al., 2018). These myths stem from a superficial understanding of the role of literature in research (Urquhart & Fernández, 2013). The interaction between literature review and data analysis is not unidirectional. While prior engagement with literature can inform data analysis, the examination of empirical data also guides the researcher in identifying which literature may be useful to anchor the study and interpret the data. Therefore, whether an analysis using GTM is “contaminated” by pre-existing concepts does not depend on whether such concepts are involved, but rather on when and how the concept came into play. As Urquhart (2023) clarifies: “it is more accurate to say that grounded theory research does not start with a theory to prove or disprove” (p.32, emphasis in original), “but to consider what the data says first” (p.230). As illustrated in the section Finding Operating Concepts, the key analytical notions for this research were not defined prior to, but during data analysis. In other words, the lens of relational values emerged from data, rather than dictating my reading of data. Thus, it serves as a valid lens for focus coding.

Focused coding in this research, namely the categorisation of the initial codes, was therefore informed by the notion of relational values. Before examining the initial codes, I drew on the typology of relational values developed by Raymond and colleagues (2023) to orient my understanding of the concept toward using it as an analytical lens. According to Raymond et al., there are four key layers of relational values:

  1. Worldviews are the “lenses” through which individuals and groups perceive, interpret, inhabit and modify the world. […] Overall, worldviews can be clustered into three orientations regarding people-nature relationships. Anthropocentric worldviews prioritise humans […]; Bio/ecocentric worldviews place importance on living beings (i.e. biocentric) or nature as a whole (i.e. eco centric) as having inherent worth in themselves […]; pluricentric worldviews, an emerging concept, focus on reciprocal, intertwined and embedded relationships between humans and other beings, and nature’s elements and processes (i.e. with no centre).
  2. Broad values are life goals and guiding principles, including what constitutes desirable people-nature relationships.
  3. Specific values are judgements regarding the importance of something in “specific” contexts, including biodiversity, ecosystems, people–nature relationships or human wellbeing. These are sometimes called “assigned” or “contextual” values.
  4. Value indicators are quantitative measures (e.g. hectares, money and indices) or qualitative descriptors (e.g. expressions, arguments and stories) of specific values. (p.3–4)

In focused coding, I adapted this typology into a set of guiding questions that helped me identify “value” within initial codes: How do the initial codes reflect participants’ beliefs, principles and preferences regarding connecting with nature? How do they convey the importance of connecting with nature to participants? What benefits do participants perceive from this connection? While scanning the initial codes through these questions, I selected the most illustrative ones, identified the underlying relationships among them, and then merged and categorised them into focused codes. An example of this process is how I categorised the initial codes “writing and translating texts about nature knowledge and history”, “doing consulting work”, “teaching knowledge about nature” and “raising awareness about environmental issues” under the focused code “giving nature a voice”. These initial codes appeared frequently across different parts of the data and were therefore selected for further analysis. By revisiting the data segments associated with these codes, I identified a common thread: Through these actions, participants advocate for a deeper understanding of nature’s complexity, resilience and agency and challenge a common notion of nature as a passive subordinate of humans. Drawing inspiration from a phrase encountered in the field, “give nature a voice”, I grouped these initial codes under the focused code giving nature a voice. It reflects participants’ recognition and respect for nature’s active role in shaping the interactions between people and nature, and their belief that this attitude forms the basis of a reciprocal human-nature relationship that should be communicated and shared. Thus, giving nature a voice expresses their value regarding building meaningful relationships with nature.

Naming the focused codes was also a rigorous process. Charmaz (2006) reminds us that focused codes should be “more directed, selective and conceptual” (p.57). To reach this, I drew on both data and literature to search for precise and meaningful conceptual phrases for focused codes. As illustrated by the above example, some focused codes were derived directly from the data and the field, such as grasping nature with hand and mind and giving nature a voice. These codes remain closely tied to the ethnographic data while vividly synthesising the shared implications of relevant initial codes at a conceptual level. Other focused codes, such as nature as guide and human as a collaborator with nature, were informed by existing concepts, such as de Groot’s (1992) notions of “Man the Steward of nature” and “Partnership with Nature”. While inspired by these established ideas, these focused codes are intended to capture implications from my data that diverge from the original concepts in nuanced ways (see chapter Findings and Discussion). Additionally, some focused codes were directly borrowed from developed conceptual frameworks, such as nature as “serious leisure” (Stebbins, 1982). These codes emerged through an iterative process of examining relevant data segments, identifying connections among the initial codes and engaging with literature from multiple disciplines. Focused codes drawn from established literature benefit from conceptually developed notions, allowing the findings from my fieldwork to be addressed in an interdisciplinary manner. The following list demonstrates the generated focused codes:

