Notes
2. Literature Review
Before outlining the methodological implementation of this study, I first review theoretical and empirical literature to situate my research within existing scholarly debates. This literature review is structured around two main objectives. First, it aims to map the landscape of definitions, concepts, debates, and empirical findings related to the human-nature connection. Second, it seeks to identify theoretical and empirical gaps, demonstrating how an ethnographic approach can illuminate nuanced ways in which people conceptualise their relations with nature.
To achieve these aims, I begin by defining the core terms central to this study – nature and human-nature connection. I then review two bodies of empirical research that have approached this connection: environmental ethnography and green applied linguistics, in order to identify the interdisciplinary niche that this study addresses. Following this, I turn to the notion of value of nature, which is essential for understanding why reconnecting with nature matters. Finally, I argue that focusing on mundane, everyday interactions between people and nature has the potential to reveal the complexity and diversity of human-nature relationships. Insights from examining these interactions can contribute meaningfully to efforts aimed at reconnecting people with nature.
In the following sections, I begin this mapping by defining the terms nature and human-nature connection as they are used in this work.
Defining Nature and Human-Nature Connection
Conceptualising Nature
While commonly used in everyday language, the concept of nature is highly fluid and volatile. As de Groot (1992, p. 213) points out, “[o]n closer inspection, however, ambiguities creep in”. Semantically, the term encompasses a wide diversity of phenomena, from concrete manifestations such as plants, animals, forests, and rivers, to large-scale constructs like ecosystems or the idea of Gaia (de Groot, 1992). It is also used to describe a diversity of landscapes, ranging from human-influenced landscapes like urban parks to untouched wilderness, such as rainforest (de Groot, 1992; Hartig et al., 2014; van den Berge & Koole, 2006). What is considered nature varies from time, space, culture and individual circumstances (Bratman et al. 2012; Chawla, 2020; van den Berg & Koole, 2006). As such, “[t]he term nature is among the more elusive and vaguely defined concepts” (Wohlwill, 1983, p.6) across disciplines. As Brondizio et al. (2019) summarise:
Within the framing of the natural sciences (context of science), nature include[s] e.g., all dimensions of biodiversity, species, genotypes, populations, ecosystems, the biosphere, ecosystem functioning, communities, biomes, Earth life support’s systems, and their associated ecological, evolutionary, biogeochemical processes and biocultural diversity. Within the framework of economics, it includes categories such as biotic natural resources, natural capital and natural assets. Within a wider context of social sciences and humanities and interdisciplinary environmental sciences, it is referred to with categories such as natural heritage, living environment, or the nonhuman. (p.14)
To navigate this conceptual diversity and ambiguity, researchers tend to adopt broad definitions that are adaptable to their research contexts. For example, in reviewing how nature experience impacts human cognitive function and mental health, Bratman et al. (2012) define nature as “areas containing elements of living systems that include plants and nonhuman animals across a range of scales and degrees of human management” (p.120). Within the context of the Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES), nature is defined as the nonhuman world with an emphasis on the diversity of living organisms and their interactions among themselves and with the abiotic environment (Brondizio et al., 2019; Díaz et al., 2015).
In a similar vein, I use the term nature to refer both to concrete species and landscapes and to larger-scale ecosystems, in which the species and landscapes interact, to reflect the fact that in my data, participants discuss and foreground all these levels.
Conceptualising Human-Nature Connection
Another key notion is connection with nature. Like the term nature, connection with nature is a fluid and multifaceted concept, approached from diverse perspectives and encompassing a range of meanings. Therefore, this section reviews the various interpretations of this idea and clarifies how it is applied within this study.
Historically, the relation between people and nature is a topic that has been contemplated across cultures. Ancient Chinese conceptualised the relationship between nature and humans as 天人合一 (Tiān rén hé yī), meaning that nature and humans form a harmonious whole (Liu, 2019). In Western antiquity, nature is perceived to have a distinct spirituality from that of humans: “every tree, every spring, every stream, every hill had its own genius loci, its guardian spirit” (White, 1967, p.1205). Christianity believes that humanity has been entrusted by God with the responsibility of managing nature, as indicated in Genesis 1:26–28:
And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth. (Book of Bible Quotations, 2005)
More generally, research shows that nature has always been talked about and an integral part of culture (Binney, 2006). In 1984, Wilson proposed the biophilia hypothesis, the idea that humans are genetically predisposed to seek connections with nature. This hypothesis has not yet been definitively tested as the genes associated with biophilia have not been identified (Rogers, 2024). Nevertheless, by synthesising several survey-based studies on people’s attitudes toward different images of relationships with nature, van den Born and colleagues (2024) found a high level of nature-friendliness across different cultural contexts and a minimal cross-cultural variability of the nature-friendliness levels. Their finding suggests that people commonly express a strong tendency to affiliate with nature, offering strong support for the biophilia hypothesis.
Given that connection with nature is deeply rooted in human history and societies, and is increasingly attracting scholarly attention, researchers have sought to deepen their understanding of this issue through empirical investigation. Yet, upon closer examination, ambiguities once again creep in. In conducting a systematic review of the empirical studies on the human-nature connection, Ives and colleagues (2017) note that studies on this topic encompass a wide range of “disciplinary and conceptual perspectives, language, methods and research approaches” (p.106). This is because the issue of connecting with nature spans multiple fields, such as ecology, psychology, education, and sociology. The diversity of approaches has led the relevant literature to become fragmented, resulting in low coherence in the use and understanding of terminologies (Ives et al., 2017). The fragmentation of the literature is also attributed to the different conceptual applications of the term connection: “[i]n some instances, connection to nature refers to a cognitive appreciation of being embedded within nature, in others to an emotional attachment, while still others focus on material dependence on nature” (Ives et al., 2018, p.1390). Researchers use terms such as nature connectedness (Martin et al. 2020; Mayer & Frantz 2004; van Heel et al., 2024a, 2024b; Zylstra et al., 2014), connectivity with nature (Dutcher et al., 2007) and nature relatedness (Nisbet et al., 2009) interchangeably to refer to the psychological attachment to nature. Phrases like contact with nature (Martin et al. 2020) and reconnecting to biosphere (Andersson et al., 2014; Folke et al., 2011) focus more on the physical interactions with flora, fauna, and geological landforms. While most researchers define their respective terminologies in their studies, the terms remain relatively scattered with meanings that are highly dependent on specific research contexts, often failing to capture the multiple dimensions of the connection between humans and nature. To consolidate concepts, ideas, and their practical applications, Ives et al. (2017) adopt the term “human-nature connection” (HNC) as an umbrella concept, based on their multidisciplinary review of 475 empirical studies on how people relate to nature. Ives and other colleagues (2018) define HNC as a concept encompassing
(1) material connections such as resource extraction and use; (2) experiential connections such as recreational activities in green environments; (3) cognitive connections such as knowledge, beliefs and attitudes; (4) emotional attachments and affective responses; and (5) philosophical perspectives on humanity’s relationship to the natural world. (p.1389)
The multifaceted and inclusive nature of the HNC concept enables it to capture the diverse ways in which people interact with and relate to nature in real life. This conceptual consolidation fosters the discussion on reconnecting people with nature from multiple dimensions, along a spectrum from external connections to nature (e.g., material and experiential connections) to internal connections (e.g. emotions and worldviews) (Ives et al., 2018).
Having clarified the core terms nature and human-nature connection, I now turn to a review of empirical studies that investigate these notions. The following sections aim to situate this research within the ongoing scholarly debates and to demonstrate how this ethnographic study, informed by linguistic perspectives, can offer new insights into the topic of human-nature connections. To this end, I engage with existing research from two key domains: environmental ethnography and applied linguistics.
Researching Connection with Nature
Environmental Ethnography
While there has always been ethnography of nature, it is only recently that the term Environmental ethnography has emerged. The earliest explicit discussion I have found of this approach is Lezak’s (2023) examination of its theory and practice in the field of human geography. Realising that “while environmental ethnography is already widely practised, it has not yet been clearly defined in scholarly literature”, Lezak refers to environmental ethnography as “a methodological affinity, a knapsack of geographical, anthropological, and critical theoretical tools to understand the more-than-human world” (p.289).
In environmental ethnography, two trends are noticeable: one is to conduct ethnographies of the environment, and the other is to conduct ethnographies about environmental topics. We can examine these approaches in turn.
As a field, environmental ethnography is closely related to multispecies ethnography, which shifts the focus from humans to other species that are integral to human social worlds but have traditionally been treated merely as contexts or symbols (Kirksey & Helmreich, 2010). Acknowledging the shared posthumanist orientation of both approaches, Lezak emphasises that environmental ethnography not only attends to DNA-bearing life forms but also directs its research gaze toward existents that are neither life nor chemicals, such as ice, fire and rocks, making it ethnography of the environment. From a geographer’s perspective, Lezak argues that environmental ethnography is particularly useful for researchers interested in the importance of space and place, because “it can accommodate the landscape itself as an object of ethnographic consideration” (p.291). A few studies corroborate his point. For example, Pyne (2004) discusses how wildland fires shape not only ecosystems and biodiversity but also human societies and values (Pyne, 2004). Rantala et al. (2011) examine the integral role of weather in wilderness guiding in Finnish Lapland. Hastrup (2013) observes the ice’s predominant role in forming social imagination and human/non-human network in the Arctic. Lezak therefore calls for adopting environmental ethnography as an approach to “think with environments” and to “honour the uniqueness of place, keeping research grounded in habitat” (p.304, emphasis in original). As such, for geographers, environmental ethnography is the ethnography of the environment, foregrounding ecological context and nonlife existents.
Contrasted to the ethnography of the environment, another comprehensive discussion of environmental ethnography is introduced by Cordner (2024). Cordner’s interpretation of the term leans towards the ethnography about environmental topics. In this sense, ethnography is not viewed as a method to examine non-DNA bearing life-forms, but for investigating people’s actions, perceptions, and social tensions in contexts of environmental issues. Instead of adopting a human-decentring lens to expound environmental ethnography, Cordner draws on studies from environmental sociology to discuss the strengths of ethnographic approaches in revealing the social dynamics, power relationships and inequalities that shape people’s experiences of their natural environment. While acknowledging that ethnographic data collected from nonhuman animals essentially contribute to the field of environmental sociology (Kalof & Whitley, 2021), her review of the intellectual work and key findings in environmental ethnography concentrates on people’s reactions to environmental issues, their interactions with the environment and negotiation of interpersonal, social and human-nature power dynamics. As such, Cordner’s sociological view of environmental ethnography represents the ethnography about the environment – in other words, ethnography of people in the context of environmental issues.
