Skip to main content

Connecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain: 3. Methodology

Connecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain
3. Methodology
  • Show the following:

    Annotations
    Resources
  • Adjust appearance:

    Font
    Font style
    Color Scheme
    Light
    Dark
    Annotation contrast
    Low
    High
    Margins
  • Search within:
    • My Notes + Comments
    • Notifications
    • Privacy
  • Publication HomeConnecting with Nature through Hands, Heart and Brain
  • Publications
  • Learn more about Manifold

Notes

table of contents
  1. Cover image
  2. Title Page
  3. Imprint
  4. Logos
  5. Contents
  6. Figures
  7. Tables
  8. Abbreviations
  9. 1. Introduction
  10. 2. Literature Review
  11. 3. Methodology
  12. 4. Analytical Framework
  13. 5. Findings and Discussion
  14. 6. Conclusion
  15. References

3. Methodology

An Ethno-case Study Approach

Qualitative researchers seek to elaborate on a certain group of people’s meaning-making process, focusing on their identities, actions, interests and beliefs (Erickson, 2018). For this purpose, they have developed “a baffling number of choices of approaches” (Creswell & Poth, 2018, p.8). Among these various approaches, two widely applied methods are ethnography and case study (see Creswell & Poth, 2018; Saldaña, 2011). Although these two terms are often used interchangeably, many qualitative researchers argue that it is necessary to distinguish between ethnographic and case study research. The distinctions are made from different perspectives, for example, the length of time a researcher spends in the field (Parker-Jenkins, 2018; Smart, 2008), the scope of the research (Smart, 2008), and the intent of the research (Creswell & Poth, 2018). However, even experienced researchers still find it challenging to draw a fine line between ethnography and case study as “both concepts overlap and draw on related techniques” (Parker-Jenkins, 2018, p.23). As a result, it can be a struggle to situate one’s research within the ongoing debates on the divergence and convergence between ethnography and case study. Was the study doing both or neither? In case of the present research, it looks at a group of environmental volunteers and their perceptions of connecting with nature as expressed through their accounts and actions. This kind of immersive perspective is one of the defining features of ethnography. Therefore, simply categorising this research as a case study without fully acknowledging the ethnographic approaches I engaged in would partially dilute its emic nature. However, unlike ethnography, this research does not seek to develop a “complex, complete description of the culture of a group” (ibid., p.91) in the sense of “writing (-graphy) about people (ethno-)”. This is because, first and foremost, this research does not aim at producing a Geertzian thick description of the community of these environmental volunteers or revealing how their shared culture works. In this study, “ethnography” is rather a process than a product, which suggests the researcher is better off, following Wolcott’s (2008) urge, to distinguish between doing ethnography and borrowing ethnographic techniques. In this project, I utilised ethnographic data collection tools to explore the contextual question of how people connect with and perceive nature, using a group of environmental volunteers as a specific illustration. In this vein, my research falls into the category of case study methodology (see Creswell & Poth, 2018; Denzin & Lincoln, 2018). Case studies, as defined by Thomas (2015), are “analyses of persons, events, decisions, periods, projects, policies, institutions or other systems which are studied holistically by one or more methods” (p.23), aiming to “catch the complexity of a single case” (Stake, 1995, xi). Case study methodology does not prioritise understanding how people in the field act and interact from their own perspectives, nor does it emphasise the value of participant’s voices. These concerns, however, are the key interests of ethnographers (Fetterman, 2010).

Parker-Jenkins (2018) helps resolve the “neither or both” dilemma. Her paper Problematising Ethnography and Case Study points out that the essential distinction between ethnography and case study is the extent to which the researcher immerses him/herself in the context and/or data, and that “the method commonly employed when people claim to be doing ethnography, is really ‘case study’ drawing on ethnographic technique” (p.18). The author argues that research can represent a hybrid form of both approaches and proposes the term ethno-case study to designate such an approach, which

conveys the sense of conducting an inquiry with people, employing techniques associated with long-term and intensive ethnography but limited in terms of research time, engagement with the data and the extent of the findings. The coining of this new term provides the social science researcher with an addition to the existing toolkit of terms with the benefit of being able to locate their work within a space which need not be defined as either ethnography or case study but which usefully draws on both. (p.29)

This research is situated within the ethno-case study approach for two key reasons. The first reason is related to the purpose and nature of the study. As the research aims to explore the multifaceted issue of human-nature connections, using a group of environmental volunteers as an entry point, ethnographic techniques were employed to examine participants’ emic understanding and meanings of nature that are constructed and shared within the group. For such studies that intend to provide a context-specific understanding of an issue from an insider’s perspective rather than aiming to portray the culture of a certain group of people, the term ethno-case study provides an appropriate positioning from a methodological point of view. This term acknowledges that the study is located within a richer, broader context and values the voices of participants employing ethnographic techniques (Parker-Jenkins, 2018). The second reason to adopt this term is to consider the extent of immersion in the field. According to Hammersley (2006), ethnography is derived from anthropology and traditionally involves “actually living in the communities of the people being studied, more or less round the clock […]. (…) over a long period of time, at least a year and often several years” (p.4). In this project, although I drew on ethnographic techniques such as interviews and participant observation, the extent of my immersion with the context and field falls significantly short of this standard. There was no occasion where I lived with the environmental volunteers for an extended period of time. The fieldwork mainly took place during two late autumns to early spring periods, namely from October 2022 to March 2023, and from October 2023 to March 2024. The whole corpus consists of approximately 5 hours of videotaped recordings, 60 hours of participant observation, and 9 ethnographic interviews that last between 1 hour and 2.5 hours, and fieldnotes of approximately 12,000 words. Hence, the project is not ethnography in the sense of traditional anthropology. This limited immersion into the context is due to, on the one hand, the realistic time constraints on doctoral research, and on the other hand, the nature of my research questions and objects. The project did not seek to produce a comprehensive and interpretative account of the culture of the environmental volunteer community, but set out to understand a certain aspect of the human-nature connection within the context of participatory conservation projects. Therefore, I did not need to spend an extensive amount of time living with the participants to capture the cultural nuances in their lives. I needed, however, ethnographic sensibility (Mills & Morton, 2013) to examine volunteers during conservation work. The term ethno-case study thus implies my limited research time and immersion in the context, as Parker-Jenkins (2018) suggests.

Although my project is not ethnography in line with traditional anthropology, in that sense, I still employed ethnography as a way of looking (Wolcott, 2008). In other words, I used ethnographic tools as an outsider to elicit emic perspectives (Parker-Jenkins, 2018) to gain insights into multifarious human-nature connections and notions of nature by showcasing the insider perspectives of a group of environmental volunteers.

In the following section, I detail the methods of data collection and explain how I approached the negotiation of the researcher-participant relationship.

Methods of Data Collection

The previous section set out the reasons for adopting the ethno-case study as my methodological approach, which implies that the research draws upon ethnographic methods to collect data. Traditionally, the term “ethnographic methods” is used as an umbrella term to refer to qualitative data collection methods that include, for example, interviews, observation, document analysis, collection of personal constructs and mental maps (Delamont, 2004; Kawulich, 2005). In this section, I justify my selection of the research setting and describe its relevant characteristics, outline my process of applying the tools of participant observation and ethnographic interviewing, and reflect on the negotiation of language and positionality in fieldwork.

Research Setting

Why Luxembourg, LetzEarth and Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt?

In this ethnographic research, I have chosen the reflexive narrative style (Gobo & Molle, 2017) to engage with the data and present my findings. This means that I neither seek to conceal my researcher’s interpretative work by presenting myself as invisible in the field and attempting to provide a “snapshot” of the field as the realist narrative ethnography writers do; nor do I align with the processual narrative writers by foregrounding my experience of “comprehension of the other” (Rabinow, 1977, ix), namely my own cognitive process of “coming to know the field” in the ethnographic text (Gobo & Molle, 2017). Instead, I value a balance between reality and my own perceptions of the field in presenting the research process and findings, for which I must “[e]xplicitly stat[e] the circumstances of the knowledge production process” (ibid., section 15.4.5). Therefore, before I delve into the data collection methods, I will first introduce the multi-layered research setting, namely Luxembourg, the environmental NGO LetzEarth and its participatory conservation project series Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt1 (pseudonym).

Luxembourg as the Broad Context

Luxembourg is often associated with a range of unique attributes: it is the world’s only Grand Duchy, one of the four institutional seats of the European Union, a trilingual state, home to a high immigrant population and a host to a rapidly developing financial sector. These traits make Luxembourg an appealing context for researchers in the fields of politics, multilingualism, migration and finance. However, readers may question how Luxembourg can serve as a meaningful research context for studies in the field of environmental humanities. In fact, Luxembourg’s environmental history makes it a microcosm that reflects the dynamics between people and nature. From the early 20th century to the present, Luxembourg’s economic pillar has shifted from agriculture to the steel industry, and eventually to the financial sector. This transformation has inevitably been accompanied by changes in how people exploit, conserve and coexist with nature. In the following paragraphs, I will explain why Luxembourg is a meaningful setting for researching human-nature relationships within the context of contemporary socio-economic development, using two examples of its distinctive natural and cultural landscapes: the Minette region and traditional high-stem orchards.

The discovery and exploitation of iron ore in the country’s southern region, known as “Minette”2, has profoundly impacted not only the country’s population distribution and industrial development, but also its landscapes. As Crowther (2020) described:

Over a very short space of time at the end of the 19th century, the Minette ore field grew at a prodigious rate. Villages became towns, and great swathes of land disappeared under massive industrial plants, which spewed out fire, smoke and fumes. And wherever the ore-bearing strata lay close to the surface, the land was opened up to enable opencast mining to ravage the countryside. (section “Industrialisation”)

While this chapter of history echoes the well-known narrative that human extraction of natural resources has led to environmental degradation, it may be surprising for many to learn that several former opencast mining sites have transformed into nature reserves today. Following the cessation of mining in the mid-1970s, these sites began to host flora and fauna that would not have established themselves in the region without these anthropogenic changes, transforming into “biodiversity hotspots” (Crowther, 2020; Arendt et al., 2020). In 2020, the former opencast mining areas such as the Ellergronn (Esch-sur-Alzette) and Giele Botter (Differdange/Pétange) were designated as a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve (Visit Luxembourg, n.d.). As such, the Minette region offers an example of Luxembourg’s potential as a meaningful research context for examining the transformation of human-nature relationships from exploitive extraction to coexistence, which is embedded in socio-economic development.

In addition to industrialisation, urbanisation is another key theme that is closely linked to human-nature dynamics. It is widely believed that urbanisation results in people’s lifestyle changes and often restrains their nature experiences (Hartig et al., 2014). As a historically agrarian country, Luxembourg has undoubtedly undergone rural urbanisation, “a process by which rural areas become urbanized” (Ofori-Amoah, 2017, Abstract), on the way to its current status as a key player in the global financial sector. One trace left by Luxembourg’s rural urbanisation is the significant decline in the number of its high-stem orchards (Luxembourgish Bongerten) (Crowther, 2020; Lorgé & Melchior, 2015/2020), which have been a prominent characteristic of Luxembourg’s natural landscape. All Luxembourg’s villages were once encircled by the traditional orchards and depended on the “green belt of fruit trees” for fresh fruits and winter preserves (Lorgé & Melchior, 2015/2020, p.175). However, rural urbanisation has rendered these orchards its first victims (ibid.). As my research participant Birgit noted in an interview:

[…] in orchards there are fruit trees and people used to live on them. They used to pickle and preserve apples and pears and everything to get through the winter. And today, you go to Cactus3 to buy everything. You go to Cactus, in December you go to Cactus to buy strawberries, things like that. All the trees were overgrown, they were no longer taken care of, they broke, died and so on. Around 1900, there were over 1 million fruit trees in Luxembourg. For the tiny Luxembourg, 1 million is crazy. And now, more or less 30 years ago, another inventory was made. There were only 500,000 trees left. (original in German)

The example of the rise and fall of Luxembourg’s traditional orchards showcases the impacts of social development on natural landscapes and everyday human-nature connections. At the same time, the current revival and maintenance efforts for Bongerten at the government and local community levels reflect a transformation in people’s relationship with and perception of nature. This shift moves from a material connection rooted in livelihood to a recognition of Bongerten’s ecological significance as semi-natural ecosystems and cultural value. According to the communication campaign for Luxembourg’s Natura 20004 sites by the Ministry for the Environment, Climate and Sustainable Development, local administrations and communities have been actively engaged in the restoration and maintenance of traditional high-stem orchards (Chronicle.lu, 2022). As evidenced by my analysis of ethnographic data collected from such orchards, ordinary citizens in Luxembourg value Bongerten as meaningful sites to build experiential, cognitive and philosophical connections with nature.

