Notes
Online Incel Speech on incels.is: A content analysis
22Theoretical Background: The worldview of involuntarily celibate men (incels) is known to involve a distorted view of reality which can lead to harmful behavior including gendered hate speech. Incels form online communities in which they “often bemoan their lack of a loving relationship with a woman while simultaneously dehumanizing women and calling for misogynistic violence” (Glace et al., 2021, p. 288). However, not all online comments from incels contain misogyny or gendered hate speech, and some of the problematic comments address depression, self-harm, or the reasons why someone became an incel. To get a deeper understanding of the incel phenomenon, it could be better not to only focus on the misogynistic and hateful comments. Thus, this study employed the framing theory (Entman, 1991) to investigate the general comments and the hybrid masculinities model (Glace et al., 2021) to investigate the misogynistic comments from incels.
23Research Questions: We wanted to find out about the subjective causes (RQ1) and emotional consequences (RQ2) of being an incel, but also about the verbal behavior including gendered hate speech (RQ3).
24Methods: A sample of N = 600 thread posts on incels.is was subjected to a quantitative content analysis. A codebook was created based on the state of research on incels, the framing theory (for RQ1 and RQ2), and the hybrid masculinities model (for RQ3). All content categories of the codebook were found to be reliable before application (Gwet’s AC1 >.80). To answer the research questions, inferential statistics (e.g., chi-squared tests) were employed.
25Online incel speech / gendered hate speech / misogyny / sexism / manosphere