Both strands of environmental ethnography offer valuable insights into the diverse ways in which people relate to their natural environments in diverse cultural and social contexts. Lezak’s (2023) review finds that the ethnographies of the environment bring to the foreground the objects and forms of existence that are often regarded as contexts or inert, such as weather, ice, fire, forests, gold ore, pollution, and garbage. Attending to “the irreducibility of context and the individuality of living and non-living entities” (p.289) proves a valuable approach to enriching the understanding of things “in relationship to their contexts in a non-contingent way” (p.291) and fostering new perspectives on human-nature connections. Yet, while a human geologist approach to environmental ethnography is effective in addressing “the ways in which place, space and environment are both the condition and in part the consequence of human activities” (Gregory, 2009, p.350), its emphasis on the external environment hardly delves into people’s inner world, therefore telling us little about how people construe, position, and emotionally engage with nature. To foster the reconnection of people with nature and encourage concrete changes in behaviour, it is critical to understand “what reconnecting to nature means, why it should happen and how it can be achieved” (Ives et al., 2018, p.1389). To promote this understanding, it seems important to study people’s knowledge, emotions and perceptions in relation to nature. Therefore, the current research aims to explore people’s perceptions and beliefs regarding their connection with nature, aligning with the sociological approach within environmental ethnography. In the following section, I present a critical overview of empirical findings from the ethnographies about the environment.
Power and (In)Justice
Because ethnography is powerful in illustrating how people act, respond to and think in social situations and uncovering underlying power dynamics (Cordner, 2024), one prominent strand of research within environmental ethnography critically examines how environmental issues are entangled with power relations – both among people and between people and nature. Within this strand, three fields of study are particularly important to review: environmental justice, Indigenous studies, and ecofeminism. Each offers distinct yet intersecting perspectives on how environmental tensions are experienced by communities marginalised by historical, cultural, and structural power systems, particularly those differentiated by socio-economic status, race, cultural background, and gender.
The first set of studies falls within the field of environmental justice, where ethnographic studies have covered several topics. Some researchers have considered how environmental vulnerability is experienced by communities confronted with toxic environments (Gutierrez et al., 2021). For example, Checker’s (2005) ethnographic monograph Polluted Promises tells the story of an African-American community in Hyde Park, Georgia, that is surrounded by polluting industrial facilities. Suffering from debilitating health issues, the community members turn to activism to fight not only against industrial contamination but also against environmental racism. By examining the daily experiences of the Hyde Park community, Checker highlights that environmental injustice is still prevailing in the post-civil rights era, pointing out that “environmental burdens are unevenly distributed around the globe, and people of colour and poor people are on the front lines of poisonous exposures” (p.186). Auyero and Swistun (2009) demonstrate individual testimonies of environmental suffering based on their collaborative ethnographic fieldwork in Flammable, an Argentine shantytown surrounded by a large petrochemical compound, a river highly polluted by industrial toxic waste, an unsupervised waste incinerator and an unmonitored landfill. The authors argue that people’s experiences of environmental vulnerability induced by toxic surroundings can only be understood within the broader material and symbolic context, such as the community’s historic relationship with the landscape and the discourses of outside agents that shape people’s perceptions of their lives and environment. Luna’s (2018) study examines the environmental inequality faced by Burkinabe farmers in cotton production based on participant observation and semi-structured interviews conducted in Burkina Faso. The researcher finds that a key reason that Burkinabe cotton farmers widely adopt new agricultural technologies, which significantly increased their exposure to pesticides, is that these technologies offer them “a higher status, modern, technical, whiter identity” (p.231, emphasis in original). Her study demonstrates how racist cultural ideologies can influence marginalised people themselves to act in ways that reinforce environmental inequalities.
Still linked to environmental justice, other researchers have explored unusual events, for example, disasters (Cordner, 2024). Ethnographer Kim Fortun (2001), for instance, traces the advocacy for the victims of the 1984 explosion of the Union Carbide chemical plant in Bhopal, India. By analysing the victims’ narratives, Fortun sheds light on the nexus between the unequal power relations in globalisation, the global distribution of technological and environmental risk and environmental legislation. Petryna’s (2013) ethnography of Chornobyl’s aftermath tackles “the vexed political-economic, scientific, legal, and social circumstances” (p.215) that came after the disaster. Through writing an ethnographic account of lawmakers, radiation scientists, health professionals, and sufferers, Petryna demonstrates “different points along the continuum of knowledge production, power, moral sensibility, and self-disclosure” (ibid.) that followed the nuclear contamination. These studies of people’s lived experiences of damaging relationships with their environments reveal the economic, social, racial and political aspects of the relationships between different groups and the natural environment. In these cases, the detrimental relationship between communities and nature is not “mutual”, because those who bear the negative consequences of nature that has been severely harmed are not the ones who have inflicted the harm. In these tragedies, nature plays the role of a “magnifying glass” that amplifies social injustices.
A second field that has been concerned with environmental justice comes from Indigenous studies. These scholars have also adopted environmental ethnography as a helpful tool to critically examine how Indigenous environmental knowledge, practices and relationships with nature complement or contrast with Western systems, as well as how the former has been appropriated and downplayed by the latter. Drawing upon his fieldwork in western Mali, Duvall (2021) finds that Indigenous environmental knowledge represents a holistic understanding of biophysical reality rather than particular geographic or biological features. He further argues that “there is no objective or universal form of environmental knowledge, and therefore, the importance and subjectivity of environmental knowledge together create remarkable possibilities for new concepts to enter into environmental knowledge systems” (p.35). Kondo’s (2021) ethnography focusing on Alaskan Athabascans’ practices in using natural resources and conservation points out the challenges and significance of traditional salmon-human interactions in the Upper Kuskokwim region. Kondo reveals the tension between the government's control of natural resources and the Indigenous community’s subsistence ways of life, as well as the tension between local river maintenance practices and marine biologists’ perspectives. The researcher also synthesises the Athabascan belief in the special spirits of predatory animals and conservation ecology, arguing that effective management of salmon in Alaska should not exclude Alaskan Indigenous knowledge and practices. Thekaekara (2021) sheds light on the Kattunayakan and Bettakurumba peoples’ relationships with, and strategies for living alongside, Asian elephants based on his ethnographic fieldwork in Southern India. By illuminating Indigenous people’s perceptions and interactions with elephants, Thekaekara describes the core elements of their worldview that shape their coexistence with the animal. The author criticised the exclusion of Indigenous worldviews from policymaking and the homogeneous assumptions of people’s relationships with landscapes and species, calling for the inclusion of Native perspectives to inform policy meaningfully. Often adopting a decolonial perspective, Indigenous environmental researchers have analysed Indigenous practices, knowledge and perceptions of interacting with the natural environment using ethnographic methods, and have provided insights into the diversity of, and the tensions between, different perceptions of nature and relationships with it. The insights from Indigenous studies have brought alternative discourses to the table, other than extractivist views of nature. The decolonial approach to understanding human-nature connections has challenged extractivism, which is deeply rooted in colonialism and refers to the intensive natural resource appropriation intended for raw material exports (Chagnon et al., 2022; Gudynas, 2018). The debates in this field are essential to Indigenous study, but may also inform studies on human-nature connections in non-Indigenous contexts by offering a multi- perspective framework that integrates diverse ways of interacting with nature and perceiving nature.
A third field of study that examines the human-nature connection as a real-life issue is ecofeminism. Ecofeminism addresses the cultural and symbolic associations often made between women and nature (Miles, 2024). As Plumwood (1993) points out, “women’s inclusion in the sphere of nature has been a major tool in their oppression” and “feminine ‘closeness to nature’ has hardly been a compliment” (p.19). An example of a common form of denial of women and nature is backgrounding. Plumwood (1993) explains that the backgrounding of nature refers to “the denial of dependence on biospheric processes, and a view of humans as apart, outside of nature, which is treated as a limitless provider without needs of its own” (p.22); similarly, women are traditionally framed as “the environment” against which male “achievement” takes place, yet they are not recognised for their own achievements. As such, ecofeminism is relevant for analysing how gender-dependent human- nature relations are shaped by intersecting systems of oppression (Patarin-Jossec, 2024). Although ethnographic studies in ecofeminism are relatively rare due to the field’s theoretical orientation, a few researchers have adopted ecofeminism as an analytical lens in their ethnographic environmental studies. In her research on offshore fishing labour in Vietnam, Alonso (2022) examines how masculinities and labour relations mutually shape each other in offshore fishing based on ethnographic data collected from fishers, boat owners, captains, and their partners. Her findings show that labour relations in the offshore fishery are maintained mainly through an emphasis on men’s abilities to do heavy physical work and behavioural expectations associated with masculine norms. Therefore, the author argues for considering masculinity dynamics when addressing illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing. Similarly, Fabinyi’s (2007) study in the Calamian Islands, Philippines, also found that young Calamian men are motivated to participate in the illegal fishery because it is considered a way to demonstrate masculinity and gain status. These cases resonate with ecofeminists’ argument that “we cannot begin to respond adequately to the core forces that continue to energise the domination and degradation of the natural world without first dismantling male-dominated patterns of reasoning, privilege, exclusion, and hierarchy” (French, 2008, Ecofeminism). Ecofeminism contributes to the debate on human-nature relationships by exposing and challenging the ideologies that reinforce the domination of nature, which is an important ideological support for sexism (ibid.).
Critical environmental ethnographies from the fields of environmental injustice, Indigenous/decolonial studies and ecofeminism present a shared core discourse. They view the relationship between humans and nature as deeply entangled with social power relationships. Exploitive and detrimental relationships between people and nature are the product of unequal social, gender and racial relationships, and therefore, can only be understood in depth by delving into the questions that are rooted in societies, such as: how power is exercised to manipulate people’s experiences and perceptions of their natural environment; who bears the consequences of environmental degradation for what reasons; how knowledge and meanings about nature are produced, and who is entitled to justify them; and how practices of interacting with nature are ascribed social meanings and reproduce unequal relationships – both among people and between people and nature. Answering these questions partly explains the prevalent alienation from nature. Yet, exclusively focusing on the discourses of power and injustice in environmental issues is just one aspect of the scholarship on environmental issues.
Meanings and Patterns
Environmental ethnographies have not only covered “activist” topics and broad questions of social (in)justice. A number of researchers have also considered other dimensions, particularly in relation to the meanings and patterns of engaging with nature in routine activities (Cordner, 2024). Several fields have produced knowledge from this perspective: environmental education, leisure studies, and environmental volunteerism.
