Notes
People’s Beliefs regarding Phones ‘Listening’ to Offline Conversations: Comparing results from the United States, the Netherlands, and Poland
150The surveillance effect is the phenomenon by which people believe that their electronic devices (e.g., smartphones, smart speakers) are listening in to their offline conversations, resulting in this information then being used for personalized communication. Though companies state that they are not engaging in such practices to target consumers with relevant advertisements, previous literature offers various explanations for why people might feel surveilled by corporations. One potential explanation is the confirmation bias: people are more likely to notice an online advertisement if it is about a service or brand they recently discussed with a family member or friend. Guided by the Dataveillance Framework, we will examine media users’ beliefs and factors that predict when they are more likely to believe that their devices are listening.
151After IRB approval and preregistering the study, we are now in the process of data collection with an online survey in the U.S., the Netherlands, and Poland. The U.S. and Europe are chosen based on their regulatory differences related to privacy. Additionally, Eastern European countries have undergone a recent transition from states with extensive state surveillance practices and limited guarantees of human rights to states embracing the European human-rights standards and enshrining a more robust body of human-rights guarantees in their constitutional orders. This may impact individual expectations and experiences of surveillance.
152The current research will advance our theoretical understanding of the omnipresence of surveillance and privacy issues in the media landscape. Furthermore, gaining insights in the surveillance effect is vital to combat consumers’ false beliefs regarding digital advertising. It highlights the role of transparency regulations and literacy programs in it and shows the potential regulators have in correcting false and contributing to forming correct beliefs.
153Surveillance effect / privacy / dataveillance framework / international survey