The aforementioned cases of the Minette region and Bongerten illustrate how transformations of human-nature relationships and everyday interactions with nature are deeply embedded in Luxembourg’s development, history, and culture, particularly within the context of industrialisation and urbanisation. Therefore, Luxembourg represents a meaningful research context for examining human-nature relationships.

The specific place in Luxembourg I selected for exploring human-nature connections is the environmental NGO LetzEarth (pseudonym). In the following section, I will elaborate on why LetzEarth represents a rich and meaningful research site for this inquiry.

LetzEarth as the Research Setting

To conduct the ethnographic fieldwork, I selected one of Luxembourg’s most prominent environmental NGOs, LetzEarth, as the research site. With a history spanning more than 100 years, LetzEarth’s developmental trajectory illustrates the evolution of social perceptions of nature and human-nature relationships, which is reflected in the changes to the NGO’s mission and name. Before introducing further details about LetzEarth that are relevant to contextualise this research, it is necessary to include a note on how these relevant details will be presented with careful considerations of research ethics. Luxembourg is a small country with a limited number of large environmental organisations, among which LetzEarth is one of the most active. Its history, mission, activities and operational mechanisms are widely known among residents, which creates an inescapable challenge when describing its characteristics. As a publicly available document, this work is subject to readers’ assumptions about the site under research, its components, and even specific members (Badder, 2021). While the changes in LetzEarth’s name and mission are meaningful for providing a contextualised understanding of its significance as a research setting for studying human-nature connections, discussing its historical names and missions would highly likely lead to the identification of the organisation, rendering the use of a pseudonym ineffective. To address this dilemma, I adopted a compromise approach: I do not reference the NGO’s historical names in the text but present the changes in its mission and core activities. This decision was guided by the intention to minimise the risk of external identification of the research setting and participants, while preserving as much relevant contextual detail as possible. Achieving this balance requires careful ethical consideration and actions. I emphasised to both the gatekeeper and participants that, despite my efforts to safeguard their anonymity, it may still be possible for readers to identify them due to the specific context and niche focus of this research. All stakeholders confirmed their understanding and provided consent in both verbal and written forms. Following data analysis and formulation of the key arguments of this research, I re-evaluated the potential risks and negative consequences that my findings might pose to the NGO and the participants. As the findings primarily highlight how volunteers at LetzEarth construct and perceive reciprocal relationships with nature, I assessed the negative impact on the organisation and participants to be relatively low. Therefore, I consider it ethically appropriate to discuss the development of LetzEarth’s mission while omitting exact time points as part of the justification for selecting the research setting and for contextualising this ethnographic study.

At the time of LetzEarth’s founding more than a hundred years ago, the founders of its predecessor envisioned the mission of the forerunning association as the general protection of animals and natural habitats. However, just eight months after the association was established, the board decided to significantly narrow its focus to the protection of the “useful” birds in Luxembourg. While the exact reasons behind the focus on birds are difficult to determine due to limited documentation, the emphasis on “useful” is particularly noteworthy. It suggests a prevailing anthropocentric view of nature at the time: that its primary value was seen as serving human interests, and only species deemed to have instrumental value were considered worthy of protection. Over the following three decades, the predecessor of LetzEarth focused on the conservation of “useful birds” as its core mission. In the 1930s, the association was recognised as a non-profit organisation.

It was not until the 1950s that this mission expanded to include the protection and study of all bird species. The organisation’s main activities included, therefore, installation and maintenance of nest boxes, winter bird feeding, and birdwatching and monitoring for both leisure and research purposes. To this day, maintaining nest boxes and monitoring migratory birds remain major activities of LetzEarth’s various local sections. The expansion of its mission from protecting “useful” birds to general bird conservation and ornithological research reflected a move away from an anthropocentric approach to conservation.

The 1980s marked a critical period for the development of environmentalism. High-profile grassroots and community-based offshoots of the environmental movements began to emerge, and by the end of the decade, environmentalism had become both a global and national political force (Haq & Paul, 2011; Elliott, 2025). This era also witnessed a series of environmental crises, including the 1986 Chornobyl nuclear disaster, which intensified opposition to nuclear energy across Europe (Haq & Paul, 2011). Environmental issues gained unprecedented attention among the wider public. Against such a backdrop, the predecessor of LetzEarth experienced rapid growth, with its membership increasing nearly fivefold during the 1980s. Meanwhile, a narrow focus on ornithology was no longer sufficient to respond to the growing calls for action on environmental crises. In response, the board of LetzEarth’s forerunning organisation declared:

It is not enough anymore to protect a single species through legislation without preserving the ecological environment at the same time. Successful and meaningful nature conservation in the long term requires preserving (and if possible, creating) the basic living conditions for animals and plants. Thus, our scope of activities and missions has expanded. (original in German)

Accordingly, the organisation’s mission evolved to encompass broader conservation approaches beyond bird protection. This included, but was not limited to, biotope networking, species diversity preservation, agricultural sustainability, land consolidation and landscape conservation. This significant expansion marked a departure from a decontextualised, human- preference-driven perception of nature and signalled a shift toward advocating an ecological perspective that emphasises interdependence and human responsibility for environmental stewardship.

The organisation LetzEarth took on its current form and public presence in the early 2010s. Following the merger with two other environmental NGOs, the forerunning organisation evolved into today’s LetzEarth, which now covers a broader range of conservation activities. These include bird monitoring, environmental awareness-raising, political advocacy, advice services, nature education, and scientific research. The functioning of the organisation largely depends on the volunteers who participate in the activities organised by its local sections across the country. One section of LetzEarth that stands out from the region-based local sections is the “Language” section. This section was created in the early 2010s to engage nature enthusiasts whose primary language is not one of Luxembourg’s official languages – Luxembourgish, French or German. Given Luxembourg’s multilingual context and the steady demographic input from immigration, which has further enriched its linguistic diversity (Sharma, 2018), individuals from diverse migratory and linguistic backgrounds may face additional challenges in participating in local, community-based environmental activities. The establishment of the Language section represents LetzEarth’s endeavour in promoting connection between people and nature in an era of globalisation and debordering.

LetzEarth’s developmental trajectory, along with its current environmental mission and activities, make it an ideal site to research human-nature connections. As the overview above illustrates, its mission and practices closely interact with how nature and relationships with nature are conceptualised, as well as how engagement with nature is preferred and experienced. Therefore, LetzEarth offers a valuable lens through which to explore environmental values and practices, ranging from anthropocentric to relational approaches to conservation. With its current reliance on volunteer-driven environmental activities that emphasise community and inclusivity, it provides a rich empirical setting for studying how human-nature connections unfold in everyday contexts and are shaped by issues such as access to nature and nature activities, environmental concerns and relationality toward nature.

Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt as the Ethnographic Field

Among the various events and activities organised by LetzEarth, I selected the participatory conservation project series Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt as the site for my ethnographic fieldwork. Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt originated in the 1980s from the spontaneous grassroots efforts of members of LetzEarth’s predecessor organisation to preserve the diversity of natural landscapes and habitats. Today, LetzEarth’s local sections organise these activities annually from October to March across the country, with the aim of maintaining natural habitats to support the reproduction of flora and fauna in the upcoming spring. The activities involve hands-on conservation work and are open to the general public without any prerequisites. Projects take place in natural environments such as wetland reserves, meadow orchards, city parks, and urban or suburban forests. Volunteers participating in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt engage in a variety of tasks, including clearing undergrowth, monitoring birds, setting up and cleaning nest boxes, pruning and planting trees and harvesting ripe fruit.

This choice of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt as the ethnographic field was guided by the research focus. This study aims to explore how ordinary people connect with nature and perceive their relationships with it through everyday engagement. For this purpose, the hands-on and participatory nature of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt activities offers valuable access to people’s direct, routine practices and interactions with nature. These activities are open to the general public and require no prerequisites, specialised knowledge or equipment. The volunteers are ordinary citizens, most of whom have not received formal training in wilderness skills or academic education in biology or environmental studies. As such, Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt provides an accessible and grounded empirical setting for capturing how laypeople construct and perceive their connections with nature. It therefore serves as an ideal field site for this ethnographic research into everyday human-nature relationships.

After justifying the selection of the research setting and outlining its relevant characteristics, I now turn to elaborating on the process of collecting ethnographic data.

Participant Observation

Ethnographic methods, according to Atkinson and Hammersley (1998), rely substantially or partly on participant observation. Participant observation refers to the process by which the researcher participates in and observes the activities, events and interactions of participants within their natural contexts, in order to learn their explicit and tacit meaning-making process (Kawulich, 2005; DeWalt & DeWalt, 2010). Therefore, it constitutes a valuable tool for this study, which aims to explore how people conceive of their connections and relationships with nature.

To conduct participant observation, the researcher must “establish a place” within the natural setting of the participants, namely the field, to investigate, experience and represent the lives and processes experienced by participants on the ground (Emerson et al., 2001). During participant observation, ethnographers must navigate the vagaries of establishing such a place, remain open to empathetic immersion into participants’ daily lives and meaning systems, and address the ethical considerations embedded in these endeavours (ibid.). They must also “write, sketch and record […] to remember, document and reflect, […] describe, interpret and analyze” (DeLyser et al., 2010, Ethnography in Practice). In this section, I detail how I established my place in the field, sought empathetic immersion into participants’ lived experiences with nature, navigated ethical concerns, and generated a record from my field engagement.

Entering the Field

The first step in conducting fieldwork is to achieve access to the research site and participants. Like most ethnographers, my access to the field depended on gaining formal and informal permission from the gatekeepers (Agar, 1980, as cited in Simmons, 2007, p.12), the individuals who grant and smooth the researcher’s access to the participants (O’Reilly, 2009). Gaining access to LetzEarth and its volunteers was relatively straightforward for me. The volunteer coordinator at LetzEarth, Emma, had worked on a previous project with my supervisor. Emma quickly became an ideal gatekeeper: as the staff at the NGO, she had an insider’s insight into how the organization works with the volunteers to achieve its environmental goals; as the volunteer coordinator, she had a close connection with the volunteers and is trusted by them; as a former collaborator in a qualitative research project, Emma was open to ethnographic research methods, aware of the challenges that a researcher may encounter in the field and willing to help; and the good cooperation and mutual trust between her and my supervisor nurtured the rapport between Emma and me. Given these reasons, it was quite straightforward for me to approach Emma and gain access to the organisation from her.

After initial email exchanges and informal meetings at my university and her workplace, on 7th June 2022, Emma gave me an oral agreement to conduct fieldwork at LetzEarth. Upon receiving the approval of data collection from the Ethics Review Panel of the University of Luxembourg on 12th October 2022, I wrote Emma an email asking her to inform her colleagues and the volunteers about my research. Soon after receiving my email, Emma briefed the director of LetzEarth on my research. The director permitted me to present my research proposal in the plenary session on 28th February 2023. In addition, Emma sent the overview of my research to all staff at LetzEarth via email.