The field of environmental education has long explored how children experience nature in their daily lives. Jørgensen’s (2016) study, for example, is based on observations, informal conversations and photos collected from Norwegian kindergarten children. This study of early childhood experiences in nature concludes that children demonstrate a “sense of wonder” in their daily direct and multisensory experiences in nature. These experiences engage children emotionally in encounters with animals in natural habitats and foster their ecological knowledge and environmental consciousness. Apart from nonformal learning about nature, researchers have also explored how environmental pedagogies unfold in school settings. Tal and colleagues (2023) examine the pedagogical practices and epistemology in Forest Education by analysing ethnographic data gathered in a leading Israeli Forest Education organisation. They identified four key pedagogical practices, namely outdoor play, primitive skills and crafts, sensing, and dwelling. These practices, as argued by the authors, “reflect an epistemology in which knowledge and learning are situated in the immediate embodied context and sensory experiences, and are intended to facilitate a meaningful connection with nature” (p.1502). Ruck and Mannion’s (2021) study provides an understanding of how young people enact their relationships with the natural world in school grounds conservation activities. Through participant observation, the researchers found that while the planned curriculum is underpinned by a stewardship perspective and a utilitarian view of other species, moments during its implementation revealed young people’s enactment of collective thinking with the more-than- human world. This way of thinking is described as “more than a purely rational, cognitive process” (p.1505), in which one sees oneself as part of a collective with other species, expressed through excitement, fascination and empathy. Patel and Ehrenzeller’s (2023) case studies in Indian and German schools show that the experience of immersion in nature shapes children’s relationship with nature. Drawing upon observation, semi-structured interviews with teachers and school leaders and informal interactions with students, their cross-cultural ethnographic study finds that across both Indian and German contexts, nature is perceived as a peace educator: “teaching key concepts and skills, promoting ecological ways of living and being, enabling conditions for wellbeing and inner-peace, and a reciprocal children-nature relationship of care” (p.294). Based on these findings, the authors argue for an ontological and epistemological shift where educators should prioritise nature for its intrinsic value in being with nature rather than instrumentalising it for future academic gain. These findings from environmental education studies are deeply grounded in everyday life and therefore inspire approaches to transmit environmental practices and mindsets to adults. In addition, since the cornerstone of education consists of values, insights from environmental education contribute to understanding how environmental values can be integrated into everyday life.
Besides education, connecting with nature can also be achieved through leisure and recreation activities. Rantala and Puhakka (2020) take camping as an entry point to discuss how interaction with nature during outdoor recreation enhances young people’s well-being. Archambault’s (2016) multispecies ethnographic study in Inhambane, Mozambique, focuses on human-plant relations formed in gardening. Her analysis of the encounters between gardeners and plants, characterised by “the love of plants”, shows that in Inhambane, gardening is “constructed as evidence of a particular aesthetic sensibility” derived from the city’s colonial past, “imagined as a response to the commodification of intimacy”, and “experienced as a profoundly affective and genuine pursuit” (p.264). Baker and Fick (2022) address the paradox between recreational land users’ appreciation of natural landscapes and the negative ecological impacts of their activities and values on the landscape. Their ethnographic fieldwork and interviews with rock climbers and other local stakeholders in the Indian Creek area of Bears Ears National Monument in Southeast Utah show that “recreational users value the landscape as a site for experiencing, expressing, and building wilderness values, authenticity, and a corresponding set of identities, practices, and ‘ethics’” (p.357). However, the economic drivers underlying these values have led to government prioritisation of commercialised outdoor recreation, resulting in ecological impacts that undermine the ethical foundations of these values. Findings from these studies demonstrate how people perceive a range of benefits and principles regarding interacting with nature, and how they navigate through different, sometimes even conflicting discourses about the values of nature in relatively relaxing, approachable contexts.
Another everyday setting where people interact with nature is voluntary participation in environmental stewardship or conservation projects. While extensive research has examined the motivations, profiles, benefits, and challenges of environmental volunteers, relatively few studies have ethnographically explored how people engage with nature within this context. A few studies in this domain include Adams and colleagues’ (2023) ongoing ethnographic exploration of volunteer shepherding – also referred to as “urban shepherding” or “lookering”, in which volunteers spend time outdoors observing and reporting on the welfare of livestock. This project finds that the volunteers experience and understand lookerking primarily in terms of a positive connection to the landscape in general and the animals in particular. While the “walkalong” interviews indicate that the volunteers perceive a sense of guardianship towards the herds, the researchers recognise an imbalance between how much participants talk about the meaningfulness they derive from lookering and how little they mention the animals’ fate of being slaughtered as agricultural commodities. As such, the researchers observed “the lively complexity of a variety of human-animal relations” (p.169) in volunteer shepherding. Another ethnographic exploration of the human-animal relationship in volunteering is Lloro-Bidart’s (2017) analysis of a volunteer’s experience at the Aquarium of the Pacific. As part of the author’s doctoral research based on multispecies and institutional ethnography, this case study analyses how people develop care for animals through performing embodied and emotional labour, and how their relationship with animals is embedded within the political context. Insights from the studies that examine human-nature relationships in the context of pro- environmental actions are valuable because they illuminate the dynamics between environmental beliefs and actions by showing how beliefs are translated into actions, and how actions, in turn, shape perceptions of relationships with nature.
Environmental ethnographic studies looking at everyday interactions with nature are primarily concentrated in the areas of environmental education, recreation and pro-environmental behaviour research. The primary aim of these studies is not to expose the power dynamics that shape people’s experiences with and perceptions of nature. Instead, they seek to reveal the patterns within these experiences and perceptions, and to elicit how people construct meanings of nature and their relationship to it. Findings and arguments from these ethnographies suggest that examining the everyday, non-confrontational and positive interactions with nature also deepens our understanding of people’s relationship with nature and yield arguments and reflections on how to foster reciprocal human-nature relationships, thus contributing to the human-nature connection debate, asking why and how people should connect with nature.
In this section, I reviewed studies on human-nature connections through the lens of sociological environmental ethnography, identifying two major strands of inquiry: one that examines power and (in)justice within environmental tensions, and another that reveals meanings and patterns of environmental engagement. In the following section, I turn to another field that has also contributed empirical insights into human-nature connections: applied linguistics.
Human-Nature Connection in Applied Linguistics
Against the backdrop of the global anthropogenic environmental crises, it has become clear that drawing from one perspective is not enough to address the social and cultural dimensions of environmental issues, and that solely focusing on isolated symptoms and their technical solutions is insufficient (Stibbe, 2015). In this section, I would like to look at the contribution of the field of language science to the debate on the environment, and particularly the field of applied linguistics.
Applied linguistics is “a transdisciplinary field which connects knowledge about language and language users to policies and practices in specific contexts” (Li et al., 2023, p.1). The field focuses on “the theoretical and empirical investigation of real-world problems in which language is a central issue” by integrating insights from language study with other disciplinary approaches (Brumfit, 1997, p. 93; Li et al., 2023; Schmitt & Celce-Murcia, 2002). Because the unprecedented environmental changes and crises driven by human activities are certainly one such problem, it is not surprising that applied linguists have developed an interest in the relevant questions. Studying real-life language use concerning environmental matters is one way to shed light on the “common curiosity and anxiety about the state and future of Earth” (Lorimer, 2017, p.121), because language both reflects and shapes how people perceive and treat the natural world, which lies at the core of the contemporary ecological challenges (Stibbe, 2015). Therefore, the field of applied linguistics has the power to inform the emerging debates on how to address “the life-sustaining relationships of humans with other humans, other organisms and the physical environment” (Stibbe, 2015, p.9) in the era of Anthropocene. In turn, the current interdisciplinary endeavour to examine these relationships in diverse cultural contexts allows applied linguists to critically engage in conversations about how to foster healthy human–environment relationships following the diagnosis of the Anthropocene (Lamb, 2020). Within the field, several recent paradigms are particularly relevant to address human- nature connections: posthumanist applied linguistics (Pennycook, 2018a, 2018b), critical assemblage analysis (Pietikäinen, 2024), and green applied linguistics (Lamb, 2020).
To explore the relationships, boundaries and assemblages within the Anthropocene, Pennycook (2018a, 2018b) introduced posthumanist applied linguistics. It argues that everyday semiotic practices involve not only humans, but also “the dynamic relations between semiotic resources, activities, artefacts, and space” (Pennycook, 2018a, p.446). For applied linguists, as pointed out by Pennycook, posthumanism goes beyond abstract engagement with the question of what it means to be human (2018b). It offers a lens to address various sets of ethical and political concerns related to urgent real-world issues, such as climate change and human relations with the planet and its other inhabitants (2018a).
In researching the complex and dynamic relations between people and nature, the concept of assemblage emerges as a key notion. As the English translation of the Deleuzian-Guattarian term agencement in French, assemblage is defined as “a becoming that brings elements together” (Wise, 2014, p.91). As Wise (2014) elaborates:
An assemblage is not a set of predetermined parts (such as the pieces of a plastic model aeroplane) that are then put together in order or into an already-conceived structure (the model aeroplane). Nor is an assemblage a random collection of things, since there is a sense that an assemblage is a whole of some sort that expresses some identity and claims a territory. (p.91)
Assemblage thinking, which “takes interactions, relations, heterogeneity, and connections as a starting point” (Pietikäinen, 2024, p.59), offers researchers a lens through which to examine the interplay among language, discourses, nature and society. Combining Deleuzian-Guattarian notions of assemblage and rhizomatic ontology with Foucauldian understanding of discourse, Pietikäinen (2024) develops the critical assemblage analysis framework in her study of the Cold Rush – “an intensified race for extraction and protection of Arctic natural resources fuelled by accelerating climate change, expanding markets, and a novel revaluating of commons as commodities” (p.3). Rather than privileging language or discourse as the a priori analytical focus, Pietikäinen adopts an assemblage lens to investigate which elements – material or discursive, natural or social – are assembled to produce a revaluation of Arctic natural resources. By treating language as embedded within the multiple interactions between socio-economic and natural elements, she argues that assemblage thinking offers an effective framework for examining how material and discursive components interact in specific moments to shape how nature is valued, thereby shedding light on the dynamic, relational connections between human societies and the natural world.
