Notes
Does pretrial publicity predict actual criminal sentences? Evidence from a field study across 128 murder cases.
55Previous research has shown that pretrial publicity (PTP) may affect legal evaluations of criminal cases. Such an effect could threaten the legitimacy of court rulings. However, most studies did not analyze actual legal judgments as they took place in the lab or surveyed non-jury members with regard to single cases in the real world. To fill this gap, we conducted a field study combining data from three databases: First, we used the Federal Court Cases Integrated Database to identify relevant cases and to retrieve additional information such as the sentence. This resulted in N = 128 U.S. federal first-degree murder cases with court rulings in 2015-2017. Second, the Public Access to Court Electronic Records allowed us to match cases with defendants' names. Third, we turned to Lexis-Nexis for obtaining pre-trial press coverage (N = 891 articles after screening). We examined whether (1) the mere level of pretrial publicity (number of news articles) predicted criminal sentences, (2) the severity of the crime (which could affect both, publicity level as well as a criminal sentence) played a role, and (3) whether article contents of the PTP was related to actual sentences. For the latter, we ran automatic text analyses across all news articles and had a subsample of articles content-coded regarding the presentation of the suspect, emotionality, etc. We discuss the implications for both, media practice as well as legal decision-making.
56Pretrial publicity / legal decision-making / juror bias