Emma’s support largely facilitated my access to the organisation as a researcher. I clearly noticed the acceptance of me through the friendly greetings I received from Emma’s colleagues at the LetzEarth events, such as “How’s your PhD going?”. As the gatekeeper, Emma was instrumental in facilitating my access to the research site. She also played a significant role in establishing contact between the volunteers and me. She informed me of which local sections have been active in recent years and would therefore likely be willing to participate in my research, and offered that I could cc her on emails sent to the committees of the local sections. Besides, she put me in touch with several veteran volunteers who have been active at LetzEarth for decades. Most of the volunteers I approached with Emma’s help consented to participate in my research almost without further question.

Fetterman (2010) underscores the vital role of gatekeepers in ethnographic research: “An introduction by a member is the ethnographer’s best ticket into the community. […] The trust the group places in the intermediary will approximate the trust it extends to the ethnographer at the beginning of the study” (p.36). Interpersonal trust, centred on Emma, was instrumental in facilitating my entry into the field. Her prior research collaboration with my supervisor enabled a swift development of rapport between us. Furthermore, Emma’s act of introducing me to the organisation prompted both her colleagues and the volunteers to extend their trust in her, as volunteer coordinator, to me. My experience of entering the field corroborates many fieldworkers’ expositions on the value of the relationship with gatekeepers to researchers’ access to the study site and participants (e.g. Broskevičová et al., 2024; McAreavey & Das, 2013; Roller & Lavrakas, 2015).

While gatekeepers play a crucial role in researchers’ entry into the field, researchers also rely on their personal skills and ethnographic sensibility to gain insight into the people and reality in the field before inevitably influencing the field with data collection techniques such as conducting audio or video recordings. Mannay and Morgan (2015) remind us of the importance of the “waiting field” as “an opportunity to explore the times where real lives carry on before they make room for the intrusion of the data production techniques” (p.178), and that “in times of waiting we often learn new things about our participants and ourselves” (p.172). At the beginning of my fieldwork, I took advantage of two waiting fields: one is Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt, which was later chosen as my main fieldwork site; and the other is Discussions publiques5 (pseudonym), the monthly casual get-together on environmental topics open to the public. For the period October 2022 to February 2023, I attended ten events from these two series. During this six-month “waiting fieldwork”, I did not participate in the activities as a doctoral researcher collecting data, but rather as an ordinary event participant while awaiting approval from the Ethics Review Panel of the University of Luxembourg to begin data collection. During this period, I informed people in personal conversations that I was a PhD student intending to collect research data in such activities, but had not started yet. I also mentioned that, if they were interested in participating in my research, I would contact them at the appropriate time.

The “waiting field” benefited my research in two ways: first, I had the opportunity to learn what was really going on in the field. I learnt what to expect from these activities, the interests of people on the ground and the appropriate ways to dress and behave. For example, in my fieldnotes, I recorded the following gap between my assumption and the reality of a session of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt:

The work is to clean the birdhouse provided by ville du Luxembourg. […] it’s different than I’ve imagined. I thought the volunteers would be physically engaged in the cleaning work. Actually, most of the time it’s [Jenny] who climbs onto the ladder, opens the birdhouse and clean out the old nest. The most communication between [Jenny] and us is not instruction about how to clean the nest, but the knowledge about the bird, eggs and the difference between the nest texture. We helped her hold the ladder, take the tool bag and the trolley, and hand her the tools. None of the volunteers climbed on the ladder, and only lady B cleaned one birdhouse after [Jenny] took it down from the tree. For me, it seems like a ‘lecture’ on site. […] (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 09.10.2022)

The second advantage of the waiting field is that it enabled me to establish rapport with the people in the field. I was able to approach volunteers who appeared engaged and receptive to my research and had the opportunity to introduce myself, my research, and the data collection methods I intended to use. When I later invited them to participate in the interviews and asked if I could videotape their activities, almost everyone I knew from the “waiting field” readily agreed to my request. In addition, there is a “snowball effect” in the process of participant recruitment. Several initial participants offered to introduce me to their colleagues at LetzEarth who might also be interested in my research. Many subsequent participants also facilitated similar connections. Their kind support was indeed invaluable to me as a foreign researcher with a limited network. All in all, the 6 months spent on the “wait field” were well worth it.

In the Field

Once in the field, my fieldwork has two salient features. One is that the research sites are located in outdoor natural settings, and the other is that the fieldwork took place in scattered locations.

Let us consider the “outdoor” dimension first. Given my interest in exploring people’s connection with nature, my fieldwork mainly took place in the outdoor conservation activities in the city park, orchard, wetland and forest. Compared to the ethnographic studies conducted in social system settings such as classrooms, workplaces, healthcare and families, research in the natural environment requires additional ethnographic attention to the non-human elements such as grass, trees, puddles of water and mud, etc. I had to ask myself: What type of landscapes are formed by these natural elements together with the environments in which they are situated? What kind of feelings and emotions can these landscapes evoke? Wild? Comforting? Tough?

Reading back through my first fieldnotes and watching back the very first videos I recorded, I realised it took me quite a while to gain the insights mentioned above. I had placed a strong emphasis on people when conducting observations and recordings. I was focusing almost entirely on what the participants were saying and doing, thus ignoring the environment and non-human elements. As the fieldwork progressed, nature came to the forefront of my research. I realised that it was as essential to learn about nature as it is to learn about people, to understand how people connect to their natural environment. Therefore, in the following fieldwork period, I also paid attention to documenting the landscape. For example, during my fieldwork at the wetland reserve Reed Marsh in February 2024, I photographed different landscapes in the wetland (Figures 1 and 2).

Figure 1: Puddles formed after rain.
Figure 1: Puddles formed after rain.
Figure 2: Bird netting among the reeds.
Figure 2: Bird netting among the reeds.

Some authors like Kiik (2018) question the lack of attention to nature – plants, animals, and non-human worlds –in most ethnographies of conservation practice and argue for wilding the ethnography of conservation. He suggests three paths toward more writing of nature’s value and agency into research: first, a deeper engagement with the global ecological crises and the environmentalist valuing of nature; second, more applications of multi-species ethnography; and third, a greater inclusion of natural-scientific research results. While for this project, I generally agree with Kiik’s idea that a wilder ethnography of conservation that values the agency of nature can help us refrain from ontological over-flattening, namely diminishing the heterogeneity of the roles that human and non-human actors play in conservation issues and that it is important to include nature in ethnographic research in nature conservation settings, I nevertheless did not conduct a multispecies ethnography because of my focus on the expenences of humans in my field; whereas the multispecies ethnography method foregrounds creatures that traditionally appear on the margins of anthropology (Kirksey & Helmreich, 2010) and is marked by its attentiveness to nonhuman agency (Ogden et al., 2013).

The second notable feature of my fieldwork is that it took place in a field that was not unified, but across a variety of scattered settings. This was due to the specificity of the organisational mechanisms of the volunteer groups of LetzEarth. As mentioned before, the volunta1y conservation project Aktioun fir d'Emwelt is organised independently by 21 local sections across Luxembourg. Due to the seasonal timeliness of the maintenance of natural landscapes, the local sections are mainly active from October to March. The frequency of the work depends on various factors such as the need for maintenance of the local landscape, weather conditions and the availability of volunteers. For example, Michael from the local section City informed me of the cancellation of a session of Aktioun fir d'Emwelt due to sapling sho1tages and delayed apple ripening (Figure 3); and a planned activity to maintain the local wetland landscape by the section Nord had to be cancelled because of flooding (Figure 46).

Figure 3: Message from Michael.
Figure 3: Message from Michael.
Figure 4: Cancellation of the activity.
Figure 4: Cancellation of the activity.

Therefore, if I had focused on one local section for fieldwork, I would likely have risked a lack of data. Another factor that led me to the decision to conduct fieldwork at multiple sites was the consideration of the diversity of the natural landscapes in various regions of Luxembourg and the resulting diversity in the work of different local sections. For example, Luxembourg City and its surroundings are characterised by a high degree of urbanisation; therefore, the local group City is active mainly in the maintenance of bird nesting boxes in city parks and forest parks, as well as in the work within the orchards. As for the local section, Reed Marsh, active in the eastern part of Luxembourg, its volunteers are dedicated to preserving the biodiversity in the local wetland habitats through bird monitoring and organising excursions to raise public awareness on the conservation of wetlands. Therefore, conducting fieldwork at different local sections of LetzEarth allowed me to explore diverse human-nature connections within various settings and landscapes.

As described in the previous section, I employed two strategies to approach local groups with a relatively high frequency of activities: seeking help from the gatekeeper and establishing personal connections in the waiting field. The gatekeeper forwarded me the email addresses of the active local groups that she thought might be interested in my research. Eventually, the committee of the section Nord responded positively to my invitation to participate in research. From October 2022 to March 2023, I volunteered with the local sections City and Reed Marsh, participating in conservation work and getting to know the contact persons of both sections. Later, Michael from City and Tom from Reed Marsh agreed to my request to conduct research at their local sections and introduced me to their colleagues. Hence, my fieldwork at LetzEarth took place at its three local sections: Nord, City and Reed Marsh.

At first, it seemed that my fieldwork in scattered sites could be labelled as multi-sited ethnography. However, after consulting the literature on multi-sited ethnography, I decided not to use the term to refer to my ethnographic fieldwork, but stick to the phrase “fieldwork in scattered settings”. This decision was made based on consideration of the scope and purpose of my research. Multi-sited ethnography emerged against the backdrop of globalisation and the resulting increasing mobilities and complex interconnections. As a result, “[m]ulti-sited ethnographic research is therefore mobile. The approach pursues links, relationships and connections, follows unpredictable trajectories, and traces cultural formations in its pursuit of explanations beyond borders” (O’Reilly, 2009, Mobile and Multi-Sited Ethnography).

As such, ethnography moves from its traditional single-site location to “multiple sites of observation and participation that cross-cut dichotomies such as the ‘local’ and the ‘global’, the ‘lifeworld’ and the ‘system’” (Marcus, 1995, p.95). Namely, compared to the conventional single-sited ethnographic research, multi-sited ethnography tends to “broaden ethnography beyond the local” (O’Reilly, 2009, p.146) and to trace the flow of people, objects, discourse, stories, life and conflicts (see Marcus, 1995) in geographically dispersed settings, often crossing national and cultural boundaries

In contrast, the scope of my ethno-case study is a “local” community, namely the volunteers of LetzEarth. Although my fieldwork took place in scattered places in the different regions of Luxembourg, the contexts remained essentially the same: the organisation of LetzEarth. In that sense, the fieldwork did not strictly constitute a multi-site ethnographic study, as I understand “multi-site” to mean not only “different locations”, but also alluding to diverse organisational or cultural contexts.

Despite my decision not to use the term, my fieldwork in scattered sites shares some challenges faced by multi-site ethnographers. First and foremost was the logistical complexity concerning travelling. In my case, the sites of my fieldwork varied from week to week, not only because the activities of the three local sections were interspersed in the programme of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt, but also because the venues for activities of the same local section could also vary according to the location of the natural landscapes to be maintained. As a researcher in a foreign country without a driver’s licence, I found it particularly challenging to locate the right place, which is often situated in non-residential areas surrounded by nature and not directly accessible by public transport. I recorded my frustration in the notes taken on 15th of October 2022:

[Finding the spot] was quite an adventure. It took me about 45 minutes to find the place. […] It’s my first time in [town] and I have a very poor sense of direction. So I asked a bus driver how I can find [road] and if he knows there is a football field along the road. […]Luckily, the second lady knows what I’m talking about, “you want to collect apples right?” She took me out of the hall and pointed the way up the hill: go this way and you will find them. (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 15.10.2022)

Second, compared to the fieldwork in a single location, conducting fieldwork in multiple sites requires the researcher to learn about and adapt to the new settings quickly. Therefore, apart from finding the place, another challenge I encountered during fieldwork in the forests, wetlands and orchards was having to quickly learn the appropriate ways to dress and work in different settings. While hiking shoes were perfect for navigating the rugged orchard meadows, rubber boots were indispensable for work in the wetland. Although gathering apples and cleaning bird nesting boxes were not physically demanding, tasks like trimming blackthorns and clearing knee-high weeds required a certain level of physical strength and skill. Upon entering the field in October 2022, I had to learn about various conservation projects and practical skills from different local sections. However, the knowledge I gained over one week may not be applicable in the following week.