Drawing on the theoretical framework of posthumanist applied linguistics and assemblage thinking, Lamb (2020) introduced the framework of green applied linguistics. This framework’s central aim is to provide “empirical insights into the role of language and discourse in mediating diverse human relationships with animals and nature” (p.1). green applied linguistics calls for a critical examination of how the natural world is engaged in people’s semiotic practices – in other words, how people create, interpret and communicate meanings within and through their relationship with nature – aiming to address the “dynamic, socioculturally specific, and ethically problematic” (p.2) ways in which people construe and treat nature through semiotic practices. Lamb illustrates the idea of green applied linguistics through examples from his research on the convergence of sea turtle conservation and ecotourism practices at Laniākea Beach, Hawai‘i. Applying nexus analysis to ethnographic data such as interviews, video-recorded interactions, documents and photographs, Lamb examines how moments of interactions among volunteer turtle protectors, tourists, and sea turtles emerge from three pathways of discourse: (1) discourses in place, which empowers and legitimates certain actions of either the volunteers or tourists; (2) interaction order, which foregrounds the real-time, situated encounters between volunteers, tourists and sea turtles; and (3) historical body, which refers to the past, routine lived experiences with sea turtles that shape and manifest in concrete actions in relation to the animal. His data shows, for example, how people’s interactions with the turtles are determined by two co-existing yet potentially conflicting discourses: the discourse of wildlife protection, which emphasises maintaining distance between humans and the species, and that of sea turtle ecotourism, which highlights intimate humans-turtles interactions; how volunteer turtle protectors discursively position themselves as outreach educators rather than “turtle police” by explaining the risk of wildlife- to-human disease transmission to persuade tourists not to touch sea turtles, instead of issuing stern verbal warnings; and how volunteers draw on their previous unsuccessful experiences in persuading tourists to maintain distance from sea turtles to construe human-animal relationships in different cultures and to inform their further confrontations with transgressive tourists. Lamb’s research showcases how applied linguists can shed light on the dynamic and diverse relationships between people and animals by examining discursive and semiotic practices. As such, he argues that “applied linguistics’ empirical grounding in everyday language practices [is] of broad relevance to a wide range of societal issues including environmental problems” (p.2).
By positioning human beings within a human-nature assemblage, the green applied linguistics framework shifts from an anthropocentric perspective. Building on posthumanist concerns, it urges applied linguists to consider, on the one hand, “the central importance of language as a mediating factor in human-animal assemblages” (Lamb, 2020, p.22), and on the other hand, how species and natural environment engage in the discourse on the more-than-human world, as well as how nature bears the consequences of discourse.
Within the green applied linguistics framework, two prominent subfields delve into the pivotal role of language in reflecting and shaping individuals’ and societies’ ways of knowing and perceiving nature: ecolinguistics and environmental linguistics.
Ecolinguistics: Revealing the Stories That We Live By (Stibbe, 2015)
Ecolinguistics. Ecolinguistics is an emerging subfield of language and communication studies (Chen, 2016). Scholars commonly acknowledge that the term ecolinguistics was proposed by Einar Haugen in the 1970s (see Chen, 2016; Fill, 2018). In The Ecology of Language, Haugen (1972/2001) used the ecosystem as a metaphor to describe (1) how languages worldwide are interconnected, and (2) how languages interact with their contexts of use. Haugen’s original elaboration of ecolinguistics takes a metaphorical approach to conceptualising ecology and its relationship with languages. Instead of addressing the actual environmental and ecological issues, Haugenian ecolinguistics focuses on linguistic topics such as language diversity, minority languages, and endangered languages, investigating “language loss and language maintenance in the age of globalisation” (Fill, 2018, p.1). This metaphorical rather than literal use of the prefix eco has sparked some debate about whether the Haugenian framework is actually more a part of sociolinguistics than an independent field. Nonetheless, ecolinguistics began to consolidate as a discipline and expand its focus to the interplays between language and environmental matters, particularly following Halliday’s (1990/2001) keynote speech titled New Ways of Meaning at the 1990 World Congress of Applied Linguistics (Chen, 2016; do Couto, 2014). Halliday elaborated these interplays by criticising the “linguistic anthropocentrism” from two aspects: on the one hand, everyday language use tends to only emphasise the instrument value of nature and non-human species, reflecting a utilitarian anthropocentrism; on the other hand, discourses propagating non-sustainable actions accelerate the deterioration of environmental issues (Chen, 2016; Stanlaw, 2020). Halliday’s talk marks the establishment of the two complementary strands of ecolinguistics, for which Fill (2018, p.2) suggests the terms (1) the ecology of language(s), which is concerned with the question of can language diversity be sustained on this earth? and (2) ecological linguistics, which centres around the question of how language construes people’s view of nature and the environment. In this section, I focus on reviewing the ecological linguistics strand, relevant in the context of exploring the value of the people-nature connection through discourse analysis, which is central in my work.
Ecological linguistics (hereafter ecolinguistics) primarily examines how language and discourses reflect and shape relationships between people and nature, and their potential to escalate or mediate environmental issues. Stibbe (2015) defines this strand of ecolinguistics as “[The analysis of] language to reveal the stories we live by, judges those stories according to an ecosophy, resists stories which oppose the ecosophy, and contributes to the search for new stories to live by” (p.183).
Ecosophy, also called deep ecology, represents the belief that humans must change their relationship with nature from valuing nature solely for its usefulness to recognising its intrinsic value (Madsen, 2024). Adopting ecosophy as its principal normative framework (Chen, 2016), ecolinguistics aims to critique environmentally destructive discourses and promote beneficial ones, often advocating for language reform to encourage ecocentric language. In The Routledge Handbook of Ecolinguistics (Fill and Penz, 2018), studies in the strand of ecological linguistics are categorised into three perspectives, highlighting its focus on linguistic phenomena and discourse: (1) the role of language in creating, aggravating and solving environmental problems, (2) how environmental topics appear in texts and the media and (3) how language and discourse transport ecological and unecological ideas.
Ecolinguistics has examined the role of language in environmental degradation mainly by analysing texts about environmental problems. Studies have exposed dominant discourses that promote unsustainable behaviours such as greenwashing that misrepresent individuals or organisations as environmentally responsible, consumerist discourses that encourage overconsumption, and economic discourses that emphasise economic growth as the primary goal of society (Stibbe, 2018). Specifically, there is a tradition of examining the business discourses on corporations’ environmental representation (Alexander, 2018) through critical discourse analysis and corpus linguistic techniques. For example, Rutherford (2006) systematically analyses and compares the business-environment discourses of two books written for the 1992 Rio Earth Summit and the 2002 Johannesburg Earth Summit, respectively. Rutherford’s findings reveal that while the business discourse on the environment kept attempting to conceal a traditionally antagonistic view of environmental issues, the growing intensity of public commitment and concern among international business resulted in a progressive increase in environmental symbols, imagery, rhetoric and concepts within business discourse; however, the global environmental summits have had only limited influence on corporations in reformulating their business environmental discourses, as they tend to speak at a more generic, anticipatory level rather than expressing concrete commitments. Another study conducted by Ihlen (2009) applies content analysis to examine the role of climate change and its rhetorical presence in the non-financial reports of the world’s 30 largest corporations. Ihlen identified four central topics highlighted by language patterns: (1) the gravity of the climate change issue; (2) the corporation’s alignment with scientific and political authorities in curbing emissions; (3) the corporation’s actions taken to reduce its emissions; and (4) the business opportunities posed by the climate challenge. Based on these findings, the author points out that the corporations’ rhetoric “exposes a type of economic instrumentality that seems ill-suited to the systemic criticisms and changes that are needed” (p.258), because climate change is framed as an opportunity to establish positive business representations rather than as a harmful ecological problem. A further example is Alexander’s (2018) corpus-based investigation of the Coca-Cola and WWF partnership on water conservation in 2008, which reveals how the cooperation linguistically masks their damage to the environment.
While acknowledging the necessity and significance of analysing environmental discourses through a critical lens, Stibbe (2018) argues that merely identifying negative discourses is insufficient to address environmental issues; we must also search for new positive discourses to guide societies towards a transition to environmentally friendly actions. Therefore, he advocates for adopting Martin’s (2004) Positive Discourse Analysis framework to examine the ways in which language reflects and shapes people’s relationships with the natural world that “inspire, encourage and hearten us” (Stibbe, 2018, p.165). Examples of such positive alternatives include nature writing, the New Economics discourse that linguistically attributes negative associations to economic growth, and representations of nature as both knowledge and aesthetics in Indigenous literature and oral traditions (ibid.), demonstrating the role of language not only in creating and exacerbating environmental problems but also in mitigating them.
Another question that concerns ecolinguists is how environmental topics are represented in texts and the media. Stöckl and Molnar (2018) focus on eco-advertisements and propose dividing this public discourse domain into three sub-genres: green commercial advertising, green-washed commercial advertising and green nonprofit/social advertising. The authors point out that green commercial advertisements tend to utilise a range of pragmatic techniques to emphasise the brands’ engagement with the consumers and argue that the product or service would relieve them of their environmental responsibilities; green-washed commercials are characterised by the pragmatic strategy of making far-fetched connections between the product and nature through either elusive or exaggerated claims; and social advertisements often foreground the ‘Green Nightmare’, calling “public attention to the “Dystopia” – the destruction of nature, the environment and our entire habitat” (Hansen, 2018, p.139). As such, the different eco-advertisements employ various pragmatic strategies to achieve their communicative purposes and simultaneously construct different images of the relationships between individuals, products and nature. Besides eco-advertisements, the media coverage of natural disasters is another topic that draws research attention in ecolinguistics (Döring 2018). In addition to media representation of environment-related topics, researchers also examined the political discourses on environmental matters (Kuha, 2018). According to Kuha (2018), there are three major perspectives through which the presence of environmental issues in the language of politics is examined: framing, labelling, and constructing social actors. Environmental matters are often framed as security threats, forming the discourse of environmental security that presupposes environmental issues as urgent (Fischhendler & Katz, 2013) and gives rise to concepts that are open to manipulation and different interpretations, such as energy security (Fischhendler & Nathan, 2014). Regarding labelling, Kuha (2013, as cited in Kuha, 2018) discusses how labels categorising people based on their stances towards environmental issues shape public perception of the matter. She argues that labels such as “climate denier” and “climate believer” in mainstream climate discourse are actually problematic because such expressions “represent climate change science as if it were religion, superstition or a conspiracy” (p.253). With respect to the construction of social actors, Krzyżanowski (2015) analyses European Union policy discourses on climate change from an identity construction perspective. The results show that EU policy constructs the EU’s identity as a global leader with a distinctive role in shaping the global policy framework on climate change through extensive use of the “othering” strategies, namely by juxtaposing positive “us” and negative “them”.
