Notes
“Just Turn Them Off” – Investigating the Effects of a Notification-Disabling Intervention on Objective Smartphone Behavior and Subjective User Experiences
61In response to the growing public concern about people spending too much time on their smartphones, a common advice is to turn off notifications as this is a prominent device feature that drives smartphone engagement. It has been demonstrated that a higher number of notifications correlates with higher daily screen time and number of phone use sessions. Notifications draw immediate attention to the smartphone and form a source of distraction during daily activities, reducing one’s productivity. Furthermore, partly due to the constant possibility of receiving new notifications, individuals have developed a cognitive pre-occupation with their smartphones (i.e., smartphone vigilance). Relatedly, notifications play a key role in the formation of pervasive checking habits (i.e., excessively checking one’s phone without any reason). Turning off notifications to combat these negative consequences may thus seem like a sound solution.
62However, research is still scarce and inconclusive as to whether the commonly advised strategy of disabling notifications indeed helps the user to feel more in control about their smartphone behavior. For instance, no study has yet looked at the effect of disabling smartphone notifications on objectively measured screen time. In addition, research on the effects of disabling notifications on subjective experiences is also limited. The present study therefore aims to test the effects of disabling notifications on both objective smartphone behavior (daily screen time; number of phone unlocks) and subjective experiences (perceived overuse; perceived control; distraction; productivity; smartphone vigilance; perceived checking habit strength).
63To this end, a preregistered two-week intervention study with a Randomized Controlled Trial design (baseline vs. intervention week; treatment vs. control group) was conducted. Participants installed a research app on their phones that continuously logged their smartphone behavior and sent daily surveys including the assessment of the subjective outcome variables. The sample (N=195) was recruited via a student pool and via Prolific.
64Push notifications / smartphone logging / subjective experiences / checking habit / online vigilance / intervention / randomized controlled trial