Fortunately, these challenges were gradually resolved as my fieldwork progressed. During the second round of fieldwork for Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt 2023, I was able to locate the natural landscapes where local sections carried out conservation work without getting lost. Besides, as my relationship with the participants deepened in the fieldwork, some participants kindly offered to give me a lift to the site, which significantly reduced the pressure of travelling. As for the clothing and techniques needed for the field, I had learnt how to use tools such as pitchforks during the previous year’s fieldwork, and how to dress correctly to protect myself from dew and mud.

Similar to the main criticism faced by multi-sited ethnography, a concern that may be raised about my fieldwork in scattered settings is the perceived insufficient depth of engagement with each context. How can you learn each setting in depth if you have to engage in a new setting every week? My answer to this question is that, indeed, compared to a single-sited field study of the same duration as my fieldwork, the depth of immersion in my research contexts must not be as deep as in the former. However, as argued before, conducting fieldwork in diverse settings enables me to capture the diversity and multiple facets of the issue I study. In addition, to compensate for the limited engagement time in each setting, I conducted two rounds of fieldwork at Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt in autumn-winter 2022/23 and 2023/24. With the expectations and experiences gained from the first year, I was able to engage in more depth in the fieldwork through more proficient participation in activities and a better ability to identify the focal points for my observation and video recording.

My third response to this potential critique of the scatteredness of my fieldwork is grounded in the object of my inquiry. This research does not aim to describe the characteristics of the NGO LetzEarth, nor to uncover the peculiarities of the people involved as a specific group or community. Instead, the focus is on the relationship between participants and nature. Therefore, instead of solely pursuing a longitudinal engagement with a particular group or setting, I aimed to explore and trace the unfolding of various relationships. In this sense, my approach aligns with the methodological framework of relational ethnography proposed by Desmond (2014). Specifically, my data collection does not centre on places (such as a specific NGO, its local sections or a certain natural environment) or processed people (such as LetzEarth volunteers as a community), but the field as a set of people-nature connections that mutually shape individuals’ actions in nature, and the processes of these relationships. Thus, collecting data in scattered settings supported my research aim by enabling me to capture and reveal the diversity and nuances of human-nature relationships, rather than undermining my meaningful immersion in the field.

Having elaborated on the approaches that I employed to conduct the ethnographic fieldwork for this research, I now delve into the specific methods that I used to collect data. As I intended to analyse participants’ perspectives on their connections to nature, I need methods that could precisely capture their words and actions. Taking fieldnotes became insufficient to achieve this goal, as I was not able to accurately write down in real-time what the participants were saying and doing in the field. Fieldnotes are also never an “objective” record of the field and will always reflect, to varying degrees, the researcher’s sentiments and interpretations of the field. Therefore, in order to document participants’ words and actions authentically and in real time, I conducted video recordings during the second round of fieldwork in 2023/24.

There was a noticeable shift in my primary data collection method from taking fieldnotes in the first round of fieldwork to videotaping in the second round. In 2022/23, I did not bring any recording devices to the field. As Parker-Jenkins (2018) warns, the use of cameras or video recorders can be problematic, especially concerning the potential intrusiveness for some communities if the research involves sensitive issues. Although, according to the feedback of the participants, my research was not perceived to touch on sensitive topics or invade personal privacy, I remained cautious about videotaping, considering the intrusiveness of video recorders. I decided to ask permission for video recording after building rapport with the participants. Having become acquainted with some volunteers in the first round of fieldwork, I reached out to them again before the Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt 2023/24 started to explain the necessity of video recording for my research and ask if they could help me negotiate the informed consent from their colleagues. I received straightforward consent from Maria, Tom and Michael from the local sections Nord, Reed Marsh and City, respectively.

The influence of videography on the participants has long been a key issue of discussion among ethnographers. While some researchers are concerned about the imperial gaze of the camera and the performative behaviour of participants before the camera, and even had to terminate the project due to these considerations (Gregory, 2020), others have concluded that “the presence of the camera had negligible impact on the course of the conversation” (Iino, 1998, p.11). Having viewed my video data, I believe both sides have valid arguments. The extent of the camera’s impact on the field is ultimately dependent on the nature of the research and how sensitive the topic is. In my fieldwork, I noticed that the specific condition of the field also influences participants’ awareness of the camera: the number of people present, the type of conservation work and the location of the camera. For example, during my fieldwork on 30th September 2023 in a regional orchard managed by the local section City, Jenny, Jules and I were present. That day’s work was relatively easy, including collecting ripe apples, planting fruit seedlings and cleaning nest boxes. While doing this not-too-physically-demanding work, Jenny, Jules and I talked to each other quite often. The filming on that day felt as if I were shooting a science documentary: when Jenny and Jules spoke to me, they would often switch from Luxembourgish to English or German, and explain the varieties of fruit trees and animals that inhabit the nest boxes with instructive language and gestures such as “Schau der Name! (Look at the name!)” and pointing to the labels of the seedling. They often talk straight to the camera, as Figure 5 shows.

Figure 5: Jenny introducing the fig tree seedling.
Figure 5: Jenny introducing the fig tree seedling.

Apparently, Jenny and Jules were fully aware of the camera. Nevertheless, the presence of the camera did not seem to bother them, as their work methods and processes did not show much difference from last year, when I did not bring a camcorder. And I did not worry about the “performative behaviour”. In my previous field experience, which did not include video recording, I have noticed that sharing knowledge about nature was an important behavioural pattern in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt. For example, my fieldnote on 15th October 2022 records how people exchanged knowledge about mushrooms and addressed me in English:

A staff at [LetzEarth]was introducing two mushrooms to some volunteers in Luxembourgish. […] [A volunteer] then explained to me in English that the mushroom on the left is one of the most poisonous mushrooms in Luxembourg, and the [LetzEarth] staff was explaining how to distinguish it from the benign mushroom. […] Then the [LetzEarth] staff continued in English to introduce the characteristic of this dangerous fungus. An audience (I guess he works for the Commune) also explained to me in English that this mushroom can lead to kidney failure with chronic poison, and even there is antidote nowadays, still victims will suffer from permanent damage to the organs. (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 15.10.2022)

Therefore, I believe that even if I were not holding a camera, Jenny and Jules would have explained the information to me in English just as well.

In contrast to Jenny and Jules, Neo did not seem to notice the camera too much, although I explicitly asked him if I could start filming and received an affirmative answer from him. Neo’s task was to trim the branches of two big trees so that he could have enough space to securely place the nest boxes for owls (see Figures 6 and 7).

Figure 6: Neo trimming the tree.
Figure 6: Neo trimming the tree.
Figure 7: Neo putting the nesting box onto the tree.
Figure 7: Neo putting the nesting box onto the tree.

From his panting captured by the collar microphone, I recognised that Neo’s work was not relaxing. Being high up on the ladder, he had to stay focused. Besides, I was videotaping him beneath the tree from the direction where his back was turned. Therefore, the presence of the camera seemed relatively inconspicuous for Neo. Unlike Jenny and Jules, Neo barely spoke to me and only had some brief conversations with his colleague about passing tools and confirming the position of the nest boxes.

Besides the impact of videotaping on the field, another question that I always had to consider is: who am I going to film? More specifically, should I focus on one person or follow the actions of several people? Who should wear the only collar microphone, or should this microphone be worn at all? I had to constantly negotiate these questions according to the specific situation in each fieldwork.

One challenge of conducting fieldwork in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt was that I was not able to anticipate who would be present except for the research participants with whom I had negotiated in advance, because participation in this conservation project series was open to both pre-registered and unregistered individuals (although technically, pre-registration is required). In order to strike a balance between ensuring that all attendees’ right to be informed about my recording and not deterring people by terms such as “research” and “videography”, I left it up to the contact persons of the local sections to decide whether or not to inform potential volunteers of my research in advance. The contact persons of Nord, City and Reed Marsh all thought it would be fine if I asked for consent on the spot. Hence, at the beginning of each event, I explicitly announced the goal of my research and my intention to conduct a video recording. I made it clear that if anyone did not consent to be videotaped at any point, I would immediately refrain from recording the person. On one occasion, a group of high school students led by their teacher took part in the conservation activity organised by the section Nord. I explained my project to the teacher, making it clear that I would not film the juveniles.

Another challenge was to determine the focus of videotaping. Because people were dispersed while working in the natural landscapes, it was impossible to capture the entire group or the discourses of everyone. In some cases, there were even several different activities going on in parallel. For example, during the sessions of Reed Marsh in February 2024, there were two groups of volunteers who were responsible for pruning thorns and ringing birds, respectively. Therefore, I often had to make a choice. Most of the time, I shadowed the participants who were already engaged in my research before the videotaping took place, either through the pilot fieldwork or interviews. Sometimes, I asked these participants for their suggestions: what do they think I should record? Maria from Nord, who is in her 70s, told me that I should film “the younger guy”. I soon realised that only the young man of about thirty could lift the pole high enough to hang a nest box on the tree branch. To conclude, I consider two factors when making decisions: one is the rapport with the participants, and the other is the potential effectiveness of the data to answer the research questions.

The last issue I want to address concerns the audio and video recording, which was key to constructing the data through which I could analyse how participants articulated their connection to nature during fieldwork. In order to collect usable data, I used a collar microphone. The collar microphone is a device that enables the camcorder to capture the participant’s talking clearly, minimising the effects of background noise. Moreover, the microphone can capture detailed sounds that can potentially contextualise data analysis. As mentioned before, I was able to notice Neo’s hard work through his panting recorded by the collar mic. However, I also discovered the limitations of the collar microphone. Since my camcorder has only one microphone jack, only one participant could wear the collar microphone. This could significantly reduce the flexibility of videotaping, on the one hand, due to the limitation of the connecting cable; on the other hand, while the microphone ensures the clarity of the wearer’s speech, it reduces the ability of the camcorder to record other people’s speech, especially from a distance. Reviewing the recordings from the first videotaped fieldwork, I found that the words of the interlocutors of the person wearing the microphone were very poorly recorded. In the next phase of fieldwork that took place in a quiet forest, I took the plunge and did not use a microphone. To my delight, the conversations and discussions were recorded clearly. After this experiment, I always decided whether or not to use a microphone depending on the situation. If there was much background noise in the field, such as the noise of the wind, saws or planes (the local section Reed Marsh is located near Luxembourg Findel airport), I would ask one participant to wear the collar microphone. If the work took place in relatively quiet forests or small orchards, I would not use the microphone.

Leaving the Field

My fieldwork drew to a close at the end of February 2024. Since October 2022, I have participated in 22 events organised by LetzEarth, including the participatory conservation project series Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt, the monthly casual get-together Discussions publiques, information sessions for volunteers and Nature Film Night. I also had 12 interviews with 10 individuals who either work or volunteer at LetzEarth and its local sections. In this process, I received kind support from the research participants, and I have noticed a change in myself from being confused and timid, to enjoying the conservation work while conducting fieldwork. As such, wrapping up the data collection and leaving the field were not as easy as I had anticipated.

Compared to getting in the field, namely accessing a research population or site, the issue of getting out, or leaving the field, has received less attention (Iversen, 2009). Yet, as Smith and Atkinson (2017) poetically write: “Being personally contoured by a physical culture under study can enchant a researcher as new physical experiences occur, meaningful social bonds are forged, affective curiosities are explored, and one’s analytic imagination is unleashed” (p.636).