In addition to analysing how environmental topics are represented in the media and texts, and how language implies environmental problems, ecolinguists have further examined how language and discourse convey ideas about the relationship between humans, animals and nature. An example is how the discursive representation of animals justifies and encourages the exploitation of animals, which Cook and Sealey (2018) argue to be an essential topic in ecolinguistics. They stress that merely addressing the changing relationships between human animals that are represented in discourse should be “complemented by the investigation of the stated beliefs and purposes of those who produce language about animals; the perceptions and reactions of those who receive it; and the social, economic, ideological and historical contexts of that production and reception” (p.311). In this vein, Stibbe (2012) examined how discourses used in animal product industries have a direct impact on animal welfare. By analysing a corpus consisting of (1) articles from industry-specific magazines in the meat sector, (2) articles written by the meat industry for external audiences, and (3) professional articles by interested parties such as veterinarians specializing in food animals or lawyers defending product manufacturers, Stibbe finds that the animal product industry uses the discourse of science to justify the oppression of the animals. For example, “the discourse of evolutionary biology is often invoked to equate the intensive farming and slaughter of animals with the behaviour of predators in the wild, representing it as ‘natural’” (p.25–26). Moreover, in these texts, animals are frequently represented as resources rather than lives, as indicated by the language use such as damage instead of injury in the expression “bird damage” in the Poultry magazine. Stibbe thus concludes that the discourses of animal product industries imply the ideological assumption that animal oppression is “inevitable, natural, and benign” (p.33). He calls for alternative discourses from the animal rights movement that challenge such oppression, as opposing discourses nurture social change (Fairclough, 1993). Along the same lines, Trampe (2018) examines a variety of strategies and perspectives regarding the use of euphemisms for killing and using animals. He identifies two typical language strategies of euphemisation: those that euphemise taboos surrounding the killing and suffering of animals and those that downplay the importance of animals beyond their productive value and utility to human beings. Through examining the euphemisation strategies relating to animals, namely: (1) utilisation of linguistic practice that impose human requirements and standards onto the categories of animals and their behaviours (e.g. laboratory animals), (2) linguistic reification of animals using profit- motivated and technically engineered attributes (e.g. ornamental fish) and (3) the use of euphemistic terms to avoid directly addressing the killing of animals (e.g. male chicks are sorted out in the hatchery), Trampe critically analyses “how language allows humans to appropriate nature in an anthropocentric fashion” (p.328).
Altogether, the ecological linguistics strand of ecolinguistics has furnished us with insights into the role of language in fuelling or alleviating environmental problems, the representation of environmental topics in texts and the media, and the environmental ideologies embedded in language and discourses. Researchers have explored these topics mainly by examining textual data through close analysis of lexicogrammar and corpus. Often adopting a critical discourse analysis perspective, researchers have been working toward linking the language use to specific “genres, topics, purposes and practices” (Cook & Sealey, 2018, p.320), to reveal the discourses – i.e. the stories we live by (Stibbe, 2015) – that shape people’s perception of nature, their relationships with it, and how its treatment is justified. As such, ecological linguistics is strongly oriented toward discourse and shows the relevance of adopting such an approach for this work.
Environmental Linguistics: Positioning Language as a Channel for Environmental Knowledge (Harrison, 2023)
While ecolinguistics has established a paradigm for studying the role of language and discourses in shaping environmental issues and ideologies, Harrison (2023) notes that its “largely metaphorical and narrative program” does not emphasise language as the “preeminent conceptual framework and channel for environmental knowledge” (p.113). Deeply influenced by his training in linguistic anthropology and fieldwork in the Republic of Tuva, Harrison stresses, therefore, a third linguistic approach to ecological questions: environmental linguistics.
Harrison argues that “[e]nvironmental knowledge may be found at every level of language, from single phonemes used in sound mimesis to oral epic tales that extend to more than 10,000 lines” (p.114). This ubiquitous presence leads him to develop environmental linguistics as a field that lies at the intersection of linguistics and natural sciences, examining the linguistic structures and verbal practices that people use to conceptualise, encode, and transmit knowledge about nature. In addition to foregrounding environmental knowledge, another prominent feature of environmental linguistics, compared to ecolinguistics, is the emphasis on Indigenous and decolonial perspectives. Building on his findings on the interconnectedness between the Tuvans’ language and environment, Harrison elaborates on the environmental linguistics framework by expanding the data set with examples from other languages, with a highlight on Indigenous science and the concept of traditional ecological knowledge. Shedding light on six domains of knowledge about nature embedded in Indigenous languages – namely landscapes, lifeforms, time, sound, memory, and survival – “environmental linguistics helps decolonise the sciences” (p.127) by giving these often marginalised or appropriated voices visibility. Harrison (ibid.) argues that:
Indigenous concepts of sustainability […] must be included in any equitable discourse about conservation. But these voices cannot be fully appreciated without the linguistic expertise that can help interpret them for a wider audience. Linguistic methods are thus an essential element of conservation science.
Before the term environmental linguistics began gaining traction with Harrison’s paper published in 2023, the field of Indigenous environmental knowledge was already well- established, as seen in works such as The Routledge Handbook of Indigenous Environmental Knowledge (Thornton & Bhagwat, 2021). I have already provided examples of ethnographic studies on Indigenous environmental knowledge, practices and relationships with nature. Notably, the environmental linguistics framework offers a unique focus on the role of language in documenting, understanding and transmitting Indigenous knowledge about nature. A few empirical studies on this niche include Grenoble and colleagues’ (2019) research on the linguistic encoding of land in Kalaallisut, a Unangan-Yupik Inuit language spoken on the west coast of Greenland. The authors found that in Kalaallisut, the landscape terms are structured around the distinction between land and water, reflecting the people’s ontology of landscape and seascape, as well as their way of life that adapts to dynamic changes of the coastline, as vividly depicted by the authors as “liv[ing] in constant dialogue with the sea and the land” (p.35). They also revealed the essential role of navigational functionality in Kalaallisut lexicons and speakers’ perceptions of landscape, as accurate navigation is critical for survival in Greenland. Demonstrating how the grammatical and lexical system of Indigenous language is shaped by “the physical topography of the land and the cultural practices of engagement with the land”, the authors call for an understanding of the “complex interplay between language, culture and environment” (p.2). Similar insights are also provided by Si’s (2011, 2016) fieldwork with Solega speakers in southern India. Based on everyday language data collected with the Solega community, his monograph (2016) discusses what and why the species or landscapes are named, the dialectal variation, as well as the natural cycles and Solega knowledge of natural resources that are encoded in the Solega language. His works showcase linguists’ potential to contribute to conservation efforts by documenting and analysing how endangered languages preserve traditional ecological knowledge and reflect complex ecological relationships among various local organisms. A further empirical study that illustrates the argument that “[l]anguage diversity is […] the key to safeguarding biodiversity and a balanced human relationship with nature” (Harrison, 2023, p.113) is Harrison’s linguistic anthropology research on Tuvan’s nature-centric worldview. Harrison elaborates his ethnographic data from six perspectives: (1) interdependency between land and language, (2) folk taxonomies in botany and zoology, (3) cultural understanding of time, (4) nature sound mimesis in the semiotic system, (5) individual and generational memories embedded in the landscape and (6) strategies of survival and sustainable stewardship encoded in the language. Combining his own findings with a review of studies that he includes within the environmental linguistics framework, he argues for a conceptualisation of language and environment as a unified and reciprocally constructed network of relations.
This section reviews applied linguistic studies that investigate how nature is incorporated into people’s semiotic practices, and how language plays a pivotal role in shaping their ways of knowing and relating to nature. Insights from these studies demonstrate that linguistic analysis can serve as a powerful lens for exploring human-nature connections. By taking language as an entry point to approach the human-nature assemblage, researchers have sought to uncover diverse relationalities and contribute to the decolonisation of science and language. Next, I will synthesise my reflections from the reviewed studies in the domains of environmental ethnography and applied linguistics to demonstrate how this interdisciplinary engagement enables me to carve out a niche for a dimension that remains underexplored: everyday environmental values held by ordinary individuals.
Establishing a Research Niche
In the previous section, I reviewed empirical studies on human-nature connections from two fields: environmental ethnography and applied linguistics. I now turn to elucidating how this review informs the development of a research niche for the present study.
Environmental ethnographic studies have adopted both critical and non-crisis perspectives to examine the relationship between people and nature. Most of this research focuses on the power dynamics and injustices underlying human-nature tensions. Compared to the studies with a strong critical orientation, research that explores the meanings and patterns of everyday engagement with nature appears much less common. Moreover, an important dimension continues to be overlooked: ordinary people’s everyday interactions with nature. While there is a relatively larger body of ethnographic research within the field of environmental education, much of it centres on structured settings such as schools. Overall, compared to studies on environmental justice or studies examining structured or exceptional experiences with nature, research into informal, mundane, and unstructured interactions with nature remains scattered. This gap leaves us inattentive to the small yet accessible entry points through which individuals initiate, develop, and reflect on their connections with nature. These everyday encounters matter, as they continuously shape people’s awareness of, knowledge about, emotional responses to, and relationships with nature.
Empirical studies within the framework of green applied linguistics offer valuable insights into how language use produces, reflects, and shapes communities’, institutions’ and societies’ knowledge and perceptions about nature. However, little research has zoomed into how ordinary individuals talk about their beliefs and values regarding personal experiences with nature in everyday life. By overlooking individual-level perspectives about engaging with nature, we risk missing the nuanced diversity of people’s preferences, principles and values regarding connecting with nature. Delving into the individual variations enriches our concrete understanding of why nature matters to people in their daily lives, thereby informing more grounded and inclusive approaches to fostering human-nature reconnection. Furthermore, examining personal experiences sheds light on how people’s valuing of nature emerges and evolves. This is meaningful for anticipating and encouraging broader social shifts towards reciprocal relationships with nature, as societal change begins with individuals as one of the primary actors of environmental mindsets and behaviours.
Synthesising the gaps identified in existing ethnographic and linguistic research on human- nature connections, this study carves out a research niche focused on the everyday values of connection with nature held by ordinary individuals. Therefore, this research seeks to elevate the voices of individuals without institutional power or direct experiences of environmental disasters by exploring how they perceive and value everyday interactions with nature. For this purpose, value emerges as a central concept. The following section provides an overview of how scholars have theorised and empirically examined the values of nature, with a particular focus on the concept of relational values, which serves as a key conceptual lens for this study.
