Notes
Player Performance and Video Game Entertainment: Why is Low Difficulty So Appealing?
42Video gamers’ entertainment experiences have been studied with regard to challenge, performance, and achievement emotions (e.g., Schmierbach et al., 2014). Psychological flow theory suggests that optimal experience will occur when players are neither over- nor under-challenged (Csikszentmihalyi, 1988; Sherry, 2004). Similarly, self-determination theory suggests that pleasurable competence experiences will be strongest when mastering nontrivial challenges (Deci & Ryan, 2000; Schmierbach et al., 2014). Empirical findings contradict these propositions (e.g., Klimmt et al., 2009) because easy difficulty was found to be more enjoyable for skilled players than higher levels of challenge.
43Two experiments test two potential explanations for these observations: (1) Non-demanding games facilitate relaxation (Wulf et al., 2019). Hence, while the enjoyment of optimal challenges might be based on flow and competence, easy games might be particularly enjoyable due to relaxation (H1). (2) Easy difficulty levels may bore players only after some time (H2) when they have learned the game and can judge their performance, so that hedonic adaptation effects may occur (Frederick & Loewenstein, 1999).
44In study 1, N=248 participants (age M=29 years, SD=8 years; 69 females) played PacMan for four minutes at one of three randomly assigned difficulty levels – easy (n=79), medium (n=90), or hard (n=79). Subsequently, high scores, the number of ‘deaths,’ and experiences of flow, competence, relaxation, and enjoyment were measured. Study 2 (N=160, age M=26 years, SD=9 years; 44 females) employed the same stimulus and measures within a 2x2-between-subject design, manipulating the difficulty level (easy vs. medium) and the duration of playing (four vs. seven minutes).
45ANOVAs served to compare players’ enjoyment between the difficulty levels. Mediation analyses were conducted to investigate whether competence, flow, and relaxation mediated the effect of difficulty levels on enjoyment (i.e., H1). In Study 2, the potential moderating effect of playing time (i.e., H2) was tested in an ANOVA.
46Entertainment / Video Games / Difficulty / Flow / Self-Determination Theory