Because the researchers’ experiences in the field are not only instrumental for their studies, but also have a profound influence on the researchers themselves and can potentially impact the field, we should reflect on the meaning of leaving the field. I believe that leaving the field marks the end of data collection, but does not necessarily mean the end of the researcher’s physical presence in the field; it is certainly not the end of the researcher’s relationships with the gatekeepers and research participants, nor the conclusion of the mutual influence between the field and the researcher.

In one of my last fieldwork in February 2024, the volunteers of Reed Marsh invited me to join them for lunch after a whole morning of trimming blackthorns in a barren orchard. During the lunch, they discussed the plans for next year’s Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt and agreed that it would be necessary to continue reclaiming this overgrown orchard next year. Having set the plan, Laura and Neo turned to me with smiles:

  • “Are you in next year?”
  • “Oh yes, I’ll be there, I’ll be in Luxembourg until at least the end of next year.”
  • “Perfect!”

Given the time constraint of the doctoral study, it would be unlikely for me to continue collecting data in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt 2024/25. But I was glad that Laura and Neo asked me, and my answer to their question was not a random empty promise. My relationship with the volunteers of Reed Marsh did not end with the conclusion of my fieldwork, but changed from researcher-researched to co-members of the local section as I received the membership card in February 2024. I hoped that my “staying” despite “leaving the field” could convey a message to these people who shared with me their stories, knowledge and enthusiasm, that their dedication was not only worthy of being researched in academia, but also deserved to be passed on to more individuals in the broader public.

Every research project will come to an end at some point, but the connections and relationships that we as researchers have forged in the field, which is at the heart of ethnographic research, often last beyond the framework of the project and continue to influence our research agenda or even personal development. I often think of the people from LetzEarth when I move an earthworm from the asphalt road to grassland, when I sort garbage and when I hike in the woods. This also echoes part of my research analysis and arguments that multifaceted connections to nature can be prompted and enhanced through social and emotional bonds.

I conclude this section by citing Smith and Atkinson (2017) again:

We encourage all ethnographers then to exit as gently, thoughtfully, and analytically as one enters the field. Through a more thoughtful and empathic research process, and by engaging more reflexive forms of leaving, researchers can heighten their analytic connection to the study and enhance the intellectual rigour of qualitative research. (p.648)

Interviewing as Part of an Ethnographic Approach

Besides fieldwork, ethnography also often involves close conversations with participants in the form of more or less formal interviews. Ethnographic interviewing has become a widely applied data collection method across various disciplinary and applied fields in social science (Heyl, 2001). Following the “interpretive turn” in social science at the end of the twentieth century (see Mottier, 2005), along with the growing critique of the positivist paradigm, qualitative researchers have increasingly emphasised the interpretation of participants’ accounts within their own context and lived experiences (Parker-Jenkins, 2018). Within the interpretive process, according to de Fina (2019), “special significance was given to language as a site for the construction of interpretations of cultural practices and to interaction as the domain where such interpretations are shared and negotiated” (p.157). Therefore, interviews where participants talk about their “experiences, attitudes, opinions, complaints, feelings and emotions and beliefs” (Cicourel, 1986, ix) became an essential tool to elicit language data and explore informants’ construal of their interactions in the field. As participants’ perceptions are at the heart of my current research on people’s connection to and understanding of nature, I utilised ethnographic interviews in combination with participant observation to gather data. In this section, I discuss three questions concerning interviewing within the frame of an ethnographic approach: How did my interviews and field observations nurture each other? What roles does the interviewer play in constructing the data? Why and how should interviewees be empowered in ethnographic interviews?

To address the first question, “How did my interviews and observations nurture each other?”, another question comes first: What is an “ethnographic” interview? From a historical perspective, in anthropology, which is widely regarded as the disciplinary origin of ethnography, interviewing has been used as a complement to other ethnographic techniques such as participant observation and collection of documents or artefacts to grasp the emic perspective of participants (de Fina, 2019). Later, researchers from other disciplines, such as sociology, consolidated the position of interviews in ethnographic research. Hammersley (2006) defines ethnographic methods as “[…] fairly lengthy contact, through participant observation in relevant settings, and/or through relatively open-ended interviews designed to understand people’s perspectives, perhaps complemented by the study of various sorts of document[s] – official, publicly available, or personal” (p.4).

However, Hammersley also raises the debate on the extent to which ethnographic research should rely on interviews to collect data. Scholars from the fields of sociolinguistics, discourse analysis and narrative research encounter criticism over the generalised use of interviews in an increasing amount of “self-labelled” ethnographic studies (Hammersley, 2006; de Fina, 2019). Critics argue that ethnographic data collection and analysis should rely primarily on direct observation of participant behaviour, rather than on eliciting participants’ perspectives through interviews (de Fina, 2019). Proponents of interviewing as a primary method, conversely, argue that interviewing is an effective means for realising the ethnographic principle of capturing participant perspectives and giving voice to the researched (Hammersley, 2006).

Considering this methodological debate and reflecting on my own data collection process, I understand “ethnographic interviews” as interviews with a strong interconnection with participant observation. An interview is “ethnographic” when the interview schedule is developed based on the researcher’s observations and interactions with participants during fieldwork, and the information gathered from the interview can enhance the researcher’s understanding of the field and inform or redirect the focus of the researcher’s observation in the field. Byrne (2004) and Rapley (2001) elaborate on the epistemological status of interviews as either a resource or a topic. In a realist approach, interviews are treated as a tool to access participants’ reality, which is seen as existing independently of the language used to describe it. In contrast, an idealist perspective views interviews as social events in their own right, providing one possible version of the social reality. I believe that ethnographic interviewing treats interview data as a topic. The collection and analysis of ethnographic interview data can be combined with other ethnographic data sources, such as participant observation, in order to enquire into the multiple facets of the researched issue constructed by research participants and the researcher.

As mentioned before, Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt takes place annually from October to March. The persistent cloudy or rainy weather of the season makes this time of the year in Luxembourg not as cheerful as the spring or summer time for many people. Continuous precipitation also leads to standing water or mud in the natural landscapes where the activities take place, which greatly limits the volunteers’ work. Therefore, I wondered why this conservation project series begins in late autumn rather than in spring. Wouldn’t nature be more attractive in spring or summer, and more people would join the activities then? I asked Emma this question in the second interview. Emma explained that this is because the primary goal of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt is to benefit fauna and flora rather than entertain people. If the maintenance work were to take place in spring when animals begin to breed, the activities would actually be disturbing to the local ecology. This piece of interview data revealed to me the significance of the concept of biocentric environmentalism in my field. Through the interview, I gained a new perspective to analyse the data I had collected from my prior observations, but also a new focus for the coming ones, namely asking: why do people actively connect with nature even in challenging conditions?

Having applied interviewing as one of the data collection methods in my ethno-case study convinced me that data from ethnographic interviews and other ethnographic data complement each other. Rapley (2001) emphasises that in the interview-data-as-topic approach, the collected data are treated as (more or less) reflecting a reality jointly constructed by the interviewee and interviewer. This approach is in line with the “interpretive turn” of qualitative inquiry, “which rehabilitates subjectivity and views data collection as a mutual construction of meaning where the researcher is engaged in ‘double hermeneutics’” (Mottier, 2005, Abstract). Hence, the role of the interviewer in data construction is worth discussing.

Brinkmann and Kvale (2018) metaphorically liken the role of the interviewer in knowledge production to either a miner or a traveller. In a miner metaphor,

knowledge is understood as buried metal and the interviewer is a miner who unearths the valuable metal. The knowledge is waiting in the subject’s interior to be uncovered, uncontaminated by the miner. The interviewer digs nuggets of knowledge out of a subject’s pure experiences, unpolluted by any leading questions. The nuggets may be conceived as objective real data or as subjective authentic meanings. (p.19–20)

In contrast, the traveller metaphor understands the interviewer

as a traveller on a journey to a distant country that leads to a tale to be told upon returning home. […] The interviewer-traveller, in line with the original Latin meaning of conversation as ‘wandering together with’, walks along with the local inhabitants, asks questions and encourages them to tell their own stories of their lived world. The potentialities of meanings in the original stories are differentiated and unfolded through the traveller’s interpretations in the narratives he or she brings back to home audiences. (p.20)

The miner/traveller metaphor beautifully elaborates different views on researcher subjectivity and reflexivity in interviews. For a miner-interviewer, interviewing is exploited as an instrument to explore a reality that exists out there and is independent of individuals’ subjective views and emotions, while a traveller-interviewer acknowledges interviews as a real communicative event shaped by the assumptions, experiences and values of both interviewee and interviewer. Setting out to explore the multifaceted question of how people with different experiences connect to and make sense of nature, I was certainly not a miner digging for the one-only gem. Curious about how people come to conservation engagement from different trajectories, I was a traveller who was also willing to share my own stories with the “local inhabitants” and fully aware that my stories, whether told or not, had profound influences on this journey. To illustrate how my interaction with the interviewee and my own background have shaped the interview data, I present here an excerpt from the interview with Bob:

Yimin: Yeah, that’s also what inspired me to work for my dissertation because for myself actually, how I started to get so interested in LetzEarth and the nature here in Luxembourg, basically, it’s because first of all, I want to finish my PhD. I entered this topic but now I’m keeping my research journal and now I’m realizing I’m really geni-, like really getting into interested in the nature itself. Sometimes I forget about my research and I’m like, yeah, with the nature itself, it’s so interesting and that’s why I'm actually very grateful for LetzEarth. So those people are...

Bob: It’s... You start off with one thing and it takes you to a certain point and then you sometimes have to decide, do I want to take this further? Do I not? I mean I started off with birds. Yeah, I mean my home background is a little industrial town in England. Yeah. I grew up in England and went to university in England and I knew nothing about nature until I met my wife. […] And then sometimes you go from nature conservation to general environmental protection and then sometimes you go from there to politics. And it’s up to you how far of this track you follow.

It is worth noting here that Bob’s account of how he started bird watching and then conservation volunteering was not elicited by a question. Although similar data could also be collected through an explicit question, I wonder if the same story would be told in a different way. If I had not shared my unforeseen encounter with the research topic, would Bob still recount his trajectory to his engagement as “following a track” with an unexpected start and many possible endpoints? As Mishler (1986) argues, in interviews, “both questions and responses are formulated in, developed through, and shaped by the discourse between interviews and respondents” (p.52), and therefore, a comprehensive understanding of interview data is based on recognizing the discourse negotiation of the interviewer and respondent in context of their mutual understanding as meanings unfold during the interview.

While the role of the interviewer should not be overlooked, the focus of ethnographic interviews is on the interviewees. Since the core of ethnographic research lies in understanding the meaning of actions and events from the perspective of those involved (Spradley, 1979/2016), respondents of ethnographic interviews should be given the opportunity to express themselves and to interpret their own experiences. Mishler (1986) suggests several ways “to empower respondents so that they have more control of the processes through which their words are given meaning” (p.118), including letting them decide the topics and timing of interviews and asking for their feedback on the research instrument or the transcripts obtained (see also de Fina, 2019). The essence of empowering interviewees is “to encourage them to find and speak in their own ‘voices’” and to elicit their own narrative accounts, because “one of the significant ways through which individuals make sense of and give meaning to their experiences is to organize them in a narrative form” (Mishler, 1986, p.118).

The interviews conducted for my project are semi-structured or unstructured. The two interviews with the volunteer coordinator Emma are semi-structured and led by interview schedules prepared in advance. These two semi-structured interviews were used to gather background information, including the aims and operational mechanisms of LetzEarth and its local sections. Upon Emma’s request, I sent her the first interview schedule via email in advance. During the second interview, I put the question guide on the table within her line of sight. The other interviews with the volunteers were unstructured, prompted by a few general topics depending on the conversation flow. These unstructured interviews aimed to gather the volunteers’ stories, opinions and feelings regarding their environmental engagement at LetzEarth.