Researching Values of Nature
Conceptualising Values of Nature
To motivate reconnection with nature, it is essential to understand why such connections matter. The concept of value helps address this question. In a general sense, value refers to the worth and quality of something in two respects: one is measured by a standard of equivalence, such as the material or monetary worth; the other is based on the thing’s importance, usefulness, desirability, or esteem (Oxford English Dictionary, n.d.). From a philosophical perspective, value tackles questions about what is regarded as good or preferable (Schroeder, 2021; Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2015). The concept of value has therefore multiple layers of meaning:
[t]he word ‘value’ can refer to a principle associated with a given worldview or cultural context, a preference someone has for a particular state of the world, the importance of something for itself or for others, or simply a measure (Pascual et al., 2017, p.9).
The concept of value has been employed as a lens through which to explore how people perceive and assign significance to nature. Values of nature, also called environmental values, have been discussed in various fields including sociology, psychology, anthropology, economics and philosophy (van den Born, 2008). Synthesising the multidisciplinary insights, researchers have reached a consensus that the values of nature should be construed from multiple dimensions. Van den Born (2008) notes that “[v]alues can be considered on two different levels. The first level concerns qualities of nature that are important to the evaluator. The second level concerns moral guidelines” (p.86). In a similar vein, researchers have identified four key levels of values of nature (Pascual et al, 2023; Raymond et al., 2023): (1) worldviews in terms of orientations regarding people-nature relationships, including anthropocentric worldviews, bio/eco-centric worldviews and pluricentric worldviews with no specific focus on either side but emphasizing reciprocal relationships between human and nature; (2) broad values that entail moral guidelines and life goals that define desirable interactions and relationships with nature; (3) specific values, which refer to judgements regarding the importance and contributions of nature in specific contexts; (4) value indicators as quantitative measures and qualitative descriptors that denote nature’s concrete influences on people in biophysical, monetary or socio-cultural terms.
In efforts to unpack values of nature, a central debate has emerged around whether nature is valued for its intrinsic worth, or for its usefulness for human beings, namely the instrumental value (Chan et al., 2016; Elliot, 2025; Tallis & Lubchenco, 2014). However, this dichotomous framing often fails to resonate with how people on the ground experience and value their everyday connections with nature (Chan et al., 2016; Muradian & Pascual, 2018). Rather than philosophically considering the inherent worth of nature or merely aiming for the instrumental benefits, people often cherish the relation they hold with nature, and “the preferences, principles and virtues associated with relationships with and responsibilities towards nature” (Muradian & Pascual, 2018, p.8, emphasis in original). This argument presses the need to answer the question posed by de Groot (1992): “what are the values, the desirable qualities, specific to the people-nature relationship?” within the context where “[…] sufficient attention has been paid to the values of people and nature separately, e.g. on nature’s side […]” (p.531), but not yet on human-nature relationships.
Therefore, scholars have called for a relational turn in valuing nature (Chan et al., 2016). This shift has given rise to the emerging concept of relational values, which will be presented in the following section.
The Relational Turn in Valuing Nature
In exploring a complementary approach to understanding nature’s significance, a team of sustainability researchers have proposed the concept of relational values (RV) as a third category for valuing nature, alongside intrinsic and instrumental values (see Chan et al., 2016). They define relational values as the “preferences, principles, and virtues associated with relationships, both interpersonal and as articulated by policies and social norms. […] [They are] not present in things but derivative of relationships and responsibilities to them” (ibid., p.1462). In other words, relational values are “the values that pertain to relationships between people and nature or among people through nature” (Gould et al., 2024, p.9).
The key to distinguishing relational values from instrumental and intrinsic values is the content of valuing. As Deplazes-Zemp and Chapman (2021) explain, while the usefulness of nature to humans constitutes the content of instrumental valuing, and nature’s inherent properties form the content of intrinsic valuing, the content of relational valuing is, as the term itself suggests, the relationships between people and nature. In the same vein, Raymond and colleagues (2023) expound:
Instrumental values include things important as a means to an end or to satisfy preferences (usually for humans). At least in principle, they are substitutable. Intrinsic values include something’s worth as an end in and of itself, something’s value independent of reference to people as valuers and nature’s inherent moral value regardless of human importance or usefulness (i.e. right to exist). Relational values encapsulate meaningful relationships between people and nature and among people (including across generations) through nature (p.4).
While the introduction of RV as a complementary epistemological framing to value nature offers a bridge between polarised views of nature’s values, namely either as economic metrics or as abstract moral worth (Stålhammar & Thorén, 2019), the concept has also faced critique, particularly regarding the ambiguity surrounding the meaning of “relational” within the term. For example, Norton and Sanbeg (2021) suggested that “all environmental values are ultimately relational” (p.695). Luque-Lora (2023) argues that “relationality is inherent to held, instrumental and intrinsic values. This means that there is no meaningful way in which to distinguish relational values from more familiar types of values” (p.411). He questions if the proposal of RV actually downplays the relational natures of those other values, and as such, “has the perverse effect of confining, rather than promoting, relational thinking” (ibid.). Such criticism appears to find support in Rolston’s (1981) statement: “Values [of nature] are actualised in human relationships with nature” (p.113).
While agreeing that “all valuations are essentially relational” (Himes & Muraca, 2018, p.2), proponents of RV elaborate on their perspective:
We propose that all categories of values are derived from different cognitive frameworks that shape a given relationship with nature. For example, when something is considered to have an ‘instrumental value’ is mainly due to an underlying correspondence to a given [relational model], namely, ‘utilization’. Similarly, intrinsic values can be related to an alternative [relational model] that allocates a particular set of rights to nature (e.g. ‘wardship’). Lastly, the current use of the term ‘relational values’ in the sustainability discourse may be associated with other [relational models], such as ‘stewardship’ or ‘ritualized exchange’. (Muradian and Pascual, 2018, p.9)
Put differently, in terms of how nature is valued, all forms of value emerge from the ways in which people relate to nature, and therefore are inherently relational in process. However, as for what is being valued, the three values address distinct aspects. In relations where the relationship itself holds significance, the concept of relational values is useful to articulate the importance and virtue of that connection (e.g. care and support in friendship); in relations where the interests and power of one party are emphasised, instrumental values highlight the utility of the exploited side (e.g. animal as product and food); in relations where one party’s worth is perceived as independent of the other, intrinsic values focus on the intrinsic rights and moral worth (e.g. Mother Earth and Gaia). Therefore, the concept of relational values facilitates a shift toward a relational understanding of nature.
Given the strength of the concept of relational values in illuminating the preferences, principles, virtues, and perceived benefits that people associate with their relationships with nature (Chan et al., 2016; Gould et al., 2024), it offers an effective analytical lens for this study. This research uses this lens to explore how people value their everyday engagement with nature, focusing on participants’ beliefs about preferred ways of cultivating meaningful connections and their perceptions of what constitutes reciprocal human-nature relationships.
Having clarified the meaning and theoretical contributions of the concept of relational values, I now turn to a review of empirical studies that have applied and examined this concept in practice.
Researching Relational Values
The last section considered how we can understand and define relational values. In this section, I provide an overview of how relational values have been examined empirically. Referring to both relevant systematic reviews and key empirical studies, this section addresses the following questions: Which relational values have been studied? How to study relational values? What is still missing from the discussion?
A recent systematic review of empirical studies on relational values of nature (Pratson et al., 2023) shows that RV has been gaining growing research interest in various fields such as ecology, human geography, marine science, ecological economics, environmental psychology, environmental education, and environmental policy. Existing studies employ both qualitative methods (e.g. participatory approaches, interviews, participant observation, focus groups) and quantitative methods (e.g. surveys and questionnaires, choice experiments) to elicit and interpret relational values (Pratson et al., 2023; Riechers et al., 2022). Based on the empirical data, researchers have discussed relational values from diverse perspectives. They have identified values ranging from individual and cultural identity, social cohesion, place attachment, knowledge, care, stewardship and responsibility, etc. (Pascual et al., 2017; Pratson et al., 2023; Riechers et al., 2022).
In the studies published, two clusters of empirical works on relational values can be identified. The first cluster encompasses the endeavours to unpack the constructs, measurements and “syntax” (Chapman & Deplazes-Zemp, 2023) of relational values. The second cluster includes case studies that aim to understand specific relational values in greater depth and within a broader context of environmental issues. Studies of the first cluster mostly adopt quantitative methods. Klain et al. (2017) examined whether relational values resonate with diverse populations and whether people perceive relational values differently than the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP) statements, which measure people’s environmental concern (e.g. “Humans are seriously abusing the environment”) (Anderson, 2012). Referring to studies on cultural ecosystem services, the researchers describe six major relational values in plain language in the surveys distributed to a sample of residents of northeastern Costa Rican farmers and tourists in Costa Rica, as Table 1 shows:
| Relational value | Description |
|---|---|
| Sense of community | There are landscapes that say something about who we are as a community, a people. |
| Health | My health or the health of my family is related one way or another to the natural environment. |
| Identity | I have strong feelings about nature (including all plants, animals, the land, etc.). These views are part of who I am and how I live my life. |
| Kinship | Plants and animals, as part of the interdependent web of life, are like ’kin’ or family to me, so how we treat them matters. |
| Responsibility | How I manage the land, both for plants and animals and for future people, reflects my sense of responsibility to and so stewardship of the land. |
| Care for wilderness | I often think of some wild places whose fate I care about and strive to protect, even though I may never see them myself. |
Klain and colleagues find that this “relational framing” (p.11) of the significance, feelings and virtues derived from connection with nature are widely resonant with the study populations. Statistics show that while the level of agreement with relational values is largely consistent across different groups, the pattern of agreement with NEP statements varies significantly across the groups. This implies that, although people hold different environmental concerns to varying degrees, their understanding of meaningful relationships with nature tends to resonate with one another. Their findings suggest the potential of relational values in alleviating the often polarised divide in the perceptions of nature’s value and fostering a wider public’s connection to the natural world. This potential can be confirmed by Kleespies and Dierkes’ (2020) study series. Demonstrating that RV is a multidimensional construct with three factors: care, community, and connection, their survey-based studies with samples of 350 university students and 878 high school students in Germany illuminate the strong correlation between relational values and connection with nature. To explore the structure of relational values, Saito and colleagues (2022) developed a questionnaire to survey the preferences, principles, and virtues associated with the human-nature relationship among 1862 residents of the Greater Tokyo Area in Japan. Their results show a six-dimensional model of relational values: worldview, social responsibility, satisfaction from being eco-friendly (general stewardship eudaimonic), satisfaction from local stewardship (place-based stewardship eudaimonic), individual identity, and social cohesion.
