Notes
Effects of subtle and blatant antisemitic and islamophobic hate on ingroups and outgroups: an experimental study
158Even though exposure to online hate has been identified by current scholarship as one of the main threats in the cyberworld (Waquas, Salminen, Jung, Almerekhi, & Jansen, 2019), little has been done so far to understand the effects of online hate on media users. Ethnic and religious minorities can count as the most understudied target groups of online hate (Waquas et al., 2019) even though they appear to be among the most frequently attacked (Hawdon et al., 2017).
159Some studies have shown that exposure to hate has harmful effects on those who experience it, especially the members of the groups being attacked (ingroup-members; see Boeckmann et al., 2002; Leets, 2001; Leets & Giles, 1997; Subrahmanyam and Šmahel, 2011). Among the effects of online hate on media users are short- and medium-term emotional effects, including dysthymic feelings, confusion, reduced well-being (Keipi et al., 2017; Tynes et al., 2004; Tynes, 2006), and reduced trust (Näsi et al., 2015). Online hate also breeds further hateful discourse online – unless media users cope with the initial expression of hate by employing problem-focused coping strategies. At the same time, online hate comes in different shapes and can be blatant versus subtle (Ben-David & Matamoros-Fernandes, 2016). These differences are likely to have different effects on different media users.
160In the current study, we were interested in the differential effects of blatant versus subtle hate messages on ingroup versus outgroup members of hate target groups. It comprised two between-subjects experiments in which individuals were confronted with either antisemitic Twitter comments in Study 1 (N = 81) or islamophobic ones in Study 2 (N = 67). IV1 hate explicitness distinguished blatant from subtle hate expression; IV2 religious membership differentiated ingroup and outgroup members. Outcome variables were well-being, self-esteem and coping. Data were subjected to analyses of variance.
161Hate speech / hate speech effects / religious groups / islamophobia / antisemitism