  • Grasping nature with hand and mind
  • Experiencing nature as serious leisure
  • Relational learning about nature
  • Giving nature a voice
  • Emotion sparks connection with nature
  • Positive emotions as a way to connect with nature
  • Positive emotions as a gain from connecting with nature
  • Nature as a guide in learning about nature
  • Nature as a participant of environmental engagement
  • Collaborating with nature

Following the focused coding phase, the analysis progressed into theoretical coding.

Theoretical Coding

According to Urquhart (2023), “[t]heoretical coding is the stage where codes are related to each other” (p.79). In this phase, researchers move beyond an empirical description of data toward a higher level of conceptualisation and theorisation. The goal of theoretical coding is to “specify possible relationships between categories you have developed in your focused coding” in order to “tell an analytic story that has coherence” (Charmaz, 2006, p.63). Thornberg and Charmaz (2014) clarify the fundamental distinction between theoretical codes and initial or focused codes:

Initial and focused coding generate data-driven and empirical codes and categories by building on constant comparisons of data, data and codes, and codes and codes. In contrast, theoretical codes consist of ideas and perspectives that researchers import to the research process as analytic tools and lenses from outside, from a range of theories. Theoretical codes refer to underlying logics that could be found in pre-existing theories. (p.159)

As such, theoretical coding is the stage where external, extant theories and concepts play a vital role in GTM. Thornberg and Charmaz (2012) encourage researchers to explore and engage with a wide range of established theories across academic disciplines and professional domains to figure out theoretical codes. In this research, the conceptual frameworks identified during the first round of analysis played a crucial role in theoretical coding: the multi-dimensional human-nature connection (HNC) framework (Ives et al., 2017) and the human-nature relational model (Muradian & Pascual, 2018). The HNC framework offers a way to approach people’s connections with nature from multiple perspectives spanning inner to outer worlds. When I re-examined the focused codes and associated pieces of data with the HNC framework in mind, a metaphor emerged: it seemed that three vital organs played essential roles in fostering participants’ connections with nature: hand, brain, and heart. This led to the conceptualisation of grasping nature with hand and mind and experiencing nature as serious leisure as embodied experiences with nature, relational learning about nature and giving nature a voice as intellectual engagement with nature, and the three emotion-related focused codes as emotional resonance with nature. These three theoretical codes illuminate how participants value different pathways for connecting with nature, enabling me to tell the first part of the “analytic story” by answering the first research question: which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening connection with nature? Meanwhile, two elements from human-nature relational model proved useful in conceptualising the shared implications of the focused codes nature as a guide in learning about nature, nature as a participant of environmental engagement and collaborating with nature, namely “nature entity with agency” and “how nature is positioned vis-à-vis humans” (Muradian & Pascual, 2018, p.10). The data segments associated with these codes suggest that participants reject the notion of a dichotomy between human and nature or the idea that nature is only “natural” without human presence. Instead, they value reciprocal interactions with nature and do not perceive such interactions as disturbances to nature. These data also reflect participants’ recognition of and care for nature as an active agent in their interactions with it. From these reflections, I developed the theoretical codes of human-included naturalness and recognition of nature’s agency. These two theoretical codes ultimately enabled me to articulate how participants view their relationships with nature.

This section outlines my trajectory in applying GTM-informed coding techniques to analyse my data, constituting what Hadley (2019) describes as a “[r]eflexively interpretive analysis, starting with empirical description and moving progressively towards higher levels of theorisation” (p. 266). Before presenting the organisation of my findings yielded from this rigorous analytical process, I will first explain how I applied GTM in specific ways that align with the nature of my object of inquiry and ethnographic data.