Two recent qualitative studies in this cluster are noteworthy. They draw on interview data to introduce new relational values referring to concepts in social psychology (Hagen & Gould, 2022) and explore the syntax of relational values (Chapman & Deplazes-Zemp, 2023) respectively. Hagen and Gould explore how empathy and perspective-taking interact with the relational values among residents of a large watershed in Vermont, the United States of America, using semi-structured interviews. Both originating from the field of social psychology, empathy refers to “an other-oriented emotional response congruent with the perceived welfare of another” (Batson et al. 2002, p.1656), and perspective-taking involves “attempting to perceive the experience of another from their point of view” (Hagen & Gould, 2022, Empathy and sustainability section). Through thematic analysis, they find a close alignment between the two concepts and relational values such as care and stewardship. Combining their finding with the previous empirical research revealing the positive effects of perspective-taking and empathy toward nature on environmental perceptions and behaviours (Berenguer, 2007; Schultz, 2000; Sevillano et al., 2007; Swim & Bloodhart, 2015), the authors argue that empathy should be considered as a relational value.
Chapman and Deplazes-Zemp (2023) move from the semantics (the “what”) to the syntax (the “how”) of relational values. Based on semi-structured interviews with Swiss alpine farmers, they propose that relational valuing can be better understood using a lens of bidirectionality. Their interview data show that the alpine farmers perceive their relationships with farm animals, wild animals and the environment from two perspectives. One is an intrinsic aspect characterised by respect, attention and care, and the other is a eudaimonic aspect encompassing the practical, emotional, and experiential satisfaction derived from building relationships (e.g. treating farm animals well brings joy and trust to farmers and makes animal-assisted farming more manageable). Building on this empirical finding, the authors compared intrinsic, instrumental and relational values by illustrating the valuing relation between the valuer (A) and the valued object (B). They described that in an intrinsic valuing relation, the valuer is only oriented towards the valued object, namely A→B. In contrast, instrumental valuing relation is unidirectional towards A, B→A, as B is valued solely based on the extent to which B serves a purpose for A. They propose that relational valuing represents a bidirectional relation A⇆B, meaning that relational values entail both people’s genuine respect and care for nature’s intrinsic values and their pursuit of nature’s contribution to wellbeing (instrumental values). Chapman and Deplazes-Zemp’s research resonates with the arguments that reinforcing the dichotomy between instrumental and intrinsic values may not contribute to a comprehensive understanding of how lay people value their connections with nature, and therefore, there is a need to include “non-instrumental anthropocentric” values in the debates (Chan et al., 2016; Muradian & Pascual, 2018; Stålhammar & Thorén, 2019).
In addition to research aiming to unpack the components and the overall structure of relational values, there is another cluster of case studies on RV using ethnographic approaches, life histories and participatory workshops that aim to understand how relational values unfold in real life. Some of these studies focus on understanding how specific communities relate to their adjacent natural environment. For example, Kaltenborn et al.’s (2017) case study in the fishing community of Røst in the Lofoten Islands in Northern Norway. Through ethnographic observations, in-depth interviews, and a participatory scenario workshop, the authors explored the community’s connection with nature and the benefits the people derived from the environment. Besides sustaining livelihoods and providing public services, people perceive their interactions with nature as supporting their well-being, encompassing “maintenance of identity through traditional practices for harvesting of natural resources, nurturing of skills, social cohesion, and acting meaningfully in one’s local environment” (p.166). Cundill and colleagues (2017) present a case study of the Likhayalethu Community from South Africa. Although the Likhayalethu Community claim a portion of land that falls into today’s Double Drift Nature Reserve in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa, the community does not have physical access to the land due to the proclamation of the reserve and the following eviction. The life histories of the experiencers of the eviction reveal that “the forced removal from their land had disrupted social ties, networks and sense of community” (p.144), and had led to the loss of livestock-keeping culture, food security and physical security. These findings illustrate that people attribute place identity and place dependence to land and the long-term impacts of removing people’s access to nature. Bataille et al. (2021) conducted semi-structured interviews in Aotearoa New Zealand to study the values that tangata tiaki (Māori environmental guardians) and landowners have towards wetland ecosystems. Their findings show that although tangata tiaki and landowners share values such as ahikāroa (longstanding occupation of and connection to place) and attachment to place, which implies a potential common ground, they place different priorities on values. While tangata tiaki prioritises relational over instrumental values, landowners generally emphasise instrumental values. This triggers tensions in values between groups and constrains tangata tiaki wetland ecosystem management and use. Jackson et al.’s (2022) auto-ethnographic study explores the relationship between river rhythmicity (“the periodic, recurrent phenomena of a riverscape that are synchronised with the rise and fall of river water”, p.949) and riparian communities. Their analysis of two of the authors’ lived experiences with rivers in north-central Canada and Amazonian Colombia illustrates “the irreplaceability of riverine rhythms and the strong desire to maintain and centre relationships with rivers that have been forged from generations of observation, engagement and communal practices of care and reciprocity” (p.960). Their findings also show that river alteration shapes society, and “how disturbance to riverine rhythms through dam construction, deforestation and a changing climate have disrupted intimate relationships that resonate across generations” (ibid.). Likewise, focused on rivers, Mould et al. (2020) conducted a case study in the Macdonald Valley, New South Wales, Australia, to investigate factors that influence landholders’ participation in river rehabilitation projects, and how river management programs can better respond to landholders’ values. Interview results show that the landholders are motivated to participate in river management by their visions of the river’s ideal condition. These visions are shaped mainly by relational values such as aesthetics, amenity and caring for wildlife. Besides, most participants expressed a sense of responsibility and duty of care towards the river. Based on these findings, the authors argue that “[a]pproaching participation through the lens of relational values engenders opportunities for improving river management practice, making it more responsive and adaptive to the particular values that motivate action” (p.17). Moving from relationships with landforms to living species, Monroy-Sais et al. (2022) ran participatory workshops with two communities, one Indigenous and the other non-Indigenous, in a highly biodiverse region in western Mexico. The workshops aim to explore how different values are attributed to various plants and how these values influence strategies for plant resource management in both wild and anthropogenic environments. The results reveal a web of interactions from a relational perspective:
i) multi-directional relationships with biodiversity; ii) connections between community members and their land; iii) a source of knowledge and education for younger generations; iv) balance in the use of the landscape (e.g., forests, cultivation plots, and orchards); and v) reciprocity with plants under the different forms of management, such as protection or enhancement. (p.1240)
Tadaki et al. (2022) studied the diverse meanings and experiences with introduced trout and their management in Aotearoa New Zealand. “To explore the relational values of trout and understand how trout have become an object of moral concern” (p.466), Tadaki and colleagues interviewed 13 knowledge holders including Māori community members, scientists researching the impacts of trout and participating in freshwater decision-making, and staff of the Department of Conservation and New Zealand Fish and Game Council whose primary responsibility is managing native fish conservation and introduced fisheries. Their interviews reveal that the three groups share experiences in care, wonder, and loss in relation to the natural world. The experiences with fish enabled the participants to “pursue lives of value” (p.474) and develop environmental consciousness as well as care for the natural environment. Tadaki et al’s results also reveal that different groups’ relationships to fish and fish management are culturally-, historically- and place-specific, which results in differences or even conflicts in values. As such, the authors argue that “it is not just the fish themselves that are of moral concern, but the relationships between people and fish, and between different groups of people that are at stake in current conflicts over trout” (p.475).
This section reviews the expanding body of qualitative and quantitative research on relational values. Researchers have identified and elaborated a diversity of relational values attributed to nature by people across various sociocultural contexts. Existing studies show that adopting a relational perspective on how people value nature advances our understanding of the tensions between policy frameworks, management strategies and local community values (Pratson et al., 2023; Wainaina et al., 2023). These studies also highlight the importance of Indigenous knowledge and worldviews in addressing environmental issues, as well as the role of natural elements in cultural heritage and community identity (Riechers et al., 2022). However, research that focuses explicitly on the interplay between relational values and everyday connections with nature from the perspectives of ordinary individuals remains limited. Aside from a few case studies that delve into everyday experiences and perceptions of nature’s relational values (e.g. van Heel et al. 2024a), qualitative research exploring how people value their everyday interactions with nature is relatively scarce. This gap confirms the research niche outlined in Section 2.3: the need to examine the values that ordinary people associate with their meaningful connections with nature as formed through everyday engagement.
Thus far, I have reviewed empirical studies that illustrate human-nature connections across three domains, each characterised by distinct methodological, disciplinary and conceptual orientations: environmental ethnography, green applied linguistics and relational values. Based on this review, I have identified the research niche that this study seeks to address. Before presenting the problem statement, it is necessary to elaborate on several concepts that will inform the subsequent data analysis and allow my findings to contribute to the expansion of the relational values framework.