Out of respect for the research participants, I invited them to decide the time, place and language of the interviews according to their personal preferences. I informed the participants in advance that the expected duration of an interview is around 60 to 90 minutes; however, the length of the interview was entirely up to them. Most of my interviews fell within this estimated length, but there were two exceptions: one interview lasted approximately 150 minutes, with Michael from the City section. After a 90-minute conversation before lunch, he said he was not tired and would like to share his stories as much as possible; therefore, we continued the interview for another hour after lunch. The other case was with Birgit and Maria from the section Nord. They expressed the preference to be interviewed together, which I accepted without hesitation. This interview did not proceed in the way where I posed a question, then Birgit and Maria answered respectively; instead, they led the conversation by reminding each other of their respective experiences, adding details to each other’s accounts and commenting on each other’s differing views. Naturally, this interview was longer than the ones with only one respondent. Hence, I always tried to reserve sufficient time for interviews. Normally, I would not schedule any other tasks on my agenda on the day of the interview. In terms of place, I asked the participants to choose the location that was most convenient for them. As a result, the interviews took place in my office, at a bar, at LetzEarth and at the local section Nord. As for the language, I offered English and German, a point I will further probe in the next section, Researching Multilingually.

To encourage volunteers to share their stories in their own voices, I employed several techniques during the unstructured interviews to avoid treating respondents as mere information sources or dehumanising them with irrelevant questions. To prepare for the interviews, I sought to learn about their professional engagements beyond environmental volunteering, their connection and trajectories to LetzEarth and their areas of interest in conservation, be it bird watching, nature writing or landscape maintenance. I looked for such information in my fieldnotes or through the publicised interviews that some of them did with the local media or the publications of LetzEarth. The interview questions and prompts were prepared to match their backgrounds. For example, I read in the annual report of LetzEarth that the senior volunteer Bob was awarded the Outstanding Contribution Award for his long-term dedication in the year prior to the interview. At the beginning of the interview with Bob, whom I had never met in the fieldwork before the interview, this information acted as a nice icebreaker, and Bob started to recall his decades of engagement in LetzEarth almost right after the interview began.

[0:00:14.8] Yimin: So first of all thank you so much for coming, to travel from [town] to Belval and it’s a pleasure to meet you of course. First of all, I want to congratulate you for the prize by the LetzEarth, because I was reading all the annual reports of LetzEarth, and then you got the Outstanding Contribution Award.

[0:00:39.2] Bob: Yeah, it's 100 year. It’s on a nice prime place at home.

[0:00:45.5] Yimin: Yeah, and I think that's lovely, like they are actually...

[0:00:46.7] Bob: I was very pleased, the only problem with getting it in Covid year, of course, was that was no public presentation because we had no public meetings. It was mainly for, I mean, it’s a kind of lifetime achievement award, but basically it was for what we did in [year]. Because I produced the English version of the Die Vogelfreunde des Großherzogtums.

At the beginning of each unstructured interview, I would explain that I had come to listen to their stories, and it was supposed to be more of a chat than a traditional question-and-answer interview. As I told Birgit and Maria before the interview:

[0:00:00.0] Yimin: Ja, danke sehr. Ich möchte zuerst einmal die vielen Dank für Ihnen sagen, also für Ihre Zeit und Ihre freundliche Unterstützung. […] bin ich hier gekomme und da interessiere mich für alle ihre Geschichte sozusagen mit LetzEarth. Ja, und eigentlich habe ich, ((lachen)) das ist meine kurze Liste von der Interviewfragen, aber es muss nicht so sein. Ich komme nur für Ihre Geschichte...

(Many Thanks. First of all, I would like to thank you very much for your time and your kind support. [...] I'm interested in all your stories with LetzEarth, so to speak. Yes, and actually I have, [laughing] that's my short list of interview questions, but it doesn't have to be like that. I just come for your stories...)

These strategies proved effective, as respondents began narrating their experiences of working at LetzEarth relatively quickly. I received positive feedback from several participants that they were happy to have such a chance to share their stories at LetzEarth, and were curious about my research findings based on their inputs.

After discussing the interview process, the next section delves into the issue of researching multilingually.

Researching Multilingually

Conducted within an NGO that has developed for over a hundred years in multilingual Luxembourg, this research inevitably encompasses the main languages of Luxembourg: Luxembourgish, German, French and English. Holmes and colleagues (2013) use the term researching multilingually to discuss the multilingual methodological dimensions of the studies that involve the use of more than one language in the research process and dissemination. Concerning the complexities of researching multilingually, here I focus on two issues that emerged in my research process: the researcher’s influence on the linguistic situation of the field, and multilingual data analysis.

My presence as a researcher began to have an impact on the field, including its linguistic situation, from the moment when I entered the field and met the participants. Finding a common language was always the first issue that the participants and I had to negotiate before the interviews or fieldwork. My Asian appearance often led the locals to assume that English is my most comfortable, or even the sole, language to communicate in. In fact, I am proficient in English and German, with an intermediate level of Luxembourgish and limited proficiency in French. To capture the authentic discourse of these Luxembourgish participants who predominantly communicate in Luxembourgish, German, and French in their daily lives, and to minimise the impact of translation, I applied different strategies to negotiate language for interviews and participant observation. Since an interview is a communication event where I as both the researcher and the respondents should be fully engaged, I proposed English and German, and asked the interviewees to speak Luxembourgish at a slower pace if they felt it was the language through which they could express certain topics most effectively. For the participant observation, in contrast, I asked the participants to speak whichever language they felt most comfortable speaking, without considering my presence. In each phase of the fieldwork, I had at least one “key participant” from whom I could ask for explanations in German or English. With the help of a camcorder, I could review the interactions by playing back the video in slow motion and then ask a student assistant proficient in Luxembourgish, German, and French to transcribe the conversations.

Although I tried to minimise my influence as a researcher on participants’ language choice, there were two interesting cases where the participants with relatively limited proficiency in English still spoke English with me. One case was mentioned in the previous section, In the Field, that Jenny and Jules from the section City often switched from Luxembourgish, which they used in their conversations with each other, to English when speaking to me, who was holding a camera. Through our previous contacts, as well as their pauses and occasional inaccurate phrasing when speaking English, I noticed that English might not be their most comfortable language. Therefore, I responded to them in a mixture of English and German. As the fieldwork proceeded, they gradually spoke only German with me.

Another case was the interview with the 70-year-old Luxembourger, Michael. Michael insisted that the interview could be conducted in English because he wanted to practice his English skills. Based on my years of living experience in Luxembourg, I assumed the older generation would prefer German. Thinking that Michael might be adjusting to accommodate my language preference, I explained that I could manage to conduct the interview in German, and he could even speak Luxembourgish slowly if needed. However, Michael insisted on speaking English. The interview turned out to be bilingual in English and German. Sometimes, Michael would switch to German by himself, and sometimes I proposed that he might want to speak German when I noticed that he was struggling to find the correct phrases in English.

These two cases inspired me to reflect on my understanding of the “natural setting” of a multilingual research site. I simply assumed that it would be most “natural” if the Luxembourgish participants spoke Luxembourgish or German; however, I did not consider my own role as part of this “natural setting”. The moment when I started interacting with the participants, I began to shape the “natural setting” of the field as a researcher. The influence of my presence on their initial choice of English was much less visible than the impact I had on their subsequent switch back to German. The participants could perceive their language choice for English as “natural” given my presence as a foreign researcher and an international student. Perhaps Jenny and Jules were indeed influenced by the presence of the camera; perhaps Michael just wanted to grasp every chance to practice English; or perhaps, all of them still subconsciously believed that a student from China would be most comfortable with English, and they were so kind that they would like to adapt to my language preference. Although my research does not intend to delve into these psychological factors, I argue that it is necessary to consider the researcher’s reflexivity while researching multilingually and recognise the subjective nature of what is considered “natural” in a multilingual context. The core of multilingual ethnographic research lies in giving participants voices and choices, also in terms of languages.

Another challenge that practitioners of multilingual research face is handling multilingual interviews specifically and engaging in multilingual data analysis (Holmes et al., 2013). Especially for my research where the collected data are often not in the first language of either the researcher or the participants, the multilingual data analysis merits further attention. I must consider the impact of translation on the accuracy of the discourses under examination, and that the respondents’ opinions were not distorted due to the use of a language other than their first language. An example is how I treated an excerpt from the interview with Michael. Michael lamented the decline of biodiversity and believes that there should be a call to reduce, or even ban, the use of pesticides and fertilisers:

The front part of the car, it was full of insects when we arrived. At every stop my father had to clean it. When we filled up the car, we always cleaned the windshield. […] And nowadays when you go such a long distance, there are rarely any insects anymore. […] You have a view over the decline, just going by car. Therefore we must incite [encourage]* people in their garden to avoid all, all chemistry and everything.

The word “incite” was amended to “encourage” here, because considering Michael’s English skills and the content of the whole interview, I judge this to be a vocabulary misuse. Michael could not have meant that the boycott of pesticides and fertilisers is something violent, illegal or unpleasant, and it should be achieved by stirring people’s emotions. Therefore, I made a correction note in the transcript.

This shows that researchers need a multilingual sensitivity when treating multilingual data, especially when the languages involved are not the ones that the researcher or participants are most proficient in. An exclusively verbatim focus on the transcripts may not always be the optimal approach for data analysis. In fact, at times, it can even result in a misinterpretation of the participant’s intentions. To avoid this, researchers should carefully examine the contexts while treating the data.

This discussion on language choice is related to another concept that ran through the entire process of ethnographic research: researcher positionality.

Negotiating Positionality

“For ethnographers, writing about how we are positioned is part of the data” (Chiseri-Strater, 1996, p.116), because ethnographic researchers are never external neutral observers but part of the research process, and their perceived identities shape the data collection process in a significant way (Lønsmann, 2016).

The concept of positionality has been discussed by various scholars not only in terms of the fixed or culturally ascribed attributes such as age, gender, race, class and nationality, but also regarding the subjective-contextual factors such as institutional affiliation, historical-personal circumstance and intellectual predisposition (Chiseri-Strater, 1996). However, as Lønsmann (2016) points out, previous studies on positionality tend to limit their focus on the “macro-level demographic categories” (Bucholtz & Hall, 2005), namely the relatively stable identities such as gender and nationality, but ignore the more dynamic identities or positions. In Bucholtz and Hall’s sociocultural linguistic identity framework, identities are produced in linguistic interaction, encompassing local, ethnographically emergent cultural positions (such as researcher, student and volunteer) and temporary interactional roles (such as story listener and knowledge learner) in addition to the macro-level sociological categories. Therefore, Lønsmann (2016) argues that when discussing researcher positionality, we should go beyond the macro-level demographic categories and acknowledge that researcher positions and identities are not stable, but dynamic, multifaceted and negotiated in the interactions with the informants. Consistent with Lønsmann’s arguments, here I discuss how I positioned myself or was positioned by the research participants during my fieldwork, and reflect on the relevance of these various positions to the data collection process.

Being a Young Person within an “Old” Organisation

Although sharing similarities in age and gender between researcher and participants is often thought to foster a more intimate tone (Lønsmann, 2016), I found that the generational age gap between my participants and me actually benefited our rapport. Among the twelve informants, nine are between 50 and 80 years old at the time of the study. In the early stage of my fieldwork, the volunteer coordinator Emma told me that one challenge faced by many local groups of LetzEarth was the ageing of the active members and the lack of youthful power, which she referred to as an “age gap”:

[…] but the thing is, that their members are ageing. Or are at a certain age, and the thing is it, then there’s not new people coming in and saying “Oh hey let’s go and let’s continue doing this”, then it kinda dies out.