How Grounded Theory Method Was Adapted to This Research

In addition to following the conventional coding steps of GTM, I also employed this analytical tool in a way tailored to the aim and characteristics of this study. The central goal of this ethnographic research is to explore people’s perspectives and values associated with their relationship with nature, as expressed from their own viewpoints grounded in real-time life and lived experiences. This aim led to two particular emphases in my application of GTM: close attention to participants’ language use, and a commitment to preserving ethnographic vividness in the presentation of the findings. I will now explain why these two aspects are important for my analysis, and how I engaged with them in the analytical process.

Attending to Language and Discourse

As thought finds its expression, reality and form in language (Vygotsky, 1934/1986), examining participants’ language use offers a tangible entry point to explore their beliefs, values, and perspectives. Therefore, placing analytical focus on language directly supports the aim of this study. This approach can be effectively integrated into GTM. In fact, language plays a crucial role in how and what grounded theory codes are constructed and analysed, as Charmaz (2006) expounds:

[…] language confers form and meaning on observed realities. Specific use of language reflects views and values. […] we attribute meanings to specific terms and hold perspectives. Our codes arise from the languages, meanings, and perspectives through which we learn about the empirical world, including those of our participants as well as our own. Coding impels us to make our participants’ language problematic to render an analysis of it. Coding should inspire us to examine hidden assumptions in our own use of language as well as that of our participants. (p.47)

Therefore, close attention to participants’ language use facilitated me to construct the grounded theory codes and articulate how the theoretical codes reflect participants’ perspectives on their connections and relationships with nature. To examine language use within data, I incorporated discourse analysis techniques in this grounded theory analysis. Specifically, I looked for environmental discourse, defined by Mühlhäusler and Peace (2006) as “the linguistic devices articulating arguments about the relationship between humans and their environment” (p.458). This entailed “trac[ing] a particular linguistic regularity” in participants’ verbal expressions during interviews and fieldwork to identify the “ideas, concepts and categories” through which they attributed meanings to their experiences with nature (Hajer & Versteeg, 2005, p.175).

An example of this analytical act is the development of the focused code grasping nature with hand and mind. This code was directly inspired by a participant, Eric, who offered a compelling interpretation of the semantic link between the German verbs greifen and begreifen. Both can be translated as “to grasp” in English, yet greifen means “gripping” while begreifen means “to comprehend”. Using this etymological insight as a metaphor, Eric argued that learning about nature begins with hands-on engagement. The examination of this piece of data, originally in German, inspired me to consider how a similar view can be embedded in and expressed through the English word grasp through its dual meaning. With this linguistic inspiration in mind, I revisited the data segments associated with the tentative code grasping nature, paying particular attention to linguistic regularities in participants’ speech. I then observed a frequent use of transitive verb phrases that take nature as their object, along with participants’ consistent expressions of approval for such actions. These language uses often occurred in narratives that articulate a causal link between physical contact with nature and a deepened understanding of it. Thereby, I confirmed that the focused code grasping nature with hand and mind effectively captures participants’ perspective that practical interactions with nature foster a meaningful inner connection with it.

Deliberate attention to language use enhances this grounded theory analysis by offering sources for tentative codes, establishing logical links between raw data and conceptual codes, and facilitating an analytical presentation of the findings to address research questions. This suggests that GTM can benefit from the incorporation of discourse analysis techniques.

Retaining Ethnographic Vividness

There appears to be a subtle tension between a GTM way and an ethnographic way of making sense of the data. While a grounded theory approach emphasises conceptual development and theorisation, an ethnographic approach is oriented toward producing detailed and meaningful (“thick”) descriptions of lived experiences and settings (Oktay, 2012). When applying GTM as an analytical tool in this ethnographic case study, this nuanced divergence became my practical dilemma, particularly during constructing and presenting the results. Should I prioritise a higher level of theorisation encouraged by GTM, or foreground the empirical description valued by ethnography?