Niche Concepts for Everyday Relational Values
Serious leisure
Previous studies have provided evidence that many people appreciate experiential connections with nature for recreational interests (e.g. Baker & Fick, 2022; Kellert et al., 2017). Engaging in activities in nature is widely recognised as a popular form of leisure, a “relatively self- determined activity-experience that falls into one’s economically free-time roles, […] that is psychologically pleasant in anticipation and recollection […]” (Kaplan, 1975, as cited in Blackshaw, 2010, p.3). While the term leisure is often associated with relief, relaxation, and carefreeness, sociologists have noted a form of leisure that enables people to “express their abilities, fulfil their potential, and identify themselves as unique human” (Stebbins, 1982, p.251). Such leisure activities often require participants to devote relatively considerable time and effort. To conceptualise this more physically and/or mentally engaging form of leisure, Stebbins (1982) proposed the term serious leisure. According to Stebbins, serious leisure refers to a long-term endeavour performed by amateurs, hobbyists and volunteers with specific knowledge, skills or training, and characterised by perseverance, careers, personal effort, durable benefits, unique ethos, and enthusiastic self-identification. Stebbins argued that these six constructs of serious leisure are hardly identifiable in unserious, casual pastimes. He elaborated on the six dimensions:
| Quality of serious leisure | Description in Stebbins, 1982 |
|---|---|
| perseverance despite challenges | […Despite] moments when they suffer stage fright (Stebbins, 1981b), embarrassment (Floro, 1978: 198), freezing cold (Stebbins, 1981 c), anxiety (Dannefer, 1980: 396), fatigue and injury (Thompson et al., 1979; Hershkowitz, 1972), and other strains […] it is clear that the positive feelings about the activity come, to some extent, from sticking with it through thick and thin, through conquering adversity. (p.256) |
| long-term endeavour with psychological continuity | These endeavors are enduring pursuits with their own histories of turning points, stages of achievement or involvement, and background contingencies. (p.256) |
| significant personal effort based on specific skills or knowledge | […] such characteristics as manual dexterity, scientific knowledge, verbal skills, long experience in a role, showmanship, athletic prowess, and, above all, persistent individual effort, differentiate amateurs and hobbyists from dabblers and the public, and volunteers from trainees and clients (p.256) |
| durable benefits including self- enrichment and personal growth | self-actualization, self-enrichment, recreation or renewal of self, feelings of accomplishment, enhancement of self-image, self-expression, social interaction and belonginess, and lasting physical products of the activity. A ninth benefit-self- gratification or pure fun – which is considerably more evanescent than the preceding eight, is the only one that is also characteristic of unserious leisure. (p.256–257) |
| strong identification with the pursuits | They are inclined to speak proudly, excitedly, and frequently about them to other people, and to present themselves in terms of them when conversing with new acquaintances. (p.257) |
| unique ethos within groups | […] amateurs, hobbyists, and volunteers tend to develop subcultures composed of special beliefs, values, moral principles, norms, and performance standards. Put otherwise, serious leisure participants carry on their interests within their own social worlds […] (p.257) |
The concept of serious leisure has not yet been used to examine human-nature connections, despite its potential to deepen our understanding of nature’s relational value from a recreational perspective. Many nature-related activities that require physical effort, continuity, knowledge and skills fall into serious leisure, such as hiking, environmental volunteering, and birdwatching. Although nature-related serious leisure is more challenging to access compared to casual activities in nature, such as having a picnic, its “seriousness” enables participants to transform experiential connections with nature into deeper connections at a cognitive and philosophical level. Moreover. The six qualities of serious leisure overlap with multiple relational values of nature, such as identity, recreation, community, knowledge and environmental principles. As such, a serious leisure lens is not only useful for identifying the relational values emerging in such activities but also has the potential to reveal the dynamic interplay among different connections and values. Therefore, it can be used as an effective lens in relational value research to understand why there are people who are willing to invest a significant effort to connect with nature, how these “serious” connections with nature unfold, and what values can be derived from such connections.
Agency of Nature
In philosophy, agency denotes the exercise or manifestation of the capacity to act (Schlosser, 2019). This concept is most frequently applied as a quality of human beings. The notion of human agency, “the ability of people to act intentionally to shape their worlds”, underpins the field of history (Nash, 2005, p.67). In the early 21st century, environmental historians have proposed the idea that nature possesses agency too. However, this notion is challenged by the arguments emphasising the unique connection between human action and ideas. It is argued that although human action is not the only force that alters the world, “the agency of human beings is distinguished by our ability to convert ideas into purposeful actions” (ibid.). Nash reminds us of the classic bee/architect metaphor:
[W]hile a bee can build a hive, the bee cannot envision the hive prior to its building. The bee just builds, whereas the human is presumed to think and then build. The bee is not an agent, while the architect clearly is. (p.67)
Nash argues against this view, drawing on insights from environmental history studies. Taking Mart Stewart’s (1996/2002) work on the mutually transforming relationship between the natural environment and human culture on the Georgia coastal plain between 1680 and 1920 as an example, Nash aligns herself with Stewart that nature also has agency because natural environments shape human intentions and actions and therefore should be regarded as an active participant in human-nature interactions rather than a background, a vacuum:
No overarching plan ever existed for tidewater rice cultivation on the southeastern coast; in fact, no one is quite sure how the system originated in America (although west African slaves probably brought many of the techniques). But certainly for those who found themselves in this location, both slaves and planters, the characteristics of the Georgia landscape suggested certain alternatives. To put it simply, tidewater rice cultivation could be imagined on the Georgia coast but not in the Colorado desert. Actual methods, moreover, hardly comprised a unified system; they were idiosyncratic and often ad hoc. Many actions undoubtedly emerged spontaneously in the fields, and only later were they passed on as “ideas” or “expertise”. (p.68)
The field of environmental education has also been reflecting on the concept of agency. Examinations of nature-based learning programs and early childhood curricula on sustainability (Ross, 2020; Weldemariam et al., 2017) uncover that “[t]he certainty that intentional human agency alone can change the world (for the better) is firmly entrenched within the humanist and activist framings of education for sustainability and/or environmental education” (Taylor, 2017, p.1451–1452). However, merely considering nature as a substrate for people to act upon fails to address nature’s role in shaping people’s ways of acting, seeing, living and thinking. To understand the reciprocity of human-nature relationships, it is necessary to extend our understanding of agency beyond humans, to include nature as well. This aligns with an alternative philosophical conception of agency, that “genuine agency can be exhibited by beings that are not capable of intentional action, and it has been argued that agency can and should be explained without reference to causally efficacious mental states and events” (Schlosser, 2019, para.1).
Reconsidering our relationships with nature from a perspective of agency prompts us to reflect on the influence, self-functioning and resilience of nature, as well as our positions in the face of nature. Such reflections help capture the complexity of the relationships between people and nature and may shape moral principles for conceiving and interacting with nature. Therefore, bringing the notion of nature’s agency into the relational value dialogues contributes to the understanding of how diverse relationships with nature are formed and construed from a non- anthropocentric perspective.
Nature-inclusive Eudaimonia
The Greek philosophy concept Eudaimonia, also spelt eudaemonia, refers to “the condition of human flourishing or of living well” (Duignan, n.d., para. 1). The notion goes beyond “happiness” as it does not represent “a state of mind or a feeling of pleasure or contentment” (ibid.) but consists of “states and/or pursuits associated with using and developing the best in oneself, in accordance with one’s true self and one’s deeper principles” (Huta, 2013, p.201). As such, pointing to self-realisation and the quality of a morally good life, eudaimonia is intrinsically linked with value in the sense of moral guidelines and life goals. In the context of environmental studies, there have been voices calling for attention to eudaimonia as a relational value (Knippenberg et al., 2018; van den Born et al., 2018) because “humans are born relata.That is why the ideas of relational values and eudaimonia (the good, meaningful, worthwhile life) are intimately bound; good relations are key constituents of the good life” (Knippenberg et al., 2018, p.43, emphasis in original). In response to this call, Knippenberg and colleagues introduced the notion of nature-inclusive eudaimonia, meaning “a flourishing life in which nature is an integral part” (p.43). While this notion can be helpful to delve into the philosophical aspect of human-nature connection because it integrates nature into the process of realising self-worth and meaningful life, very few studies have yet employed it as a conceptual lens to explore how the eudaimonic value of nature is expressed in real life. One of the few such studies is Russo Lopes and Bastos Lima’s (2023) qualitative research on the sustainable land-use initiatives in the states of Acre and Mato Grosso, Brazil, identifying values that have motivated decisions for conservation in deforestation frontiers and how these values are articulated. Their results reveal that eudaimonic values, including increased meaningfulness, personal growth through learning and knowledge sharing, as well as a sense of contributing to the world, are key factors in these initiatives.
The concept of nature-inclusive eudaimonia does not frame nature as an external background for human living, but a component of meaningful self. Therefore, understanding how it unfolds in everyday, accessible interactions with nature offers strong arguments for why we should (re)connect with nature.
This section presents the key conceptual framework for this research: relational values, and proposes several niche concepts to add to the discussion. Synthesising the above theoretical and empirical insights, I will present the problem statement and research questions in the next section.
Problem Statement and Research Questions
This literature review examines conceptual frameworks and empirical studies related to human- nature connections, with the aim of identifying the research niche that the current study seeks to address. It presents a critical review of relevant scholarship in sociological environmental ethnography, green applied linguistics, and the emerging concept of relational values. Through this review, I establish the specific focus of this study: exploring how ordinary individuals value their everyday connections with nature.
Overall, ethnographic studies that investigate people’s connections with nature in everyday, non-activist settings are significantly less than those that adopt a critical, activist lens focused on power dynamics and inequalities. Similarly, research examining the personal values that ordinary individuals attribute to informal, mundane, and unstructured interactions with nature remains scarce and scattered. Addressing these gaps through the lens of relational values offers an opportunity to illuminate the diverse, nuanced pathways through which people connect with nature, and to understand the significance and virtues embedded in this connection.
Given ethnography’s grounding in real-life contexts and its strength in revealing the meaning of everyday interactions, an ethnographic investigation of mundane connections with nature can uncover subtle, invisible and often taken-for-granted dimensions of unstructured engagement. Some may argue that such moments represent unique, transient experiences and, therefore, that findings derived from their analysis lack generalisability or replicability as solutions to the broader disconnection between people and nature (see de Saint-Georges, 2018). I argue, however, that it is not the generalisability, but the everydayness and mundanity of these encounters that make the insights gained from studying them meaningful for efforts to reconnect people with nature. While I do not assume that such moments of connection can be precisely replicated, which would be essentially impossible, this study can nonetheless provide empirical evidence to better understand how connections with nature are cultivated and valued in daily life.
By shifting the research gaze to ordinary people’s everyday engagement with and valuation of nature, this study moves beyond the polarised framing of privileged versus marginalised groups. In doing so, I do not intend to diminish the significance of environmental justice research, fully acknowledging that the separation between people and nature has long been, and continues to be, closely tied to social divisions in terms of gender, social class and (post)colonialism. However, I argue that responding to the call to reconnect people with nature also requires a more inclusive narrative that highlights the experiences of the broader public, including those who are neither privileged enough to possess institutional power nor belong to the underrepresented groups that bear the most harmful consequences of environmental degradation. I therefore propose that ethnographically exploring ordinary people’s mundane encounters with nature, and the values they associate with these encounters is necessary and valuable. Such in-depth examinations can deepen our understanding of the significance of everyday connections with nature beyond crisis-driven narratives. Moreover, understanding what nature means to ordinary individuals may offer practical insights for fostering the reconnection between people and nature.
This research, accordingly, aims to explore the values held by ordinary citizens – namely, their preferences, beliefs and perceived benefits – regarding their everyday, mundane engagement with nature, using ethnographic methods. It seeks to answer two research questions: 1. Which perspectives do participants consider important for initiating and deepening connections with nature? 2. What views of nature and human-nature relationships are embedded in participants’ engagement with nature from these perspectives? In light of these questions, the next chapter presents the methodology employed to address them.