Notes
The effect of perceived narrative ambiguity on appreciation
5Narratives are interpreted by different people in different ways (see Ewoldsen et al., 2022). Perceived narrative ambiguity (PNA) is a psychological construct that describes the extent to which a user perceives that a narrative can be interpreted in multiple ways (see APA, 2015; Currie, 1995). I argue that PNA should motivate deliberative cognitive processes intended to resolve ambiguity by achieving a sufficient level of confidence in one’s preferred interpretation (see Ball-Rokeach, 1974; cf. Cacioppo et al., 1996).
6Scholars have proposed that appreciation, a eudaimonic media effect, results from positively appraised media use characterized by deliberative cognitive processing (Tamborini et al., 2021). Therefore, I predict that perceived narrative ambiguity will be positively associated with appreciation (H1).
7As reactions to ambiguity are idiosyncratic (Ball-Rokeach, 1974), two traits that should influence the effects of PNA are ambiguity tolerance and need for cognition. Ambiguity tolerance describes an individual’s dispositional orientation to ambiguity; low AT individuals tend to experience ambiguity as noxious and respond with aversion, whereas high AT individuals will view ambiguity as a desirable challenge (see Furnham & Ribchester, 1995). Need for cognition describes an individual’s intrinsic motivation to pursue cognitively effortful activities (see Cacioppo et al., 1996). I predict that the relationship between perceived narrative ambiguity will be positively moderated by ambiguity tolerance and need for cognition (H2).
8Participants for this study include n = 369 adult US citizens recruited via Prolific. In a quasi-experimental survey, participants first reported trait need for cognition and ambiguity tolerance. Next, participants named and described a familiar movie that was either ambiguous or unambiguous (randomly assigned). Then, participants responded to measures assessing PNA, appreciation, and moral conflict (control). All closed-ended measures followed a seven-point Likert format and demonstrated appropriate dimensionality and good reliability.
9Entertainment / narrative / individual differences / cognitive processing / eudaimonia