Notes
A Gendered View on Media Use Guilty Pleasures
116The term guilty pleasure is used heavily in public and academic discourse when discussing media habits. As a self-conscious moral emotion, guilt arises when people fail to follow internal and social norms. Media use is often perceived as hedonic behavior driven by a desire for immediate pleasure; however, as such pleasure can be considered ""bad behavior"" lacking long-term benefits, people may term many media use behaviors as guilty pleasures. Although men and women experience guilt differently when consuming media, research tapping into what media content is attributed to be a guilty pleasure by different people remains limited. In this preregistered study, we explore which media content people label as guilty pleasure and test whether the term is used in a gendered way (https://osf.io/6r4qd/?view_only=cfb2a1cb882746bf86f3f8bed282395b).
117A mixed-methods survey was fielded using a panel company to reach a representative Dutch adult sample and completed by 1863 participants. Participants named their own guilty pleasure in terms of media use or a typical media guilty pleasure when they did not have one themselves (additional option: not knowing the term). Finally, participants rated the named content on a scale from 1 (mainly for women) to 10 (mainly for men). Four hypotheses were tested, namely (H1) women are more likely to report personal media-related guilty pleasures, (H2) content named as a personal guilty pleasure is perceived as being more ""for women,"" and (H3) this is similarly true for typical guilty pleasures. We further expected that the gendered nature is more pronounced for typical guilty pleasures (H4). Open-ended survey responses were analyzed to identify content commonly associated with personal and typical guilty pleasures. The codebook includes categories for type/genre, platform, and specific titles. This mixed-method approach contributed to a deeper understanding of media guilty pleasures and first insights on whether there is a gendered view on guilty pleasures.
118Guilty pleasure / entertainment / gender / reception mode