After careful, iterative reading of data and codes, I chose to strive for a balance between the two aspects – preserving an ethnographic vividness within this grounded theory analysis. This decision was guided by the overarching research goal: to explore how participants value their connections with nature from their own points of view, grounded in real-life experiences. An emic perspective in reading the data, both for the researcher and readers, is therefore essential for this study. A mere pursuit of conceptualisation and theorisation at the expense of the richness and originality of the ethnographic data would risk undermining this goal. Thus, in presenting the analysis results generated through GTM, I aimed to preserve ethnographic vividness – in other words, to foreground participants’ voices – by presenting and analysing the ethnographic moments (Prost, 2003) captured from fieldwork, and participants’ original narratives and expressions from interviews, rather than limiting the analysis to summaries or abstracted codes.

Social anthropologist Prost (2003) defines ethnographic moments as

the moment in which the anthropologist rises to meet a revealed problematic encapsulated in a particular instance of fieldwork, may be paralleled to the experience of religious epiphany, whereby embodied and intellectual understanding of phenomena and situation come to merge, producing a totalising understanding of the field and the “afield”. (p.1)

In other words, an ethnographic moment constitutes an incident during fieldwork that strikes the researcher with its vividness and distinctiveness in revealing the complexity of the situation, process, phenomenon or issue under study. Therefore, incorporating ethnographic moments into GTM not only contributes to “grounding” the findings in field data, but also effectively conveys the tensions, interconnections and complexity embedded in the object of inquiry. In the Finding and Discussion chapter, I present ethnographic moments from my fieldwork by combining thick description, screenshots from video recording, transcripts of participants’ speech in the video clips and excerpts from fieldnotes. In doing so, I demonstrate how the analytical codes and their conceptual insights emerged from participants’ lived realities, thereby carrying practical richness.

In treating narratives from ethnographic interviews, I align with Flyvbjerg (2006), who asserts that “[g]ood narratives typically approach the complexities and contradictions of real life” (p.237). Flyvbjerg further argues that such narratives often cannot, and should not, be summarised, as doing so would strip them of their embedded richness. This perspective also applies to excerpts in which participants articulate their opinions and emotions. Not only do the original expressions matter, but even the length of the speech conveys the participants’ stance and intensity of beliefs and emotions. For instance, during the interview with Daniel, I initially assumed he was relatively introverted and not particularly communicative. I had to remind him to speak louder so the recorder could clearly capture his voice, and I prompted him several times to elaborate on the details of his relevant experiences and views. However, when our conversation turned to Luxembourg’s new conservation law, which bans the private capture of wild animals, including butterflies, regardless of intent, Daniel had much to say. His response resulted in approximately 1100 words of speech (in German) in the related transcript excerpts. This indicated to me his strong opposition to the delegitimisation of direct contact with nature. Therefore, I chose to present the original transcript excerpts rather than a summary, allowing Daniel’s voice, rather than solely my interpretation, to convey his view and experiences to the reader. Based on similar considerations, I retained the long narratives in which participants recounted their experiences in data analysis, in order to preserve the richness and expressiveness embedded in their speech.

By presenting ethnographic moments and participants’ original speech in data analysis, I aimed to preserve ethnographic vividness in this GTM-informed ethno-case study. This approach grounds the grounded theory codes within the perspectives of participants, demonstrates how conceptual insights emerged from the texture of field data, and creates an open and transparent “scope for readers” (Flyvbjerg, 2006, p.238) to engage with and evaluate my analysis, or even to develop their own interpretations of my data. Therefore, integrating ethnographic vividness does not undermine but rather enriches the implications of grounded theory research.

So far, I have elaborated on the actions, decisions and reflections that I engaged with during the second round of data analysis using a Grounded Theory Method. This rigorous procedure eventually gave rise to the “narrative framework” in which I report my findings (Urquhart, 2023, p.5) in the Findings and Discussion chapter, which follows the current chapter outlining my data analysis trajectory. In the next chapter, I will present a story of a group of ordinary citizens who have developed meaningful connections with nature through everyday environmental engagement from embodied, intellectual and emotional perspectives, and who have cultivated intriguing understandings of nature and human-nature relationships through these connections. Through eliciting their preferences, beliefs and views regarding engagement with nature, this narrative reveals how they value their relationship with nature as constructed in everyday, mundane interactions with it.

Notes

  1. 7[DE] native, indigenous.

Annotate

Next Chapter
5. Findings and Discussion
PreviousNext
CC BY-SA 4.0
Powered by Manifold Scholarship. Learn more at
Opens in new tab or windowmanifoldapp.org