As the fieldwork progressed, I found that the majority of the volunteers who regularly participated in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt at the local sections City and Nord were around 50 to 70 years old. There were relatively few volunteers in their twenties or thirties. Senior volunteers like Maria (71) and Birgit (60) are aware of the lack of younger volunteers:

Maria: […] Insgesamt haben wir keine Negativ. Sagen außer, eben junge Leute müsste man noch mehr haben.

Birgit: Das ist klar, das ist klar.

Maria: Schon jetzt, jetzt haben wir zwei, drei junge.

Birgit: Ja, zwei Jahre.

Maria: Hoffentlich bleiben die.

Birgit: Ja, aber so, ja, wie alt sind die? In den 20, im Anfang 30. Für uns ist das schon jung. [laughing] Noch jung. Aber man müsste wirklich 17-jährige, so jung müsste man bekommen, aber die haben kein Interesse dafür.

(Maria: […]Generally we don’t have anything negative. Except that we still have to have more young people.

Birgit: That’s true, that’s true.

Maria: Now we have two, three guys.

Birgit: Yeah, [for] two years.

Maria: Hopefully they’ll stay.

Birgit: Yeah, how old are they? In their twenties or early thirties. For us that’s already young. [laughing] Still young. But you really would need 17-year-olds, that young you would have to recruit, but they have no interest in it.)

As some types of maintenance work can be quite physically challenging, such as digging ponds, pruning thorns, and climbing tall trees to place nest boxes, the lack of younger helping hands could be a serious issue for local sections that wish to continue their conservation projects. The senior volunteers, such as Michael (70) and Bob (73) were pleased that a young woman in her twenties, like me, expressed her interest in their work and started to participate in the activities regularly. After my first participation in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt at City, where I assisted at their stand at Forest Ministry’s Open Day, Michael sent me a message (Figure 8):

Figure 8: Michael's message.
Figure 8: Michael's message.

During the interview, Bob jokingly mentioned that he might consider recruiting me:

[…] So we need new people in the [Language Section]. So maybe I need to recruit people like you, Yimin. [laughing]

As such, the age gap did not alienate the participants and me. In contrast, the generational difference brought me closer to these senior volunteers. The general lack of involvement from the younger generation in their activities made my presence in the field a positive thing for the participants. Interestingly, LetzEarth made a photo that Jules (63) and I planting seedlings together as the banner for Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt (Figure 9), which could be interpreted as a call for intergenerational transmission of and cooperation in conservation actions.

Figure 9: Banner for Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt.
Figure 9: Banner for Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt.

During the initial data analysis, I realised another reason that the senior volunteers welcomed me as a young researcher. When asked about the motivations of their environmental engagement, the participants frequently mentioned phrases like “the next generation” and “children”, which implies that their dedication to conservation is closely linked to a concern for the future generation. As Carmi and Arnon (2014) argue, environmental attitudes and behaviour have a future orientation, assuming responsibility for the future outcomes of present actions. For the senior volunteers, I represented the next generation whom they were preserving nature for. Thus, they were open to my presence in the field and to sharing their insights with me.

Student, Researcher or Volunteer? A Difficult Endeavour

The way in which I introduced myself to the participants was also a matter of self-positioning in the field. Should I present myself as a “doctoral researcher” or a “PhD student”? Having weighed the different perceptions that the two phrases would bring to the table, I chose to introduce myself as a “PhD student” instead of “doctoral researcher”, unless I had to write down my institutional affiliation and job title on the formal documents, such as the information sheet and consent forms. By positioning myself as a student rather than a researcher, I hoped to negotiate the power dynamic between the participants and me. Overemphasising my identity as a “researcher” in front of the volunteers from all walks of life would likely create an unnecessary distance between us. A researcher-researched relationship implies an asymmetric power dynamic where the informants could feel dehumanised as data under examination or being judged. This could lead to the reluctance to share their genuine opinions, experiences or complaints.

In contrast, as a “student”, I learn from people. I learnt the information about the organisation from the volunteer coordinator, and how to build connections to nature from the volunteers. Besides, compared to people with extensive knowledge and skills about nature who are adept at pruning trees and capable of distinguishing bird species from their songs, I am a pupil of natural knowledge. As my data analysis showed, the conservation projects were often discursively constructed as a setting for learning environmental knowledge and attitudes. Therefore, positioning myself as a student in the field not only helped me negotiate the researcher-participant power relationship, but also enabled me to integrate better into the field where learning is an important form of interaction.

Alongside negotiating the researcher/student identity, I also had to maintain a balance between my roles as a researcher and a volunteer. As discussed before, an ethnographic researcher cannot remain an external observer and is always part of the field. Yet, how do practitioners of participant observation position themselves in the field? Delamont (2004) asserts that the term “participant” observation does not usually mean real participation of the researcher, namely doing what research participants do, but rather watching the things being done and interacting with the informants while they do it. However, I found it hard to follow Delamont’s advice in my fieldwork. Given the participatory nature of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt and its emphasis on involving people in hands-on conservation work, being a passive participant like a bystander (Spradley, 1980) who watches without actively doing would appear quite awkward. As some tasks were physically demanding for the senior volunteers, my passive observation without active contribution would not help build rapport with them. In addition, as I initially entered the field as a volunteer rather than a researcher (see section Entering the Field), completely switching my position from a participant-volunteer to an observer-researcher would disturb my ongoing relationship negotiation with the participants. Therefore, I tried to participate in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt as a “volunteering researcher”. While explicitly explaining to the informants that my primary goal in participating in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt is to collect research data, I also actively engaged in physical work with the volunteers and learnt knowledge and skills from them. As it was not possible to take fieldnotes while engaged in the hands-on work, I had to memorise the interactions in the field that I deemed worth documenting. Later, I would take notes or audio-record myself on the way back from the fieldwork. In my later fieldwork assisted by a video camera, interestingly, I was able to engage in more passive participation by only filming the participants without conducting the conservation work, asit was obvious to others that my hands were already occupied. Nevertheless, I still had to negotiate between moderate participation and active participation (Spradley, 1980) by deciding when I should stop videotaping and lend a hand to other volunteers. For example, during the process of clearing weeds on a wetland at the section Nord with Maria, I started with only filming Maria’s work. Later, as I noticed that the task was quite exhausting, I put away the camera and grabbed a pitchfork to gather the weeds with her.

Negotiating multifaceted identities as both a volunteer and researcher was challenging, particularly when multitasking between collecting ethnographic data and engaging in physical work. However, this endeavour benefited my fieldwork in several ways. First, through working with the volunteers, I developed a closer relationship with them. The similar experiences and feelings from Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt often served as a good conversation starter. Second, my engagement in the field not only as a researcher but also as a volunteer helped me negotiate continuous access to the field. The senior volunteers from the Nord section agreed to my request for video recording during our first meeting, because they saw the photos of me working with other local sections and recognised me as “the girl on the poster”. Thirdly, through these hands-on efforts, I gained first-hand experience of what it's like to engage in environmental work. Reflecting on my own experiences, I also gained insights into the informants’ perspectives.

Negotiating the diverse, dynamic positions and identities at different levels, and navigating through their combinations and collisions, are the endeavours that all ethnographic researchers must undertake. Whether as a young volunteer who could help out, a university student who learnt about the human-nature connection or a researcher who conducted ethnographic fieldwork, I was constantly positioning myself and being positioned by the participants. As researchers can actively use positioning to negotiate access to the field and the relationship with informants, we must attend to the issue of honesty and manipulation (Lønsmann, 2016). As Lønsmann questions, would consciously positioning myself in one way or another be a way to manipulate the informants? My answer would be, as long as we ensure the transparency of “who we are and who we are not” (Lønsmann, 2016, p.34), the active positioning is ethical. While introducing myself as a “PhD student”, I never denied that I was also a researcher, and I explained to several curious participants how I would treat the information I gathered in analysis. While engaging in the activities as a young volunteer, I made it clear to the senior volunteers that I could not promise any long-term engagement as I did not even know if I would stay in Luxembourg after my doctoral study.

In this section, I elaborated on the data collection methods for this study: participant observation and ethnographic interviews. Additionally, I reflected on the negotiation of language in multilingual research sites and the positioning of the researcher in fieldwork, both of which profoundly influence the data collection process and the data collected. In the next section, I will present the data constructed from the ethnographic fieldwork.

Data Constructed

My main period of fieldwork took place from October 2022 to March 2023 and from October 2023 to March 2024 in the participatory conservation project series Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt. The fieldwork involved participant observation and ethnographic interviews with the volunteers and the volunteer coordinator. In addition, I regularly participated in the monthly casual get-together, Discussions publiques, information sessions for volunteers and Nature Film Night organised by LetzEarth. I also occasionally helped at outreach events such as its Open Days, the exhibition at the Forest Ministry and the Christmas publicity campaign in local bio-supermarkets. During the process of interacting with the people at LetzEarth and collecting data, I gathered data involving, as noted before, approximately 12,000 words of fieldnotes, 5 hours of videotaped recordings, 60 hours of participant observation, and 10 interviews that lasted between 1 hour and 2.5 hours. I now present the profile of the research participants.

Profile of Research Participants

The recruitment of research participants was quite straightforward. Two criteria applied: potential participants should be at least 18 years old and have been active in volunteering at LetzEarth. Emma, the volunteer coordinator, acted as the gatekeeper for my fieldwork and is also the first research participant. She participated in two formal interviews where she provided valuable background information on LetzEarth and its local sections. After sending out formal invitations to volunteers I had met during the pilot fieldwork or who had been introduced by Emma and other volunteers, 12 people agreed to participate in interviews and/or be videotaped during their volunteering. Among them are the active volunteers from the three local sections City, Nord and Reed Marsh, as well as Bob from the Language section, and Eric, the Honorary President of LetzEarth, who has been volunteering at LetzEarth since its predecessor was established. Table 3 presents the profiles of the 12 participants:

Table 3: Participant Profile.
PseudonymAge at time of study startNote
Jenny55City
Jules63City
Michael70City
Laura28Reed Marsh
Neo30Reed Marsh
Christophe51Reed Marsh
Daniel30Nord
Birgit60Nord
Maria71Nord
Bob73Language Section
Emma31Volunteer Coordinator
Eric80Honorary President

Fieldnotes

As mentioned previously, writing down fieldnotes during my fieldwork was very challenging. Engaging in active participation observation, I was unable to take notes on site using a phone or notebook. Therefore, I had to memorise my observations, experiences and feelings and recall them afterwards in order to write, as Emerson and others (2011) put it, “[the] process of recalling in order to write involves reimagining and replaying in one’s mind scenes and events that marked the day, actively repicturing and reconstructing these witnessed events in order to get them down on a page” (section “Recalling in Order to Write”). I often took quick notes on my mobile notepad and audio-recorded myself on the train back from the fieldwork, and then transcribed the audio recordings to add to the notes. In the later stages of my fieldwork, where video recording was involved, the main content of the notes shifted from event descriptions to my reflections that the camcorder could not capture, or to additional clarifications on what happened when I turned off the camera. For example, in one piece of my fieldnotes from September 2023, when video recording was applied, I noted down the interaction between Jules and me before the work started:

Conversation happens before the [work] started. [Jules] and I were waiting for [Jenny]. I asked how [Jules] had started his work with [LetzEarth]. He recalled how his interest for nature started almost 50 years ago (he laughed when mentioned this number) as a student in ecological education (concrete name needs to be confirmed). He used to work for the [place], but was not happy with the administrative work in his job profile. […] (Excerpt from fieldnotes on 30.09.2023)

As such, the approximately 60-hour participant observation has resulted in approximately 12000 words of fieldnotes.

