Notes
To Thine Own Self Be True (on Social Media): Longitudinal Associations of Emerging Adults’ Perceptions of Self-, Peer, and Influencer Authenticity with Depressive Tendencies
325A primary motivational pull for youths’ social media activities is to satisfy self-presentation needs (see Hollenbaugh, 2021). Unlike in public debates where idealized self-presentation often takes center stage, authenticity typically serves as a positive buzzword for promoting new applications or features (Salisbury & Pooley, 2017), partially given that authentic self-presentation is known as a solid predictor of well-being (both online [Twomey & O’Reilly, 2017] and offline [Sutton, 2020]).
326Based on a subjective (rather than objectivistic; see Jongman-Sereno & Leary, 2019) definition of social media authenticity and well-established theoretical approaches explaining intra- and interpersonal benefits of self-authenticity (i.e., self-determination, meaning-making, social exchange theory, and social penetration theory) and ambiguous effects of perceived authenticity in others (i.e., emotional contagion and different kinds of social comparisons), this study addresses crucial research gaps by examining how emerging adults’ self-perceived social media authenticity (H1, with negative prediction being assumed) and their perceptions of online authenticity among their peers (RQ1a) and influencers (RQ1b) they follow relate to depressive tendencies over time.
327Methodologically, we address the frequently bemoaned lack of longitudinal research and non-student samples (e.g., Valkenburg, 2022) by using two-wave panel data (with an approximately four-month interval between surveys) from a heterogeneous sample of emerging adults from [COUNTRY] (NT1 = 978 after applying several data quality checks; NT2 = 415). Given that this study was part of a comprehensive survey, short versions or high-loading items of established scales were implemented to avoid response fatigue while minimizing losses in measurement quality. In addition to standard demographics (age, gender, education), we followed recent calls from scholars arguing that true authenticity effects need to be isolated from related self-relevant evaluations (Rivera et al., 2019) by accounting for participants' perceptions of positive and negative feedback to their self-presentation on social media. Statistical analysis was conducted via measurement invariant over-time structural equation modeling.
328Authenticity / self-presentation / social media, peers / influencers / depressive tendencies