Notes
Privacy Calculus, Privacy Paradox, and Context Collapse: A Replication of Three Key Studies in Communication Privacy Research
80With the emergence of social network sites (SNS), privacy has become a staple research topic in communication science. By now, thousands of studies have investigated how privacy concerns relate to users’ privacy protection behaviors and self-disclosure on SNSs. Despite such a large body of work, little attention is dedicated to the replicability of individual findings. To this day, the privacy literature only includes few, rather conceptual than exact replication studies. Yet, scientific claims can only be trusted if studies repeated under the same conditions lead to the same results. To fill this gap, this preregistered study replicated three key studies that are representative of three prominent research lines in the work on privacy on SNSs: Krasnova et al.’s (2010) investigation of the privacy calculus, Dienlin and Trepte’s (2015) study on the privacy paradox, and Vitak’s (2012) analysis of the impact of the context collapse. We therefore conducted a survey study with n = 797 (80% power for detecting small effect sizes) which included all three studies’ items. The first goal was to conduct exact replications, i.e., estimate the same structural equation models outlined in the original papers. We assessed the replication success of individual paths by checking whether the original effect size was included in the 95% confidence interval of the replication. Second, we tested whether the analytical robustness of the findings held across meaningful modifications of the models (e.g., inclusion of previously omitted paths, alternative specification of measurement models). Finally, given that all three studies investigated the relationship between privacy concerns and privacy behavior, we explored the robustness of this relationship across a variety of conceptual (e.g., different operationalizations) and analytical decisions (e.g., inclusion of covariates, subset analyses).
81Privacy / self-disclosure / social network sites / replication