Notes
They approve but they don't act: Promoting sustainable behaviour in explainer videos by using (conflicting) social norm appeals
82To motivate sustainable behaviour, social norm appeals (SNAs) have proven successful when individuals learn that the majority engages in the behaviour (descriptive SNA, DSNA) or that there is majority approval (injunctive SNA, ISNA). However, when the behaviour is not prevalent, minority DSNA run the risk of backfire effects. In this case, majority ISNAs could be used instead of minority DSNAs. Nevertheless, they can be counterproductive if majority ISNAs do not match salient descriptive minority norms (Smith et al., 2022). To counteract this, ISNAs might be combined with dynamic DSNAs: The majority has a positive attitude, and more and more people start acting accordingly. However, studies investigating dynamic DSNAs did not address this social norm conflict and vice versa. Furthermore, most studies use text stimuli, but a video might facilitate effects (Rhodes et al., 2020). Moreover, it is not clear what role characteristics play in determining whether minority DSNAs are effective or backfire (Carfora et al., 2022; de Groot et al., 2022). Different DSNAs appear to have greater impact on individuals with weak than strong personal norms. However, those studies did not include (majority) ISNAs which might have stronger effects.
83This fundamental research investigates how SNAs can be used within explainer videos to promote sustainable minority behaviour and if there are differences depending on personal norms. We will conduct a two-wave study because measuring moderators/covariates before the stimulus may lead to priming effects, while measurement afterwards may be influenced by it (N=1400). In the first survey, perceived social norms, personal norms, environmental concern, behavioural intentions, and pre-attitudes are measured. Two weeks later, respondents participate in a 3 (DSNA: static vs. dynamic vs. absent) × 2 (ISNA: present vs. absent) between-subjects experiment. They will watch an explainer video about voluntary carbon offsets including different SNAs before persuasive outcomes are measured again.
84https://osf.io/87y6t/?view_only=bb647eae503446d5b03aa58e777214fe
85Social norm / social norm appeals / experiment / persuasion / minority behaviour