Audio, Video Recordings and Their Transcription

The ethnographic interviews were all audio-recorded. The interviews were conducted in English and German, and sometimes the two languages were used interchangeably. I used two software programs to transcribe these audio recordings: MacWhisper and MAXQDA. In compliance with research ethics and GDPR, I did not use automatic speech recognition (ASR) programs that run on cloud servers and store data on external servers. I chose MacWhisper for the initial auto-transcription because this offline program transcribes audio locally on the device without transferring data to external servers. After obtaining the texts transcribed by MacWhisper, I imported the preliminary transcripts together with the audio recordings into MAXQDA for further detailed manual transcription. Similar to MacWhisper, MAXQDA processes and stores data on my device. It integrates the transcription window and the audio player into the same interface and allows users to adjust the rewind interval and playback speed (see MAXQDA, 2021). During the process of manual transcription, the identifiable information disclosed in the interviews, such as real names of people, places and organisations, was anonymised by replacement of pseudonyms or deletion. Besides, I manually corrected the speaker turns and the mis-transcribed phrases, as well as added punctuation to ensure a faithful reproduction of the informants’ words as accurately as possible. As for the transcription convention, Kowal and O’Connell (2004, p.250) suggest four different forms of transcription: standard orthography, literary transcription, eye dialect and phonetic transcription. In literary transcription, the linguistic deviations from the standard written language are taken into account to preserve the originality of the conversation. Given my research focus on understanding people’s thoughts as expressed in their own language, I chose literary transcription to process the interview data.

The transcription of video recordings was more complicated than that of audio recordings. Since most of the participants are elderly Luxembourgers, their first language, namely Luxembourgish, is the most frequent language in video data. Although my Luxembourgish skills are sufficient for simple communication with them, I am not able to conduct the verbatim transcription with rigour. To address this challenge, I explored ASR tools for Luxembourgish in compliance with research ethics, including the LuxASR program newly developed by Prof. Peter Gilles’ team from the Institute of Luxembourgish Language and Literature at the University of Luxembourg. However, these tools are not yet fully trained to transcribe spontaneous data recorded in real-time interactions, and my intermediate language skills do not enable me to conduct quality control and revision for the machine-generated transcripts. Thus, to ensure an accurate and timely transcription, I hired a student assistant with proficiency in Luxembourgish and basic knowledge of transcribing. Before the transcription, I presented my research context, goals, and data sets to the student assistant, and introduced her to the transcription conventions and precautions concerning research ethics and data protection. As the LuxASR program already transcribed some video clips, the student assistant received these machine-generated transcripts for manual correction. After the transcribing process, the student assistant and I conducted quality control and revision together. Since I am capable of understanding written Luxembourgish, the student assistant did not have to translate the texts into English. A fixed-term contract for 3.5 months with 20 working hours per month was signed with the student assistant for the transcription of 4-hour video clips involving interactions in Luxembourgish.

Ethical Considerations

Fieldwork also raises ethical questions as “ethical dilemmas and concerns are part of the everyday practice of doing research – all kinds of research” (Guillemin & Gillam, 2004, p.262). Although research ethics is not confined to only qualitative inquiries or studies involving human participants (Guillemin & Gillam, 2004), ethics tend to be considered “an even more pressing concern” to qualitative researchers due to “the emergent, dynamic and interactional nature of most qualitative research” (Iphofen & Tolich, 2018, p.1). As Murphy and Dingwall (2001) point out, questions concerning the appropriate ways to treat each other as human beings within the context of research are not wholly different from the questions about which values should be prevalent within a society. For any study, ethical research practice is rooted in the moral principles of respect for persons, beneficence, and justice (Marshall &Rossman, 2016). This means researchers should refrain from treating participants as merely a tool to achieve their research goals or harming the participants during the research process in any way. Instead, we should uphold the inherent rights of research participants such as privacy, anonymity and self-determination, and be mindful of the social justice implications of the research in terms of who benefits and who does not (Marshall &Rossman, 2016; Murphy & Dingwall, 2001).

Guillemin and Gillam (2004) distinguish two major dimensions of ethics in qualitative research, which they term procedural ethics and ethics in practice. Procedural ethics involves seeking approval from a research ethics committee, and ethics in practice refers to the ethical issues that arise in the doing of research (ibid.). In my research, there seemed to be a gap between these two dimensions. In my application for ethics approval handed to the University of Luxembourg Ethics Review Panel, I assessed the potential harm for the participants as “participants may be made uncomfortable by my presence, taking fieldnotes and conducting audio/video recordings during their activities; fear being misrepresented and/or depicted negatively; worry about information leakage concerning personal data, experiences and frank opinions”. However, this was not the case in my fieldwork. The participants never asked me to stop participating in their activities or to stop recording, nor did they ever express concerns about information leakage or request elimination or rectification of the information disclosed. To avoid manipulating the participants to give consent before knowing what their participation in the research implies (Etherington, 2007), before each fieldwork and interview, I briefed the participants on the research aim, my ways of storing and treating data, their rights as research participants and the potential risks. Before any audio or video recording began, I explicitly asked the participants if I could start recording. Participants were also informed orally and by information sheets that they could decide whether they would want to receive a copy of the recordings or transcript, and I would remain available for any further questions or requests. If the participant wished, he or she would also receive the preprint or/and published research results and was welcome to give feedback.

Although none of the participants expressed specific concerns about the risk of still being identifiable despite pseudonymisation, and many joked that we were not discussing sensitive secrets, they would not worry even if I were to publish their real names. Nevertheless, pseudonymity and confidentiality remained the biggest concern of my research. This was largely due to the specificity of my research context. Given Luxembourg's small size and the locals' strong personal connections, acquaintances may find it relatively easy to identify participants through my research, which draws heavily on personal accounts. Moreover, LetzEarth is one of the oldest, largest and most well-known environmental NGOs in Luxembourg. It is highly likely that the public can still identify the organisation and the people involved through my ethnographic description of the activities despite the pseudonyms. However, to ensure a meaningful contextualisation of data collection and analysis, I need to retain the relevant background information. To address this dilemma, I negotiated several solutions with the gatekeeper and participants. Taking advantage of the multilingual research setting, I created symbolic pseudonyms for the organisation, the local sections and activities in another language by employing Luxembourgish, German, French and English in an alternating manner. While the pseudonyms are not direct translations of the real names, I tried to preserve the thematic relevance in the pseudonyms. I discussed the pseudonyms with the gatekeeper and adopted her suggested modifications. As for the anonymisation of the participants, the disclosed identifiable details that were not relevant to the research were eliminated or replaced by non-identifying placeholders; if the information needed to be retained for data analysis, I substituted the identifiable details with similar fictional information that would not compromise the rigour of the study. Despite all the efforts made by the researcher to safeguard participants’ privacy, however, as Walford (2005) points out, “even if the identity of the community or organisation could be concealed, it is very unlikely that individual anonymity can be maintained through pseudonyms in relation to the other people involved” (p.87). Therefore, I repeatedly emphasised to the participants the risk of remaining recognisable despite the pseudonyms. They indicated their acceptance of this risk orally and by signing the consent form.

While ensuring confidentiality through the use of pseudonyms is a norm for studies involving human participants, there can be circumstances where participants wish to waive their right to anonymity, and the institution or organisation participating in the study wishes to be publicly acknowledged for its involvement in research. During my fieldwork, a senior volunteer who is also the contact person of his local section reached out to me and expressed the wish to post about their participation in my research on the local section’s Facebook page. Another local group discussed with me whether they could present their involvement in the annual assembly meeting. In both cases, I explained that it is my obligation as a researcher to safeguard confidentiality and why this is important for both the researcher and participants. While I asked the participants not to publish their involvement in my study online, I agreed that they could present their participation in my research during their internal meetings. Another time, the volunteer coordinator asked for my consent to use the photo of me working with another volunteer in Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt (see Figure 9) for designing banners, posters and brochures. As the other volunteer agreed, and the photo did not indicate a researcher-researched relationship, I gave Emma my consent. While LetzEarth never requested to waive its anonymity for acknowledgement of its contribution to the research, the public dissemination of the photos of me participating in its activities made my endeavour to uphold confidentiality more complicated. Nevertheless, I believe that the negotiation of anonymity with the participants and the organisation complies with research ethics norms. During this process, the participants’ rights to be informed and their autonomy were respected. In addition, the fact that some participants believed that disclosing their involvement in my research could benefit them personally or support their communities highlights both the reciprocal nature of my research practices and the broader value of the study.

Methodological Limitations

Previously, I argued for the application of an ethno-case study approach in my research. Parker-Jenkins (2018) underscores the inherent limitations of ethno-case study research in her definition, that compared to the traditional ethnographies, research applying an ethno-case study approach is “limited in terms of research time, engagement with the data and the extent of the findings” (p.29). In line with Parker-Jenkins’ elaboration, I now discuss my limited immersion in the field from a methodological perspective.

One of the main constraints I had for my doctoral research was time. Having to complete the project within four years, I have limited opportunities to engage more extensively in the field and develop deeper connections with research participants beyond what was feasible within the scope of this research. It would be fruitful to conduct fieldwork beyond the framework of Aktioun fir d’Ëmwelt to further explore the volunteers’ connection with nature in other activities, for example, observing how they are involved in environmental continuing education, gardening or hiking. However, it was not feasible for me to engage in a more comprehensive ethnographic fieldwork due to the time restriction of the doctoral study.

Another factor that posed challenges to my fieldwork is multilingualism in the field. As discussed in Section 3.3, navigating through a multilingual research setting requires language proficiency and multilingual sensitivity of the researcher. However, despite being plurilingual with language skills in English, German and Luxembourgish, it was challenging for me to grasp all the communicative details in the field. I could not fully understand the proper terms for plant and animal species in German, which sometimes made it difficult to make sense of the activities and fully engage in the “learning in nature” interactions. When the participants communicated with each other in Luxembourgish at the speed of native speakers, I could only grasp the main topic of the conversation, but hardly understand the details. This led me to miss opportunities to ask follow-up questions in a timely manner and initiate informal interviews during participant observation. Although I attempted to rectify the situation by seeking clarifications from participants afterwards and discussing the videos with the student assistant, I recognised that I could have gained more profound insights into how human-nature connections are discursively constructed if I had comprehensively understood participants’ communication and posed relevant questions on-site.

Thirdly, my active participation during participant observation resulted in certain limitations for the research. Although active participation “is an extremely useful technique” (Spradley, 1980, p.61) and helped me continuously negotiate access to the field, establish rapport with the participants and gain personal feelings and insights from the field, sometimes my intensive engagement in the volunteering work refrained me from “studying other members of the social world and, perhaps more vitally, time spent writing the fieldnotes”, as Delamont (2004) argues. Sometimes, when I was doing the hands-on work, I was not able to pay full attention to the words and actions of other volunteers at the same time, or had to miss the chance to videotape the meaningful yet transient interactions. There were also circumstances where the volunteering task was quite exhausting, for example, clearing a barren orchard located in the wetlands by trimming blackthorns and sawing through dead trees. The physical work left me with no energy for writing up fieldnotes after a whole morning of physical work, with my research agenda still on my mind. If I had the chance to continue the participant observation for another year, I would consider detaching myself a bit more from the engagement in the conservation work and reclaiming more of the researcher position in the field.

In Chapter 3, I expound on the research setting, approaches and methods used to collect ethnographic data, and a series of decisions and reflections I engaged in during the data collection phase. In the following chapter, I will outline how I analysed these data employing a Grounded Theory Method approach.

Notes

  1. 1[LB] Actions for the Environment.
  2. 2Diminutive of the French word “mine” (meaning “mine”), referring to the relatively low iron content of the ore found in this region.
  3. 3a Luxembourgish supermarket company.
  4. 4a community network of nature protection areas created under European Union’s 1992 Council Directive on the conservation of natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora.
  5. 5[FR] Public Discussions.
  6. 6Translation of the Luxembourgish text in Figure 4: Unfortunately, we can’t organise the alternative activity at [place] either, because the wetland that we want to work on is flooded…

Annotate

Next Chapter
4. Analytical Framework
PreviousNext
CC BY-SA 4.0
Powered by Manifold Scholarship. Learn more at
Opens in new tab or windowmanifoldapp.org