Notes
The Role of Suspicion in Warranting Offline Characteristics from Online Claims
10Warranting theory (Walther & Parks, 2002) addresses this connection of the, “self to an on-line presentation” (p. 551), and theorizes the process by which online claims are determined to reflect an offline self is a useful means of understanding this process. However, research into and applying warranting theory has generally operated in a truth-default state, taking online claims as prima facie evidence of an offline self. This research builds on recent work considering and studying the fidelity of online claims to an offline self (Van Der Heide et al., 2022). Leveraging both warranting theory (Walther & Parks, 2022) and truth-default theory (Levine, 2014), this study hypothesizes a serial mediation process between trigger events (i.e., incident suggesting deception), suspicion of the claimant and/or claim, the warranting value of a claim, and the resultant perceptions of the target’s offline characteristics.
11Hypotheses will be tested using an experiment, using the context of ordering food—via an online delivery app—from either a traditional restaurant or its online-only ghost kitchen (a restaurant using its own kitchen facilities and staff to make food [typically consistent with the in-restaurant menu] only available via delivery Cai et al., 2022]). Participants will be randomly assigned to first see one of three trigger conditions (low, medium, high); and then consider a restaurant’s Grubhub profile. Profiles will be digitally altered to hold rating stars (3.7), number of reviews (4), and delivery times (40-50 minutes) consistent; but otherwise depict one of four popular chain restaurants or their ghost kitchen equivalent. Participants will then complete standardized scales for their state and general suspicion, the warranting value of the review, and their perceptions of the restaurant’s offline characteristics, as well as their prior experiences with their assigned restaurant and the Grubhub app.
12Warranting / perceptions / online-offline / impression formation / ghost kitchens