Notes
The persuasive effect of user comments on YouTube in moral discourse: Exploring the influence of ideology-matching moral framing and impression motivation in the context of social media
162The new social media landscape influences the way individuals interact with information on moral topics and make moral judgements. Here, comments may affect individuals’ interpretation of information concerning the moral debate (Winter & Krämer, 2016). Research explaining the psychological processes of moral decision making emphasizes the significance of using messages containing moral arguments (Feinberg & Willer, 2015). Matching moral arguments to the target group’s dispositions can influence the persuasiveness of said message (Feinberg & Willer, 2013). Therefore, using ideology-matching moral framing may be a powerful strategy for promoting opinion change (Hoover et al., 2018). This is especially relevant in social media where processes of social influence take place and, in accordance with the Heuristic-Systematic Model (Chaiken et al., 1996), an impression-motivated mode of information processing is promoted. This desire to make a good impression leads to individuals orienting themselves towards the majority opinion shown in comments and shifting their attitudes.
163The aim of this study is to explore how individuals form attitudes when presented with comments containing moral arguments. We hypothesize that people adjust their attitudes to align with the perceived majority opinion conveyed through comments, particularly when being impression motivated. This persuasive effect is likely to be enhanced if moral arguments within comments match a person's political or moral beliefs.
164In two pre-registered experiments (N = 314, N=1015) we utilized a 2x2x2 between-subjects design where participants were shown a YouTube video with accompanying comments, after which they gave their opinion on the topic. We manipulated the inclusion of moral arguments within the comments (harm vs. authority), their valence (positive vs. negative) and the participants’ motivational states (high vs. low impression motivation). With this study we intend to advance research on the relevance of moral discussions in social media by examining aspects of moral psychology from a media psychological perspective.
165Social media / YouTube / user comments / moral framing / persuasion