Notes
Which cues do laypeople use to evaluate the credibility of feigned and actual experts on YouTube?
290As the Covid-19 pandemic demonstrated, social media plays an instrumental role in disseminating and discussing scientific information. Given that most viewed content concerning Covid-19 was created by users rather than official sources, it is not surprising that a concoction of true and false information spread on YouTube (e.g. D’Souza et al., 2020; Li et al., 2020). Specifically on YouTube, numerous feigned experts who highlighted their expertise (as, e.g., medical doctors) disseminated disinformation. This circumstance highlights the need to better understand to what extent laypeople are able to distinguish between true and false information and which cues are used to make this decision. Even though credibility cues have been extensively analysed in text-based material, there is almost no knowledge on how credibility judgements of videos are formed.
291We will present an exploratory study modelled after the “thin slices” approach (Ambady & Rosenthal, 1992, 1993) employed in nonverbal behavior research. We present short video sequences of real and feigned scientific experts in order to identify which (non)verbal behaviours and additional cues affect recipients’ trust and credibility assessment of (seemingly) scientific content on YouTube.
292The exploratory procedure encompasses the following steps:
- 940 Participants rate a random selection of 235 thin slices from YouTube videos showing real and feigned experts presenting information on Covid-19.
- The thin slices that are rated as most and least trustworthy as well as credible are selected to be presented in qualitative interviews. This is used to receive first hints on relevant cues that determine trustworthiness and credibility.
- Based on the interviews and relevant literature, a codebook is compiled by which all thin slices will be coded.
- By means of regression analyses, it is determined which cues are most important predictors of trust and credibility judgements.
294Credibility / trust / YouTube / thin slices / disinformation